Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not comply...?

287 replies

Largethighsbadeyes · 18/12/2021 22:42

...if the government imposes restrictions over Christmas, given what we now know happened last Christmas with parties at downing street.

The possibility of this is rumour at the moment and hadn't been confirmed but I'm interested to see how others are feeling.

By restrictions I mean rule of 6 indoors for Christmas day or even no mixing of households for Christmas eve, Christmas day, boxing day.

I will not comply. I cannot do that to my child who is an only child and whose grandad is dying. He wants to be with extended (but very close) family at Christmas, as do I.

If we all test negative the day before we will be carrying on as normal regardless of the rules (all adults triple vaccinated)

YABU - I will follow the restrictions if brought in over Christmas

YANBU - i will not follow restrictions if brought in over Christmas

OP posts:
SoItWas · 19/12/2021 16:30

"I have to say that if restrictions/rules are put in place either before or after xmas (or at any time) and any of my neighbours break the rule then I will absolutely be reporting it"

With no clue as to why they feel compelled to break the rule? If they ban mixing of households again, and one of your neighbours dies, are you going to report the family and friends of their grieving spouse, children etc, for coming to comfort them? What if a woman has a miscarriage and needs her mum and sister, or someone has noticed every time they phone their brother, he sounds really drunk, even first thing in the morning, so they feel an intervention is necessary? Or will you just report anyone, without a second thought, because that's what a good upright citizen does?

Tiptoearound · 19/12/2021 16:27

Ontherebound34

You have no idea about my circumstances, I cannot even see my neighbours from my windows as I don’t live on an estate or in an urban area. If I see anyone that I feel are putting other people at risk & there are restrictions in place then I’ll report it, simple as that.

FrazzledCareerWoman · 19/12/2021 16:26

Anyway perhaps there are more vaccinated now in hospital with Covid bc they are there for other reasons. &/or because there are many more of them (like the chart shown up thread).

I'd be interested to see the breakdown between "hospitalised for Covid" and "tested positive while in hospital"

Scrabblecrabapple · 19/12/2021 16:24

No way. Not this time.

FrazzledCareerWoman · 19/12/2021 16:23

@Ontherebound34

But why are we constantly told that the vast majority of Covid patients in ICU are unvaccinated? Are you saying this isn't true? Because it is fact

It was fact at the start of the vaccination programme and the literature on it comes from that period. It’s not fact anymore. Most people in ICU are vaccinated because the vast majority of the population has been vaccinated. There are some people who are not vaccinated out of choice and we have to allow them to make that choice. There are also some that can’t be vaccinated for health reasons. But it’s a myth that restrictions are due to anti-vaxxers. And the more pressure is put on anti-vaxxers, the less likely they are to get the vaccine.

I didn't say hospitalisations I said in ICU.

The mayor of London posted as recently as yesterday that majority in ICU are unvaccinated.

Ontherebound34 · 19/12/2021 16:22

@Tiptoearound

SoItWas

I was referring to base language on a public forum directed at a stranger, that is no way to speak.

When did I mention I was wrongly reporting anyone; I will only report those breaking rules if there are any. Why assume any reports will be false?

Because you wouldn’t have the full facts if you stand behind your curtains watching the comings and goings of your neighbours and you wouldn’t have a clue what backstory there was even if they were technically in breach of an arbitrary rule that hugely favours those who live with their spouse/parter and children while utterly pissing on those whose living arrangements differ to that. It’s a pathetic waste of scarce public resources to call the police because your neighbour spent time with a friend over Christmas. That people like you can still think they have the moral high ground is both astounding and disgusting.
SoItWas · 19/12/2021 16:19

Sorry if this was from earlier in this thread, and not another thread

To not comply...?
Tiptoearound · 19/12/2021 16:16

SoItWas

I was referring to base language on a public forum directed at a stranger, that is no way to speak.

When did I mention I was wrongly reporting anyone; I will only report those breaking rules if there are any. Why assume any reports will be false?

