Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sentimental family Christmas cards - does ‘everyone’ do these?!

183 replies

Whohashiddenthebiscuits · 18/12/2021 19:07

Not a serious one but just been having a conversation with DH after opening DMIL’s usual Christmas large card to us with a soppy poem (sorry, showing my bias here!). DD got one too.

My family never give cards to anyone actually in the same house as them and we never give ‘Mum’, ‘Dad’ etc cards on any occasion with the exception of Mother and Fathers Day. DM has definite opinions about ‘twee & faux sentimental’ cards snd while I’m less judgy about them, they do make me squirm a bit.

DH has a very different background to me, big family, working class, big on sentiment and emotion and demonstrating that. He’s just told me that my family are ‘weird’ to send ordinary cards and most families do send/give individual ‘Mum at Christmas’ etc cards. I think he’s wrong & while I didn’t want to say it, think perhaps whether you do or not might depend on your background.

I do for the record give DH a card and have done for years. I wouldn’t have done if I wasn’t married to him but I always get one from him. He gives me a big one (which I usually hate but kind of love him for anyway) and in return he gets a small, discreet one from me!

So - are my family weird?! Is everyone else giving out these cards?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RobertSmithsLipstick · 20/12/2021 10:11

I'm not sure why someone wouldn't buy a card that their loved one would prefer.
How weird!

Ellieboolou33 · 20/12/2021 08:36

@Footprintsinthegrass

My mum gives me super soppy old fashioned cards and I hate them. I like more modern ones without a verse in. She insists that I get her a card even though I wouldn't, I get her a modern one with no verse and I know she'd like a soppy one but she doesn't push it. I see her twice a week and will see her on Christmas day so I've no idea why she wants a card
Aw this makes me feels bit sad, you get her a card you like and not one she'd like because you hate soppy words, that's weird and a little selfish.

For the record, I'm really not fussed about cards, soppy words or otherwise but would send a special one for those people in my like who I know would appreciate them.

RhubarbFairy · 20/12/2021 07:34

@Dacquoise

If the sentiments on the card are genuine and heartfelt then I don't understand how there can be a right or wrong about the cards. However, looking for a non sentimental mother's day card used to be a minefield because I didn't want to give a card that was dishonest and sending a card (out of duty) that expounded virtues she didn't have just felt wrong. Now NC the dilemma has completely disappeared.
I had exactly this issue too. I'm not a fan of Mothers Day in general. It all feels too forced. I'd rather random nice things throughout the year, both as giver and receiver.

I had one memorable Mothers Day with my own mother where I got up at the crack of dawn and got a 2.5 hour coach to see her, take her for lunch and give her a lovely gift, then got the coach back in the evening (working both Saturday and Monday so no option to make it an overnight).

She kicked off when I rang to say I was home as she was so hurt and upset that I hadn't given her a card.

We're NC now but all cards after that were a simple 'Mum' with 'Happy Mother's Day'.

RhubarbFairy · 20/12/2021 07:24

My dad and stepmum are big on sentimental cards. They always send to us and one year I had the gall to send them a generic one from a box. They actually told me how hurt they were by it so I've never dared since and always buy a special one now.

I was about 20 then. I'm now 39 and did actually have a conversation with my stepmum about it this year where I encouraged her to spend the money on our card in the hospice her friend is in instead. I pointed out that they just end up in the recycling anyway. She agreed but said it wouldn't feel right not sending us one.

In-laws always send them too so we feel we have to. They're not bothered but DH felt bad one year when we spent Christmas there and our generic card was in pride of place in the 'family' spot next to BILs big 'Mum and Dad' one.

They're the same at birthdays too. The only way I get away with not buying a special one is by making a photo one with pictures of them and the DC on.

Fritilleries · 20/12/2021 07:14

Does anybody have a MIL that will actually take a card and READ it? Any card?! Like.... being nosey and physically reading a personal message?

Whohashiddenthebiscuits · 20/12/2021 06:34

DH does actually buy the PILs specific card.. along with one for me, my stepdaughter and our own daughter, my DD2. Everyone else (my eldest DD from a previous relationship, my family, all our friends) get non specific cards chosen by me. He has bought DD2 quite a few presents off his own back without any prompting but I’ve bought everything else present wise including a present to his closest friend and their children. We share the cost. When it comes to birthdays, I buy all presents to his family, he will buy the cards.

Someone upstream mentioned that a lot of the burden of Christmas, birthdays etc falls on women which from observation I think is true. In our case, i just think I’m better at multi tasking, DH is usually mentally swallowed up in a project, working all hours, I’ve usually a better idea of what people like so it’s just easier to get on and do it.

@Gennz18, typically we give/send 20-25 cards. DD2 is only giving 2 this year but back in Primary days would give 30. So that would be 55 cards. And yes, a heck of a lot of paper waste. I buy cards made with recycled paper that are recyclable but it still ain’t great!

OP posts:
CrimbleCrumble1 · 19/12/2021 22:13

I send four cards and they are all sentimental.

Megan2018 · 19/12/2021 22:04

I don’t get sentimental ones, but do send Mum, Dad, Grandma, Grandad, Great Grandma ones. I receive Daughter and Granddaughter ones, DD gets granddaughter ones.
I like them, but I am selective about content!

VikingOnTheFridge · 19/12/2021 21:56

People increasingly don't do them/are reducing the number sent. There are usually some fairly vicious debates about cards on here in December. This year has been a quieter one than usual.

Gennz18 · 19/12/2021 21:36

I have done 3 for teachers, 1 for the person I manage at work and 1 for our nanny. All to accompany gifts. Mainly because they are people I want to thank for all their hard work this year.

Family and friends get gifts but no cards. No cards for DH, or 2 DC.

A lot of the posts here seem to be about ILs “insisting” on a specific category of card. The sum total of DH’s contribution to Christmas has been buying a remote controlled boat for DS (that I sent him the link to) so if he expected me to organise naff cards for his family I would probably divorce him.

Gennz18 · 19/12/2021 21:31

Can I just ask you all how many cards you would need to write of a Christmas season. Between family, friends, kid’s friends etc?

Mind boggling down here in the colonies

Snuggledupforwinter · 19/12/2021 19:10

I send a flowery one to DMas she loved them and always used to send each of us when she was fit and well. Siblings and I don't send a card to each other unless were not meeting up Xmas day.
DM now has dementia and doesn't always recognise us so I've kept the last card that she wrote herself.

Redglitter · 19/12/2021 18:16

We do the family ones. Mum/sister/niece etc but they're not flowery with poems type. It's just a tradition now

lottiegarbanzo · 19/12/2021 18:16

I've always seen cards as a way of communicating with people you're not going to see on the day, or don't live with. Wouldn't occur to me to send members of my immediate family, who live in the same house, a card. Seems odd and OTT to me!

RampantIvy · 19/12/2021 18:14

No.
No parents alive now, and I don't write cards for people living in my house.

I buy cards to support charities. They get recycled after Christmas.

DustyMaiden · 19/12/2021 18:11

I paint a picture personal to the recipient then have it printed on a card. How much do I regret starting that.

CounsellorTroi · 19/12/2021 18:11

Footprintsinthegrass
My mum gives me super soppy old fashioned cards and I hate them. I like more modern ones without a verse in. She insists that I get her a card even though I wouldn't, I get her a modern one with no verse and I know she'd like a soppy one but she doesn't push it. I see her twice a week and will see her on Christmas day so I've no idea why she wants a card
But shes your mum? Cant you just get her what you know she will love?

This. You’re buying the card for her, not for yourself.

crochetmonkey74 · 19/12/2021 18:10

@BellaChagall

I no longer have a mother, father, sister or brother. Trust me, it hurts when you walk around card shops. People may mock, but is it really a bad thing to buy a card like this for a family member? One of my most treasured possessions is the last 'daughter' card my mum bought me. I'm not a daughter any more.
Me too bella , it's a pain like no other
linerforlife · 19/12/2021 18:08

My in laws all expect this so I have to buy them and they're quite expensive as my DH has 3 siblings! I really resent the money out of my Christmas budget.

crochetmonkey74 · 19/12/2021 18:06

@Footprintsinthegrass

My mum gives me super soppy old fashioned cards and I hate them. I like more modern ones without a verse in. She insists that I get her a card even though I wouldn't, I get her a modern one with no verse and I know she'd like a soppy one but she doesn't push it. I see her twice a week and will see her on Christmas day so I've no idea why she wants a card
But shes your mum? Cant you just get her what you know she will love?
Echofallen · 19/12/2021 18:03

I went out and got a "to you all" card for my DB/SIL/niblings and wrote it out before realising that I couldn't put "love from Auntie X" as I'm not my brother's Auntie... Went back out and got separate DB/SIL card and a card for the kids. I refuse to get separate kids cards. Bah.

Fatgalslim · 19/12/2021 17:26

My mum loves a card with a nice verse so that's what she gets, I get the same in return with lovely words written by her. I like it and I know I'll miss it when she's no longer with us

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 19/12/2021 17:14

I will never forget my first Christmas with DH where he handed me a Christmas card on Christmas Day and looked at me expectantly for his one. I did not have one. He was crushed! He seems to think exchanging Christmas cards with one another is akin to birthday cards. I will happily write and post to all our friends and family, doctors etc but giving one another a card?! 😆🤦🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️

lemmein · 19/12/2021 17:11

I'm as WC as they come and send a box set card - can't be arsed standing around in a card shop hunting for relationship cards. Even then I only send cards to those I know would be hurt if I didn't - Christmas cards annoy me, both giving and receiving.

My mum buys sentimental cards though.

crochetmonkey74 · 19/12/2021 17:00

I love them, they make me feel nostalgic and really loved

Swipe left for the next trending thread