Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP uncomfortable about a school run dad taking DD swimming

661 replies

Eastie77Returns · 18/12/2021 19:08

DD (8) will be attending swimming lessons at a new venue in the New Year. There are a couple of other kids in her class who attend lessons at the same pool, I am friends with both sets of parents. I was chatting to the dad of one of the kids and he mentioned that he and and the other child’s mum take it in turns to take both children swimming each week. He asked if I’d like to join the ‘rotation’ which would mean taking all 3 kids every 3 weeks and I said I’d be happy to. We all live a few minutes walk from each other and DD knows the 2 boys well. I’d already discussed this with the other mum so she is on board.

DP has announced he is uncomfortable about the arrangement as there is a male parent involved (when I originally mentioned the plan to him he thought it would only be mums). I think he is being absolutely ridiculous, I have known the school dad since our children were 2 years old and DD adores him.

However I discussed this with a friend who said she 100% understands why DP is unhappy and I need to see this from his point of view. AIBU??

OP posts:
ilovegingercats · 19/12/2021 21:13

I wouldn't allow this either I simply wouldn't take the risk.

Graphista · 19/12/2021 21:13

It would be a mixed cubicle environment as they do not have male/female changing rooms at this pool. It’s a changing ‘village’ with individual cubicles

I was already erring towards your dps side and with the above info

Hell no!

There are a lot more of these creeps about than people realise and they very often present as perfectly normal friendly people - my dad did! He wasn't!

When I disclosed to childhood friends and their parents many years later the majority were genuinely shocked and would never have thought that's what he was.

They knew him for 20+ years

They had no clue

With my own experiences I would never have let my dd be part of such an arrangement

Interesting that as some have noted, children are most likely to suffer abuse at the hands of a male relative but presumably no one on this thread would have a problem with their DH/Dad/Grandfather taking their DD swimming despite the statistically greater risk.

We tend to know if our male relatives present a risk or not. I wouldn't allow my father literally within arms reach of dd. If you look into the more publicised cases where the male relative has abused a child and a parent didn't protect in many cases the parent did know but was so messed up by their own abuse and/or so afraid of the same person they were incapable of protecting their child. Mners who know their male relatives aren't like this are in a different scenario altogether

@Clymene you're really not hot on safeguarding at all

The ‘opportunity’ for any adult to abuse a child in this setting and scenario is very low.

Actually sounds pretty high to me! Lots of adults about BUT focused on their own dc. A predator could easily take advantage of this situation

a close relative is a social worker

Then frankly why haven't you sounded them out? I'm thinking cos you know exactly what they'd say!

Quite honestly I'm disgusted at the number of people on thread dismissing the concerns of those of us who have survived csa and so know what it's like to do so!

I have never left dd with a sole male I didn't know EXTREMELY well because of being a survivor

I think that's understandable and sensible NOT paranoid.

Men are more likely to be sexual predators that's fact.

MrsPnut · 19/12/2021 21:08

I am with you OP, I was a social worker on an initial assessment team (child protection), and I would have no concerns in the situation being proposed.

You’ve known him for years, your daughter has had multiple play dates at his house. He has had ample opportunity in the past if he had nefarious intents.
Swimming rota would mean one lesson in three he would walk all the kids to the pool, they would get changed in a unisex village in separate cubicles and go to their lesson. Come back after lessons to get changed again in separate cubicles when the village will be full of parents and carers hurrying up their child so they can go home.

How on earth would that be an ideal place to decide to abuse a child when they could have done it in their own home. There are all kinds of red flags for someone wanting to be inappropriately close to a child such as excessive tickling and engineering babysitting but standing in a changing village telling three kids to hurry up and get their socks on isn’t one.

whatkatydid2013 · 19/12/2021 21:00

We’d let the kids go and do stuff with the neighbours and we have the neighbours kids round all the time. That includes swimming, having a go at paddle boarding, visiting the beach, playing round each other’s houses for hours at a time, going to local shops and all manner of other things. Fact is anyone could be a potential abuser even if it’s your husband or your brother or someone you knew since you were two. One of a really tight knit group of friends my husband went to school with pled guilty to various counts related to indecent images of children when I was pregnant with our eldest. I would never have guessed it and I’m aware other men (& albeit much less likely other women) could be a risk but at the same time it’s much more likely to be fine and we all enjoy the sense of community with the kids freely moving between houses & playing. We’ve talked to the girls about their personal space and how people need to respect it and about private parts and how we don’t share those and that if they are ever unhappy or uncomfortable they should tell us. I don’t think your OH is unreasonable to have some degree of caution but I also would question if it’s good for kids to deny them lots of options to try and eliminate fairly small risks.

Eastie77Returns · 19/12/2021 20:55

Lostforideas just to clarify that DD has never stayed overnight but has stayed on her own for play dates etc.

JTK50 when are women ever a danger to boys and girls? Ask the families of Arthur Labinjo-Huges and Star Hobson. Tragic cases that may not have involved sexual abuse (although who knows) but the idea that women are never a threat to children is ludicrous.

OP posts:
homealoneagain1 · 19/12/2021 20:40

@Untang13d

I’m staggered. Posters are actually saying all men should be regarded as abusers so all our sons are literally potential abusers in waiting.

Utterly bonkers!

Utterly utterly bonkers! This post makes me very sad!
LostForIdeas · 19/12/2021 20:37

@JTK50, in that case, the OP shouldn’t leave he dd going to play dates with him and his house. Nor should the OP’s DH be happy for her to stay overnight.

But HE IS. Her DH is happy for his dd to do all that. But somehow swimming is not ok….

LostForIdeas · 19/12/2021 20:35

As I've already pointed out, DD has been to his house for play dates over the last 8 years. On occasion in the last couple of years we have left her there (birthday parties, playing after school with his son and other kids) which would have given him ample opportunity to practice evil deeds.

@Eastie77Returns if I was you, I’d ask him why he is feeling comfortable with dd staying at his for play dates and even sleepovers but he isn’t comfortable with him taking her to the swimming pool.

For me it makes no sense. I’d be more careful with a sleepover than with swimming lessons tbh.
But he might have other worries/different outlook and it might be interesting to see what he think.

I have to say if he is comfortable with her staying there for the night, I’m thinking what he is more uncomfortable ‘because men aren’t supposed to be left alone with young girls at the swimming pool’.

I’d also say that if it is right that you shouldn’t be over ridding him and not take his POV into account, this also works in reverse and he shouldn’t be over ridding your POV and act as if whatever he says goes either….
For me, that means atbthe very least being able to explain why he is uncomfortable so that some sort of compromise can be found. Incl him taking responsibility for his dd to go swimming wo all the work falling into your shoulders if the only possible answer for him is ‘you are the inky one who take her swimming’

Btljalrrl08 · 19/12/2021 20:31

*doesn’t trust your partner?

JTK50 · 19/12/2021 20:29

For those asking what is the risk and when will he have the opportunity. Predators can and do abuse children in few seconds if given the opportunity, and sexual abuse isn’t just rape. I was abused right in front of my family disguised as play fight at the age of 11 and I didn’t have the words to speak up but my discomfort was obvious and it continued to happen for many months, always at home as he was left alone with me. They trusted him like the op trusts her male friend and because of that they saw everything he was doing as innocent. Some people can’t see danger in the people closest to them.
Why are some posters asking “ would you leave your son with a woman” since when are women a danger to boys or girls, they must live in a different world to me.

Bovrilly · 19/12/2021 20:24

@perfectstorm

I think the assumption that all kids can manage as well as your own is perhaps misplaced.

This is about the OP's child, not mine (about whom you know nothing) and unlike you I am not assuming anything - by the time you posted she had made it perfectly clear that her DD was capable of changing by herself. She had also made it clear that the man in question would be walking the children to and from the pool and waiting in the cafe while they were swimming. And yet you still spouted this rubbish about the DD being at risk while he performed "unsupervised intimate care". Absolute nonsense.

Hertsgirl10 · 19/12/2021 20:21

@Alisae

Obviously, you get to know someone before you leave your child with them, and you trust your instincts.

No offence but a completely nonsense piece of advice.

I didn’t keep my dd safe because I got a ‘vibe’ from the horrific school ground pedophile, I did it because I treated him as though he could have been one. I said no to his offers of lifts/sleepovers/to take dd to a shared dance class because of that.

The poor mums who trusted him didn’t miss a signal, their ‘instincts’ didn’t fail. That is the very nature of these fucking predators. You don’t get a off feeling, you think he’s trustworthy. He probably has a wife/children. He’s ‘proven’ himself to be trustworthy in the past. He’s attractive, successful, charming.

He’s not skulking around the playground giving off evil vibes.

@Alisae

Mmm hmmm in plain sight but people aren’t ready for these conversations, and act like protecting your children from potential dangers makes us hysterical.

But I must say in OP’s case I would be wondering why DP is so worried about this if he trusts the same parent to have his daughter for play dates as she’s said. It doesn’t make any sense unless he’s worried about her being in the mixed changing room by herself, which is also understandable.

Kanaloa · 19/12/2021 20:21

@CrankyFrankie

It depends on the specific lesson. At my kids lessons one pool was a lesson pool but adults could still pay to swim in the other pools. So the lesson kids would change for their lesson but members of the public would also change before using the other pool. So yes, a free for all.

That’s what I’d be worried about more than the friend taking the kids to the pool. I think if my kids are changing where adult strangers are also changing I’d like to be there supervising.

