Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think letting agents prioritise their existing tenants

64 replies

Lettingagentsaretwats · 18/12/2021 19:00

And per my username, are twats? Or other expletive of choice?

DP and I have just been turned down for our 15th property in a row. No explanation from the agents, because 'its DPA' Hmm.

There's nothing wrong with our applications. We're both professionals with good credit history. We earn more than double the affordability criteria. No pets, children etc. We've been applying solidly since August and nothing.

The only property we were offered was one with DPs current letting agents. Same information for every other application and we've been turned down every time (this is with another 8 or 9 different agents, the ones DP is with have only had 1 house on their books since we started looking).

I understand theres competition, blah blah, but if they're favouring their own tenants then we are basically wasting hours of our time every time aren't we? It takes hours of my life - checking Rightmove, contacting agents about viewings, then having to do a kind of initial vetting JUST to be allowed to view. Then DP has to attend viewings all over the county with little notice because they won't let you apply without an in person viewing. Then theres the applications (one for me and one for DP, so 2 lots every time) which take a good 45 mins to print, complete by hand, scan and email every single time. None of them use online forms.

DP has said we may as well throw in the towel and give up applying unless something comes up with his current agents but as theyve only had 1 house in 4 months it's unlikely. We are both at the end of our tether with it.

The latest place, we would have offered £50 more a month but didn't even get the chance it's just a flat no.

OP posts:
Corrag · 18/12/2021 22:44

I suppose from the letting agent's point of view, if they let you apply without viewing it you may be more likely to pull out /change your mind /not stay long. I only asked because we bought a house without viewing it recently, the market was so crazy.

JustLyra · 18/12/2021 22:43

[quote Lettingagentsaretwats]@JustLyra the rejection email came through after close of business today so not had a chance to speak to them yet but I will do on Monday.

I don't think there are any typos or inaccuracies, I handwrote both forms for DP and I, as they can't be typed but I will check.

My issue with the agent doing the picking is more that they're liars about it. Oh we have to run this past the LL, oh its the LL choice we have nothing to do with it, oh the LL needs to read the forms etc. They all make out thats how it is but I heard somewhere that for 'DPA' reasons they can't share the forms so that part isn't true and possibly none of it is.[/quote]
They can share the forms with the LL.

Double check your forms for errors.

If your DP is doing all the viewings is he rubbing the agents up the wrong way somehow?

Lettingagentsaretwats · 18/12/2021 22:33

@Corrag we've asked agents if we can apply without a viewing and every one has said absolutely not - one place the only viewing was on a weekday afternoon (tenants still in situ and they would only allow a single 2 hour slot) which neither of us could make. We basically begged the agents and they were firm in saying it wasn't possible to apply without viewing. So I can't see how people could apply without viewing unless the agents are again lying to us.

@user1471538283 its all very well to say keep applying but how are we suddenly going to be accepted if we haven't been so far? Whats going to change? And its not like this requires no effort or investment of time, it requires a lot of both. DP is utterly sick of it, dropping work to rush to viewing after viewing, and to no avail.

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 18/12/2021 22:31

The places you are looking at, what % would the rent be of your post tax income?

Are you stretching yourselves? You might have perfect credit history but some letting agents will not want you if (for example) the rent will be over 1/3 of your net pay.

user1471538283 · 18/12/2021 22:12

I dont feel that my landlord or managing agent favors those already here. I always get the feeling they are waiting for people to leave so they can increase the already ridiculously high rent.

This is the end result of not building affordable and local authority properties. All you can do is keep applying.

FrippEnos · 18/12/2021 22:11

I can safely say that you are wrong.

I have been in the same place 10 + years and with the same LA 16 years.

Its all about the market, there is a glut of renters and very few places to rent.

Even though I am on the books, I miss out on so many places that its unreal.

Corrag · 18/12/2021 22:00

Is it possible some people are applying/offering without viewing, therefore getting ahead of you?

Lettingagentsaretwats · 18/12/2021 21:50

I phone as soon as properties go on Rightmove. I check on there hourly. I give my details for initial screening/decision as to whether we're worthy to view. We, or usually DP, attends viewings at any time offered, be it 10am on a Tuesday, 3.45pm on a Friday or any other time. We've returned early from holiday and cancelled work meetings. We apply as soon after the viewing as we can - usually about an hour or two by the time they've sent the form over (because you can't have the form before the viewing) and I've then spent the obligatory 45 mins printing handwriting and scanning the thing back to them.

