Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP uncomfortable about a school run dad taking DD swimming

661 replies

Eastie77Returns · 18/12/2021 19:08

DD (8) will be attending swimming lessons at a new venue in the New Year. There are a couple of other kids in her class who attend lessons at the same pool, I am friends with both sets of parents. I was chatting to the dad of one of the kids and he mentioned that he and and the other child’s mum take it in turns to take both children swimming each week. He asked if I’d like to join the ‘rotation’ which would mean taking all 3 kids every 3 weeks and I said I’d be happy to. We all live a few minutes walk from each other and DD knows the 2 boys well. I’d already discussed this with the other mum so she is on board.

DP has announced he is uncomfortable about the arrangement as there is a male parent involved (when I originally mentioned the plan to him he thought it would only be mums). I think he is being absolutely ridiculous, I have known the school dad since our children were 2 years old and DD adores him.

However I discussed this with a friend who said she 100% understands why DP is unhappy and I need to see this from his point of view. AIBU??

OP posts:
Bovrilly · 19/12/2021 19:05

if you exclude opportunity for a male person to perform unsupervised intimate care for your child, then you reduce their risks of abuse to almost nothing

OK, but what "unsupervised intimate care" do you think this man is "performing" for the OP's DD? Is it the walking to the swimming pool or the walking back that's the problem? Or sitting in the cafe?
Utterly ridiculous.

Offmyfence · 19/12/2021 19:03

@Hertsgirl10 your over zealous "parenting" is bloody awful. Yours is going to be the "I've got socially anxiety" teenager and adult.

We see them all the time on MN, I can see now why and how they were raised.

perfectstorm · 19/12/2021 19:02

@pollymere

A penis doesn't make someone a child abuser. Children are abused by women just as much. Ask him how he'd feel being accused of being an abuser just because he has a penis.
99% of sex offenders in prison are men. 99% of those caught using child sexual abuse material online are men, too. The ONS says that of the very small number of women believed to abuse, most will do so in tandem with (and usually to please) a man.

Almost all child sexual abuse is by men. That's simple statistical fact.

explodingeyes · 19/12/2021 19:01

@Kanaloa some posters are. They are saying 'absolutely not' and suggesting that the dad must be suspicious and it's a massive safeguarding risk. It's just not. They aren't looking at the actual facts of the situation. Male teachers at primary schools take classes swimming all the time too. They don't have to have a female: year 3 upwards in some schools.
(Teachers have dbs but that just means no criminal record).

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 19:00

@explodingeyes

Can someone screaming NO NO NO on here explain to me how & when the dad is actually going to abuse the 9 year old girl? It's three friends and a parent walking to the baths. In public. Three children taking themselves to cubicles in an open changing room area. In public. Three children getting themselves dressed in private in a cubicle. Loads of people about and staff. Three friends walking home again. Supervised by a dad. Once every 3 weeks. It does not flag any safeguarding alarm bells. And yes OP I agree that DP seems happy to object but it's not him having the hassle of going every week when you don't need to.
@explodingeyes

Nobody is screaming honey.

There’s more to this than it just being a man, like the dad is taking them and sitting in the cafe, who’s watching these 3 unattended children in a mixed gender changing room?

I follow a young man on Instagram that is recovering from being sexually abused by his grandad, this once happened on Xmas day in front of the whole family, there is always an opportunity, people are so naive.

There’s a news story about a swimming instructor that just got caught abusing students in the changing rooms of a swimming baths, he made and uploaded thousands of graphic child abuse images. There is always opportunities, and we can’t be too careful and it’s sad that people that are over protective are classed as hysterical.

pollymere · 19/12/2021 18:56

A penis doesn't make someone a child abuser. Children are abused by women just as much. Ask him how he'd feel being accused of being an abuser just because he has a penis.

buzzkaye · 19/12/2021 18:54

@CherryAndAlmond

I wouldn't do it, personally. Most abusers are known to the child (and the parents). I only leave DD with DF, no other males.
Tbh I would feel the same .you know the parents .but how well ? Tbh most abusers are known to the child .I wdnt leave my child tbh
Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 18:52

@mnp321

Iv always been the one to have the sleep overs at my house, I wouldn’t send any of my children with another parent for a lift without me, you never really know anyone and I don’t trust just anyone with my children.

But you wouldn't be having sleepovers at your house without the other parents trusting you. Is that not a little hypocritical that you expect them to trust you but won't reciprocate?

