Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP uncomfortable about a school run dad taking DD swimming

661 replies

Eastie77Returns · 18/12/2021 19:08

DD (8) will be attending swimming lessons at a new venue in the New Year. There are a couple of other kids in her class who attend lessons at the same pool, I am friends with both sets of parents. I was chatting to the dad of one of the kids and he mentioned that he and and the other child’s mum take it in turns to take both children swimming each week. He asked if I’d like to join the ‘rotation’ which would mean taking all 3 kids every 3 weeks and I said I’d be happy to. We all live a few minutes walk from each other and DD knows the 2 boys well. I’d already discussed this with the other mum so she is on board.

DP has announced he is uncomfortable about the arrangement as there is a male parent involved (when I originally mentioned the plan to him he thought it would only be mums). I think he is being absolutely ridiculous, I have known the school dad since our children were 2 years old and DD adores him.

However I discussed this with a friend who said she 100% understands why DP is unhappy and I need to see this from his point of view. AIBU??

OP posts:
hangrylady · 19/12/2021 20:01

@CottonSock

My 8yo is shattered after swimming and can't dress herself very well. I don't she'd be comfortable with a male.
If her dad took her she'd have to get changed alone though.
Btljalrrl08 · 19/12/2021 19:59

Does this mean some of you have never let your children go to sleepovers at their friends house or stay over at grandparents or other family members.
How would you feel if you found out that some of your children’s friends haven’t been allowed to come to play dates/parties/sleepovers because another parent doesn’t trust your parent.
Believe me, I know about the dangers of sexual assault as I was abused by a family member for 10 years but I hate to think that my children were missing out on lots of fun because I was too cynical of every male I have ever met. Obviously, you get to know someone before you leave your child with them, and you trust your instincts. Although we leave our children with unfamiliar adults all the time, teachers being the ones we trust implicitly but have lots of opportunity.
Just food for thought.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 19:59

[quote Offmyfence]@Hertsgirl10 mine are 28 & 30 and not been abused, one married with a DS.

You are a totally wrong with fact?

Lockdown had nothing to do with the reason why I believe one or more of your children will have anxiety.

They've been taught to trust no one, it's just completely bizarre!

[/quote]
@Offmyfence

You have totally misunderstood what I meant about lockdown and social anxiety, I know exactly what you’re implying about my parenting, I’m not thick.

And what I said is fact, going by the responses here.

People can be married with a son and be hiding childhood abuse but ok.

They’ve not been taught to trust no one?
I just decided not to leave them with strangers, I don’t know what’s so strange about that … people left their kids with Micheal Jackson once, would you have? Probably 😂

People left their kids with Jimmy Savile.
The list goes on, but 30 years ago this was happening and no one noticed or suspected a thing.

Not saying anything extreme would happen ever, but I would rather never risk it. And they are extreme cases, it happens though, doesn’t it?

If you weighed up the risks and decided it was ok that’s good for you, and with all due respect child protection and the way children are raised now compared to 30 years has changed a lot, thank god.

Offmyfence · 19/12/2021 19:59

@Untang13d

I’m staggered. Posters are actually saying all men should be regarded as abusers so all our sons are literally potential abusers in waiting.

Utterly bonkers!

Thank you!

The voice of reason!

Alisae · 19/12/2021 19:55

Angling a camera above the door…I mean, this thread is truly taking a surreal turn...

There were issues in a pool local to us with an unknown perv drilling ‘peep’ holes in the mixed sex family changing room walks (unfortunately not the same man as the man who was convicted).

It’s not exactly unheard of. There are horrific places on the internet where men share these opportunistic photos they’ve taken. Twitter is awash with men filming themselves in mixed sex changing rooms wanking in a cubicle.

So, given it’s not a rare occurrence, who is one of these frighteningly common perverts going to attempt to film? A supervised child or an 8 year old girl on her own?

Untang13d · 19/12/2021 19:54

I’m staggered. Posters are actually saying all men should be regarded as abusers so all our sons are literally potential abusers in waiting.

Utterly bonkers!

Offmyfence · 19/12/2021 19:50

@Hertsgirl10 mine are 28 & 30 and not been abused, one married with a DS.

You are a totally wrong with fact?

Lockdown had nothing to do with the reason why I believe one or more of your children will have anxiety.

They've been taught to trust no one, it's just completely bizarre!

Nillynally · 19/12/2021 19:46

He is perfectly within his rights to be unsure of this. I probably would be too. Most abusers are known to the child and the reason they don't get caught is because trust them. If she is 8 and well versed on the pants rule, will use a changing room by herself and knows what to do if she feels uncomfortable then I might allow it. It depends on the child

Eastie77Returns · 19/12/2021 19:45

@Alisae

I realise in this case the man says he would not be going in.

A) Who would know if he did? ‘Oh, she’s forgotten this, I’ll take it to her’.

B) Assuming he is a good man, would a child that age know what to do (or even notice) if another man in the changing room was angling a camera above or below the adjoining cubicle door?

Angling a camera above the door…I mean, this thread is truly taking a surreal turn..

But in answer to your question, yes I think DD would notice and mention it if a camera appeared above her head in the cubicle

OP posts:
Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 19:38

@Eastie77Returns

Thank you to those of you with balanced responses that have brought some sanity to the thread!

I've taken on board the comments that I cannot simply disregard DP's feelings. Fair enough. He has misgivings that he cannot articulate beyond "it is not appropriate" but I'm not going to just ride roughshod over this feelings.

However, laying that aside, some of the attitudes and comments on here are perplexing and depressing to say the least.

I see people are still commenting on the dangers of the lift share, DD being the last one left in the car...once again the dad will not be driving. Everyone walks to the swimming pool.

I’ve been accused of being lax because I’m not supervising DD whilst she swims. She’s attending a swimming lesson so there is a teacher and a lifeguard in the pool. No supervision from parents required.

I'm reading that some of you have 9 & 10 year old children who cannot dry and dress themselves/feel uncomfortable doing so and I'm putting DD at risk because she "might need help". Help with what? I’ve never met a NT 9 year old who cannot use a a towel and put their own clothes on. KS1 Primary school aged children who attend PE and swimming lessons have to do this on their own as teachers cannot help 30+ children.

As I've already pointed out, DD has been to his house for play dates over the last 8 years. On occasion in the last couple of years we have left her there (birthday parties, playing after school with his son and other kids) which would have given him ample opportunity to practice evil deeds. Instead, many of you think it is entirely feasible that he is going to wait until he takes DD swimming every 3 weeks, find some pretext to go into the changing village and engineer his way into her locked cubicle and then attempt to abuse her with other children close by.

Alternatively I've also read that he might try to abuse her on the walk home from the swimming pool whilst the other children walk on ahead. I can't even fathom what kind of scenario that would involve Confused

I'm aware many paedophiles brazenly abuse children in plain sight and I'm not trying to make light of the very real and serious issue of child sexual abuse but some of the comments on this thread are ridiculous. I'm not even going to comment on the "I've never left my DD with a man apart from DH" except to say that level of mistrust sounds exhausting and stressful.

@Eastie77Returns

I think you need to ask him why it’s not ok for him to take her when he’s happy for her to spend time at his house for play dates and things, I can see why you’re confused about this if he’s not so strict about other things like this.

perfectstorm · 19/12/2021 19:36

@Bovrilly

if you exclude opportunity for a male person to perform unsupervised intimate care for your child, then you reduce their risks of abuse to almost nothing

OK, but what "unsupervised intimate care" do you think this man is "performing" for the OP's DD? Is it the walking to the swimming pool or the walking back that's the problem? Or sitting in the cafe?
Utterly ridiculous.

@Bovrilly as I explained, my kids have additional needs. They needed/still need help changing at this age. I can't comment on a neurotypical child's capacities at 9, because I don't have one. But given lots of kids aren't diagnosed until everything falls apart for them in secondary, I think the assumption that all kids can manage as well as your own is perhaps misplaced.

The OP has clarified that her own child can (and was also kind enough to clarify that she accepted that was a NT level of development), and that's great. It doesn't mean they all can.

pinkpantherpink · 19/12/2021 19:32

DP needs to meet the people involved and make an assessment then. Not all abusers are male. He is making a risk assessment without adequate data

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 19:29

[quote Offmyfence]@Hertsgirl10 I still stand by your parenting style is massively over zealous!

I find it amazing you say don't judge parents by a few words on the Internet but you have said

as you can see from this post, a lot of people don’t seem too bothered about who they leave their kids with

So as you have judged them, I will judge you.

I'd hazard a guess that your younger children will have "social anxiety", due to your parenting. [/quote]
@Offmyfence

Why would my older ones be ok but not the younger ones?

That’s not a judgement, going by what people have said on here it’s a fact, isn’t it?
So many have said they don’t see any issue and would allow their children to go with someone to swimming.

You can hazard a guess all you like but my parenting style hasn’t changed since I had the older ones and the 15 year old is outgoing, 11 year old would probably jump in a van that said free Pokémon cards on the side.

And considering the lockdowns and so many children that actually do have social anxiety I think you’re throwing that around a bit too casually actually, it’s a very big issue for so many adults and children and just because you don’t agree with someone doesn’t mean you can use that mental health issue to try and belittle someone’s parenting on MN, many posters here will be suffering with social anxiety as will their children will be and it’s not such a flippant issue to accuse people, I mean protecting your own children shouldn’t be something to mug someone off about and say ‘parenting’ as if what I am doing is an issue.

Eastie77Returns · 19/12/2021 19:27

Thank you to those of you with balanced responses that have brought some sanity to the thread!

I've taken on board the comments that I cannot simply disregard DP's feelings. Fair enough. He has misgivings that he cannot articulate beyond "it is not appropriate" but I'm not going to just ride roughshod over this feelings.

However, laying that aside, some of the attitudes and comments on here are perplexing and depressing to say the least.

I see people are still commenting on the dangers of the lift share, DD being the last one left in the car...once again the dad will not be driving. Everyone walks to the swimming pool.

I’ve been accused of being lax because I’m not supervising DD whilst she swims. She’s attending a swimming lesson so there is a teacher and a lifeguard in the pool. No supervision from parents required.

I'm reading that some of you have 9 & 10 year old children who cannot dry and dress themselves/feel uncomfortable doing so and I'm putting DD at risk because she "might need help". Help with what? I’ve never met a NT 9 year old who cannot use a a towel and put their own clothes on. KS1 Primary school aged children who attend PE and swimming lessons have to do this on their own as teachers cannot help 30+ children.

As I've already pointed out, DD has been to his house for play dates over the last 8 years. On occasion in the last couple of years we have left her there (birthday parties, playing after school with his son and other kids) which would have given him ample opportunity to practice evil deeds. Instead, many of you think it is entirely feasible that he is going to wait until he takes DD swimming every 3 weeks, find some pretext to go into the changing village and engineer his way into her locked cubicle and then attempt to abuse her with other children close by.

Alternatively I've also read that he might try to abuse her on the walk home from the swimming pool whilst the other children walk on ahead. I can't even fathom what kind of scenario that would involve Confused

I'm aware many paedophiles brazenly abuse children in plain sight and I'm not trying to make light of the very real and serious issue of child sexual abuse but some of the comments on this thread are ridiculous. I'm not even going to comment on the "I've never left my DD with a man apart from DH" except to say that level of mistrust sounds exhausting and stressful.

OP posts:
Angel2702 · 19/12/2021 19:21

@BraveGoldie

I would be cautious with this, especially when the other two kids are boys. She would have to change all on her own? Or where? It just seems very young, alone, in a swim suit to be without any reliable female figure to be around.
No different to a Dad taking a daughter swimming, 8 and over have to change in female changing rooms independently.
Offmyfence · 19/12/2021 19:20

@Hertsgirl10 I still stand by your parenting style is massively over zealous!

I find it amazing you say don't judge parents by a few words on the Internet but you have said

as you can see from this post, a lot of people don’t seem too bothered about who they leave their kids with

So as you have judged them, I will judge you.

I'd hazard a guess that your younger children will have "social anxiety", due to your parenting.

Alisae · 19/12/2021 19:18

I realise in this case the man says he would not be going in.

A) Who would know if he did? ‘Oh, she’s forgotten this, I’ll take it to her’.

B) Assuming he is a good man, would a child that age know what to do (or even notice) if another man in the changing room was angling a camera above or below the adjoining cubicle door?

