Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP uncomfortable about a school run dad taking DD swimming

661 replies

Eastie77Returns · 18/12/2021 19:08

DD (8) will be attending swimming lessons at a new venue in the New Year. There are a couple of other kids in her class who attend lessons at the same pool, I am friends with both sets of parents. I was chatting to the dad of one of the kids and he mentioned that he and and the other child’s mum take it in turns to take both children swimming each week. He asked if I’d like to join the ‘rotation’ which would mean taking all 3 kids every 3 weeks and I said I’d be happy to. We all live a few minutes walk from each other and DD knows the 2 boys well. I’d already discussed this with the other mum so she is on board.

DP has announced he is uncomfortable about the arrangement as there is a male parent involved (when I originally mentioned the plan to him he thought it would only be mums). I think he is being absolutely ridiculous, I have known the school dad since our children were 2 years old and DD adores him.

However I discussed this with a friend who said she 100% understands why DP is unhappy and I need to see this from his point of view. AIBU??

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 18/12/2021 22:29

@Eastie77Returns

I am very sorry to read the accounts of those of you who have suffered sexual abuse and I’m not downplaying the potential risks children face, a close relative is a social worker and I’ve heard some horrific stories, but I do not believe DD is at risk. I realise some think this makes me appear naive, so be it.

It seems a few people haven’t read all my posts: the dad will not be in or hanging around outside DD’s cubicle; he will not be in the pool; he is not driving to the swimming pool or driving her home.

We have known him and his wife since DD was a year old. He is not a dad I’ve recently met or casually befriended at the school gates. The suggestion that be creepily offered to take DD swimming is very unpleasant. The other mum mentioned it first, I followed up with him and he explained the rotation they have in place so I said I’d be happy to join in.

If his objective was to abuse DD I’m guessing the dozens of times she has been to his house on play dates would have presented an easier opportunity than a crowded swimming pool changing village.

DP cannot take her as the lesson clashes with work. He says he has no problem with the dad (“a nice guy”) but thinks it is inappropriate for DD to go alone with a male parent.

Hello OP

I made a suggestion earlier how to proceed.

You need to ask him questions. Uncomfortable with no reasons is too vague.

Ask him what exactly he feels uncomfy about. Get to bottom of it.

I put a load of questions up earlier. But if he says what exactly is worried about happening in practice in this scenario, and why he thinks the friend might be iffy in whatever way. Then ok.

If he's just uncomfy generally because dad is man, then in this situation, with no solid reasons at all, super low risk and bloke know well and he has no reason other than cos man.

Then he's being unreasonable.

IMO.

Crayzeefrog · 18/12/2021 22:29

DH always makes sure I can come when he offers to take DSD and her friends swimming and he always mentions that it’s both of us going when he speaks to the parents to invite the child. If I couldn’t come at the last minute he would change the activity. It’s sad that he has to do it but it’s covering his own back as much as anything else.

Changechangychange · 18/12/2021 22:26

If this man was offering to share the lifts to brownies, or football, would everyone be crying “no he might abuse her”? It’s no different.

There are people on this thread saying their children are not allowed on play dates, or to afterschool activities, or allowed to be anywhere where there might be men other than their father present, unless their mother is there to chaperone. So I think responses would be similar whether this was swimming or basketweaving club, unfortunately.

ohreallynotreally · 18/12/2021 22:26

So all the dads that uses to take my sons to rugby / football matches ,sometimes involving overnight sleepovers were all potential child molesters ! What a crazy way of thinking…never ever crossed my mind that there was a weirdo taking my children to their fun,sporting fixtures!
TBH how would families manage if they don’t rely on helping with transport etc …it’s just normal helpful favours that every parent has got involved in , for many years! It’s part of being a Mum/Dad 🤦‍♀️

BlingLoving · 18/12/2021 22:22

If his objective was to abuse DD I’m guessing the dozens of times she has been to his house on play dates would have presented an easier opportunity than a crowded swimming pool changing village.

This. People’s understanding of risk and ability to assess it is massively skewed.

CheeseMmmm · 18/12/2021 22:22

Oh no getting fighty. Because people feel defensive about comments saying paranoid, overprotective / no understanding of risk,

And that is absolutely 100% understandable, natural. Especially on a topic as massively sensitive and sometimes v personal topic of child sexual abuse.

I hope no one gets too upset.

It's AIBU fight club, words on a screen.

And the thread is a situation where the two parents totally disagree, one is in the why risk it camp and the other in situation risk totally massively tiny too tiny to refuse a handy friendly offer to take turns.

It's not about, or shouldn't be, judgement, upset, anger between women posting in response. We have enough judgement from media society about everything, without knocking 7 bells out of each other as well.

Anyway yes always the way esp on AIBU and that's just how it is.

Hope no posters with v personal reasons for views get upset though. Through history of abuse of worst imaginable. Or thinking about it the obviously nowhere near as bad but still unpleasant memories of a childhood with very little freedom for years and years.

