Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sentimental family Christmas cards - does ‘everyone’ do these?!

183 replies

Whohashiddenthebiscuits · 18/12/2021 19:07

Not a serious one but just been having a conversation with DH after opening DMIL’s usual Christmas large card to us with a soppy poem (sorry, showing my bias here!). DD got one too.

My family never give cards to anyone actually in the same house as them and we never give ‘Mum’, ‘Dad’ etc cards on any occasion with the exception of Mother and Fathers Day. DM has definite opinions about ‘twee & faux sentimental’ cards snd while I’m less judgy about them, they do make me squirm a bit.

DH has a very different background to me, big family, working class, big on sentiment and emotion and demonstrating that. He’s just told me that my family are ‘weird’ to send ordinary cards and most families do send/give individual ‘Mum at Christmas’ etc cards. I think he’s wrong & while I didn’t want to say it, think perhaps whether you do or not might depend on your background.

I do for the record give DH a card and have done for years. I wouldn’t have done if I wasn’t married to him but I always get one from him. He gives me a big one (which I usually hate but kind of love him for anyway) and in return he gets a small, discreet one from me!

So - are my family weird?! Is everyone else giving out these cards?!

OP posts:
awmum2b · 19/12/2021 07:10

My family do this....mostly I do photo cards with my DC on but mum likes one with nice words in it.

It's so hard as she is also particular about the image...one year she was upset because I got her a card with "vermin" on it, actually fairly cute mice in Christmas hats!

That sounds quite bad but its actually pretty funny n I just laugh that stuff off 😆

ouchmyfeet · 19/12/2021 06:47

@Driposaurus

My MIL gave us hers today too. Big and special. “To the loveliest son and dil” (I wondered if BIL got “to the second loveliest son… ;)”).

MIL expects family cards to be displayed prominently, so I stuck hers behind loads of others on a over the door card hanger thing. It’s petty but I find it weird giving cards to people you actually see yo say happy Christmas to.

My parents would never do the family card thing but I notice they’ve given us a few in recent years. Need to nip it in the bud. It’s hard enough sending the cards to the people I want to communicate with by card (and a short note inside).

I have exactly the same situation. Wouldn't dream of giving a Christmas card to someone I'm actually seeing on Christmas Day, they are for people you don't see at Christmas!

My MIL is similarly obsessed with cards and sends us horrible big ones to my son and daughter-in-law and separate ones for the DC. These come in the post on 1 December despite the fact that we spend every Christmas with them. She expects family cards to be displayed prominently so i do similar and make sure they are in with everything else and not at all prominent. There's a big gap on her mantelpiece every year until she gets a card from us. I leave this to DH and it's one of her few ridiculous ideas that he does sort of pander to. He gets the card but doesn't give it to her till he sees her on Christmas Day. That shameful gap on the mantelpiece drives her crazy all month Grin

I am with the OP. Your DH's family are BONKERS.

Blurp · 19/12/2021 06:42

PIL are firmly in the "Oddly specific named cards for every family member" camp (no matter how obscure the relationship, they'll find a card for it); my parents don't send a lot of cards, but if they do it's often ones my mum has painted herself, or generic ones from a box of 20.

I do giggle a bit at some of the more specific named ones, and I think it's a bit daft to spend so much on cards that are just going to be binned (they'll send a card to DH & I, and one each to the DC, so multiply that by all their children and grandchildren and you're talking 15 cards just for immediate family), but I'm not really one for Christmas cards anyway. I never read the poems etc inside them, to be honest. I used to think they were just to fill the space; it's only really on MN that I've come across people who pay any attention to them.

Whatever floats your boat, though, I appreciate that PIL find it meaningful and it makes them happy to send them.

PurBal · 19/12/2021 06:21

I don’t know anyone who sends these cards.

TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek · 19/12/2021 06:17

@FluffyRabbitGal

I’m with you. I find the faux sentiment in those cards vulgar.
@FluffyRabbitGal I had to laugh a little at your statement when you have the username that you do. Unfortunately that is not the only thing that I find funny in your little complaint, as it is posts like the OP's, yours and many other pp's on this thread, that, maybe ironically, I find vulgar. In fact I find them both vulgar and ignorant. I will bow out now as I don't suppose that anything I have said will have encouraged any of you to rethink your prejudices.
TurkeyRoastvBubbleandSqueek · 19/12/2021 05:46

@RedwineforSantaplease

MIL does these - the one for my DHs birthday is always a source of much hilarity between us. She means well but they're awful.

