Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP uncomfortable about a school run dad taking DD swimming

661 replies

Eastie77Returns · 18/12/2021 19:08

DD (8) will be attending swimming lessons at a new venue in the New Year. There are a couple of other kids in her class who attend lessons at the same pool, I am friends with both sets of parents. I was chatting to the dad of one of the kids and he mentioned that he and and the other child’s mum take it in turns to take both children swimming each week. He asked if I’d like to join the ‘rotation’ which would mean taking all 3 kids every 3 weeks and I said I’d be happy to. We all live a few minutes walk from each other and DD knows the 2 boys well. I’d already discussed this with the other mum so she is on board.

DP has announced he is uncomfortable about the arrangement as there is a male parent involved (when I originally mentioned the plan to him he thought it would only be mums). I think he is being absolutely ridiculous, I have known the school dad since our children were 2 years old and DD adores him.

However I discussed this with a friend who said she 100% understands why DP is unhappy and I need to see this from his point of view. AIBU??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
marcopront · 28/12/2021 10:38

@HangingOutWithTheSandman

But his issue was this other dad taking his daughter and this won’t be happening, so his principles haven’t disappeared.

Except the other Dad is still taking her sometimes, so it is still happening.

And as @Eastie77Returns so eloquently put it there was little logic to his concerns anyway.

There have been very few justifications for the increased risk of the dad sitting in the cafe alone as opposed to with the Mum and none for the increased risk of him sitting in the cafe as opposed to having the daughter in his house alone.

Eastie77Returns · 27/12/2021 19:36

@HangingOutWithTheSandman

So many men have all kinds of controlling ‘principles’ that mysteriously disappear as soon as said principles require actual effort on their part or disrupt aspect of their lives, hobbies etc.

But his issue was this other dad taking his daughter and this won’t be happening, so his principles haven’t disappeared.

You seem to to sneer at anyone who agrees with your partner about this issue. You’re not on the same page with parenting, you laugh along with other posters who have laughed at him and say he moans when pulling his weight with the kids. You seem to want to prove he’s mad for thinking this was an issue in the first place. If you think it was about controlling you, why are you with him? And if not, and you believe he is doing this out of genuine concern, your posts seem quite shitty about him.

I don’t think he is ‘mad’ but his line of reasoning (or lack of) doesn’t make sense.

He objects to the school dad taking DD to the pool along with other children. Yet he has dropped DD to this same man’s house and left her there on play dates where she would be at far greater risk from him than when she is at the swimming pool

I’m putting that bit in bold because a lot of people who are convinced DP is right to be worried are curiously over looking this.

If you had a concern about someone who wanted to take your DC to a public place would you leave your child with that same person in the private confines of their house? In his own home, the school dad has ample opportunity to ‘help’ her to the bathroom, remove clothes if she’s feeling hot after running around playing etc.

But while DP is seemingly not worried about DD falling victim to any of these scenarios in the school dad’s house, he is concerned that she might be abused by him in a pubic changing roomHmm

Does any of that make sense to you?

The problem is DP picks and chooses his safeguarding concerns based on outdated views and situations that suit him. Dropping DD for a play date at the school dads house, when he is supposed to be looking after her, suits him as he gets to have time to himself for a couple of hours while another parent who he is allegedly concerned about does the childcare.

He is fine with DD going to the swimming pool with the other school mum, who he doesn’t know, and the school dad’s wife as he doesn’t seem to think any harm can befall her when she’s in the care of women who are “instinctive carers” (his words)Confused

He drops DS off at football on Saturdays and often leaves him there in the care of male coaches he knows absolutely nothing about. Yes they will be DBS checked etc but that doesn’t mean anything. He knows about the awful stories of historical abuse many footballers have spoken about in recent times. but he doesn’t share the same concerns for DS’ welfare at all because he doesn’t think boys are really at risk.

And the only people I’ve sneered at are those who have written absolute nonsense e.g. the person who asserted that the fact I’ve never left DD at the school dad’s house for a sleepover ‘proves’ that deep down I know he is a sexual offenderConfused

OP posts:
HangingOutWithTheSandman · 27/12/2021 16:06

So many men have all kinds of controlling ‘principles’ that mysteriously disappear as soon as said principles require actual effort on their part or disrupt aspect of their lives, hobbies etc.

