Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP uncomfortable about a school run dad taking DD swimming

661 replies

Eastie77Returns · 18/12/2021 19:08

DD (8) will be attending swimming lessons at a new venue in the New Year. There are a couple of other kids in her class who attend lessons at the same pool, I am friends with both sets of parents. I was chatting to the dad of one of the kids and he mentioned that he and and the other child’s mum take it in turns to take both children swimming each week. He asked if I’d like to join the ‘rotation’ which would mean taking all 3 kids every 3 weeks and I said I’d be happy to. We all live a few minutes walk from each other and DD knows the 2 boys well. I’d already discussed this with the other mum so she is on board.

DP has announced he is uncomfortable about the arrangement as there is a male parent involved (when I originally mentioned the plan to him he thought it would only be mums). I think he is being absolutely ridiculous, I have known the school dad since our children were 2 years old and DD adores him.

However I discussed this with a friend who said she 100% understands why DP is unhappy and I need to see this from his point of view. AIBU??

OP posts:
Forsure69 · 21/12/2021 19:22

"Don’t forget that DP also MUST have strange tendencies if this is how he thinks… but fella from the school is 100% a trusted person cos (not all men)"

@Hertsgirl10
Oh absolutely!! Such scandal to think irrationally of thy neighbour!

Hertsgirl10 · 21/12/2021 18:46

@Forsure69

How very sad!! It's highly unacceptable to place boundaries and have people respect them otherwise your child will have mental health issue! Such bollocks!

Imagine ignoring a father's (possible) instinct- he doesn't feel comfortable- yet he is unreasonable! The world we live in today is toxic. People who choose to say no are the crazy ones causing mental issues- ok!
Hang on while I freely hand my kids over to you even tho my husband has concerns but who cares what he thinks cause your so such a nice person! It's nice that you devalue your partners feelings!

@Forsure69

Don’t forget that DP also MUST have strange tendencies if this is how he thinks… but fella from the school is 100% a trusted person cos (not all men)

gerryk62 · 21/12/2021 17:52

LIsten to your head

LovelyIssues · 21/12/2021 17:46

I wouldn't have an issue with it but I know my DH would absolutely not have it.

massiveblob · 21/12/2021 13:40

I guess children being sent alone to communal single sex changing rooms is a reason why the norm now is mixed single cubicle village type ones.
They are deemed safer.
A parent on own, going swimming and changing themselves with children too big to all cram into one cubicle, has to take their eye off kids at some point.
(Only ever 1/2 family ones for those with really little kids)
My DH always took the DC swimming and all just went in a cubicle each post age 6/7 or so.
But according to some posters, really the only truely safe way is to stand by child's cubicle watching.
But then when do you get changed? Make them wait first?
I think reality is that everyone just changes.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 21/12/2021 13:13

@Drunkpanda

You do know if it's single sex changing rooms by 8 all the boy children need to be waved off by their mothers with never a worry for their own safety? But you are suggesting helping a girl until she's 11?
In the real world lots of fathers take their daughters out and about and send them off to the ladies without thinking twice too.

We actually started doing it when I was with them in preparation for this occurring so that I could go after them if the need occurred. The only thing that has happened was another women helping younger DD turn a tap on.

My teenage niece managed to lock herself in a shower once though...

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 21/12/2021 13:04

@Drunkpanda

You do know if it's single sex changing rooms by 8 all the boy children need to be waved off by their mothers with never a worry for their own safety? But you are suggesting helping a girl until she's 11?
I've asked about 3 times now why this seems to be the case. So far no one has explained it.
marcopront · 21/12/2021 13:00

@Mousemay

Haven't you read what I said we do teach her how to react and give her confidence that she can always speak to us no matter what the situation. You respond as if we don't allow male interaction and hide her away Confused
You said you speak to her about what to do. That is different to giving her the opportunity to practise those skills.
Forsure69 · 21/12/2021 12:50

How very sad!!
It's highly unacceptable to place boundaries and have people respect them otherwise your child will have mental health issue! Such bollocks!

Imagine ignoring a father's (possible) instinct- he doesn't feel comfortable- yet he is unreasonable! The world we live in today is toxic. People who choose to say no are the crazy ones causing mental issues- ok!
Hang on while I freely hand my kids over to you even tho my husband has concerns but who cares what he thinks cause your so such a nice person! It's nice that you devalue your partners feelings!

Drunkpanda · 21/12/2021 12:48

You do know if it's single sex changing rooms by 8 all the boy children need to be waved off by their mothers with never a worry for their own safety? But you are suggesting helping a girl until she's 11?

BraveGoldie · 21/12/2021 12:33

@massiveblob

Those saying the child is at risk whilst getting changed in a cubicle. This is what happens at school swim lessons when male teachers and staff are present also. I don't know how you eliminate it. At age 8/9/10 my DD would not have expected me to lurk right outside her cubicle. (I'd be getting changed in my own one). By 9 most pools allow them to swim alone if competent. What age would you deem safe? Or never?
It's a tough one. I would be surprised if male swim teachers at schools are allowed in a shared sex change area. If they are I wouldn't be super comfortable with that, but it strikes me as lower risk, as it would be just one man, rather than multiple allowed in that space, and there would be numerous girls there, all of who know each other and know the swim coach, so there would be more of a sense of being watched.

As for what age is ok in communal swimming change spaces....this is obviously a sliding scale. I do feel age 8-10 is possibly the most delicate age, as girls and boys are independent enough to dress on their own, so may be left alone from a practical point of view.... yet they are often prepubescent/ just beginning to develop, but not fully absorbed senses of privacy/ appropriateness/ developed a radar for who is around them/ have the wisdom to suspect/ critically consider adults' approaches to them (Eg questioning whether to open a cubicle door if an adult asks)....

Younger, it is obvious they need supervision. And older - say 11+ they are a bit more mature to understand risks, to be able to talk through and retain basic guidance around protecting their privacy and personal space, more natural questioning of adults, more cemented friendships to look out for each other and know if something inappropriate is happening.

These things are all multiple sliding scales of risks, and also knowing your own child. There is also a sliding scale of how much you monitor. I'm not saying at 9, you need to be literally standing guard at the cubicle door- but changing in next cubicle, or making sure you know where she is, staying in the shared area and calling to check all ok/ being within sight line etc feels appropriate... another year older, if she is with a girl friend whose maturity I trust, after a couple of instructions to stay close to each other, I might sit outside the room and pop in once to check all ok. Another year or two, I'd probably be fine with the cafe option.

Mousemay · 21/12/2021 12:32

Haven't you read what I said we do teach her how to react and give her confidence that she can always speak to us no matter what the situation. You respond as if we don't allow male interaction and hide her away Confused

marcopront · 21/12/2021 12:22

@Mousemay

I never said I never allowed my dd to go anywhere with anyone and it's a huge assumption that because we are careful that we never explain how/what to do if a situation arises and therefore she is going to grow up not knowing how to be with men. We do our best to teach her how to handle situations and lots of other things that help her have boundaries. We're not going around dragging her away from men shouting watch out for the monster ffs!
Isn't part of teaching them to be safe putting them in a controlled environment with information on how to react.
Mousemay · 21/12/2021 12:15

I never said I never allowed my dd to go anywhere with anyone and it's a huge assumption that because we are careful that we never explain how/what to do if a situation arises and therefore she is going to grow up not knowing how to be with men. We do our best to teach her how to handle situations and lots of other things that help her have boundaries. We're not going around dragging her away from men shouting watch out for the monster ffs!

Fanmango · 21/12/2021 12:08

@Mousemay

I accept your point however when you are a victim of sexual abuse it never leaves you and you remember the opportunities that these people took to carry out the abuse. I think when you don't have that experience you see men and the world in a different way. I wish we had the luxury of seeing men through your eyes but unfortunately many, many people don't and all we have is the power to reduce the risk and try to prevent it happening to our own. That's not paranoia that's just common sense.
Its not common sense to never let a child go anywhere with a man when they won't be alone with them at any point though. The women I went to university with who had the most reckless approach to being around men were those who admit to having very over protective parents growing up. Of course make risk assessments, be wary, but its important, sadly, to equip children with confidence in what to do
Geppili · 21/12/2021 12:01

Listen to your husband. Better safe than sorry.

massiveblob · 21/12/2021 11:56

Those saying the child is at risk whilst getting changed in a cubicle. This is what happens at school swim lessons when male teachers and staff are present also. I don't know how you eliminate it. At age 8/9/10 my DD would not have expected me to lurk right outside her cubicle. (I'd be getting changed in my own one).
By 9 most pools allow them to swim alone if competent.
What age would you deem safe? Or never?

Mousemay · 21/12/2021 11:28

I accept your point however when you are a victim of sexual abuse it never leaves you and you remember the opportunities that these people took to carry out the abuse. I think when you don't have that experience you see men and the world in a different way. I wish we had the luxury of seeing men through your eyes but unfortunately many, many people don't and all we have is the power to reduce the risk and try to prevent it happening to our own. That's not paranoia that's just common sense.

BlingLoving · 21/12/2021 10:50

@Mousemay

Sadly a friend told me about her dads life long friend who had went on holidays with them and knew since she was a baby. They all had a shared hobby and got to the point where one time the father couldn't go on the booked dive so it was just the daughter and the fathers friend that went on the excursion. He raped her that night and she could never bring herself to tell her dad as it was his lifelong friend. I never trust anyone to take my dd due to my own experiences and others that I learned of in group therapy which were all always known to the family. You can never be too careful especially on an activity where she will be undressing.
That is an awful story. But the issue with stories like this for me is that there are lots of awful stories - a child killed in a car accident A child drowned A child killed by running across the road A child killed when they fell off their bike

But in most cases, we all continue to allow our children to travel in cars, walk on roads, ride their bikes, swim etc. We do it all with the best processes in place to protect them. But when it comes to abuse, one story is enough to decide a child should never be with another adult besides its mother ever again. We need genuine risk assessment in each case, not blanket decision making that doesn't take real risks into account.

An example - there is a small pedestrian bridge on one side of my road and on the other there is a small pedestrianised path that runs parallel to the main road leading from my road to another main road. Many families I know are paranoid about the pedestrian bridge and won't allow their children to walk on it. However, the bridge and the path leading to it are well lit, there is nowhere for anyone to hide and, in the nearly 15 years I have lived here, I have not heard of a single incident there (although DS does tell me that sometimes the teenagers will be there teasing each other and messing about a bit).

The other path however, while overlooked by not one but two main roads, is very dark (at night) and has many bushes. I am aware of at least 2 muggings on that path, one in broad daylight. But no one thinks twice about walking up and down it.

Risk assessment is poor.

Skeumorph · 21/12/2021 10:45

@Mischance

How sad it is that all men are assumed to be abusers until proven otherwise. When did we all become so afraid of half the human race? I would hate to be a man, or to have sons. What a state we are in.

This child will be in a car with other children and not on her own with this perceived threat.

Unless he has evidence that this man is some sort of threat then I think he is BU.

Yes it is sad isn’t it?

Make that point to the MEN because they are the only ones who are responsible for it and the only ones who can change it.

Mousemay · 21/12/2021 10:38

Mischance- the stats are there have a look. March 2020 4.9 million sexual crimes against females. 98.5%committed by males. Sadly it is now the world we live in and boundaries and safeguarding are there for a reason.

Whywonttheyhelpme · 21/12/2021 10:37

Some of these posts are utterly ridiculous.

OP the only way you can 100% guarantee your child’s safety is to take her yourself. However you know deep down the chances of this guy doing anything to your DD are slim to nil.

Not all men are perverts
Not all women are safe, so why trust the other mum and not the dad.
He is going to be in a public place with other children and parents present.
You DD knows him well & has been to their house for play dates- she is comfortable with this guy.

FavouriteMug · 21/12/2021 10:37

How many times on this forum do we (as women), tell each other to trust our gut feeling or instinct?

Your husbands 'gut' is telling him he's unhappy.

Do we ignore men's feelings on safeguarding now and only listen to our own?

Hertsgirl10 · 21/12/2021 10:35

@Double3xposure

Thank you *@Hertsgirl10 and @HangingOutWithTheSandman* for so eloquently making my point for me.
@Double3xposure

I didn’t realise you had one, what you said just sounded like strange assumptions and judgements, and was irrelevant to what anyone said.

Mousemay · 21/12/2021 10:30

Sadly a friend told me about her dads life long friend who had went on holidays with them and knew since she was a baby. They all had a shared hobby and got to the point where one time the father couldn't go on the booked dive so it was just the daughter and the fathers friend that went on the excursion. He raped her that night and she could never bring herself to tell her dad as it was his lifelong friend. I never trust anyone to take my dd due to my own experiences and others that I learned of in group therapy which were all always known to the family. You can never be too careful especially on an activity where she will be undressing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread