Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP uncomfortable about a school run dad taking DD swimming

661 replies

Eastie77Returns · 18/12/2021 19:08

DD (8) will be attending swimming lessons at a new venue in the New Year. There are a couple of other kids in her class who attend lessons at the same pool, I am friends with both sets of parents. I was chatting to the dad of one of the kids and he mentioned that he and and the other child’s mum take it in turns to take both children swimming each week. He asked if I’d like to join the ‘rotation’ which would mean taking all 3 kids every 3 weeks and I said I’d be happy to. We all live a few minutes walk from each other and DD knows the 2 boys well. I’d already discussed this with the other mum so she is on board.

DP has announced he is uncomfortable about the arrangement as there is a male parent involved (when I originally mentioned the plan to him he thought it would only be mums). I think he is being absolutely ridiculous, I have known the school dad since our children were 2 years old and DD adores him.

However I discussed this with a friend who said she 100% understands why DP is unhappy and I need to see this from his point of view. AIBU??

OP posts:
sue20 · 19/12/2021 23:17

I think it’s a bit boringly paranoid. It doesn’t sound as though he would be in any contact with her changing wise. The % of male child sex abusers what would that be against non abusers? And anyway you have a good feeling about him and know him well. Your daughter perfectly capable of talking to you if anything came up. Is your DP perhaps a bit jealous of Another man taking her swimming? Not sexually just re important Growing up experience?

LouBan · 19/12/2021 23:16

I don't think I would have a problem with it as she can get changed in her own cubicle and there are two other kids there so it's not just her and the dad. You also know this dad well and trust him. Just because he is a man doesn't mean that something untoward will happen.
Having said that if DP is really uncomfortable with the situation I think it's best to respect that.

Ontheblink · 19/12/2021 23:12

I’m with your DP on this. I would not be sending my dd in this situation. Even if there is a 0.00001 chance of it happening, it’s a risk I would not be willing to take.

Hollywolly1 · 19/12/2021 23:12

I think its unfair to put your little girl in that position no matter how good the other dad is

Hollywolly1 · 19/12/2021 23:10

Everyone should take their own children swimming instead of farming them out to other people .If children were so much bother to take them swimming why have them

Chewbunn · 19/12/2021 23:09

It doesn't seem like the dad would be alone with her at any point, presumably if his child isn't going when it's his turn he also wouldn't walk them- so there'll always be at least one another person, and he isn't going near the changing rooms, which are very public anyway and wouldn't go unnoticed Confused. I agree with others that it's not fair to disregard his feelings on it, but Confused

OopsadayZ · 19/12/2021 23:09

@Eastie77Returns

It would be a mixed cubicle environment as they do not have male/female changing rooms at this pool. It’s a changing ‘village’ with individual cubicles.

DD would have her swimsuit on underneath her clothes beforehand and is more than capable of getting dressed herself after the lesson - she is almost 9!

DP says he has nothing against the dad personally but is just uncomfortable with the arrangement. He doesn’t know him particularly well but has met him many times on play dates in the park etc.

I understand abusers are usually known to their victims etc but have known this man for almost a decade and trust him completely. The chances of anything untoward happening with DD are less than zero. I just don’t know if I’m BU to disregard DP’s concerns.

You haven't known him for "nearly a decade"... you seem to have known him for 6.5 years.

Your DP isn't comfortable. So you shouldn't be doing it.

I wouldn't be entirely comfortable with it either. She's a girl...other kids are boys...and the Dad is a dad. Nothing untoward.... just doesn't sit right with me. Also she could start her periods at 9. I think a female adult or her Dad should be with her when swimming regularly.

explodingeyes · 19/12/2021 23:04

I should add that when I worked for a year at a swimming baths as a lifeguard, at least 50% of the parents bringing children to the pool for any reason, were dads. Including dads with daughters and their mates. Loads of dads take kids swimming. So on a typical day there would be a lot of dads milling about in all areas.
Staff do actually also keep an eye out for any unusual behaviours too and report and concerns.

saraclara · 19/12/2021 22:53

@marcopront

If the OP doesn't join this swimming supervision group then this man is there every other week. On those occasions he could be in the changing room, why is he not a problem then?
A good point, but wasted. Because the paranoia on here is absolutely impervious to reason. I've asked a similar question several time (about all the other dads in the changing area) and not got a single sane reply.
saraclara · 19/12/2021 22:52

@Eastie77Returns, maybe MrsPnut's post above is what your DH needs to read (or be told about).

marcopront · 19/12/2021 22:51

If the OP doesn't join this swimming supervision group then this man is there every other week.
On those occasions he could be in the changing room, why is he not a problem then?

saraclara · 19/12/2021 22:50

@MrsPnut

I am with you OP, I was a social worker on an initial assessment team (child protection), and I would have no concerns in the situation being proposed.

You’ve known him for years, your daughter has had multiple play dates at his house. He has had ample opportunity in the past if he had nefarious intents.
Swimming rota would mean one lesson in three he would walk all the kids to the pool, they would get changed in a unisex village in separate cubicles and go to their lesson. Come back after lessons to get changed again in separate cubicles when the village will be full of parents and carers hurrying up their child so they can go home.