But his issue was this other dad taking his daughter and this won’t be happening, so his principles haven’t disappeared.

You seem to to sneer at anyone who agrees with your partner about this issue. You’re not on the same page with parenting, you laugh along with other posters who have laughed at him and say he moans when pulling his weight with the kids. You seem to want to prove he’s mad for thinking this was an issue in the first place. If you think it was about controlling you, why are you with him? And if not, and you believe he is doing this out of genuine concern, your posts seem quite shitty about him.

Eastie77Returns · 27/12/2021 15:36

@Double3xposure

So your partner was so concerned for your Dd safety that he had do it himself? Until then he realised that it would take up his valuable time taking two children to two events on the same day ( which no mother has ever done ).

So he miraculously overcame all his concerns and decided to let the original plan stand. Well I’m TOTALLY flabbergasted, who could have foreseen such an outcome !!!

It’s almost as if he was more interested in controlling you and the faux concern was just a smoke screen.

I note that he is also going to occasionally supervise this man in the cafe - what a worthy job! All these people who have up their Christmas Day to feed homeless people/ give vaccines in the NHS / work as carers - they needs to look to the altruism and self sacrifice of this man.

I trust he has a system in place for the other parents to notify him of which weeks this “ school dad day “ will be taking the children. Maybe the male parent of the other child could get involved too and all three men could sit in the cafe on a Saturday morning supervising each other.

That would allow their female partners to get on with the housework at home and look after the other children.

It’s a tough job being a man with principles.

@Double3xposure this made me laughSmile

But entirely agree. So many men have all kinds of controlling ‘principles’ that mysteriously disappear as soon as said principles require actual effort on their part or disrupt aspect of their lives, hobbies etc.

OP posts:
Tabbacus · 27/12/2021 13:43

I suspect this whole charade was about him feeling annoyed that I wouldn’t finish work early and take DD myself every single week.

Absolutely, and I'm sure after going with the other dad once or twice he will soon make excuses as to why he can't and will miraculously be fine with school dad going alone.

Eastie77Returns · 27/12/2021 13:31

@Drunkpanda

Well no male coach has ever abused a boy in his care... oh wait. Glad you have found a solution that works for you all. I bet your dh goes about twice and then decides it's all safe!
I can absolutely guarantee this will be the outcome. He works in central London so after a couple of times of dashing home on the tube to take her I know he will suddenly decide that he is fine with her going with the school dad. He is concerned until the concern inconveniences him, then he isn’t.

I suspect this whole charade was about him feeling annoyed that I wouldn’t finish work early and take DD myself every single week.

OP posts:
Double3xposure · 27/12/2021 12:28

@HangingOutWithTheSandman

Glad a solution has been found which means any risks to your daughter are minimised and your partner is comfortable. Hope she enjoys the swimming.
The risks to her Dd haven’t changed in any way. They are exactly the same as they were at the start of the thread.

The Ops partner is now supervising the other male while they both sit in the cafe together and the children swim in the pool. Or I suppose they are supervising each other.

Meanwhile the children are in the pool and the changing area. Presumably being taught by a male swim instructor on occasion, supervised by male attendants and surrounded by male swimmers.

This is all just nonsense and a complete distraction to proper risk assessment and genuine safeguarding.

HangingOutWithTheSandman · 27/12/2021 12:20

Glad a solution has been found which means any risks to your daughter are minimised and your partner is comfortable. Hope she enjoys the swimming.

Qwertykeys · 27/12/2021 11:54

Glad you found a solution , I do hope the other parents are ok with him tagging along , after all nothing stopping him abusing one of the boys

Double3xposure · 27/12/2021 11:36

So your partner was so concerned for your Dd safety that he had do it himself? Until then he realised that it would take up his valuable time taking two children to two events on the same day ( which no mother has ever done ).