I can't see anything else we can do. We can't be any quicker.

OP posts:
Lettingagentsaretwats · 18/12/2021 21:43

@JustLyra the rejection email came through after close of business today so not had a chance to speak to them yet but I will do on Monday.

I don't think there are any typos or inaccuracies, I handwrote both forms for DP and I, as they can't be typed but I will check.

My issue with the agent doing the picking is more that they're liars about it. Oh we have to run this past the LL, oh its the LL choice we have nothing to do with it, oh the LL needs to read the forms etc. They all make out thats how it is but I heard somewhere that for 'DPA' reasons they can't share the forms so that part isn't true and possibly none of it is.

OP posts:
HopefulProcrastinator · 18/12/2021 21:37

The rental market is brutal. We're long term renters because oddly enough paying someone else's mortgage makes it hard to save a deposit and this year was the hardest and most stressful move we've ever had.

We were incredibly fortunate to secure our new place (hard experience told us to apply immediately, the other viewers were naive and said they'd think about it) after old landlord issued section 21 to sell and I'm now living on eggshells trying to be immaculate tenants/neighbours and overthinking every tiny thing because I can't face going through all that again.

For what it's worth though, we jumped agents to secure this place, so they're not all blind to outside tenants.

Lettingagentsaretwats · 18/12/2021 21:36

We plan to buy in about 3 years, for various reasons we need to rent until then. At present we couldn't afford to buy a house equivalent to one we could rent, if that makes sense.

Houses were looking at are £700-850 a month to rent, but at least £250k to buy. Ultimately we want to buy somewhere bigger which will be more like £350-400k but that a few years off. Right now if we had to buy we could only get somewhere for about £150k which would be too small -and tbh would be on a par with DPs current place he wants to move from, precisely because its too small!

As will be obvious from the prices quoted, we don't live in or near London!

OP posts:
mumwon · 18/12/2021 21:34

Many landlords are/have sold their properties
Why?
Because the rules & costs are getting harder & higher
more complex laws are in the pipeline making eviction harder (& if you have ever had a non paying tenant who is wrecking the property) & the covid effect which while helping the tenants angled the landlords into getting costs if they had loans or other expenses.
The landlord now pays for upfront fees
the electric checks (no I don't object I just think the testers shouldn't be the fixers - its an opening for the unscrupulous tradesman to take advantage & they do, massively)
& the whole unthought out upgrading of energy standard. Aka the unaffordable cost/ & the inability to improve some properties (flats/ old houses insultation) & making allowances against capital (only usable at sale) versus revenue (so it can be taken against annual taxable sums) & while previously there was a maximum sum of £3500 most upgrades are in excess of £10,000
therefore many landlords have had enough.
Interestingly council houses do not have to conform to some of these rules.
Some pp have mentioned why agents/landlords may prefer known tenants & if agents knows that some of their present tenants who may well have previously viewed the available property want to move to bigger or more expensive one OR if the landlord chooses a tenant they know - I am sorry its frustrating but that is the way it is

JustLyra · 18/12/2021 21:31

[quote Lettingagentsaretwats]@SenseSphere yes we don't understand why we were rejected as we were the only viewer.

I suspect we've been misled and we were not the only viewer. I am going to ask the agents about it. At this stage I have nothing to lose. This is the 3rd property we've been turned down for by the same company. I strongly suspect its the agent doing the choosing rather than the landlord.[/quote]
If you were the only viewer then have you double and triple checked your form with that agent?

I had a man throw a hissy fit once when he was rejected, but he'd mistyped his salary on the form.

It very much often is the Agent picking the tenant - that's not sneaky or anything. Many LL's use a fully managed service so don't get involved at all.

SlashBeef · 18/12/2021 21:29

I'd be buying a house if I had the income to be paying 12 months upfront rent!

Lettingagentsaretwats · 18/12/2021 21:23

@SenseSphere yes we don't understand why we were rejected as we were the only viewer.

I suspect we've been misled and we were not the only viewer. I am going to ask the agents about it. At this stage I have nothing to lose. This is the 3rd property we've been turned down for by the same company. I strongly suspect its the agent doing the choosing rather than the landlord.

