Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think family are being selfish about Christmas mixing

240 replies

Couchbettato · 18/12/2021 14:20

My son and I live with my grandmother, not through choice but after fleeing my XH after DV last year.

Every year my grandmother hosts Christmas dinner for 22+ people, and it's where all the kids in the family open their mind Christmas presents, my 2yo included. It's been like this since I were a child, and it's just tradition in our family.

So as usual she's hosting Christmas this year, which was always to be expected.

But, this year I've got Pneumonia and I'm on my third course of antibiotics and have sent off a second sputum sample as I keep coughing up phlegm and blood on a daily basis and frequently getting breathless.

Now I've had a bit of anxiety about Christmas coming up but I've been dealing with that on my own as I know I have no control over the day.

But what's really putting my heckles up is today my uncle came to say they're going to a restaurant as a party of 37 today for his wife's family's celebration and some of the party aren't feeling well (not sure in which way they're not feeling well so may not be covid symptoms), but as the deposit was £400 non-refundable and it would be bad for the business if they cancelled, the meal is still going ahead.

Now I have no sway in whether they'll do LFTs up to Christmas, but I am losing faith that they'd isolate if they had symptoms, though it's my sincerest wishes that they would. But I'm also worried about asymptomic transmission on Christmas day, when I may still not be any better with my current chest infection.

My grandmother won't cancel hosting as she wants to see her kids, grandkids and great grandkids, but she knows I've got no where else to go for the day. My extended family also know I've been really unwell for a while.

Aibu in thinking they're all being a bit selfish at a time where I'm really worried.

Yanbu - yes they're being a bit selfish
YABU - no, you're being the unreasonable one. Christmas must go on.

OP posts:
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 18/12/2021 18:32

@LumosSolem

But I don’t understand why the grandmother wanting to host her annual Christmas party makes her an arsehole or selfish? As I said in a previous post I don’t think she thinks covid is a genuine concern based on OP’s comments so won’t see the risk to the OP. And many of her family members are vulnerable and need support and somewhere to go on Christmas. I don’t think it’s cut and dry. I’m not saying OP is a freeloader but I think it’s deeply unreasonable to think her own needs come before everyone else’s; it doesn’t make the grandmother or family unreasonable to disagree with this either.

LumosSolem · 18/12/2021 18:30

*people like womens aid exist to help that should read

LumosSolem · 18/12/2021 18:29

@Justheretoaskaquestion91 what on earth? That literally makes no sense whatsoever. Of course not everyone has family that wants to or is able to help. Which is really sad and thank god that people like women's aid to help. But if there is family able to help, why on earth wouldn't they?

I defended the OP when a bunch of posters decided to jump on to try to make out that the OP was entitled and taking the piss for living at her grandmother's. Which in the first instance- was unrelated to the issues about her illness and what to do about Christmas. But they still wanted to find ways to criticise, when she has made clear the only reason she is there is because of the DV she has experienced. Anyone who wants to criticise the OP and basically imply she is an entitled freeloader in those circumstances is an arsehole.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 18/12/2021 18:23

I think the issue of the Christmas/covid/pneumonia does not need to be conflated with domestic violence. They are separate. My mother was a victim of horrendous DV and I grew up with it (fortunately not for as many years as my elder siblings as she left him) and I have a lot of appreciation for sufferers of DV. I’ve also been in a pretty hairy relationship where I was strangled a few times/scared. Of course it’s reasonable to expect family support IF THAT IS WHAT YOUR FAMILY IS LIKE. @LumosSolem you seem to prattle on about feelings and want to be understood but don’t understand whatsoever that not everyone has loving or kind families who will help. Where is your understanding there?

Being dealt a crappy hand is not a catch all excuse. It doesn’t mean you don’t have to consider other people’s feelings. That’s why it’s not relevant to this thread. The pneumonia and covid is.

LumosSolem · 18/12/2021 18:23

It's hard getting out and it can be just as hard trying to rebuild.

I will never, ever get back to what I was beforehand. I'm doing okay-ish but I have been robbed of so much by my ex and it hurts, every day.

Sorry for the derail OP. I just think some of the comments you've had have been awful and I hope you're able to brush off the ignorance.

Couchbettato · 18/12/2021 18:14

@11GrumpsaGrumping

God op, some people on here are just awful, and so ignorant. Bit of classism too I expect!!!!

I don't have any advice, I just wanted to say well done on escaping, and I hope everything turns out well for you.

Thank you. It's hard getting out and based on some of the commenters here I can see why some abused women never reach out for help.

Because we're all clearly an imposition. Better to stay put and better the devil you know.

OP posts:
11GrumpsaGrumping · 18/12/2021 18:12

God op, some people on here are just awful, and so ignorant. Bit of classism too I expect!!!!

I don't have any advice, I just wanted to say well done on escaping, and I hope everything turns out well for you.

LumosSolem · 18/12/2021 18:10

It sounds like her grandmother has been like a mother to her, she's lived over half her life with her. So would you think it was an imposition to have your child move in with you? My children aren't an imposition to me and neither are my grandchildren, even the one who is living with me. He isn't an imposition, he's a teenager who needs somewhere to live and someone to care, just like the OP.

It's almost as if, SHOCK HORROR- family are happy to help each other and actually it isn't a dreadful imposition to have a vulnerable child/grandchild live with you. And actually it can be positive and beneficial in ways for all involved, and not every family member who falls on dreadful times is taking the piss by daring to stay longer than a couple of weeks.

ancientgran · 18/12/2021 18:04

[quote NorthSouthcatlady]@LumosSolem staying with someone for that long is realistically a hell of an imposition. The rule in our house is a couple of weeks max. In 13 months it’s not unreasonable to expect a deposit to saved for a rental property and someone to have moved on. If my fiancé would want someone staying that long and a toddler, then l most likely would have moved out. Like l said it’s a huge imposition. I’m just being honest and lm sure other people would feel the same. I appreciate the OP has had a hard time but she can’t stay at her grandmothers forever
My mother had a friend staying with her for a few months, it turned into 6 months and by the end she’d totally had enough.[/quote]
It sounds like her grandmother has been like a mother to her, she's lived over half her life with her. So would you think it was an imposition to have your child move in with you? My children aren't an imposition to me and neither are my grandchildren, even the one who is living with me. He isn't an imposition, he's a teenager who needs somewhere to live and someone to care, just like the OP.

Lollyneenah · 18/12/2021 17:59

Bless you OP. Sounds like an incredibly difficult year.
Are you open to your local homeless prevention officer or women's aid? It may be worth discussing your difficulties with them. There may be a grant that could help you to pay for a bed and breakfast for a couple of days.

LumosSolem · 18/12/2021 17:59

@NorthSouthcatlady

My first husband was abusive. That’s why l divorced him, fought for a decent financial settlement (he didn’t want to give me any of the money l put into our house -surprise surprise), moved addresses 3 times in 12 months, did a level 7 course and got a better job with more money. The divorce and legal advice were expensive

I’m not saying lm better. My perspective is people need to stand on their own 2 feet. Are you honestly saying OP should stay at grandmothers for ever and determine what goes on in that house? I appreciate she’s unwell but should a family build all of their plans round her? If had the option to have stayed with family then it would have been appreciated but no one lived close enough to work to do that or had the space. Plus it would have only ever been a stop gap

Yep, been through, and going through the same- I cannot get my financial settlement either.

At what point did I say OP should stay at her grandmother's 'forever'? Your suggestion is that people should stand on their own two feet- is moving out the only measure of 'standing on your own two feet' after fleeing DV?

Stop judging everyone by what you have done yourself. You have no idea the long term effects on other people. For two years after leaving my ex, I was having to contact the police about aspects of his behaviour. I was genuinely scared to live on my own with DC, fearing what he could do.

Like I said, I'm glad my family take a different view and I certainly would with my own DC, heaven forbid they ever end up in the same situation as me.

Pontypandytaxpayer · 18/12/2021 17:56

@NorthSouthcatlady

If my brother had had this attitude with me when our mum died then god knows how my life would have turned out.

This thread has made me very appreciate of my family.

notanothertakeaway · 18/12/2021 17:55

@gospelsinger

We are having a family gathering after Christmas. We will all do lateral flows beforehand. No judgement on what people do or don't do with their lives, but taking a test is quite a simple request. Could you request family members do that?
@gospelsinger

I think the sort of people who attended a gathering for 22 people at Christmas 2020, wish to attend Christnas for 22 now, and go for dinner with 37 people can't be trusted to do LFtests, or isolate if they're positive

Sorry, OP, but I think these people are idiots hosting / attending large events. And you can't reason with stupid

I think you'll need to take your own precautions to keep yourself safe and as healthy as possible

NorthSouthcatlady · 18/12/2021 17:53

My first husband was abusive. That’s why l divorced him, fought for a decent financial settlement (he didn’t want to give me any of the money l put into our house -surprise surprise), moved addresses 3 times in 12 months, did a level 7 course and got a better job with more money. The divorce and legal advice were expensive

I’m not saying lm better. My perspective is people need to stand on their own 2 feet. Are you honestly saying OP should stay at grandmothers for ever and determine what goes on in that house? I appreciate she’s unwell but should a family build all of their plans round her? If had the option to have stayed with family then it would have been appreciated but no one lived close enough to work to do that or had the space. Plus it would have only ever been a stop gap

Crabapple04 · 18/12/2021 17:51

I cannot believe some of the answers on this. The poor woman escaped DV, also by the sounds of it coercive control, so financially stuffed as well ( so no nice weekend break away in a hotel!!) It's a very difficult situation to get out of and doesn't just rectify itself in a year once you escape!
Mentally it's an ongoing battle - I don't have personal experience but friends who are dealing with this horrible situation.
Anyway I feel for you and having to deal with this during a pandemic can't be easy either as access to support for many things has sadly been made so much more difficult- financial, MH, legal, gp appointments., I could go on
Have you mentioned how you feel to your nan? She obviously realises you are ill. I'm being cautious myself for health reasons so I would feel just as uncomfortable with a houseful of people right now. It wouldn't be unreasonable for you to say you don't think you can cope with it, or be rude either- talk to her, perhaps between you and the family you can come up with a solution for the day.
You're not unreasonable for expecting a little bit of understanding.