CrankyFrankie · 19/12/2021 20:17

To the people who can’t understand the OP’s POV, are there absolutely no males in your life that you could envisage leaving your child with? There are so many friends and family members that I would be entirely comfortable putting in this position of trust. You can’t just imagine someone creepy and then assume that’s the person OP is talking about when she’s known him and his wife for years and doesn’t have an ounce of worry about his character.

That said, changing villages are a bit grim. Presumably if it’s a lesson then it’s not a free for all? I did discover my friend and I had been perved on (probably for months) in the mixed sex ‘changing villages’ when we were 18.

Kanaloa · 19/12/2021 20:17

@Tessabelle74

Oh and all those assuming all men could be abusers, need to remember Rose West, Myra Hindley and the one who worked in a nursery who was selling photos to a pedophile ring just for starters
Yes. Three women.

Who ALL worked in conjunction with men who abused the children with them. That doesn’t mean women abuse on the same level men do. They simply don’t. The whole reason female child murderers become so infamous is because it’s unusual.

Alisae · 19/12/2021 20:15

I’d say the posters with issues are the ones unable to differentiate between:

99% of sexual crime is committed by men

And

99% of men commit sexual crime.

The top is completely true, and scoffing about it or naming three female sex attackers doesn’t change it.

Acknowledging the first, and acting on that information, is not the same as saying the second statement.

HelpNeedCoolUsername8 · 19/12/2021 20:12

I think your husband’s concerns are valid. I’m not sure why the length of time you’ve known the person matters as some people get away with it their whole lives without anyone ever finding out, even those who know them well. Of course the likelihood is that it’s all perfectly innocent. But I wouldn’t take that risk, and even if I felt comfortable with it myself I still wouldn’t do it if husband wasn’t okay with it. Childhood sexual abuse is more common than you think, Google the statistics.

Untang13d · 19/12/2021 20:12

Oh what tosh.

It’s clear from the op that nobody is going to be near the child in a state of undress. Any adult is in a position of power to a child make or female and the absolute vast majority of men and boys are not abusers.

Some posters have serious issues.

Alisae · 19/12/2021 20:10

Obviously, you get to know someone before you leave your child with them, and you trust your instincts.

No offence but a completely nonsense piece of advice.

I didn’t keep my dd safe because I got a ‘vibe’ from the horrific school ground pedophile, I did it because I treated him as though he could have been one. I said no to his offers of lifts/sleepovers/to take dd to a shared dance class because of that.

The poor mums who trusted him didn’t miss a signal, their ‘instincts’ didn’t fail. That is the very nature of these fucking predators. You don’t get a off feeling, you think he’s trustworthy. He probably has a wife/children. He’s ‘proven’ himself to be trustworthy in the past. He’s attractive, successful, charming.

He’s not skulking around the playground giving off evil vibes.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 19/12/2021 20:08

In my experience good men don’t want or demand equal access to other peoples children

so...if you are a single dad your kids can never have friends over to play?

Tessabelle74 · 19/12/2021 20:07

Oh and all those assuming all men could be abusers, need to remember Rose West, Myra Hindley and the one who worked in a nursery who was selling photos to a pedophile ring just for starters

JuergenSchwarzwald · 19/12/2021 20:07

Anyway OP I agree with the pp who said that if your DH does not like this idea, then it's his job to come up with an alternative.

Tessabelle74 · 19/12/2021 20:05

I wouldn't be worried about the Dad in ths scenario but about my young daughter being alone in the changing room. It wouldn't take long for anyone with risky intentions to figure out she's alone when she sees her with lone male adult. If they're communal changing rooms however and the Dad will be there to keep an eye out, I'd be fine

Alisae · 19/12/2021 20:04

Posters are actually saying all men should be regarded as abusers so all our sons are literally potential abusers in waiting

@Untang13d I treat any male that isn’t dh as though they have the potential to be an abuser, yes.

Though, I don’t get all the faux concern over our sons. In my experience good men don’t want or demand equal access to other peoples children.

They don’t want to be alone supervising an unrelated child young state of undress. Not because they worry they are a pedophile, but because they do see how it could leave all in that situation vulnerable and avoid it.

They cross the road and slow down if they are following a woman on a street at night, not because they are a rapist, but because they understand the woman can’t possibly know that.

Good men understand the power imbalance between themselves and women and dc. They understand that though they are good, they unfortunately belong to a sex class responsible for the vast vast majority of sexual abuse. And so they do all they can to protect those around them.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 19/12/2021 20:02

@pollymere

A penis doesn't make someone a child abuser. Children are abused by women just as much. Ask him how he'd feel being accused of being an abuser just because he has a penis.
Well that's completely wrong. Most abuse is carried out by males. But not in the context the OP describes, where the chance of any kind of abuse would be vanishingly unlikely.
Swipe left for the next trending thread