Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP uncomfortable about a school run dad taking DD swimming

661 replies

Eastie77Returns · 18/12/2021 19:08

DD (8) will be attending swimming lessons at a new venue in the New Year. There are a couple of other kids in her class who attend lessons at the same pool, I am friends with both sets of parents. I was chatting to the dad of one of the kids and he mentioned that he and and the other child’s mum take it in turns to take both children swimming each week. He asked if I’d like to join the ‘rotation’ which would mean taking all 3 kids every 3 weeks and I said I’d be happy to. We all live a few minutes walk from each other and DD knows the 2 boys well. I’d already discussed this with the other mum so she is on board.

DP has announced he is uncomfortable about the arrangement as there is a male parent involved (when I originally mentioned the plan to him he thought it would only be mums). I think he is being absolutely ridiculous, I have known the school dad since our children were 2 years old and DD adores him.

However I discussed this with a friend who said she 100% understands why DP is unhappy and I need to see this from his point of view. AIBU??

OP posts:
Eastie77Returns · 20/12/2021 01:25

@Insanelysilver

If it’s swimming lessons then he wouldn’t b getting in with her he kids. That would worry me if that was the case. There are other kids in the group but I’d worry if other kids were off swimming some weeks and my DC ended up as the only other kid with him in the car. I am a bit of a worrier though
For the now sixth time: there is no car involved
OP posts:
Rachie1973 · 20/12/2021 01:20

@Hertsgirl10

So no one finds it concerning that a social worker and child protection assessor thinks the risk is low because she’s known him 10 years?

Starting to see why how people get away with so much if this is really the view of a child protection officer.

Even foster carers are taught better than this about safeguarding children.

Would you all leave your kids with a childminder or after school club that didn’t have the right checks? Or a scouts club that didn’t have DBS checks? What’s the difference?

Just can’t imagine it myself and highly doubt a social worker and child protection officer would recommend this either, but it explains a lot about current events if this is how they’re protecting the vulnerable.

Actually we’re taught to risk assess. This is a risk that I would take with both my own children and my foster children.

We’re taught not to over protect because this can be damaging to a child as well. We’re supposed to let them have experiences and grow.

I do a school run rotation with a couple of local parents, none are DBS checked. I’m expected to use my own risk assessing skills to decide.

liveforsummer · 20/12/2021 00:58

There are other kids in the group but I’d worry if other kids were off swimming some weeks and my DC ended up as the only other kid with him in the car. I am a bit of a worrier though
If the dads dc was off swimming don't you think he'd be at home looking after his own child with one of the other parents stepping in rather than leaving him home alone so he could take other children swimming. People are really trying quite hard to invent possible scenarios here

Hertsgirl10 · 20/12/2021 00:55

[quote explodingeyes]@Hertsgirl10 whilst most adults in kids activities are dbs checked, I can totally guarantee not all are. Most grassroots or volunteer activities get round to them quite quickly but it's naive to think they all are before any volunteer work done.
DBS checks only highlight convicted offenders. Not suspected ones. Not ones with concerns raised. Not ones on a police radar. Cases can take 1-2 years at the moment to convict even if the evidence is clear.
Safeguarding is about weighing up situations, risks and looking out for certain signs [/quote]
@explodingeyes

I mean this is why it’s more important for parents to not just leave their kids with just anyone?

We should all know that even people with DBS checks could well have just not been caught yet, as much as they’re fully innocent.

Safeguarding my own children doesn’t come to weigh up or leave any space for an opportunity for anyone .. male, female, old or teens even, to get a chance.

But for the OP scenario I can see exactly where she’s coming from with her husband and why she would be confused as the daughter has spent time in this man’s house, so I wouldn’t understand why he’s not happy with this situation.

I think that people on here belittling other people’s safeguarding parenting style really should look up Adam Whittington and learn some safeguarding of their own, so many parents still put their kids pics on social media and names in their online bios or even dating profiles, and see no issue with this. I suspect a lot of mum’s here don’t either.
I know this post isn’t about that but there is quite a few worrying comments here.

NewtoHolland · 20/12/2021 00:27

I guess I just feel unfortunately childhood sexual abuse just isn't as rare a thing as we would all wish it was.

Some stats below may help to clarify this, look at the number of crimes identified in just one year in the UK. Yes some of these will be historical...but more than 1400 a week in the UK in 2018-2019. That is just the identified crimes...not all of the under the radar activity happening- for me I believe the visible stuff is the tip of the iceberg.

