Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this safe childminding practice?

76 replies

amoobaa · 18/12/2021 19:00

Wanting to know if I’m being over anxious...

I’ve just secured a place with a childminder for our son. He will be 12 months old.

The childminder seems great in all other ways. I’m just a bit concerned about nap arrangements as she doesn’t have a baby monitor.

She will have the babies all napping together (on their own sleeping mats) on the living room floor.

I’m fine with this, so long as they are observed, but she leaves them in the room unattended and goes downstairs without a baby monitor to observe them.

Is this safe? Whilst he cannot get out of the room (she will close the door) he could easily wake up and crawl around the room. I’m imagining him climbing on things or hitting his head on the hard furniture (TV unit and low tables). Or crawling over and waking/ poking other babies.

He’s got a really strong grip!! What if he hurt another child or another child hurt him? Or if he managed to climb onto the sofa and fall of it?

I’m not sure if I’m missing something or whether this is usual practice.

He’s only ever slept in a cot or travel cot, anything else seems risky without a baby monitor.

I can’t find any official guidelines...

She seems to think she will hear any noises but the floor is carpeted and she will be on a completely different floor of the house.

What if he gets into a tricky situation but is silent? It just seems so odd not to observe them. Or am I being paranoid?

Any opinions would be really appreciated.

I’m not sure her reasoning but I’d happily supply a baby monitor if that helped.

I’m actually quite worried about the 6 month old who my 12 month old will be napping next to. What if my son crawled over and started to try and play and ended up hurting her?

All thoughts welcome.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
amoobaa · 27/01/2022 23:56

Just wanted to say thank you again to everyone who gave their opinions.

An update:

I tried to speak to her about my concerns a couple of times but each time I ended up being reassured whilst on the phone… only to realise afterwards that none of my concerns had actually been addressed and no solution was really reached.

She just said things like ‘I can’t explain how I do it, I just do it’ and ‘any time you’re worried please call me and we can find a solution and it will be ok’…

I kept thinking, but I am calling you… right now… and clearly stating my concerns but you’re really not keen on changing anything… so it’s not really ok Confused

there was lots of resistance to using a monitor or a travel cot, even if we provided both and offered to provide ones she felt happy with.

I felt so helpless because I had visited everywhere in the local area and was running out of options! The ones I loved were fully booked or just too far away.

Anyway, I called our healthy visitor and she basically said some parents wouldn’t mind that set up but I have to make my own decision (I was asking about official guidance and what the general rules are- they all seem so open to interpretation…)

Then I called our local family advice centre and hit the jackpot… got through to a childminder coordinator who was obviously very experienced and knows all the minders in our area.

She said she would have a chat and that she is always here to support both parents and childminders. She knows the childminder well and was keen to discuss the sleeping arrangements with her, in a supportive but firm way, as she was not happy with the arrangements as described. She felt 6 months was too young to be on a mat. And she thought there should be more observation/ closer observation throughout naps.

She also gave me details of another childminder, who I hadn't been aware of, she is fully registered and has a space. She has two other children who are a bit older than our son (so he’s have the chance to make friends) and she has a garden (we don’t have a garden so that would be really lovely for our son).

anyway, after the call from the coordinator, the original childminder did a huge U turn. She couldn’t have been more helpful or flexible. She said it had just been a misunderstanding. She welcomed me bringing whatever I felt comfortable with. She said she’d borrow a travel cot and was very keen to keep me signed up. She asked if I was visiting other childminders.

I said the coordinator had given me details and said it was very normal to visit other settings but I did genuinely want things to work out with her.

I thought maybe there could be a way to salvage the situation. Plus our baby had reacted to her really well.

The thing is, when the coordinator called back to see how things were going, she told me that the childminder had reassured her that her assistant is near the room they sleep in and that she uses a monitor when she leaves the room.

And that simply doesn’t add up. Because I know she won’t have an Assistant when my son starts there… and she has certainly not got a monitor.

I don’t know. It all just felt a bit off again.

So I went to visit the other childminder and she is lovely.

To cut a long story short, we are choosing the new childminder who was recommended to us by the coordinator.

She seems to hear me when I speak (if that makes any sense?) it doesn’t just get brushed under the carpet, leaving me feeling like I’m going mad!

The sleeping arrangements seem a lot more secure and I feel a sense of peace and relief feel in my gut.

So I messaged the original childminder.

In a nut shell I thanked her for being so flexible and kind, I said we had changed our plans and wouldn’t be needing care from her anymore. I apologised for letting her down (we had signed a contract to start settling in March).

I’ve given her just over a months notice that we’ve changed our mind and don’t want to settle him with her. I have also acknowledged that she has the right to keep the deposit (not great for us! But making the right decision is more important.)

I apologised for messaging rather than calling (as it was late evening already) and said I was happy to chat tomorrow if she wanted.

I wanted to tell her asap and although it’s a bit rude sending it in a message, I really wanted to make sure it was put down in writing, with complete clarity.

She then tried calling me after 10pm and I didn’t see it ring. That made me feel a little anxious about her reaction. As I’d made it quite clear that the decision was definite and that I would be free tomorrow (not tonight).

Fingers crossed for an easy conversation tomorrow.

I’ve made up my mind and am worried she’s going to be quite annoyed with me.

We sign paperwork with the new one tomorrow morning. Phew!

I just wish I could shake the guilt.

It’s such a hard decision and so emotionally charged. I just hope I’ve made the right decision.

Thanks everyone Smile

OP posts:
cleantheshelfaftertheelf · 20/12/2021 00:05

100% trust your gut and don't use her.

Nillynally · 19/12/2021 23:29

At my childminders the young ones all had separate rooms (a spare room and the playroom) in their own travel cots. It's only now that they're older (nearly 3) that they now nap together on different sofas in the living room.

Hankunamatata · 19/12/2021 23:21

Also cofused why she would nap them unsupervised in a room with furniture and not contained in travel cots

Hankunamatata · 19/12/2021 23:19

Wouldn't be happy leaving my own kids all napping together in a completely different room with the door closed when they were babies never mind someone else's, they climb, bite, poke. I wouldn't be happy with baby monitor either if she is on completely different floor, too far if something goes wrong.

bumbleymummy · 19/12/2021 23:19

Hmmm, no, I wouldn’t be happy with that. I would want her to have a baby monitor. Not sure about babies all sleeping on mats on the floor too. Is this a thing now?

nokidshere · 19/12/2021 23:16

have you checked that she is registered with ofsted.most display their ratings plaque at the front door.

I've been registered with Ofsted for 25yrs and I've never had a ratings plaque?

The sleeping arrangements are bad practice and I wouldn't leave my child there.

lisaandalan · 19/12/2021 23:04

I would not be happy with this, I'd want him in a travel cot or his pushchair. X

insancerre · 19/12/2021 17:32

@Justheretoaskaquestion91
Thank you 😀

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 19/12/2021 17:11

@insancerre

Horrendous. Incidentally, fantastic username!

insancerre · 19/12/2021 16:56

@Justheretoaskaquestion91
They look like bite marks to me
It’s what happens when children are left unattended

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 19/12/2021 16:47

Good point re furniture attached to walls too

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 19/12/2021 16:47

@Winniemarysarah
WTAF how did that happen?!

The sleeping on mats wouldn’t concern me - the being left alone would!!!

insancerre · 19/12/2021 16:43

Those photos are horrific
Op, ring her and ask her directly what the arrangements for the supervision of sleeping children are
You may have misheard and she may be able to put your mind at rest
Or, she might confirm your worst fears, in which case you should seriously consider reporting her to ofsted

marykitty · 19/12/2021 16:42

In my DC nursery they all sleep in travel cots until age 2 and then on the floor from 2+ (but parents can request to have the kid still in the cot after age 2 as needed). They also have a sound monitor in the room which is adjacent to the play area.

alexdgr8 · 19/12/2021 16:06

have you checked that she is registered with ofsted.
most display their ratings plaque at the front door.
i think you should report this practice to ofsted, and find somewhere else for your child.
if any accident occurred there, and you had not reported it, how would you feel.

Winniemarysarah · 19/12/2021 16:03

And another one

Winniemarysarah · 19/12/2021 16:02

This happened to an unsupervised baby at nap time in a nursery

forrestgreen · 19/12/2021 15:56

What would happen if your child was teething and wouldn't go to sleep at the correct time.
Would your child be the focus and can she reschedule her prayer time

Toastmost · 19/12/2021 06:55

I wouldn't be happy with this either. She can't have loads and loads of children otherwise she'd be above ratio. Ours has travel cots and just puts them up and down the morning she has mindees- what happens when they are a bit older and can walk around etc?

IHateCoronavirus · 19/12/2021 06:50

Mine is a school nursery but some of our twos still sleep after lunch. They are on mats on the floor, safest option as they can’t fall from anywhere, but they are checked every 10 mins, and we sign to say we checked them, on a chart on the wall.

PinkPrettyPearls · 19/12/2021 06:47

I think I read that you said she would be downstairs praying?

She need to be , with that mad set up.

Just cancel and look for someone registered, and sensible

PinkPrettyPearls · 19/12/2021 06:42

Don’t leave your child there.
Mats on the floor ? No, not safe at all.

Find somewhere/ someone else

RedWingBoots · 19/12/2021 06:22

Please find another childminder.

My CM has an open plan ground floor so when her mindees are asleep she can be on the same floor as them doing other stuff.

insancerre · 19/12/2021 06:14

I’m a nursery manager and I feel quite concerned by these sleep arrangements
Our babies are never left unsupervised while sleeping
We do sleep checks every 10 minutes on every child which gets recorded on the app
Anything can happen in this scenario- children can bite or harm each other or a child could have a convulsion or be sick
It’s very worrying that she thinks this is acceptable