Sorry for weird post in middle of gunfight :)

Mum1224 · 18/12/2021 22:22

A family member was wary of a male in a different situation being responsible for the kids. Let’s say an after school activity (don’t want to be specific as will be outing). She was told to stop being silly and paranoid. She took her child out of activity. Years later her fears were right and he had abused a number of the kids. Kids didn’t say anything to anyone at the time so abuse continued, only when older a few of them spoke about it. By this time that scum had had access to a number of kids as no one questioned and were too scared to say anything.

Read the book “gift of fear”. Intuition is to be trusted.

user1471543683 · 18/12/2021 22:17

This wouldn't bother me in the slightest. I live in a small village and when my kids started a new club or class you looked to see if there were any other kids from the village there so parents could share lifts. Loads of parents did this. But then I don't go around consumed with the thought that every male in a pedo.

MattDamon · 18/12/2021 22:15

OP, you say your partner knows or has met this man quite a few times, right? Men usually know what other men pretty well. If your partner has concenrs, you should listen. Better to be safe than sorry.

This. My grandfather, who rarely had a bad word to say about anyone, once told me to be wary of men other men didn't like.

Waitwhatwhy · 18/12/2021 22:14

I’m getting really sad as well as angry reading this thread. When did this happen that we can’t trust our friends to take our dc anywhere? I couldn’t have lived through my dc younger years like this, distrusting every man I knew, never letting my dc do anything with friends because their dad would be there. It’s so sad.
Yes most abusers are male. But this scenario is simply a dad walking 3 children somewhere and back home. No more than that.
My dc are only teenage but this seems to be so different from even their childhood.

Eastie77Returns · 18/12/2021 22:13

I am very sorry to read the accounts of those of you who have suffered sexual abuse and I’m not downplaying the potential risks children face, a close relative is a social worker and I’ve heard some horrific stories, but I do not believe DD is at risk. I realise some think this makes me appear naive, so be it.

It seems a few people haven’t read all my posts: the dad will not be in or hanging around outside DD’s cubicle; he will not be in the pool; he is not driving to the swimming pool or driving her home.

We have known him and his wife since DD was a year old. He is not a dad I’ve recently met or casually befriended at the school gates. The suggestion that be creepily offered to take DD swimming is very unpleasant. The other mum mentioned it first, I followed up with him and he explained the rotation they have in place so I said I’d be happy to join in.

If his objective was to abuse DD I’m guessing the dozens of times she has been to his house on play dates would have presented an easier opportunity than a crowded swimming pool changing village.

DP cannot take her as the lesson clashes with work. He says he has no problem with the dad (“a nice guy”) but thinks it is inappropriate for DD to go alone with a male parent.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 18/12/2021 22:12

@user1471447863

Seems to be a Mumsnet thing - a dad is either branded a waste of space for not getting involved enough or labeled a potential molester if he is involved with his children. On here a man can do no right.

In this particular scenario, it seems the accompanying adults role is to escort a small group of children (friends) from the door of their homes to the door of the changing village at the local pool. They then retreat to the cafe for an overpriced, watered down coffee and try to not get too bored for the next hour untill the children reappear at the door of said changing village with or without most of their belongings and then walks them home again.
As op has said this is an afternoon where the pool runs lessons there is likely to be very little general public too, mostly a continuous rotation of children and parents.
The risk while never zero, is negligible and can be further mitigate by op and her daughter having open lines of communication/a culture of safe sharing etc (which is ideal regardless of this situation) - so if the once every 3 weeks 'dodgy Dave' decides to start meeting them at the cubicles rather than the cafe or starts offering to dry her hair then OP will know about it and put an end to it if need be.
At the same time, when OP's husband has to take his daughter and the 2 other boys he'll have to promise not to molester the boys while he's there too - cos you know, all men etc

Nobody is saying a father is a ‘molester’ for trying to get involved with his own kids.

They’re simply saying it’s understandable that a parent might object to an unrelated male taking a young girl swimming with no other girls or women for a multitude of reasons.

It’s not going to harm the child if she goes swimming with her parents instead and her father will be able to take her and feel comfortable with that.

And, once again, I agree that it isn’t all men. Unfortunately the ones who it is don’t tell us. They pretend to be like all the other ‘not all men’ men. That’s why you need to be careful.

BlingLoving · 18/12/2021 22:10

As someone who spends a disproportionate amount of time thinking about how to ensure children, girls especially, have private and safe spaces… I am nonetheless floored at this attitude. It absolutely is true that most abusers are men. And that they r4 known to the children involved. But I am not willing to massively restrict my daughter’s life because of fears that can and, in this case absolutely are, being mitigated.

Op, I wouldn’t think twice about this personally. Assuming your dd is comfortable and she knows the dad involved, I really can’t see the issue. Of course there’s a risk in any situation but it’s small and what you have outlined makes it even smaller.

But sadly. This is why when I organise play dates, if dh is the one who will be here and supervising I always feel I have to tell the other parent that because I know there are many who won’t want him in charge of their children.