Ontherebound34 · 19/12/2021 16:16

fullfact.org/health/economist-vaccination-status/

Facts on current hospital admissions. Rate of hospitalisation is higher in non-vaccinated people (35% of admissions versus 19% of population being unvaccinated) but more vaccinated than unvaccinated people are admitted to hospital with Covid. To blame it on them is ridiculous and distorts reality. Even if you held everyone of them down and forced a needle into their arm, you wouldn’t get rid of Covid or the possibility of restrictions.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 16:16

I feel I should add that the week in which my ex had some sort of mental breakdown, was the only time I didn't comply, during that lockdown, and only with the approval of the police who were very unstandanding, and were an enormous help during that time.

dotsandco · 19/12/2021 16:13

What a truly pathetic stance OP!

Take your righteous indignation and playground games, and remember, when you've either caught Covid or watched a loved one suffer with it, that at least you 'stuck it to the man'!! Ridiculous!

Ontherebound34 · 19/12/2021 16:12

But why are we constantly told that the vast majority of Covid patients in ICU are unvaccinated? Are you saying this isn't true? Because it is fact

It was fact at the start of the vaccination programme and the literature on it comes from that period. It’s not fact anymore. Most people in ICU are vaccinated because the vast majority of the population has been vaccinated. There are some people who are not vaccinated out of choice and we have to allow them to make that choice. There are also some that can’t be vaccinated for health reasons. But it’s a myth that restrictions are due to anti-vaxxers. And the more pressure is put on anti-vaxxers, the less likely they are to get the vaccine.

BitterTits · 19/12/2021 16:11

@Ceramide

Education is not a high priority, which is why I will continue to see my family if they wish

I disagree. Children have missed so much already and schools are still trying to catch up even now. All schools and children have been significantly affected, but disadvantaged children particularly so.

In secondary schools, attainment dropped by 6 months for the most advantaged children, a year for the least. Primary children's attainment has dropped behind by around a year for more advantaged children, even more so for the less advantaged.

If schools are asked to close again, and parents have to home-educate again instead of working, that will reduce staff levels everywhere, including hospitals, GP surgeries, care homes and visiting carers. You may be able to visit your elderly relative but if they don't get the care they need, it is counterproductive.

Education now is also required to create the doctors, scientists, nurses, teachers, virologists, carers, key workers, too many others to mention, and informed citizens of the near future.

Of course we all want to see our elderly and infirm relatives. I have been unable to see mine anywhere near as much as usual. However, children being cut off from friends and social contact for weeks or months is also not something to take lightly.

What I meant was that education has not been prioritised for investment to mitigate transmission. Teachers have not been prioritised for vaccines. That's why we're in a mess now and it's why there's no point in me shutting myself away from family over the Christmas holiday - education will not suddenly become the priority it should have been all along in January, and I will just have to deal with the fallout.
SoItWas · 19/12/2021 16:06

Tiptoearound

The only thing class has to do with it, is that the upper echelon are more likely to get away with breaching restrictions. "It's only a crime, if you get caught".

I hope if you wrongly report anyone (there are exceptions made in certain circumstances), you get done for wasting police time.

During one lockdown, my ex with drug and alcohol issues, tried to break into my home several times, until he was caught red handed. I 100% think he was intent on harming me, or wrecking the place. I had lots of relatives coming and going, I was terrified of being alone. Roughly 5-10 different police officers were in my home over the course of 5 days or so, until he was caught red handed and arrested in my garden. Every single one assured me that covid restrictions were clearly the least of my worries. Thankfully none of my neighbours missed the initial police visits, and reported me for having family round (for shits and giggles of course, because why else would anyone breach restrictions Hmm).

My ex was socially isolated, so drinking alone at home, and drinking a lot more. He no longer had anyone checking in on him, or to help distract him from his substance abuse issues, was no longer able to attend AA sessions, counselling, or church. He isn't one for chatting over the phone, can't use/keep a smart phone, no access to computer facilities at the local library.