How on earth would that be an ideal place to decide to abuse a child when they could have done it in their own home. There are all kinds of red flags for someone wanting to be inappropriately close to a child such as excessive tickling and engineering babysitting but standing in a changing village telling three kids to hurry up and get their socks on isn’t one.

Thank you for your (qualified and experienced) voice of reason.
explodingeyes · 19/12/2021 22:43

@Vynalbob have you only got very young children? At 9/10 they are old enough to go to toilets on their own and they don't need to all stick together in a changing facility with separate cubicles.
Parents would mainly just wait for the DC to shower and then go get themselves changed. They wouldn't generally slip on the wet floor as they aren't allowed by staff to run about.

liveforsummer · 19/12/2021 22:28

OP I agree with everything you've said. Dd1's best friend has a stay at home dad so he's facilitated a lot of play dates, trips and clubs over the years. It's common for 2 working parents round here, many in techy type jobs that have flexible hours so dads are as much a part of the extra curricular activities as mums. We lift share for brownies and guides with another couple of families and it's always the dad that does one families share. The other parent in the share is a long standing teacher at our girls school. I know the swimming involves changing but OP's child confidently does not need any assistance. It doesn't even sound like the dad enters the changing (like I don't for dd8's lessons).

Vynalbob · 19/12/2021 22:27

Unisex changing rooms / boy n girl + unrelated male.... If your right it still wouldn't sit right with me.... think of possible normal problems....
struggle changing wet
slip
one needs a wee
Two kids same sex easy works
Might not be extreme but I can see several chances of accidents or a split group.

At least I hope I give u a possible easy excuse out while taking your DH gut feeling into account.
I've ignored my gut feeling once or twice when younger as it was illogical (lack of any substance) but turned out my gut was spot on..... I always listen now no matter how daft I feel/sound.

ohreallynotreally · 19/12/2021 21:57

@Eastie77Returns

Thank you to those of you with balanced responses that have brought some sanity to the thread!

I've taken on board the comments that I cannot simply disregard DP's feelings. Fair enough. He has misgivings that he cannot articulate beyond "it is not appropriate" but I'm not going to just ride roughshod over this feelings.

However, laying that aside, some of the attitudes and comments on here are perplexing and depressing to say the least.

I see people are still commenting on the dangers of the lift share, DD being the last one left in the car...once again the dad will not be driving. Everyone walks to the swimming pool.

I’ve been accused of being lax because I’m not supervising DD whilst she swims. She’s attending a swimming lesson so there is a teacher and a lifeguard in the pool. No supervision from parents required.

I'm reading that some of you have 9 & 10 year old children who cannot dry and dress themselves/feel uncomfortable doing so and I'm putting DD at risk because she "might need help". Help with what? I’ve never met a NT 9 year old who cannot use a a towel and put their own clothes on. KS1 Primary school aged children who attend PE and swimming lessons have to do this on their own as teachers cannot help 30+ children.

As I've already pointed out, DD has been to his house for play dates over the last 8 years. On occasion in the last couple of years we have left her there (birthday parties, playing after school with his son and other kids) which would have given him ample opportunity to practice evil deeds. Instead, many of you think it is entirely feasible that he is going to wait until he takes DD swimming every 3 weeks, find some pretext to go into the changing village and engineer his way into her locked cubicle and then attempt to abuse her with other children close by.

Alternatively I've also read that he might try to abuse her on the walk home from the swimming pool whilst the other children walk on ahead. I can't even fathom what kind of scenario that would involve Confused

I'm aware many paedophiles brazenly abuse children in plain sight and I'm not trying to make light of the very real and serious issue of child sexual abuse but some of the comments on this thread are ridiculous. I'm not even going to comment on the "I've never left my DD with a man apart from DH" except to say that level of mistrust sounds exhausting and stressful.

I really don’t think that mumsnet is a good forum for critical thinking!! Agree with you OP 100% . My children all survived being ferried too and from after school activities from parents of both sex,,,they are perfectly fine adults without any problems! Just because there is the odd dodgy parent in society doesn’t mean that all adults are weirdos !!
tae19 · 19/12/2021 21:52

People are so over the top on here. Very very low risk. The idea that all men are abusers is horrible. And the comments - looking for children without "And attentive mother" so no dad can take their kid swimming?!
I'd have never been allowed as a child then because my mum died very young. In many people's world this means my dad could never have taken my friends swimming (he did). She is also nearly 9 not 3 she just needs and adult there and back not to dress her!!

explodingeyes · 19/12/2021 21:47

@MrsPnut

I am with you OP, I was a social worker on an initial assessment team (child protection), and I would have no concerns in the situation being proposed.

You’ve known him for years, your daughter has had multiple play dates at his house. He has had ample opportunity in the past if he had nefarious intents.
Swimming rota would mean one lesson in three he would walk all the kids to the pool, they would get changed in a unisex village in separate cubicles and go to their lesson. Come back after lessons to get changed again in separate cubicles when the village will be full of parents and carers hurrying up their child so they can go home.

How on earth would that be an ideal place to decide to abuse a child when they could have done it in their own home. There are all kinds of red flags for someone wanting to be inappropriately close to a child such as excessive tickling and engineering babysitting but standing in a changing village telling three kids to hurry up and get their socks on isn’t one.

Great post.
Islandgirl68 · 19/12/2021 21:46

I can see both sides and the dad probably thought it would be a good idea and he would only have to do it every third week and not every second week. If it is for lessons, it will be a busy place with other kids and parents milling about. If she is more than capable of getting dressed herself I don't see the problem. When my kids were that age, they got themselves dressed and I waited out in the reception area. Don't see what the problem is. Think people are thinking to much into this. Have you asked your child if she is happy with the arrangement. If hubby not happy is he going to do the swimming run.

explodingeyes · 19/12/2021 21:44

@Eastie77Returns

Thank you to those of you with balanced responses that have brought some sanity to the thread!

I've taken on board the comments that I cannot simply disregard DP's feelings. Fair enough. He has misgivings that he cannot articulate beyond "it is not appropriate" but I'm not going to just ride roughshod over this feelings.

However, laying that aside, some of the attitudes and comments on here are perplexing and depressing to say the least.

I see people are still commenting on the dangers of the lift share, DD being the last one left in the car...once again the dad will not be driving. Everyone walks to the swimming pool.

I’ve been accused of being lax because I’m not supervising DD whilst she swims. She’s attending a swimming lesson so there is a teacher and a lifeguard in the pool. No supervision from parents required.

I'm reading that some of you have 9 & 10 year old children who cannot dry and dress themselves/feel uncomfortable doing so and I'm putting DD at risk because she "might need help". Help with what? I’ve never met a NT 9 year old who cannot use a a towel and put their own clothes on. KS1 Primary school aged children who attend PE and swimming lessons have to do this on their own as teachers cannot help 30+ children.

As I've already pointed out, DD has been to his house for play dates over the last 8 years. On occasion in the last couple of years we have left her there (birthday parties, playing after school with his son and other kids) which would have given him ample opportunity to practice evil deeds. Instead, many of you think it is entirely feasible that he is going to wait until he takes DD swimming every 3 weeks, find some pretext to go into the changing village and engineer his way into her locked cubicle and then attempt to abuse her with other children close by.

Alternatively I've also read that he might try to abuse her on the walk home from the swimming pool whilst the other children walk on ahead. I can't even fathom what kind of scenario that would involve Confused

I'm aware many paedophiles brazenly abuse children in plain sight and I'm not trying to make light of the very real and serious issue of child sexual abuse but some of the comments on this thread are ridiculous. I'm not even going to comment on the "I've never left my DD with a man apart from DH" except to say that level of mistrust sounds exhausting and stressful.

Totally where I was coming from. I can not think of one parent of a 9/10 year old that wouldn't think it was totally fine. For exactly the reasons you state.
Kanaloa · 19/12/2021 21:41

@saraclara

Again, other children in the swimming class will have fathers with them. There will be other men in the changing area.

Can anyone explain to me why this man is somehow more of a risk to DD's daughter than any other father in that changing area?

Are the same people who are saying that OP shouldn't put her DD in this situation saying that NO men should be in the unisex changing area? Is OP's DH going to demand that all men be removed from the changing area while DD changes, or just this guy? The guy who he actually KNOWS?

Because I simply cannot get their logic.

Well firstly I do think changing rooms should be single sex. I don’t think women and girls should need to change in front of/alongside unknown men and boys. I also think there should be far better changing facilities with private family rooms/areas.

But if my child was changing in a mixed environment I’d like to be supervising and supporting them to ensure they are able to be kept safe/private from unknown people while changing.

saraclara · 19/12/2021 21:40

@ilovegingercats

I wouldn't allow this either I simply wouldn't take the risk.
What risk? The risk of him walking with DD and the two boys? Or the risk of him standing in the unisex changing room with all the other fathers? And could you actually explain to me what the risk is to DD of him doing either of those things?
saraclara · 19/12/2021 21:38

Again, other children in the swimming class will have fathers with them. There will be other men in the changing area.

Can anyone explain to me why this man is somehow more of a risk to DD's daughter than any other father in that changing area?

Are the same people who are saying that OP shouldn't put her DD in this situation saying that NO men should be in the unisex changing area? Is OP's DH going to demand that all men be removed from the changing area while DD changes, or just this guy? The guy who he actually KNOWS?

Because I simply cannot get their logic.

Tessabelle74 · 19/12/2021 21:27

My point is that women can and do abuse children yet we don't feel kids are unsafe with them! I feel terribly sad that all men are looked at with such suspicions, especially as I have 2 sons. I'm not scoffing at the statistics, merely pointing out that children are never 100% safe, especially as most of them know their abusers, but unless the child will be alone with an adult, chances are very high they'll be safe

JTK50 · 19/12/2021 21:25

@Eastie77Returns I was clearly referring to sexual abuse.