Fidgetty · 18/12/2021 22:09

I understand abusers are usually known to their victims etc but have known this man for almost a decade and trust him completely. The chances of anything untoward happening with DD are less than zero

Desperately naive statement and completely contradictory. You know "abusers are usually known to their victims" yet the chances are "less than zero" - how do you square those two sentences? I used to wonder how child abuse happens so frequently under parents' noses but since joining mumsnet it's sadly become obvious why. So many parents on here are completely blase about the risk to children.

Sex offenders are NOT a teeny, tiny minority of men. It's a significant chunk of the male population. Your DP knows what men are like and is uncomfortable for good reason. It's too risky. I wouldn't allow it.

Mocara · 18/12/2021 22:08

Honestly how do some of you on here function in the real world and thats coming from someone who works within the safeguarding world.

Drunkpanda · 18/12/2021 22:08

The other child's parents are happy with this arrangement aren't they? It is not only girls who can be abused. The way it is described I would not have concerns OP - unless I had any concerns re my own feelings about this dad or how my dc reacts to being around him.

SoupDragon · 18/12/2021 22:04

>98% of sexual abuse is perpetrated by men.

What proportion is by the father?

bigbeatmanifesto · 18/12/2021 22:03

I agree with your DH, the majority of children are abused by someone they know, swimming lessons involve changing and it's not impossible for a child to inappropriately touched whilst in a cubicle and to not know it's wrong.
As a victim of abuse at the ages of 7-10 by a family friend. I'd advise you to not allow your daughter to be taken by other parents whilst she's still so young.

Hohofortherobbers · 18/12/2021 22:03

This is such a sad sign of the times, this could be your dh people are being so suspicious of. If my dd was comfortable and happy with this arrangement I would be happy too. I would expect my dd to be able to independently dress herself, if she couldn't or if there was an unexpected accident that meant she needed help I would expect to be called.
You do know that abusers can be female too don't you? Where should this paranoia end?

user1471447863 · 18/12/2021 22:03

Seems to be a Mumsnet thing - a dad is either branded a waste of space for not getting involved enough or labeled a potential molester if he is involved with his children. On here a man can do no right.

In this particular scenario, it seems the accompanying adults role is to escort a small group of children (friends) from the door of their homes to the door of the changing village at the local pool. They then retreat to the cafe for an overpriced, watered down coffee and try to not get too bored for the next hour untill the children reappear at the door of said changing village with or without most of their belongings and then walks them home again.
As op has said this is an afternoon where the pool runs lessons there is likely to be very little general public too, mostly a continuous rotation of children and parents.
The risk while never zero, is negligible and can be further mitigate by op and her daughter having open lines of communication/a culture of safe sharing etc (which is ideal regardless of this situation) - so if the once every 3 weeks 'dodgy Dave' decides to start meeting them at the cubicles rather than the cafe or starts offering to dry her hair then OP will know about it and put an end to it if need be.
At the same time, when OP's husband has to take his daughter and the 2 other boys he'll have to promise not to molester the boys while he's there too - cos you know, all men etc

Waitwhatwhy · 18/12/2021 22:02

The dad is walking 3 children to the swimming pool.
Then he is waiting in the cafe
He is not going into the changing rooms.
He is not in the pool, they are having a lesson.
They are quite capable of getting dressed themselves.

If this man was offering to share the lifts to brownies, or football, would everyone be crying “no he might abuse her”? It’s no different.

I cannot believe the responses accusing him of offering this so he can abuse her child.
We shared lifts for years with many other parents, some male some female, to all clubs.
Never would I have thought any of them were only doing it to abuse my children, and if I had ever thought anybody thought that about my dh I would have been devastated.

CheeseMmmm · 18/12/2021 22:02

OP 75% yanbu so there's your answer.

The posts saying DH has right of veto if uncomfy. In theory yes, but surely discomfort must be reasonable?

If we went by that then they'd never have done more than walking pace on scooters, never climbed a tree out of his reach, they wouldn't have a date with a boy until 16, and they wouldn't be allowed out to pub/ club/ hanging out after 9pm until maybe 25.

Reasonable veto. Has told understandable reasons (may not agree but get why he doesn't like) not just 'uncomfortable'.

He didn't want me having a flying lesson. Don't like! What if...!
I said. Get that but stop catastrophising. Sorry you worried but doing it.

pianolessons1 · 18/12/2021 21:59

Think your partner is being bonkers. I take it he will do his fair share of the extra journeys which will result if this arrangement is turned down.....?

Outlyingtrout · 18/12/2021 21:57

just because a person doesn’t automatically jump to the conclusion that every man anywhere near a child is some sort of pervert.

Also this is a complete misrepresentation of what people are saying. Not sure if again it’s because you are a misogynist or because you genuinely don’t understand. Acknowledging risk and safeguarding children accordingly is not the same as believing that every man is a predator.

Outlyingtrout · 18/12/2021 21:55

@Staffy1 “hysterical” Hmm nice bit of misogyny and exactly the kind of thing I’m talking about in terms of motive. Are you accusing me of being a paedophile because I have a keen interest in safeguarding my children? Don’t be coy. Say what you mean.

Swipe left for the next trending thread