Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not comply...?

287 replies

Largethighsbadeyes · 18/12/2021 22:42

...if the government imposes restrictions over Christmas, given what we now know happened last Christmas with parties at downing street.

The possibility of this is rumour at the moment and hadn't been confirmed but I'm interested to see how others are feeling.

By restrictions I mean rule of 6 indoors for Christmas day or even no mixing of households for Christmas eve, Christmas day, boxing day.

I will not comply. I cannot do that to my child who is an only child and whose grandad is dying. He wants to be with extended (but very close) family at Christmas, as do I.

If we all test negative the day before we will be carrying on as normal regardless of the rules (all adults triple vaccinated)

YABU - I will follow the restrictions if brought in over Christmas

YANBU - i will not follow restrictions if brought in over Christmas

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ontherebound34 · 20/12/2021 08:15

I think there’s a misperception that lockdown means the virus will go away quicker (lots of people saying ‘the more we stick to the rules now, the sooner we can get back to normal’). It doesn’t. The ONLY thing lockdown does is ease the pressure on the NHS (although finding the NHS properly would be better than endless lockdowns imo). But as soon as restrictions lift, it comes back, as we saw last year after the November lockdown. It won’t go away until either humans develop natural immunity to it or there is a vaccine that actually prevents infection and transmission. Neither seem likely.

The people I know who are in favour of strict lockdowns have a pretty good home life with partners and kids, nice houses, working from home, no money worries. For them, lockdown is pretty easy. They seem to forget that for others it is a literal hell and a matter of life and death. They all get their Amazon and Waitrose deliveries too so I’m not sure they are fully aware of the conditions others have to work in in order for their lockdowns to run so smoothly.

DdraigGoch · 20/12/2021 07:27

@xxxGirlCrushxxx

So go mix with your families

Don't be moaning when the schools close and you are back to home schooling then! As well as queuing to get in Tesco.

No one's going to be queuing to get into Tesco. Not now people have realised that covid doesn't give you the shits, so there's no need to buy excessive quantities of toilet rolls.
DdraigGoch · 20/12/2021 07:10

There's a reason why the UK has one of the highest number of cases in the world.

@Tealightsandd That would be because we are testing more than most. We have a higher testing rate than all except five other countries. We are testing four times as much as Germany and yet only have twice their case rate. That tells us that Germany actually has a higher case rate than the UK, but the cases are going undetected.

BitterTits · 19/12/2021 22:58

Perhaps I should say my employment, rather than my employer.

BitterTits · 19/12/2021 22:57

Why put your own health at risk?

This comes across as glib - my employer puts my health at risk daily.

Sparklingbrook · 19/12/2021 20:00

@Largethighsbadeyes

Yes, and I wanted to know whether people thought I was being unreasonable or not. Again not sure why that's weird.

If you have an issue either it then take it up with MNHQ

I have suggested it in Site Stuff before now.
Largethighsbadeyes · 19/12/2021 19:59

*with

OP posts:
Largethighsbadeyes · 19/12/2021 19:59

Yes, and I wanted to know whether people thought I was being unreasonable or not. Again not sure why that's weird.

If you have an issue either it then take it up with MNHQ

OP posts:
Sparklingbrook · 19/12/2021 19:56

No I'm still here. I am interested in the poll (now sure why that's weird? It's a function provided by the site after all)

The 'poll/vote' function is provided by the site to enable posters to reply to whether you are being unreasonable or not in the AIBU topic. As I said upthread i don't know why they don't have a proper topic where people can do surveys to their heart's content with graphs and bar charts etc.

Largethighsbadeyes · 19/12/2021 19:52

No I'm still here. I am interested in the poll (now sure why that's weird? It's a function provided by the site after all)

Looks like I'm not the only one thinking the same thing... after a few glasses of wine before posting. I was feeling down and pissed off. Apparently there are more than a few of us

OP posts:
Sparklingbrook · 19/12/2021 19:29

Op seems to have disappeared. Maybe they were only interested in the weird vote/poll thing.

Ceramide · 19/12/2021 19:10

Triple vaccinated isn't a guarantee by any means. It's 75 per cent effective against getting Omicron with symptoms. So one in four triple-vaccinated people who exposed to the virus will still get COVID symptoms. Of these, some will unfortunately be hospitalised. And as it is way more contagious than the Wuhan or Delta strains, this could still overwhelm the NHS.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 19/12/2021 18:54

I don't blame you for not complying, I wouldn't if I had elderly parents desperate to see us etc.
However the people at downing Street took risks for themselves?
Why put your own health at risk?

Ninjasan · 19/12/2021 17:55

@Tiptoearound

SoItWas

Of course but I’m unlikely to notice the odd visitor I’m referring to people who flagrantly break rules (many have commented here) the attitude that ‘I don’t care about any rules I’m still having 20 people over at Christmas’ these are the people that I would report if I know it’s happening, the people with several vehicles on the driveway types. Anyway no rules have been announced as yet so I don’t need to concern myself with it until such a time that it does change.

You are so sad. Please get a life. Something to do. Like hiding under a rock. You will be safe there.
HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 19/12/2021 17:45

I can’t believe an adult has written the OP Hmm. They did it Miss, so I’m doing it too, regardless of the impact on people’s lives! Absolute fuckwittery at its best!!!

wonkylegs · 19/12/2021 17:24

I'm not influenced on this subject by the awful behaviour of the government staff/MPs
I'm influenced by knowing people who have been working in the nhs and care homes. DH has had to do shifts in Covid wards, cover the difficulties brought by Covid in his own specialty and also has volunteered as part of the vaccination programme. My mother is in a care home that have been so amazing through such a difficult time and have kept their vulnerable residents safe.
We will continue to do our bit as part of society to try not to make any of those people's lives more difficult by overwhelming the system. It's not fun and I wouldn't do it for any other reason but Covid doesn't stop being an issue because we are fed up, bored, frustrated or annoyed.
What I will also be doing is my utmost to make sure the shower of shit that is our current government is not voted back in again.