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 19:15

[quote explodingeyes]@Hertsgirl10 when is it going to happen in this scenario though?
It's individual cubicles in an open area. He's not going in with her[/quote]
@explodingeyes

Who knows? Do you know the lay out of the place? I don’t and I’m not saying he would do anything, I’m saying personally for my children it would be a no. I would never judge another parents choices or boundaries.
I just would rather take my kid myself, I mean the mum knew when she signed her up she had to get there and back and it turned out the other parents are going and made a deal, she would be taking her anyway if she didn’t hear about the carpool so it’s not like the child wouldn’t go if it wasn’t for it?

It wouldn’t make any difference to me if it was another mum or dad, I would just rather go myself.

Alisae · 19/12/2021 19:13

I dread to think that when my boys grow up, people paint them in this light.

To be fair, the decent men I know (decent as far as I can know) would not ever offer to put themselves in a position where they could abuse a child. They would actively avoid it, wouldn’t moan about not having access to dc the same way as women do and definitely wouldn’t complain that it was unfair.

I assume because they also have that instinct that screams out that they don’t want unrelated men around their own dc/vulnerable parents etc.

I did often wonder about whether I was being a bit overly paranoid sometimes.

That was until that popular Dad in the playground in our dcs friendship group, the one all the other mums and teachers chatted to and trusted was unmasked. That friendly successful guy who took time out of his busy life to help around the primary school, volunteered at his wife’s guide groups, took other mums dd’s to activities along with his own, and was a pillar of the community…was last year convicted as one of the most prolific pedophiles our police had said they’d seen.

The trusting mums daughters had their images shared with his friends and some had been abused for years, along with his own daughter.

And no, I’m not saying it was the mums fault their daughters were abused. It was no one’s fault but that disgusting man’s. But I’ve never been more thankful that my own warped childhood has left me more paranoid than most, it saved my dd.

Kanaloa · 19/12/2021 19:11

And you don’t have to ‘look at the facts.’ There is no reason a school friend’s dad needs to take the child swimming if her father doesn’t want him to.

Same as my neighbours don’t need to let me take their child to the trampoline park. They can just say no I don’t want you to, for any reason they like.

Kanaloa · 19/12/2021 19:09

[quote explodingeyes]@Kanaloa some posters are. They are saying 'absolutely not' and suggesting that the dad must be suspicious and it's a massive safeguarding risk. It's just not. They aren't looking at the actual facts of the situation. Male teachers at primary schools take classes swimming all the time too. They don't have to have a female: year 3 upwards in some schools.
(Teachers have dbs but that just means no criminal record). [/quote]
So nobody is ‘screaming NO NO NO!’

People are saying ‘I wouldn’t do that.’ So no posters are. I could just as easily dramatise the other side as screaming ‘but my SONS are men are you saying THEY ARE PAEDOS!!!! Women sexually abuse kids as much as men!!!!’

Both things that have actually been said by those who agree with op but not helpful for me to characterise that entire viewpoint with a few hyperbolised moments of idiocy.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 19:09

[quote Offmyfence]@Hertsgirl10 your over zealous "parenting" is bloody awful. Yours is going to be the "I've got socially anxiety" teenager and adult.

We see them all the time on MN, I can see now why and how they were raised. [/quote]
@Offmyfence

My 18 year old is driving, studying adult nursing and has been working full time since leaving school, 16 year old attending college, working part time and both perfectly fine emotionally and not anxious judging by 18 year olds busy social life but way to judge.
The other 4 might be quivering wrecks by that age, who knows but at least they won’t be recovering from any possible child abuse, can you say the same? I would be presumptuous like yourself and say that yours are left with anyone and will need to recover from their childhood.. but I won’t because I can’t judge a parent by a few comments on the internet.

explodingeyes · 19/12/2021 19:08

@Kanaloa when do you see the risk happening?

Kanaloa · 19/12/2021 19:07

@pollymere

A penis doesn't make someone a child abuser. Children are abused by women just as much. Ask him how he'd feel being accused of being an abuser just because he has a penis.
Children aren’t abused by women just as much. I’m not sure why you’ve said that, I presume you don’t believe it to be true?
explodingeyes · 19/12/2021 19:05

@Hertsgirl10 when is it going to happen in this scenario though?
It's individual cubicles in an open area. He's not going in with her