There were many like him, left to flounder. [Not excusing his behaviour, but I can see why his mental health was shot to pieces].

FrazzledCareerWoman · 19/12/2021 15:55

@Ontherebound34

The stuff about how this is the fault of the unvaccinated is bullshit. My sister works in a hospital and the majority of people admitted for Covid are jabbed. Over 80% of the population is double jabbed. An even higher percentage in vulnerable groups. It doesn’t stop you catching or spreading Covid. It’s not people who are unvaccinated who are causing this virus to spread - it’s normal and inevitable for it to spread. It’s just a convenient way of finding a scapegoat who you can blame for the whole shit-show. Also people have the right to bodily autonomy. Nobody should ever be able to force a competent adult to have treatment they don’t want.
But why are we constantly told that the vast majority of Covid patients in ICU are unvaccinated? Are you saying this isn't true? Because it is fact.

Btw I don't agree with mandatory vaccination either.

FrazzledCareerWoman · 19/12/2021 15:53

I will not comply.

I've had 3 jabs, I wear a mask in shops etc.
I followed the rules the last 2 lockdowns.

Enough is enough. It's unvaccinated people filling up the hospitals while everyone else is left to rot basically.

Uk is 81% double vaccinated and soon will be 50%+ triple. We need to get on with life.

anon12345678901 · 19/12/2021 15:44

I'm not complying. Luckily my neighbours aren't such twats that they'd report anyone for seeing their families.

Lavender24 · 19/12/2021 15:43

I'm not complying with any bullshit rules and it's got nothing to do with Boris partying.

Tiptoearound · 19/12/2021 15:41

Ontherebound34

What a classy person you are, thankfully I don’t live around people like you, most of them know how to conduct themselves appropriately & those that don’t face the consequences

Ontherebound34 · 19/12/2021 15:39

@Tiptoearound

Ontherebound34 Thankfully I couldn’t care less what they say or think about it
I meant the police 😂 But I hope the neighbours do too.
Tiptoearound · 19/12/2021 15:37

Ontherebound34
Thankfully I couldn’t care less what they say or think about it

Ontherebound34 · 19/12/2021 15:35

@Tiptoearound

I have to say that if restrictions/rules are put in place either before or after xmas (or at any time) and any of my neighbours break the rule then I will absolutely be reporting it. Although it’s unlikely my neighbours will make that mistake again as they were caught previously & given a large fine plus the embarrassment of having the police turn up
I hope they tell you to get fucked.
Tiptoearound · 19/12/2021 15:33

I have to say that if restrictions/rules are put in place either before or after xmas (or at any time) and any of my neighbours break the rule then I will absolutely be reporting it. Although it’s unlikely my neighbours will make that mistake again as they were caught previously & given a large fine plus the embarrassment of having the police turn up

Ontherebound34 · 19/12/2021 15:30

The stuff about how this is the fault of the unvaccinated is bullshit. My sister works in a hospital and the majority of people admitted for Covid are jabbed. Over 80% of the population is double jabbed. An even higher percentage in vulnerable groups. It doesn’t stop you catching or spreading Covid. It’s not people who are unvaccinated who are causing this virus to spread - it’s normal and inevitable for it to spread. It’s just a convenient way of finding a scapegoat who you can blame for the whole shit-show.
Also people have the right to bodily autonomy. Nobody should ever be able to force a competent adult to have treatment they don’t want.

Tealightsandd · 19/12/2021 15:13

But of course on an unrelated note, if we really cared about education - particularly equal access to opportunities and life chances for children, we'd tackle the public health housing and homelessness emergency. Homelessness and insecure housing impact hugely on children's life chances. Returning to Covid, it would also have meant far fewer vulnerable. Socioeconomic risks, including overcrowded and poor housing - the interconnection with poor physical health and likelihood of developing an underlying condition - shouldn't be underestimated.