OP posts:
Lettingagentsaretwats · 18/12/2021 21:21

@MintJulia 2 of his moves were due to relocation, and 2 to landlords selling. The others were because he found somewhere better. He was in all of them for a year apart from the ones where LL wanted to sell and he agreed to leave after 6 months. He's been in his current place for over 2.5 years.

Also the agents have no idea about this as their forms only require us to give either current address only, or address for past 2 years, which is the same thing.

Both our jobs are very secure. We work in legal/ financial services. I've worked for the same company for 12 years.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 18/12/2021 21:07

Also if the other applicants who pass the same checks as you all already live together and you don't (as it seems from your OP) then that will go in their favour.

JustLyra · 18/12/2021 21:06

The year up front can be a minefield. It can't be a protected deposit because of the rules, and then you have no idea as the year progresses where their finances are at (or how organised they are) as no-one is going ot pay 12 months, then pay every month as well.

It's not an automatic good thing.

MintJulia · 18/12/2021 21:01

Op, you said earlier your dp had rented 6 places in 8 years.

If I were a landlord, that wouldn't appeal to me at all. I'd want a tenant who was going to stay put for a few years, not constantly changing. Less hassle.

Perhaps that is the issue.

Thefrenchconnection1 · 18/12/2021 20:55

Also I had a guy wanting to pay a year upfront. It made me more nervous if anything as something didn't quite add up.

Thefrenchconnection1 · 18/12/2021 20:53

I'm a landlord. I prefer someone closer to the minimum salary and in industries unlikely to not have work. For example I have rented to a 25k a year lorry driver over a 50k a year managing director.

SenseSphere · 18/12/2021 20:53

I’ve nothing to add other than to say it sounds incredibly frustrating and I’m glad I’m no longer renting, the market sounds nuts.

If you were the only viewers for one of the properties I’m confused as to why you weren’t accepted given what you stated earlier about your circumstances.

Lettingagentsaretwats · 18/12/2021 20:25

@Aprilx well I'm glad that worked for you. However none of the agents in the place we're applying will accept any documentation other than their stupid printed forms. I've tried to send covering letters saying we'll pay a lump sum of rent upfront and been told the only info they can accept is their own forms.

They won't accept references upfront, ditto any proof of savings, assets or investments etc. They have their own agenda which is to feather their nest, moving their own tenants around and keeping the money rolling in. I can pay a landlord 12 months up front and offer up to 10% more than the rent they're charging -that WOULD clearly be in the landlords interest but the agents won't put that to them.

I'm so angry about the latest one I'm considering contacting the landlord directly and offering the extra per month. And also asking why our application was turned down -assuming of course they actually saw our application and it wasn't just vetoed by the fucking agents.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 18/12/2021 20:14

@Lettingagentsaretwats

How is it not unfair? It means we will only ever get a property through DPs agents (who let flats almost exclusively, we want to move to a house) and on that basis anyone moving from out of the area, or who isn't currently renting through an agent has bugger all chance of getting anywhere.

Basically what you're saying is it's hard luck. Lovely.

I'd like to know what you'd do to find a house in this situation, or whether you'd be prepared to spend hours each week every week on it. And to get ZERO feedback too, because the agents are so sly and conniving they can't admit they're favouring their own tenants. Which is not in the landlords interest if we could offer/ pay more.

I don't know what more we can do.

I think you are being a bit ridiculous suggesting that letting agents are being sly and conniving because they have shown preference tired and tested tenants. If I were the landlord, I would prefer to have the tried and tested tenant than the unknown one too. The letting agent also does not need to be “fair” to applicants, they need to do the best they can by the landlords. There is no point moaning about letting agents who are just doing their job.

Anyway to the issue. Twelve years ago we moved to Sydney when the rental market was crazy and we came with no track record being new immigrants. I put together what I called my rental pack which contained references, proof of earnings, proof of savings and a covering letter introducing us . We had previously been to some of the rental open houses (which is how they did it in Sydney), however once I did the rental pack we got a more personal service.

JustLyra · 18/12/2021 20:13

It is just the market though. There are a lot of people looking and not enough places.

When it comes down to having half a dozen people who all pass all the checks, who all have the same score when you tally up affordability, no kids, no pets etc, then there has to be a tie break thing. When it's that they have a known background then it's completely understandable.

Just in the same way people who don't get on with the LA will lose out in the same circs because the LA doesn't like them or they're too much hassle.

It's purely down to the lack of properties available atm compared to people looking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread