Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you maintain professional relationships as a Childminder?

40 replies

isaisaisabel · 18/12/2021 15:50

Reflecting on this past 8 months of childminding I have done, I can't help feel that my terms and conditions of NMCA contract have been largely ignored.

Can any childminders tell me how you ensure parents respect your setting as much as they would respect a nursery setting without upsetting them or harming the relationship?

Examples:

Repeated lateness which has infringed on my family life and evenings with my own DC. It is usually 15/20 minutes but daily which really adds up. I cannot help feel that they would not do this with a nursery.

Repeated late payments which have cost me in terms of direct debits being missed. I need to keep good credit to keep on top of my mortgage and a good credit rating.

Bringing in children who are coughing or having a high temperature and generally quite ill. Sometimes their siblings are off nursery for these reasons but the same doesn't apply to my setting.

I have only been doing this for 8 months but am relying on a good reputation and really want to make the business work. I have had comments about how expensive childcare is from one father who seems to think the amount I'm paid is my net pay, which it isn't. It's a very long day which is fine but these issues and comments make me feel like I am being treated like a babysitter not a childcare setting.

How to build a good reputation and relationship with parents but nip these things in the bud before my business expands? I'm not good at confrontation and have left a job that I was at for over a decade where I worked quietly in an office, but starting up my own business has made me realise that I probably need to become more assertive.

Experienced CM's, AIBU and is this just part of the job or am I being taken for a mug.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
QforCucumber · 28/12/2021 10:26

You’re making it too personal - you don’t. Need to give the reasons for your closure time, just specify the time.

Ds nursery charge £15 for 15 mins late. I can phone if I’m stuck in traffic etc but that’s happened once in 4 years and so they didn’t enforce as it was a large incident on a local A road which the nursery were aware of.

Bills are received the Monday before the 1st of the month for the month in advance, if I haven’t paid by the 1st Friday in the month his place is refused.

I’ve had calls for ear infections, vomiting, coughing (over covid) fever and had to collect every time.

If you don’t treat it like a business then your clients won’t either.

isaisaisabel · 28/12/2021 10:20

I've had assurances from all parents that they understand that closing time isn't the time they should collect, they should have left by closing time and that they'll be paying on time.

Thank you all again.

OP posts:
isaisaisabel · 21/12/2021 08:34

These responses are great, just what I needed to hear and have confirmed.

After reading this thread I sent out an email about late payments and lateness as the 10/15 minutes a day adds up more than they realise. I'm looking forward to building up my business and becoming more professional with this great advice.

OP posts:
LaMontser · 19/12/2021 15:53

My childminder was absolutely lovely but ruthless on the business side. Paid holidays, late fees, no nonsense. I completely respected it and we are still friendly now.

Don’t give reasons why you need clients to comply - they will only argue back. Just state the policies and enforce them.

Good luck. Decent cms are worth every penny.

HardbackWriter · 19/12/2021 15:20

I think you're absolutely right and reasonable to be annoyed at people treating you like this, but that (sadly) you're probably wrong that they wouldn't try it with a nursery! Possibly the late thing wouldn't be as bad - it's easier for people to kid themselves that they're not putting you out if you're in your home, turning up to a nursery with almost all the lights off and your kid as the last one there is much more immediately guilt-inducning - but definitely the illness and late payment are problems for nurseries too. I think it's a real problem with childcare and it stems from the fact that people pay a low hourly rate but that adds up to a big monthly bill, so a lot of parents feel hard done to/resentful about childcare and so take the piss, while not recognizing that the people doing it are actually low paid and aren't 'ripping them off' as they imagine.

Hankunamatata · 19/12/2021 14:45

Do you have a late fee in your contract and do you enforce it?

IWentAwayIStayedAway · 19/12/2021 14:41

Why would you worry about offending crap customers. Let them shit on someone else

Knittinglibby · 19/12/2021 14:04

I read this with interest @isaisaisabel and I can echo your experience. I childminded for a few years both full time daily and for wrap around care. I still do wrap around for one family, though I now work elsewhere during the day. My honest impression is that people will always think you have an easier time and almost like you get to be at home and get paid to do it, they do not (mostly) see you in the same way they do a nursery. That impacts many things like late pick ups, late payment etc.

I would do it again, but would have to run it with far stricter policies in place. I would:

  1. Request pay twice a month, and in advance of the following two weeks. So for example the 1st and 15th. This means if people pull out you've had 2 weeks pay and aren't out.

  2. Have stricter times. I had one family start dropping their baby off before 7 am, sometimes even 6:30 am. We agreed 8 am. She was working from home and liked to go to the gym and have a coffee with her Mum before work. I would make it very clear what my hours are and unless arranged in advance, not shift those. For me I think the reality is with 3 dc myself at home, they'd need to be 8-5 to not feel like it was encroaching on my life. When I child mind I'm fully present - crafts, outings, music sessions, sensory play so it isn't like I'm getting on with my own things during that time. I find once it's after 5 it majorly impacts my evening with dc and their hobbies and after a long day everyone wants to go home. The friends I do wrap around for currently is supposed to be 5:30 but most days it's 6 pm and that last hour is very challenging. This is our year and I wouldn't' do it this way again, despite it working mostly well. We need our own evening.

  3. I wouldn't do it for friends again. I've done this 3x now and it's worked very well once, somewhat well once and terribly once. I think it is easier to have stricter policies, charge more appropriately and enforce policies when it isn't friends. It's lovely friends think highly of what I do, but I think it's very hard for them to see you in the professional way they should.

  4. I personally would drop to 4 days/week and not 5. There's always appointments, things that need doing, paperwork and planning. I've not stuck to 4 days so I could help out friends, but if I ever do it again that will be non-negotiable and another reason not to go with friends.

  5. I would have paid time off. One lot of friends insisted on this and the difference was huge. Several childminders around me have one week at Christmas and three/four weeks in summer. Not sure I'd charge for the weeks in summer, maybe a total of 2 weeks paid leave a year and 2-3 weeks unpaid as I'd want to be fair. But I really think your own dc need time with you when other dc aren't there. I'd set these dates as standard and build it into contract. For example, I do not work December 22-30 inclusive, nor do I work the first four weeks in August. Like I said I've never done it, but if I ever child minded again, I would.

Childminding is a fabulous profession, but I think often requires you to do the leg work in terms of respect & boundaries. I've definitely had to learnt that the hard way.

Blondeshavemorefun · 18/12/2021 17:44

As others said you need to toughen up

Payment month in advance

No payment. No childcare

Late fees. Apply them

Illness esp in these times. Take temp on doorstep. If coughing send home

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/12/2021 17:34

@Chickychoccyegg

I'm a childminder. 1: I advise getting paid monthly in advance, if fees are not paid, care is refused. 2: enforce a late payment fee, mine is £10 per 15 mins, I now get no lateness , same for people turning up early, again if its not paid you tell them you will be refusing care until outstanding fee is paid. 3: send a coughing, ill child home, every single time, do not be persuaded otherwise, if parents won't collect, you contact their emergency contact, they'll soon stop messing around when they have to explain themselves to someone else. 4: refer them back to the contract that they signed and agreed too. Don't engage in any chat about the amount you get paid, what you earn is your business, if you wanted you could point out how rude it is to talk about someone else's earnings. You'll toughen up in time, it's hard starting off. Do you have a network of other cms for support? I found that was the best thing to help me . I've found the firmer I am the more parents respect my position and my business, if you get overly friendly, or compromise too much, they will respect you as a professional childcare setting less. Good luck op, its a great job, but can also be really hard .
This is great advice.

It’s not about being strict OP, you are running a business. Having firmer boundaries will make it easier because people will push at them less. If you don’t have them, people push harder and then get cross when you push back.

Send out a letter now, announcing you are moving to one month in advance and late fees, and also underlying that sick kids will get sent home.

Tillsforthrills · 18/12/2021 17:27

I suspect it’d be very uncomfortable for a sole childminder to ask for an unpleasant PCR/ paid days off until results, from a parent without the backing of a professional nursery behind them so I can see why childminders are being strong armed by parents who chance bringing them in and count on the CM being too weak to enforce.

Tillsforthrills · 18/12/2021 17:20

@Toastmost

That defo makes sense, thank you.

Toastmost · 18/12/2021 17:00

@Tillsforthrills

Oh Sorry, turns out you’re stricter than me!
Negative PCR for a new continuous cough or temp is reasonable and is guidance, LFTs shouldn't be used for anyone symptomatic and have much lower accuracy rate (they also work differently and aren't a replacement for a PCR). Nurseries definitely require one with new covid type symptoms, I'd be worried if people didn't to be honest, but if the same cold lingers on for ages then obviously don't expect test after test if they tested at the start.
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/12/2021 16:57

Definelty be firm and I like the reminder sent out idea upthread

  1. Payment is every two weeks in advance. No payment - no childcare
  1. Collection time is as agreed in your contract. Any late collections will be billed at £10 per 10 minutes per child and expected within the next payment.
  1. Any children displaying the following symptoms on drop off will be turned away until they are PCR tested/no longer showing symptoms.
Tillsforthrills · 18/12/2021 16:56

Oh Sorry, turns out you’re stricter than me!

alexdgr8 · 18/12/2021 16:55

could you check all temperatures before entry.
if you do it for everybody, everyday, then it just becomes part of the routine, like hand-sanitising on entry.
i know it's not a perfect indicator, but maybe it would help you set the tone, that you are in charge and will not accept any child who is ill.
you definitely need to see it in more business like terms.
you are right; many of the parent literally do not care if you lose your business, or family time or anything else, except in so far as it inconveniences them.
that's the reality. they are customers not friends. do not think they are on your side. they use your services, and possibly choose you because you are so soft.
or you used to be. not from now on though, eh?
new year. new leaf.
good luck.

Toastmost · 18/12/2021 16:55

[quote Tillsforthrills]@Toastmost

New coughs and temperature need a negative test in most nurseries to be sure not to infect others just in case. I’d probably ask for a LFT if they seemed unwell with a new cough, not really fair for parents to present them with this.[/quote]
Yes hence why I said if they'd had a negative PCR test?

Freddiefox · 18/12/2021 16:50

I run a nursery,
Parents are late a lot. We introduced late fees, they don’t really.
They bring children in sick, they pay late. I’m lucky that I don’t always see them after I’ve had to chase them or call them, where as you have answer the door to them so it’s more tricky.

But it just a general attitude towards early years really that you are hired help.

Join the pacey Facebook page if you haven’t already.

Tillsforthrills · 18/12/2021 16:50

@Toastmost

New coughs and temperature need a negative test in most nurseries to be sure not to infect others just in case. I’d probably ask for a LFT if they seemed unwell with a new cough, not really fair for parents to present them with this.

wineandsunshine · 18/12/2021 16:50

I was a childminder for five years before returning to teaching.

1 - Use a late fee policy. I only had to implement this once for a parent onto an invoice and they were never late in paying again!

2 - Remind them of times and again state in policy that drop offs/pick ups need to be on time or you will charge.

3 - Could you check temperature on arrival? Unfortunately, younger children do tend to have more bugs and I certainly looked after a few poorly children. You could suggest LFT's daily?

Toastmost · 18/12/2021 16:48

@isaisaisabel

I had one toddler unwell and coughing like crazy in my face on arrival and the parent didn't bat an eyelid and muttered something about a cold.

I know how important it is for the parents to work but also they are in great jobs with sick pay paid for or even if they take parental leave without pay their roles are secure.

If I close down because I get sick I lose most of my income and it feels like they don't care. Although a new family have joined me and are really mindful of my circumstances so far so not all parents are the same.

I mean small children do get a lot of coughs and colds, at the moment if they've had a PCR test that's negative and are well enough to join in etc I'd be okay as some would never be in otherwise! Of course if they can keep them home that's even better, but I guess again it's about following guidance and putting in place measures you are okay with.
isaisaisabel · 18/12/2021 16:47

Yes thank you everyone that's commented with this great advice that has hit the nail on the head. It really is my own fault for trying to be too accommodating and not cause problems.

I guess I expect people to just respect contracts, terms and conditions because I would but I will have to start enforcing terms and conditions.

OP posts:
reluctantbrit · 18/12/2021 16:46
  1. Late collection fee - make it hurt and do enforce it
  2. change your in advance payment to. 4 weeks
  3. strict illness policy. Is there a CM organisation which gives guidelines what is reasonable?

You may loose some customers but we had these rules and I hadn't had any problems obeying to them.

isaisaisabel · 18/12/2021 16:44

I had one toddler unwell and coughing like crazy in my face on arrival and the parent didn't bat an eyelid and muttered something about a cold.

I know how important it is for the parents to work but also they are in great jobs with sick pay paid for or even if they take parental leave without pay their roles are secure.

If I close down because I get sick I lose most of my income and it feels like they don't care. Although a new family have joined me and are really mindful of my circumstances so far so not all parents are the same.

OP posts:
modgepodge · 18/12/2021 16:39

I don’t see why it would sour relationships. And honestly, if someone is getting pissy that you are enforcing the very reasonable terms of their contract, do you really want their business?

I use a CM. She has occasionally sent my child home for a temperature or vomiting (neither of which she had when I dropped her off), there’s no hard feelings. Yes, it’s a pain for me, but it is what it is. I am also aware she may charge me if I collect late - though she never has, probably as I’ve only been late twice in a year, both times due to unexpected traffic and I called to let her know. I wouldn’t have complained if she has charged me though, as it’s in the contract.