So he miraculously overcame all his concerns and decided to let the original plan stand. Well I’m TOTALLY flabbergasted, who could have foreseen such an outcome !!!

It’s almost as if he was more interested in controlling you and the faux concern was just a smoke screen.

I note that he is also going to occasionally supervise this man in the cafe - what a worthy job! All these people who have up their Christmas Day to feed homeless people/ give vaccines in the NHS / work as carers - they needs to look to the altruism and self sacrifice of this man.

I trust he has a system in place for the other parents to notify him of which weeks this “ school dad day “ will be taking the children. Maybe the male parent of the other child could get involved too and all three men could sit in the cafe on a Saturday morning supervising each other.

That would allow their female partners to get on with the housework at home and look after the other children.

It’s a tough job being a man with principles.

Drunkpanda · 27/12/2021 10:40

Well no male coach has ever abused a boy in his care... oh wait.
Glad you have found a solution that works for you all. I bet your dh goes about twice and then decides it's all safe!

Eastie77Returns · 27/12/2021 10:31

As an update, DP found a Saturday morning slot for the swimming lesson and announced he would take DD to that. He then began grumbling non stop because this meant he would have a hectic day since he takes DS to football on Saturday afternoons. As an aside, he leaves DS there with male coaches who are complete strangers to us but he has no issue with that...

We then found out the school dad will be sharing the rotation with his wife meaning that 90% of the time DD will be accompanied by me, the other school mum or the wife. DP declared he is happier with this and will finish work early on the ‘school dad’s day’ to take her. So he’ll just be sitting in the cafe with the school dad but if it makes him feel better, so be it.

OP posts:
ImAnonymous · 24/12/2021 01:23

As long as she's able to dress herself and doesn't need help in the changing room then I think it's fine but I would talk to your DP and ask what he's worried about

GrannytoaUnicorn · 24/12/2021 01:08

@Eastie77Returns

Ok, fair enough. Consensus seems to be that I’m BU. I’m surprised so many people would feel uncomfortable with this considering it’s someone I’ve known for many years, he’s not a random parent I’ve chatted to in passing.

Obviously I wouldn’t have agreed to this if DD was unable to get dressed unaided.

I don't see why you having "known him for many years" is relevant. Do you think paedophiles don't have people they've known for years & years? Do you think they all know that their long term friend/acquaintance/family member are a paedophile? Of course not! They all probably think they're lovely people!
Bovrilly · 23/12/2021 23:52

People are let down and disappointed by people they trust, trust can be broken

Yes I understand that's an argument against letting the family friend take the DD swimming, some men are predators, you can't know for sure, any risk however small is too great. But I am asking how people handle letting a child go to school when it's known that paedophiles seek out jobs that give them access to children.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 23/12/2021 23:39

Of course we trust teachers etc but the thing was OP saying she trusts this man 100%. Some people have different versions of themselves where they behave a certain way with one group of people and different woth another.
Just the other day there was a thread where someone commented about her dad knowing one person as two separate people because said person behaved differently in different setting.
So, OP trusts the version this man has presented to her, she doesn't know if this is how he is all of the time.
People are let down and disappointed by people they trust, trust can be broken, so for that reason, I wouldn't claim to know someone's character 100%.
As @57Hertsgirl10 says, if OP had managed to convince her DH that the friend was ok, this thread wouldn't be here.

Bovrilly · 23/12/2021 22:20

Yes I was just checking it was the same story. I was wondering how you handle letting your child go to school when some teachers are predators. As the argument about the OP's situation seems to be that some men are predators so don't let one look after your child.

Hertsgirl10 · 23/12/2021 21:57

@Bovrilly

I saw that this morning and thought of all these trusting women that leave their kids with so called trusted adults, and felt so sad.

This was a teacher though, wasn't it? So would you not let your child go to school if even so called trusted adults are to be feared?

@Bovrilly

Is the deputy head teacher and head of child protection not a teacher to you?

Even after hearing that you’re still so determined to say there’s minimal risk for all of these things…

I mean the deputy head and head of child protection filmed herself and her husband raping a child under 13. I know you all say that this is rare, but it’s not is it? And yes she is a teacher, isn’t she? Not only a teacher the head child protection officer.

My children go to school but they are taught from an early age risks of situations, even at school. And by the comments on here like, you must be in constant anxiety and the other things, I can see that a lot of parents don’t even consider some situations being a risk. Which is such a shame.

There is risk in lots of situations and comparing Child abuse as likely as being hit by a meteorite, like OP said upthread just shows how naive people are with their children.

mummysherlock · 23/12/2021 21:55

If the pool has separate male and female changing rooms then this wouldn’t bother me.
Most swimming pools/leisure centres in this situation have a policy that all dc aged 8 and over get changed in their own gender changing rooms and unless they have a disability or other SN should be able to get changed without adult assistance. Indeed when my DC’s swimming lessons first started back post lockdown and the covid guidelines were stricter, all parents of children over 8 were expected to drop their DC at the door and collect from a separate exit in order to keep the number of people in the centre to a minimum and they had to arrive swim ready and change themselves afterwards.
If the changing facilities are like a changing village, so basically this other dad and indeed other adult males could be in close proximity in the changing rooms whilst your DD is in there I can see why your DH has his reservations tbh though.

Bovrilly · 23/12/2021 21:26

I saw that this morning and thought of all these trusting women that leave their kids with so called trusted adults, and felt so sad.

This was a teacher though, wasn't it? So would you not let your child go to school if even so called trusted adults are to be feared?

Hertsgirl10 · 23/12/2021 18:49

@Treesandsheepeverywhere

The case of the female deputy head in the news now springs to mind. She was also in charge of safeguarding, so would have been trusted 100% by those around her. It's not every man or woman who will be an abuser, but if there's doubt, don't take the risk.
@Treesandsheepeverywhere

I saw that this morning and thought of all these trusting women that leave their kids with so called trusted adults, and felt so sad. Especially sad that so many of us that are always 100% on protecting out children were mocked on here, but as I said before I know my children will be protected it’s up to others to do it with theirs.

Anyway the discussion would never have happened or be up for debate, just going by the title. If my partner is uncomfortable about anything to do with our children then I would never allow it to happen.

It seems everyone that has so much respect for random man at school has no respect for the child’s actually father, including his wife.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 23/12/2021 10:15

The case of the female deputy head in the news now springs to mind.
She was also in charge of safeguarding, so would have been trusted 100% by those around her.
It's not every man or woman who will be an abuser, but if there's doubt, don't take the risk.

CheeseMmmm · 23/12/2021 01:50

It's a swimming lesson. So, organised.

Octavi · 23/12/2021 01:41

I think it's bizarre swimming baths are deemed a controlled environment by some. They are open to the public. You'd have to be mad to think that safe for an unaccompanied 8 year old. My owned was sexually abused at an NCT coffee morning. Dear God there are some very naive people about.

CheeseMmmm · 22/12/2021 03:48

IME men in general are vvv cautious about their female partners, sisters, daughters etc. When it comes to men (and boys when daughter is older) just generally.

Their feelings and judgement of risk around this imo comes from a totally different place to the feelings and judgement the risk posed by men (boys) by women (and girls).

The DH has general discomfort. I would ask what exactly are you concerned about? The walk? Changing? Something you heard about this bloke? Etc.

When it comes to being all too ingrained to pretty much constantly keep male risk radar on. Noticing, assessing. Relaxing. Going into wary mode. Going elsewhere if think hmmm nah.

Women do it generally as second nature since girls. Often informed by experience sadly.

Obviously not infallible but without it we have no idea how much worse it would be. I bet a lot.

OTOH.

Male risk assessment of risk men to girls/ women. Applies usually to those they are related to, care about, are good friends with etc.

It's not IME individual risk assessment. It's a much more general worry about men (boys) full stop.

Its usually focussed on women/ girls they care about,. In this case DD. Chances are he'd be more relaxed with a son in there circs. Even though obv boys and girls are preyed on by child molesters.

Given that, realistically. Whose risk assessment is likely to be more considered, realistic?

Esp given the OH vague reason, generally uncomfortable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread