Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really disappointed with this present

366 replies

ToMeetOrNotToMeet · 18/12/2021 14:47

I might sound like an ungrateful twat...

The gift is from my boyfriend (on/off - "on a break" at the moment, but he wants to get back together... and I wish we could as well... which is why I'm upset about this. We're just not the same.

We're at his mother's to celebrate my and her birthday. She puts on a big show, champagne, cake etc. There are six of us. We do gifts at the end. We're in a rented holiday cottage.
We swapped gifts. All very nice: ornaments, plants, choccies, jewelry, wine...

Then boyfriend pulls out a bag of apples and another bag of tomatoes and a piece of bamboo. He tells us to close our eyes and imagine being somewhere where these things are grown and being in a hotel and looking out of the window and it's raining.

Then there are three wrapped boxes. One for me. One for his mother. One for my daughter (aged 4) or his brother (aged 30). He still hasn't clarified. He says it doesn't matter who opens what, but if we get the wrong box, we won't like it.

It's three external hard drives.

We don't know whose is whose. We have no way of checking here.

He collects DVDs and Bluerays. He's obviously put a load of films on these hard drives.

I've told him in the past that I don't care about DVDs (his entire house is full of them - I mean so FULL that I can't visit. Hoarder full.). I have about 30 minutes a night to watch TV and I'm happy with Prime and Netflix).

So now, I've got to go home with a hard drive full of films that might be for his mother. She'll go home with one that could be meant for me or my kid.

I know he's probably spent time doing it (a lot of time) but I've already told him many many times that I have enough with what I have. I'm just not interested in all these fucking films.

And what the fuck are the fruit and vegetables all about?

Everything always has to be weird and cryptic and about him. If he'd asked me I'd have liked an Etsy voucher or a sodding candle.

Now he's really upset that nobody cares about his hard drives. But he hasn't even said what's on any of them.

It's mad. He's not talking to me for being so ungrateful and I just feel upset that he's given me something so weird.

AIBU?

OP posts:
DickMabutt73962 · 18/12/2021 17:26

@Hankunamatata

My cousin is autistic. He sounds exactly like him. Spends hours with DVDs
Exactly my thought as well. Sad because the lad I know really can't help it, and is lovely, but it's all he ever talks about. And I can't deal.
DickMabutt73962 · 18/12/2021 17:25

@DontBlameMe79

He may be a bit weird but to be honest you sound a bit grasping and ungrateful regarding presents. Would you rather have something that he had thought about and put effort into, even if a total miss, or something he just spent money on? Sounds like the latter…so I’m in the YABU camp
I'd rather nothing that shit I don't want. The number of times I've been given chocolate as a present by the same people who know me. And know that not only do I not like it. But I'm lactose intolerant. Goes in the bin, if you're not going to make an effort, don't bother.
steff13 · 18/12/2021 17:24

Where DO apples, tomatoes and bamboo grow together? Is it supposed to be exotic? It sounds like the greenhouse at the bottom of my elderly neighbour’s garden.

I was thinking I live in Ohio and we grow all of those things here so maybe he wants to take a trip to Ohio? 😂

Did it really not occur to him to label the hard drives?

Roselilly36 · 18/12/2021 17:23

Not read the whole thread, do you know what’s on the HD. Just wondering if it’s a proposal, yours will you marry me? DD can I be your step dad? DB will you be my best man?

DickMabutt73962 · 18/12/2021 17:22

@Ellmau

Surely this is a massive breach of copyright?
@Ellmau asking the hard questions
ChristmasRobins · 18/12/2021 17:20

Well, I’d love a cryptic puzzle present but I’d have to be sure that there actually was a fiendish puzzle to work out and ideally something lovely at the end of it, not just some random tomatoes and shit films.

Funnylittlefloozie · 18/12/2021 17:18

I think DontBlameMe79 might be the moron boyfriend.

I would also like a cat and a melon, please. Honeydew if there's a choice, but really, there is no such thing as an unwelcome melon.

MatildaTheCat · 18/12/2021 17:18

For his birthday buy him a sack of wild rats and set them free in his house and tell him to imagine a lovely cat to catch them all.

If you can’t tell us even one good thing about this peculiar person yanvu to be considering getting back together.

rainbowmash · 18/12/2021 17:18

@OneRuleForThem

Yes, I think you are actually, and his mother. You yourself have said that you have no idea what is on these hard drives. And it’s not really THAT big of a deal if you discover it’s the wrong one and needs swapping.
Having to plough through multiple films/shows to get the idea of who the hard drive was meant for? Contacting the other recipients to swap ideas and figure the "puzzle" out? Arranging multiple trips to exchange drives until they're with the "right" owner? Figuring out the vegetable link??? This is a huge faff. OP says she only has 30 mins if TV time a day as it is.

This is a faff that might have been welcome if the recipients were explicitly into that sort of thing. They weren't. This gift was all about the DP - it's an indulgent wank of a gift made to satisfy DP's interests only.

Even if he's not being deliberately selfish, he's being clueless to the point at which it becomes selfish.

That and the anti social DVD hoarding? Get rid. Life's too short.

foxgoosefinch · 18/12/2021 17:16

Wow, he sounds selfish, hard work and sulky - and unable to empathise with others. Does he always have to be the centre of attention? I could not be bothered with all of that!