Below copied and pasted from ONS website-

The Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW) estimated that 7.5% of adults aged 18 to 74 years experienced sexual abuse before the age of 16 years (3.1 million people); this includes both adult and child perpetrators.

The abuse was most likely to have been perpetrated by a friend or acquaintance (37%); around a third (30%) were sexually abused by a stranger.

The majority of victims did not tell anyone about their sexual abuse at the time, with “embarrassment” being the most common reason.

In the year ending March 2019, the police in England and Wales recorded 73,260 sexual offences where there are data to identify the victim was a child.

CheeseMmmm · 20/12/2021 00:26

What position is she putting her 8yo in?

She's having swimming lessons, walking with 2 children she knows, with a dad she knows. It's a changing village mixed sex, individual locking cubicles. Getting ready she has swimmers on already just takes off top layer. Not tricky or revealing.

Parent taking 3 8yo swimming lesson, two children in his care. He will go in changing village (same as the other parents), get 3 cubicles close together as possible, hover between them, hurry them up, when they emerge watch them head off to pool.

Then he'll breath a sigh of relief same as the other parents and there will be a large exodus to cafe to spend 30 mins drinking coffee and looking at phone.

Head back changing in a herd of parents when they get out. Cubicles hover what do you mean you can't find your socks. Out walk home. He may end up carrying all the bags while they do their 8yo children stuff.

What position is she being put in?

explodingeyes · 20/12/2021 00:21

@Hertsgirl10 whilst most adults in kids activities are dbs checked, I can totally guarantee not all are. Most grassroots or volunteer activities get round to them quite quickly but it's naive to think they all are before any volunteer work done.
DBS checks only highlight convicted offenders. Not suspected ones. Not ones with concerns raised. Not ones on a police radar. Cases can take 1-2 years at the moment to convict even if the evidence is clear.
Safeguarding is about weighing up situations, risks and looking out for certain signs

explodingeyes · 20/12/2021 00:09

@Hollywolly1

I think its unfair to put your little girl in that position no matter how good the other dad is
ReallyHmm my DD would object if she couldn't just walk with her mates to swimming.
CheeseMmmm · 20/12/2021 00:06

For me it goes-

**The vast majority of parents are actively interested in protecting their children.
Sexual abuse is nightmare scenario, and I doubt anyone has managed to miss all the need stories over the years, all the info in ads, it coming up in conversation sometimes etc.

The number of parents who either aren't aware of sexual abuse being a risk in general and that offenders are usually trusted and cunning and happy to take their time. Must be be pretty low.

** Parents in general are doing their best for their children. They want them to be safe, happy, risk taking/wary to appropriate levels as they grow up. Rounded, confident, sensible, risk aware. So as they go through life they have learnt to be wary /take risks as appropriate.

** I would say without doubt that on this thread posters are not unaware of, indifferent to the fact that children can and are molested by trusted men, and you can't tell who is which.

** Everyone has different fears, different experiences, different levels of risk level for different things.

The idea that either 'sides' of this argument are going to have a terrible impact on children is unhelpful, and unless it affects massive part of child's life and is extreme. Well it's not right to say generally this will mean terrible things for children.

And in the end. It's not like either side will say oh yeah that's true actually and completely change their deeply embedded attitudes to various risks. It's just upsetting for loads of people esp with personal reasons for their views.

Insanelysilver · 19/12/2021 23:52

If it’s swimming lessons then he wouldn’t b getting in with her he kids. That would worry me if that was the case.
There are other kids in the group but I’d worry if other kids were off swimming some weeks and my DC ended up as the only other kid with him in the car. I am a bit of a worrier though

Vynalbob · 19/12/2021 23:50

[quote explodingeyes]@Vynalbob have you only got very young children? At 9/10 they are old enough to go to toilets on their own and they don't need to all stick together in a changing facility with separate cubicles.
Parents would mainly just wait for the DC to shower and then go get themselves changed. They wouldn't generally slip on the wet floor as they aren't allowed by staff to run about.

[/quote]
Yep lots of (not recent) experience and also the experience to know Sod's Law sometimes kicks you when you least expect it... especially if your predicting the actions of children and the competence of staff.
9/10 times it will be fine but I'd want better odds and wouldn't dismiss my OH s feelings even if I thought them unfounded.

catzwhiskas · 19/12/2021 23:49

As I said before, in the past I was trusting and assumed the best of people . This was a mistake and I now know that this is exactly how children are endangered. I am not saying that this particular man is dangerous but he is as likely to be as not. And we should revert to single sex facilities as the evidence shows that more sexual offences to women and girls happen in mixed sex spaces. And I have also been involved in foster care and social work and the scales have totally fallen from my eyes. I wish the posters here who thing some of us are too extreme would consider our evidence and experience more carefully. Being kind to the men does not make us or our children safer.

bigyellowTpot · 19/12/2021 23:43

I remember being taken swimming a few times by a friend's dad at that age and all was fine. now most changing areas are mixed family and not separated male & female but should imagine she will have to go In a cubical on her own.
I totally understand your dh concerns though and not sure I'd be comfortable with it myself to be honest even though I was taken by a dad myself at that age.
I have been shocked in the past when I have discovered a couple of men in my local area, one a school dad were found out to be pedophiles and it being in the local newspaper.
These men were the nicest, most friendliest men you could meet you would never suspect them of anything like that. one even worked as a PCSO. for this reason I will never entirely trust any man other than my dp and df around my children.

CheeseMmmm · 19/12/2021 23:39

Perfect storm yes you are generally right of course.

In this case though, that would mean no playdates? Should OP be concerned that he has already abused? There will I'm sure have been opportunities with two families with same age children and families been friends for 6 years?

Thinking 8yo,

When it comes to boys there seems to be a lot of determined men who abuse via roles.
Football coaches, religious leaders, teachers, scout leaders, that sort of thing. Get into positions of trust and then seemingly often with a network of like minded men, carry out widespread long term, systematic abuse.

Can there be a balance? How to approach that? Yes of course (apart from teachers) those are not compulsory and can just not do. How can that risk be squared with child being able to pursue interests etc?

Of course for girls all the above. Plus many more abused and wider range of methods common. (Which also apply to boys obv). Opportunistic, grooming, attacked at school by boy/s (think/hope uncommon that young but we don't really know), etc etc.

Given that no one can tell which men are paedophilic abusers.

What is the actual answer?

saraclara · 19/12/2021 23:37

@LittleMissUnreasonable

Only on Mumsnet do you get women moaning that men don't do enough with the children and need to 'step up and parent', yet when a dad offers to help other mum's out by taking their DCs swimming, they're practically branded as paedos... Hmm disgusting.

Also reminds me of a thread where a SAHDad couldn't go to a baby group as one mum was breastfeeding Hmm no wonder men have such a hard time 'parenting' if this is what they're up against.

Yep. I need to walk away from this thread. The hypocrisy in addition to the paranoia is making me fear for people's powers of reason and logic.

Fortunately, in real life, I've never come across such ridiculousness.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 23:36

I agree with what you’ve just said and so you must understand surely that some of us would have concerns about and would rather not take the risk, given your personally experience.

Mirw · 19/12/2021 23:35

No. DP is being unreasonable. Kids need to get to know people outside the family who are safe. You didn't just meet this man yesterday. You have known him a long time. This is the reason why so many young people today think they have to report adults who simply look at them to the police... They have at no time spent any time with anyone other than family. As you say most kids are abused by relatives or coaches...
If DP won't trust your daughter to this man, he needs to explain it to the man and then commit to doing the swim run himself.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 23:32

[quote Changechangychange]@Hertsgirl10 are you saying your children can’t go on play dates unless the other parents are DBS checked?

Surely you see the difference between an eight year old being walked from their home to the swimming pool, in a group of children, supervised by one of their parents, and a formal childcare setting?[/quote]
@Changechangychange
Yes i have already been called a shit parent with nervous wreck children for that tonight 😂

I leave my children with a few people that I trust, I don’t risk their safety, for the many reasons that, like the victims of abuse on this post have said, and ignored.

MrsPnut · 19/12/2021 23:32

@Hertsgirl10

So no one finds it concerning that a social worker and child protection assessor thinks the risk is low because she’s known him 10 years?

Starting to see why how people get away with so much if this is really the view of a child protection officer.

Even foster carers are taught better than this about safeguarding children.

Would you all leave your kids with a childminder or after school club that didn’t have the right checks? Or a scouts club that didn’t have DBS checks? What’s the difference?

Just can’t imagine it myself and highly doubt a social worker and child protection officer would recommend this either, but it explains a lot about current events if this is how they’re protecting the vulnerable.

What social workers are taught to do is assess risk, there could be a million risks identified in the course of a conversation when someone has known a person for years but in the facts that have been disclosed here, I would have few concerns.

I don’t think just length of time known is a good thing, I do think actions of a person over the length of time you have known them is an indicator of the level of risk they pose.
My DH worked with someone for years, we weren’t friends outside work and he had very high level security clearance. It came as a massive shock to everyone when he was convicted for having CSA images in his computer. You need
To judge people on what they do and abusers don’t in my experience pass up opportunities like play dates in their home.

LittleMissUnreasonable · 19/12/2021 23:32

Only on Mumsnet do you get women moaning that men don't do enough with the children and need to 'step up and parent', yet when a dad offers to help other mum's out by taking their DCs swimming, they're practically branded as paedos... Hmm disgusting.

Also reminds me of a thread where a SAHDad couldn't go to a baby group as one mum was breastfeeding Hmm no wonder men have such a hard time 'parenting' if this is what they're up against.

Changechangychange · 19/12/2021 23:27

@Hertsgirl10 are you saying your children can’t go on play dates unless the other parents are DBS checked?

Surely you see the difference between an eight year old being walked from their home to the swimming pool, in a group of children, supervised by one of their parents, and a formal childcare setting?

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 23:20

So no one finds it concerning that a social worker and child protection assessor thinks the risk is low because she’s known him 10 years?

Starting to see why how people get away with so much if this is really the view of a child protection officer.

Even foster carers are taught better than this about safeguarding children.

Would you all leave your kids with a childminder or after school club that didn’t have the right checks? Or a scouts club that didn’t have DBS checks? What’s the difference?

Just can’t imagine it myself and highly doubt a social worker and child protection officer would recommend this either, but it explains a lot about current events if this is how they’re protecting the vulnerable.

Kanaloa · 19/12/2021 23:20

@saraclara

I’ve actually replied to you about all the other dads more than once. I’ve said that firstly I dislike mixed sex changing rooms, and also that I would rather be with my children when they are changing around unfamiliar strange men.

I don’t think that’s en extremist point of view really.

perfectstorm · 19/12/2021 23:19

[quote Bovrilly]@perfectstorm

I think the assumption that all kids can manage as well as your own is perhaps misplaced.

This is about the OP's child, not mine (about whom you know nothing) and unlike you I am not assuming anything - by the time you posted she had made it perfectly clear that her DD was capable of changing by herself. She had also made it clear that the man in question would be walking the children to and from the pool and waiting in the cafe while they were swimming. And yet you still spouted this rubbish about the DD being at risk while he performed "unsupervised intimate care". Absolute nonsense.[/quote]
I appreciate that there may be something in your own life right now that is fuelling your anger, but it's not exactly helping your point when you choose to make it in such a needlessly unpleasant and spiteful way. Why don't you try to engage like one human being, talking to another? It's not personal, surely, so why doggedly seek to make it so?

It's not just about the OP's child, when poster after poster blithely insists that abuse is very rare, and that women are just as likely to be abusive. Both are simply wrong, and the beliefs place children at risk. Grooming happens slowly and if the OP's partner is uneasy, as she says herself a discussion needs to be had on why.

Abuse doesn't happen because a young child can or can't dress themselves, anyway (though I have already conceded that I was considering my own child's abilities there, not the OP's). It happens when there is an opportunity for an adult to exert their authority to cross boundaries, and with a known abuser, it's generally a slow process, and opportunistic. Which is why some of us are very clear on our own boundaries. Our children will be the safer for it, and it's hard to fathom why people confident in their own choices are made so angry by our own. It doesn't affect your children, does it.

All I know is that abuse is common, and the best way to prevent it is to be extremely cautious until they reach a stage where they can recognise their own boundaries, and enforce them. In my view, 9 is too small for that. And if the OP's partner is expressing unease, then it's presumably similar for him (though I do get what she means about playdates etc.).

Mamanyt · 19/12/2021 23:18

Well, here's a fine quandry, no? A MAN is stepping up and being a responsible father, and another man is concerned about it. Now, had that same father refused to take part in this, and his wife had posted about it here, we'd have been up in arms, reminding her that he is a parent, too!

And so many answers indicating concern...I understand a general concern, but OP has stated that she has known this man for ten years and trusts him. Ten years, people. And please, let's not forget that women can be sexual preditors, as well, and often are.