Tiptoearound · 19/12/2021 17:16

SoItWas

Of course but I’m unlikely to notice the odd visitor I’m referring to people who flagrantly break rules (many have commented here) the attitude that ‘I don’t care about any rules I’m still having 20 people over at Christmas’ these are the people that I would report if I know it’s happening, the people with several vehicles on the driveway types. Anyway no rules have been announced as yet so I don’t need to concern myself with it until such a time that it does change.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 17:08

Tiptoearound

Shit like that happens everyday. People die, have miscarriages, have mental health issues, etc. Many suffered alone in various ways, during the lockdowns. My point is, you shouldn't tar all non compliers with the same brush.

Ontherebound34 · 19/12/2021 17:06

It's easy to distort facts tho isn't it as you have just proved, taking a single fact and isolating it to try prove your point 🥱.

How about looking at the whole picture and it looks alot different, now add the following facts to your equation, the length of time on average it takes for un--vacinated parents to recover Vs vaccinated (time taking up beds), the percentage of these continuing to develop long COVID and the severity of their illness and also their risk to transmit the disease. Factor all these into your equation with facts and come back and say blaming them is rediculus. 🤔

Nope, still not the case that the problem lies with the relatively small number of unvaccinated people (not all of whom are anti vaccination I haste to add). As I said we have a very good uptake of vaccinations in this country yet we still have a huge problem with the number of cases and we would do even if we forced people to get vaccinated. There are many factors that affect the risk of hospitalisation. Vaccination status is one of them but by far not the only one and the vast majority of unvaccinated people are at extremely low risk of hospitalisation if they get Covid. I get that you want someone to blame for all this but it’s misguided. Boris and co are happy for you to blame the unvaccinated because it takes the heat off them.

And if you remember at the start of the vaccine programme, these wonder-scientists that we all trust implicitly said that only 70% of the population needed to be vaccinated to keep the virus under control. It seems that wasn’t the case at all.

SoItWas · 19/12/2021 16:57

Even with 100% vaccine uptake, if Omicron spreads as far and fast as feared, the NHS could still struggle to cope, on sheer numbers alone. How effective is the most effective vaccine? I was shocked to discover 40 in 100 PCR test results are false negatives.

Agreed arguing amongst ourselves isn't good. I'm not angry at anti-vaxxers though, I'm angry at the government. The pandemic has been badly managed, imo.

Tiptoearound · 19/12/2021 16:43

SoItWas

Seriously what are the chances of that compared to people just breaking any rules because they don’t think they should have to be following them. Last lockdown my neighbour further up my lane had 9 cars parked on their drive & it was clear from music, laughing & shouting that they were having a party..that is irresponsible & selfish, they were reported (not by me on that occasion I hasten to add but only because someone pipped me to the post) subsequently the police arrived & dispersed the revellers & neighbour got a fine

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 19/12/2021 16:41

I have been unbelievably sick this year after not having mixed with people last winter. I’ve had a month from hell with one virus or bug after the other. I have never been this sick in my life - including when I had COVID. I am not doing this bullshit again - I’m trying to keep covid out I have let everything else in. Everyone needs to get vaccinated and just be sensible. The critical cases in hospital of people with COVID (snd there because of it) sre unvaccinated. Sorry, that’s their own issue 🤷🏻‍♀️ People just love this as an excuse to police others, judge and finger wag.

hangrylady · 19/12/2021 16:36

Just look at the state of everyone, arguing about whether it's ok to see family at Christmas, surely the anger should be directed at those who refuse to be vaccinated, they are the problem. My mum and dad will be coming for Christmas regardless. All adults present around the table will be triple vaccinated so very low risk. I will not be told that we are irresponsible or selfish Angry

Dottybackorcid · 19/12/2021 16:32

@Ontherebound34

fullfact.org/health/economist-vaccination-status/

Facts on current hospital admissions. Rate of hospitalisation is higher in non-vaccinated people (35% of admissions versus 19% of population being unvaccinated) but more vaccinated than unvaccinated people are admitted to hospital with Covid. To blame it on them is ridiculous and distorts reality. Even if you held everyone of them down and forced a needle into their arm, you wouldn’t get rid of Covid or the possibility of restrictions.

It's easy to distort facts tho isn't it as you have just proved, taking a single fact and isolating it to try prove your point 🥱.

How about looking at the whole picture and it looks alot different, now add the following facts to your equation, the length of time on average it takes for un--vacinated parents to recover Vs vaccinated (time taking up beds), the percentage of these continuing to develop long COVID and the severity of their illness and also their risk to transmit the disease. Factor all these into your equation with facts and come back and say blaming them is rediculus. 🤔

Ontherebound34 · 19/12/2021 16:32

The number of ICU patients is minuscule compared to total infections and hospitalisations. With any vaccination programme you will never secure 100% compliance and trust me you don’t want to live in a society that demands this. We have an excellent take up of the vaccine. It is convenient and tempting to blame a group of people for what you see as ruining everyone’s fun but it’s not accurate here. There are also other factors affecting the severity of the virus that can be seen to be in someone’s control such as obesity so the intense focus on vaccination status is not logical. A 25 yr old unvaccinated person who is in good health has a far lower probability of hospital admission than an overweight diabetic in their 50s.

Swipe left for the next trending thread