Any joint card is always a "son and daughter-in-law" one. Good to know your place.

@RedwineforSantaplease, will/can you please explain what you mean by this sentence "it is good to know your place"? If your obviously not D MiL, who loves both her son and you (?) wants to send you, her DDiL, a joint card with her son, what would you expect it to say "To a Dear Son and Daughter"? Incest is illegal in the UK, so probably not too many card companies would make that heading - are you not in the UK Red? or maybe if it said "To a Dear Daughter-in-law and Son", that would be all right because you like to come first?

My Dear Mother, who was the DD of a Head Constable, whose children went to private school, and who had a housekeeper at home, and my DMiL who was the wife of a partner in a firm of solicitors, always sent us (me and my husband, who was a barrister in a very high position in the Government at one time) personalised cards, and at Christmas they were joint ones. My DM got ones for her Daughter and Son-in-Law, and my DMiL did the same, but vice-versa. Neither my husband or I ever felt belittled, hard done by, or embarrassed by those cards, in fact it is lovely to be able to read them again, now that the senders are sadly no longer with us. I find your hilarity at your poor MiL's expense quite disgusting, so I do hope that if you have any DC that your DH and you don't let them hear you?

Personalised cards were always a 'thing' in both my and my DH's families. I still send them to my Children and Grandchildren, even the one who lives at home with us.

To all the other pp's on this thread who are sounding like Mrs Bucket/Bouquet, I am embarrassed for you and your snobberies.

I couldn't give a flying fig about any "class" system, but so many of you - including the OP - obviously could and do. You may not realise it, but you are embarrassing all of your acquaintances who do not belong to your distasteful set. Please, if you can't help having such horrid opinions, at least try to keep them to yourselves.

RobertSmithsLipstick · 19/12/2021 04:52

It's just my opinion.
Not hate.
Just the same as every other opinion on here, and just as valid.
Hate???
You've a warped view of hate, I'd say.

RobertSmithsLipstick · 19/12/2021 04:50

My messages were never false or in ingenuine either.
Magical?
Yes, christmas was before my daughter died.
Now, not even worth a card, even a blank one.

halloweenie13 · 19/12/2021 04:50

@RobertSmithsLipstick

So what else do you do as a catholic? A big christmas dinner? A new outfit? A twinkly tree?
I didn't say that though did I , I only spoke of the ingenuine messages towards loved ones, I don't care for material goods or fancy dinners. Please take your hate else where,
RobertSmithsLipstick · 19/12/2021 04:46

So what else do you do as a catholic?
A big christmas dinner?
A new outfit?
A twinkly tree?

halloweenie13 · 19/12/2021 04:44

@RobertSmithsLipstick

Well, most things pertaining to christmas arent necessary, are they? Dinner, starters, elves on shelves, puddings, drink, Christmas outfits on and on ad nauseam.
I'm a catholic, so christmas is actually part of my culture and religion and this has never been a thing, people don't waste paper to send false and ingenuine messages....
itbemay1 · 19/12/2021 04:44

@Tinkletwat

My mother in law sends us one of these and it does make me cringe a little (ok, a lot). Would rather her behaviour was more in line with the sentiment of the card than send these monstrosities.
Exactly this!!
RobertSmithsLipstick · 19/12/2021 04:44

As is most of Christmas.

halloweenie13 · 19/12/2021 04:43

@MalFunkshun

The rank snobbishness of some of the responses here is pretty grim, as is the fairly joyless first response - although both very MN.

I don’t send these cards because I prefer to write my own message, but my lovely (and yes, WC) Dad sends me them because, I suspect, he absolutely means every word but would never feel comfortable saying it out loud. Just because they’re not to your taste doesn’t mean it’s fair game to pull out the sly WC = tacky = so not ME, dahling - to me, that’s a far tackier and more unappealing attitude than the one that sends enthusiastic cards.

For those of you smugly proclaiming how you don’t send cards because it’s bad for the environment / it’s tacky / whatever weird MC justification you’ve come up with - They’re Not For You. For some people, that might be the only bit of post they get that’s not a bill. For others that might be the only personal message they get. I too have cleared out elderly relatives’ homes where all the cards have been saved. For the sake of a fiver and an evening scribbling some nice words, I think it’s an effort worth making to make someone smile.

They were all entirely honest opinions so please do not be so dismissive and do not assume someone's background just because they find this idea tacky or bad for the environment (which it is on both accounts)
RobertSmithsLipstick · 19/12/2021 04:42

Well, most things pertaining to christmas arent necessary, are they?
Dinner, starters, elves on shelves, puddings, drink, Christmas outfits on and on ad nauseam.

GirlOfTudor · 19/12/2021 04:41

My husband's brother loves to write a 'special' message whenever he writes a card and got very upset when he received a card from me and my husband for the first time and it was a simple 'to X, from X' that I do for everyone. He told me that's how I need to write cards, and I may or may not have ended the phone call there 🤷‍♀️
I find his messages cringey as they're always the same 'health and happiness' sentiments 🙄

halloweenie13 · 19/12/2021 04:40

@YellowandGreenToBeSeen

Absolutely not. Named or ‘Relative’ cards are considered overly emotional and, dare I say it, tacky in my family.

Mass produced poems (or joke based comments) don’t do it for us.

This! They are beyond tacky and cringey , there's just no need, say it to them when you see them if you must!
halloweenie13 · 19/12/2021 04:37

Not only is it an environmental waste, but it is just not necessary with family you are actually close with.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 19/12/2021 04:33

The only person I know who does this is my mum. I don't like them and I find it a bit of a joke to be honest as she spent most of my childhood telling me she wished I'd never been born. Yet she acts like these cards are truly how she feels.

I only buy cards that have very little inside them and struggle to buy cards for my mum as I can't bring myself to get anything that mentions love or how amazing mums are (hard to find a very basic card) and she's previously thrown a wobbler if the card doesn't specifically say mum on the front.

ElftonWednesday · 19/12/2021 04:24

I'm so sorry @neatlittlerows Flowers

I find myself getting more sentimental as I get older. If cards make me cry in the shop they are the right ones for my DM, PIL and Auntie.

neatlittlerows · 19/12/2021 04:20

I used to roll my eyes a bit at the soppy cards my mum would send for birthdays and Christmas. Now she’s not here I’m glad that I kept them each year. I’m more of a ‘blank inside for your own message’ kind of person but she wasn’t. Horses for courses. It’s the thought that counts. My auntie was another who would send those cards, but she died last night, so no more sentimental cards for me ☹️

RobertSmithsLipstick · 19/12/2021 04:13

I send them, but with my mouth twisted into a bit of a sneer.
That let's me off the "tacky" hook, I think.

ElftonWednesday · 19/12/2021 04:08

My DM loves soppy sentimental cards and I found that she and Card Factory cards are a match made in heaven. So I get my cards for all family from there recently.

Must admit it entertains me slightly to give sloppy sentimental cards to the in-laws, as I'm sure they will be slightly (inwardly at least) tutting and feeling a bit superior as the OP is here. MIL sends very tasteful blank inside religious-themed cards.

DockOTheBay · 19/12/2021 04:02

My husband's grandparents give these, and expect them in return. I hate them and I find them really disingenuous because they would never say those things to me in real life. I make my husband buy their cards and this year he forgot so they've just been given one with my kids handprint on like everyone else and a brief sincere message.

Loads of them are so badly written as well, they don't scan or make sense or rhyme. We had one this year which was 3 sides of writing and was along the lines of "the real magic of Christmas is love because when we have love, magic comes too and the loving magic we feel goes on and on in a magical way." And so on for 3 sides.

MalFunkshun · 19/12/2021 03:54

The rank snobbishness of some of the responses here is pretty grim, as is the fairly joyless first response - although both very MN.

I don’t send these cards because I prefer to write my own message, but my lovely (and yes, WC) Dad sends me them because, I suspect, he absolutely means every word but would never feel comfortable saying it out loud. Just because they’re not to your taste doesn’t mean it’s fair game to pull out the sly WC = tacky = so not ME, dahling - to me, that’s a far tackier and more unappealing attitude than the one that sends enthusiastic cards.

For those of you smugly proclaiming how you don’t send cards because it’s bad for the environment / it’s tacky / whatever weird MC justification you’ve come up with - They’re Not For You. For some people, that might be the only bit of post they get that’s not a bill. For others that might be the only personal message they get. I too have cleared out elderly relatives’ homes where all the cards have been saved. For the sake of a fiver and an evening scribbling some nice words, I think it’s an effort worth making to make someone smile.