LumosSolem · 18/12/2021 17:42

@NorthSouthcatlady good thing for me my parents don't think like you then. Kind of feel sorry for your family if that's how you feel.

Have you ever actually experienced DV, and have any idea about the long term consequences?

If you have and you've somehow managed to do so much 'better' than me and the OP, then good for you, you're clearly so much better as a person aren't you!

If you haven't, you have no idea what you're talking about.

Fl0w3ry · 18/12/2021 17:41

I really feel for you OP.
I think your family sound very selfish. I also think the lack of compassion and empathy you have received on this thread from some posters is staggering. I am sure if those same posters found themselves in a similar situation to you they would think differently. People are very much ‘I’m alright jack’ these days sadly.
At the same time I don’t know what you can do about the situation. At the very least your family should do lateral flow tests before they attend. Maybe you should emphasise the fact that you might be contagious, because if they think they might catch something from you they might think differently. If I was you I would do everything you can to move out so you aren’t put in this situation again next year. I read some people say you are ‘lucky’ to have family who want to spend time with you, but I don’t think you are lucky to have them if they care so little about your health. It seems to me that your family care more about their Christmas plans, which isn’t the same thing.

NorthSouthcatlady · 18/12/2021 17:39

@LumosSolem staying with someone for that long is realistically a hell of an imposition. The rule in our house is a couple of weeks max. In 13 months it’s not unreasonable to expect a deposit to saved for a rental property and someone to have moved on. If my fiancé would want someone staying that long and a toddler, then l most likely would have moved out. Like l said it’s a huge imposition. I’m just being honest and lm sure other people would feel the same. I appreciate the OP has had a hard time but she can’t stay at her grandmothers forever
My mother had a friend staying with her for a few months, it turned into 6 months and by the end she’d totally had enough.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 18/12/2021 17:38

I would also add that everyone sounds like they are having a pretty bad time; I understand why this Christmas is important also to the mother with mental health issues. To the Uncle who is homeless. The uncle who lives there has to attend too.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 18/12/2021 17:37

@Pontypandytaxpayer

Fully understand. Which is why I understand her concern. But explain why the family members she doesn’t speak to/isn’t close to would care about that? The grandmother clearly doesn’t care about covid so won’t see the covid worry as real/serious/a reason to cancel her plans either. Can’t OP see this?

1967buglet · 18/12/2021 17:34

@LumosSolem

Ignore the nastiness OP. You aren't selfish. Whatever the rights and wrongs, you aren't selfish.

I'd imagine the lack of empathy is because these posters cannot imagine the hell you have been through. And good- it's not a fun club to be in, is it. But it's actually really unpleasant to read. As if you wanted to be in this position.

I see no one really seems to imagine that perhaps you aren't some massive piss-taking inconvenience to your gran but that actually perhaps she was genuinely happy to help you and your DS- because she loves you and after you've been through she was probably relieved to be able to help and know you are safe. You aren't selfish for worrying about your health now. I know how it feels to be in your position, to feel like you have no control over your life because of what the abuser has done. It causes a massive scar and it is so, so difficult to get through.

well said.
Pontypandytaxpayer · 18/12/2021 17:32

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

But she has pneumonia which makes her higher risk for getting severely ill with Covid. She doesn't have anywhere else up go. If she catches Covid, she could end up in hospital.

Viostep · 18/12/2021 17:32

I can't believe so many people think op is unreasonable. I could not enjoy Christmas knowing my sick relative is in the house, feeling awful and terrified about catching covid from me and dying. Leaving their toddler without a mother and potentially going back to a violent father.

People are so selfish, yet I bet they would cry at ops funeral!

As for those criticising about spending last Christmas there, she didn't have a choice. Ops gran was kind to take her in and return the favour op did when op took care of her sick grandad.

Op, I think you're so brave getting out of an abusive house and I wish you and your son all the best

LumosSolem · 18/12/2021 17:30

[quote NorthSouthcatlady]@mam0918 exactly, it’s been going on for sometime. I wouldn’t mind helping someone out but 13 months in then l would have had enough quite frankly. That’s before we’ve even got to being told l can’t host Christmas how l want[/quote]
You really have no clue. No clue at all.

NorthSouthcatlady · 18/12/2021 17:28

@mam0918 exactly, it’s been going on for sometime. I wouldn’t mind helping someone out but 13 months in then l would have had enough quite frankly. That’s before we’ve even got to being told l can’t host Christmas how l want