@mnp321

I’m not going around asking people’s children to stay at my house, as you can see from this post, a lot of people don’t seem too bothered about who they leave their kids with so if one of mine gets invited I explain that I am not comfortable with them staying at people’s houses, but I am happy for them to stay at ours, I would not be offended if they said the same back, but like I said I couldn’t care less if anyone’s kids stay or not it makes no difference to me. I suppose it could be hypercritical but I’m not going to lessen my boundaries and say ok yea since you would let your child, then I will too.

And just to clarify I said it would make absolutely no difference if it’s a dad or mum, like I said in my 1st comment.

But some of these comments are giving me ‘not all men’ vibes.

rrhuth · 19/12/2021 18:51

@mnp321

Iv always been the one to have the sleep overs at my house, I wouldn’t send any of my children with another parent for a lift without me, you never really know anyone and I don’t trust just anyone with my children.

But you wouldn't be having sleepovers at your house without the other parents trusting you. Is that not a little hypocritical that you expect them to trust you but won't reciprocate?

It might be hypocritical but logically this poster knows what they will do and doesn't know what the other parents might do so it makes sense.
Kanaloa · 19/12/2021 18:49

@explodingeyes

Can someone screaming NO NO NO on here explain to me how & when the dad is actually going to abuse the 9 year old girl? It's three friends and a parent walking to the baths. In public. Three children taking themselves to cubicles in an open changing room area. In public. Three children getting themselves dressed in private in a cubicle. Loads of people about and staff. Three friends walking home again. Supervised by a dad. Once every 3 weeks. It does not flag any safeguarding alarm bells. And yes OP I agree that DP seems happy to object but it's not him having the hassle of going every week when you don't need to.
Why did you feel the need to say that posters were ‘screaming NO NO NO?’

I presume it was hyperbole to try and imply the women saying they don’t like the idea are hysterical and childish.

I don’t think this man will abuse the child. He likely won’t. However, when it comes to swimming I’d rather my child was supervised by me until they’re high school age (11 ish) and would go alone. If they need taking to swimming I’d be the one to take them.

It’s not ‘screaming NO’ randomly. It’s saying I wouldn’t be comfortable with that so won’t do it. I do think the father should take his turn of the swimming run also or swim with her at the weekends if that’s not possible.

Morgoth · 19/12/2021 18:44

I actually don’t think either you or your partner are being unreasonable. I think both are sensible and considered and valid viewpoints.

explodingeyes · 19/12/2021 18:43

Can someone screaming NO NO NO on here explain to me how & when the dad is actually going to abuse the 9 year old girl?
It's three friends and a parent walking to the baths. In public.
Three children taking themselves to cubicles in an open changing room area. In public.
Three children getting themselves dressed in private in a cubicle.
Loads of people about and staff.
Three friends walking home again. Supervised by a dad.
Once every 3 weeks.
It does not flag any safeguarding alarm bells.
And yes OP I agree that DP seems happy to object but it's not him having the hassle of going every week when you don't need to.

MrsDisney · 19/12/2021 18:43

Wondering if all those who wouldn’t allow this to happen, would do so if the child was male with the male adult? Or male child with female adult? I dread to think that when my boys grow up, people paint them in this light.
To me, if it is a mixed changing village, the girl can go into her own cubicle, same as the boys can, and get changed, if Mam is happy and comfortable with the male parent and her daughter is happy and comfortable with him too.
I get that we have to be conscious of the untoward, and I am the first to hold me hands up and say I find it difficult to trust people with my children, but like others have said, would people feel the same if it was the girl’s male relative? I think if your partner feels uncomfortable, then he should offer the guy some male company on his turn

mnp321 · 19/12/2021 18:42

Iv always been the one to have the sleep overs at my house, I wouldn’t send any of my children with another parent for a lift without me, you never really know anyone and I don’t trust just anyone with my children.

But you wouldn't be having sleepovers at your house without the other parents trusting you. Is that not a little hypocritical that you expect them to trust you but won't reciprocate?

Poetnojo · 19/12/2021 18:42

A lot of the people here that are saying they would have no issue with this are probably some of the same people who would shout down someone for saying not all men Confused

KatyRebecca84 · 19/12/2021 18:39

FFS most men aren’t paedophiles!

mnp321 · 19/12/2021 18:38

@Oblomov21

I can't believe the responses. Of course this is not an issue. Of course he should take your dd.
I agree. For me, given the circumstances, it's a total non issue.
Notmrsfitz · 19/12/2021 18:37

I don’t see his point really at all, what if her teacher was male?
If you had a son would he object to another Mum taking him swimming?

I think dad should try it and see how it goes.

Oblomov21 · 19/12/2021 18:37

I can't believe the responses. Of course this is not an issue. Of course he should take your dd.

perfectstorm · 19/12/2021 18:36

@howmanyways

Obviously the vast majority of men are not sex offenders, but it's not a tiny number, either. Estimates range between 5 and 20% which means between 1 in 20 and 1 in 5.

Perfect storm - in which case - how can you trust your partner with your children? (Assuming your partner is male)

Statistically, biological fathers are very low risk. Stepfathers and unrelated males are the main risk element.

Really, you can't know. But I gut level do trust him, and the children are relaxed, happy and confident in his care. And it's back to the risk versus gain, isn't it? You can shield kids from all risks by never allowing them in a car, or to school, or on a climbing frame... but that wouldn't be healthy. The risks are nothing compared to the benefits. But when it comes to allowing a strange man to take your child swimming, for convenience.. where is the gain, worth the risk?

It's not paranoid to apply common sense safeguarding. If a school wouldn't let someone do something - and a school wouldn't let a random man do this in a million years, not unless they want Special Measures - then nor will I.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 18:36

[quote marcopront]@Hertsgirl10

Iv always been the one to have the sleep overs at my house, I wouldn’t send any of my children with another parent for a lift without me, you never really know anyone and I don’t trust just anyone with my children.

So you don't trust anyone but expect them to trust you.[/quote]
@marcopront

I don’t expect anyone to trust me at all, I set my boundaries for my children and suggest they can stay at our house, I don’t say that they should trust me or that they have to, makes no difference if they want their kids to stay at mine, I have 6 kids so if someone says no it’s no skin off my nose. And wouldn’t be offended if they said no either.

People are so casual with their kids though and want a night off so nobody ever says no, maybe that shows I am too paranoid but again I can say that none of my children are going to come to me with a story about another kids family member that something happened in the past.

Don’t know why people find protecting their own children so shocking tbh. If it doesn’t work for you then fine, but sending mine off to stay at people’s houses doesn’t work for me and that’s fine too.

If you’ve ever lived in a woman’s refuse you might feel the same, I learnt a long time ago that them places are filled up with majority of woman that found out their children have been sexually abused by very close family members/friends.
Now if you you can’t trust family and friends then why would you trust a kid from schools family?

LostForIdeas · 19/12/2021 18:31

Admittedly both mine are disabled, so they're very vulnerable, but the simple reality is that if you exclude opportunity for a male person to perform unsupervised intimate care for your child, then you reduce their risks of abuse to almost nothing.

That’s totally true.

But we are talking about a 9yo who probably has already gone swimming with her school and has no need at all of ‘unsupervised intimate care’. She will get ready before swimming in her own, in her cubicle. She will get changed in her own in her cubicle too.
Surrounded by other families getting changed too.

I don’t think it’s in any way comparable

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 18:30

@howmanyways

Hertsgirl - you must live in a state of constant anxiety. Exhausting.
@howmanyways

Not anxious at all, just don’t put my children in any unnecessary dangers that they don’t need to be in, if people are happy to chance things with their kids that’s up to them. I’m not.

LostForIdeas · 19/12/2021 18:29

DP cannot take her as the lesson clashes with work. He says he has no problem with the dad (“a nice guy”) but thinks it is inappropriate for DD to go alone with a male parent.

I’d ask him what HE is going to do about the swimming.
Yes he has the right to say he is uncomfortable. He has the right to take the decisions that he thinks are better for his dd.
However, he has no right to take decision that will impact others (Aka you) wo sorting out the issue.

The dad not taking dd swimming means you, the OP, will have to take her swimming every week. It’s YOUR inconvenience as you don’t see the issue (and have as much right as he is to make that sort of decision).
Convient it he is also nit the ine who then has to go to the pool every week.
So I’d be asking him what is his solution? If you end up going to the swimming pool every week, is he going to lighten your load in a different way? Or is he just expecting you to suck it up??

notanatural2018 · 19/12/2021 18:27

I wouldn't be comfortable with it either, and to be honest it should be you're either both comfortable, or it doesn't happen.