HollowTalk · 18/12/2021 17:15

Even if I could get my head around him spending all that time fiddling around with hard drives, I can't work out why he gave them to you randomly. Why would he do that? And what the hell is it with the apples, tomatoes and bamboo?

I would have three more drinks and lock him in a room and not let him out until you find out the answer.

GreyFeederC0c0nut · 18/12/2021 17:15

Tomatoes may be for the Rotten Tomatoe film reviews

meadowbleu · 18/12/2021 17:12

On the upside I like your sense of humour @ToMeetOrNotToMeet His? Nah, not so much.

I'm pleased there were some nice gifts, happy birthday from me Cake Wine Flowers Football Ooops looks like your boyfriend snook something unintended in there Wink

He's obviously spent a lot of time and effort on the gifts, trouble is the thought and effort were all about him and not about the recipients. I don't think he brings you much joy, maybe keep him as a mate, but not as a romantic partner.

VaguelyInteresting · 18/12/2021 17:12

Might have dated this guy q a few years ago.

Is he also a keen cyclist? Like club cycling?

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 18/12/2021 17:11

Tbh you’re not right for him, just as much as he’s definitely not right for you. Someday he might actually find a woman who gets him and who loves his ‘quirks’.

You don’t.

Why - seriously, why?? - would you keep flogging a horse that is just always going to be dead?

HollowTalk · 18/12/2021 17:11

@PatriotCanes

He could have just saved himself some time and handed you all a large red flag.
This really made me laugh. It's so true.
Mrsmadevans · 18/12/2021 17:09

OP l don't know how on earth you can put up with this crap. You must have the patience of a saint Flowers

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 18/12/2021 17:07

Honestly, don’t get back together with this man! Why on earth would you want to? He’s never going to change - he’ll always be clueless, he’ll always be tight, he’s always going to hoard his tech stuff.

He. Will. Never. Change.

Don’t do it to yourself! And don’t do it to him either - it’ll always be wrong and you’ll end up resenting him.

pictish · 18/12/2021 17:03

In short he gave you a present that he would like and that gave him an opportunity to indulge his hobby.
If he’s into astrology he’s a cringe surely?

You’re right, it’s not hard to buy you a nice silver bangle. That would do me too. I wouldn’t want a hard drive full of films that someone else thinks I should watch.

trumpisagit · 18/12/2021 17:03

The belief in astrology would be the end for me. Too ridiculous.
Find a new boyfriend OP.

thetinsoldier · 18/12/2021 17:01

Sounds like he wants you to like what he likes and he doesn't care if you don't like those things; what he wants is more important.

He sounds intense, hard work and a little weird.

Who doesn't label presents?? And why?? Are you meant to plug the hard drive into your TV? Or a computer? Who wants to watch a film on your computer?

Why do you want to get back with him?

NumberTheory · 18/12/2021 16:57

So his gift to you is a bunch of stolen films that may or may not be ones that you’d like if you liked films. But you aren’t really into films anyway and he knows that?

This is one of those presents that’s actually a slap in the face.

As they say, it’s the thought that counts and the thoughts here are not those of someone who is thinking much about you.

Merryoldgoat · 18/12/2021 16:56

Why would you waste 5 more minutes on this arse?

AngelinaFibres · 18/12/2021 16:52

@ToMeetOrNotToMeet

I might sound like an ungrateful twat...

The gift is from my boyfriend (on/off - "on a break" at the moment, but he wants to get back together... and I wish we could as well... which is why I'm upset about this. We're just not the same.

We're at his mother's to celebrate my and her birthday. She puts on a big show, champagne, cake etc. There are six of us. We do gifts at the end. We're in a rented holiday cottage.
We swapped gifts. All very nice: ornaments, plants, choccies, jewelry, wine...

Then boyfriend pulls out a bag of apples and another bag of tomatoes and a piece of bamboo. He tells us to close our eyes and imagine being somewhere where these things are grown and being in a hotel and looking out of the window and it's raining.

Then there are three wrapped boxes. One for me. One for his mother. One for my daughter (aged 4) or his brother (aged 30). He still hasn't clarified. He says it doesn't matter who opens what, but if we get the wrong box, we won't like it.

It's three external hard drives.

We don't know whose is whose. We have no way of checking here.

He collects DVDs and Bluerays. He's obviously put a load of films on these hard drives.

I've told him in the past that I don't care about DVDs (his entire house is full of them - I mean so FULL that I can't visit. Hoarder full.). I have about 30 minutes a night to watch TV and I'm happy with Prime and Netflix).

So now, I've got to go home with a hard drive full of films that might be for his mother. She'll go home with one that could be meant for me or my kid.

I know he's probably spent time doing it (a lot of time) but I've already told him many many times that I have enough with what I have. I'm just not interested in all these fucking films.

And what the fuck are the fruit and vegetables all about?

Everything always has to be weird and cryptic and about him. If he'd asked me I'd have liked an Etsy voucher or a sodding candle.

Now he's really upset that nobody cares about his hard drives. But he hasn't even said what's on any of them.

It's mad. He's not talking to me for being so ungrateful and I just feel upset that he's given me something so weird.

AIBU?

Hard work, pain in the arse or not NT but either way any special celebration will be a let down and the more birthdays etc you have the greater the stress will be leading up to them. He sounds just like my former brothers in law. Everything was so intense it was just a giant fun sponge in every way.
diddl · 18/12/2021 16:50

So if you get the wrong present you won't like it and..?

He doesn't give a fuck?