Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Not Want to Pay for Step Children?

217 replies

Humal93 · 18/12/2021 13:59

My husband has 3 children prior to our marriage and we have just recently had our own child together.

We have been married almost 3 years now and over these few years have realised how much I am spending on things like almost everyday on snacks and sometimes toys, stationery and in-game purchases for Robux and Xbox. The 2 youngest always want to come to the shops with me so they can choose something as it seems and me being soft, I say yes.

I do not work as I look after the children, but husband does and as he is the breadwinner and the first 3 being his children, I feel like he should be paying these expenses. What if we were to break up and instead of saving what bits of money I can from benefits, I'm spending on children that aren't biologically mine who will obviously stay with their dad and I would be stuck trying to make ends meet for my little one. I feel as though I am spending my child benefit more on our other children when it is really meant for the youngest. It would be different had they not had their mum around or if I was actually earning, but she is so they have both a mother and father that can provide for them.

I have bought the majority of things for their rooms since we moved house and countless other things for the home. I have brought them Xbox games, clothes and many toys and things. And the thing that bugs me even more is I feel they don't respect what they have and take it for granted by leaving things lying around and their rooms are a mess - that is an understatement. I hate living in mess, it feels chaotic and miserable and have stopped tidying up their rooms as it drains me, but still find myself going in there once in a while as it just looks terrible and dislike the thought of them waking up to that. Now when they say they want something from the shops that is not edible, I say only when they tidy their rooms. But this feels wrong as I wouldn't be plying my daughter with gifts in return for her respect in tidying up after herself. I would expect our youngest daughter to tidy up once she is older and not do it for something in return or be rewarded with something other than praise at that age as I grew up a fairly clean and tidy person which I think should be the norm, but isn't? and want to raise her the same, sorry if this sounds cocky.

With Christmas around the corner, I have spent over £200 on things they have asked for. Is this something a lot of parents do as I remember when growing up, we just got what we were given and were grateful for that. I apologise for the long rant, this is my first post and have wanted to get these things off my chest for a while. Thank you.

OP posts:
Itawapuddytat · 18/12/2021 16:13

Handfastings are legal in Scotland if the celebrants are authorized to perform legal marriages. I am Pagan myself and I attended several "proper" pagan handfasting ceremonies, the celebrant was properly authorised, all the paperwork was filled in and signed by the couple and the witnesses and a marriage certificate was issued. Of course, some people prefer just to do "non-legal" handfastings if they choose to, no marriage certificate is issued in this case and the couple is not married in the eyes of the law.

Suzanne999 · 18/12/2021 16:12

Ok, so all 4 children are “ children of the family” as they live with you and DP.
Why not put all child benefit into an account and that pays for things for the children. Set a budget for small treats each week, or better still give the 3 older kids an allowance. If they run out of that then tough, they get no more til the next week. It’s a great way to teach children budgeting and strange how they don’t want to buy so much crap when it’s their own money!
The money left in the child benefit pot will then accumulate to buy shoes, clothes etc…
Set a budget for food and household stuff (TP, laundry etc..) and take that from the joint pot of his income plus UC. The remainder should pay the outgoings.
Depending on the 3 older ones ages give them a few household chores to do, won’t hurt them even if it’s just tidying their room, stripping bed on laundry day. Do chores, you get allowance.

OverTheRubicon · 18/12/2021 16:12

@sadpapercourtesan

Benefits aren't intended for you to be able to squirrel away a little nest egg in case your relationship doesn't work out!

I can't decide whether you've committing benefit fraud, or your DP is financially abusing you, or you're taking advantage of him - my head aches Confused

One thing is for sure - you're living as one household and those children are there full-time. You're responsible as a couple for providing for them, and if you don't like that you should leave (and get a job).

I think that benefit fraud - or certainly benefit error - is a given, if OP is being paid UC that somehow isn't family money.

Sounds like he's taking advantage too.

My advice would be everything all the previous posters have said about joint accounts and legal marriage, plus are you claiming CMS from the children's mother? If they're with her only once a month and she's working it should be a meaningful amount.

Scrabblecrabapple · 18/12/2021 16:10

The amount of women who put themselves in this position amaze me. He’s had one failed marriage, get a job ffs.

Georgy12 · 18/12/2021 16:09

You're not spending a penny towards your SC, your husband and benefits are covering it so yes, YABVU!

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 18/12/2021 16:08

Religious ceremonies arent legal unless there is a registrar there for the signing. Ive known some christians go to the register office the day or morning before, if not a registrar there on the day. Ive muslim friends who never bothered with the legal element. Of course some local congregation religious leaders are also authorised to conduct weddings. I worked for a Catholic priest who was. Ive know. Lots of other R.C. Priests who have needed to have the registrar there.

Op, it should be family money.

CheshireKitten123 · 18/12/2021 16:08

@Dishwashersaurous

As an aside which religious ceremony isn't a legal marriage?
Handfasting (Celtic) and Sharia Marriages are 2 that spring to mind.
Dishwashersaurous · 18/12/2021 16:07

And as others have said if you live together it's a joint uc claim for you both. The uc is not yours.

His wages and thr uc are yours joint.

You need to come up with a household budget

Dishwashersaurous · 18/12/2021 16:06

Thanks all. Really interesting.

Op. Given as you are married in religion, why don't you pop down to the the registrar and do it legally as well to provide legal certainty.

Viviennemary · 18/12/2021 16:05

If you dont work where is the monry coming from that you begrudge spending. Maybe your partner begrudges spending money supporting you as a non financial contributer. YABU.

Babyroobs · 18/12/2021 16:01

Do his 3 kids live with your full time or just stay part of the week ? If full time then is there mum contributing CM ?

Faevern · 18/12/2021 16:01

You’re not spending your money though, your DH earns working long hours and the UC is joint money so you only have £13 a week child benefit for your child, the other child benefit is for his and you can’t have UC for your child so unless your using your savings it’s not your money. If you’re claiming fraudulently then it’s still not your money.

BeyondOurReef · 18/12/2021 16:01

@Dishwashersaurous

As an aside which religious ceremony isn't a legal marriage?
Many of them would be without an actual registrar to do the actual marrying.
Ellmau · 18/12/2021 16:00

As an aside which religious ceremony isn't a legal marriage?

Any that weren't in premises legally registered for marriages and following the rules of registration.

Muslim ceremonies generally aren't.

100problems · 18/12/2021 16:00

@Dishwashersaurous seems like the majority:

It is most important to note that religious marriage ceremonies are not recognised in English law unless the legal requirements are also complied with. A marriage certificate is issued to all couples who have legally recognised marriage ceremonies.

Itawapuddytat · 18/12/2021 15:59

I know this doesn't answer your original question, OP, but you need to know that, married or not, while you live together the UC claim will need to be a joint claim. As it will take into consideration your situation: 2 adults living together + 4 children (since all 4 kids live with you). This means they will take into consideration your partner's wages/income, your savings, and yes, you will receive the UC child's element only for 2 of the children. You (you and DP as it is a joint claim) will receive child benefit for all the children, also the UC might include the housing costs element if you live in rented accommodation. If anybody has health issues you might be able to claim more, also check if you qualify to get the healthy start coupons, if you are in Scotland there is also a payment from the Scottish government if the children are under 5 or 6 (I do not remember exactly the limit). Anyway, it is worth checking with the Citizen Advice Bureau to make sure you get all the benefits you are entitled and since your DP and his children live in the same house with you and your kid, DEFINITELY let DWP know so you don't end up with accusations of benefit fraud (and also having to pay back any amounts of money you've been overpaid)

The UC money will be paid into one account so if I were you I'd have either a joint account with DP (where the benefits and wages go, so it's one pot that you can both manage and have access to) or ask to be paid in your account, so that you have access to some of the family money (assuming his wages go into his own account - this should still count as family money, not "his money"). Does the step children's mother pay anything towards their care, if they live mainly with you?

Dishwashersaurous · 18/12/2021 15:57

As an aside which religious ceremony isn't a legal marriage?

Toastmost · 18/12/2021 15:56

Well you're not married so...and are you claiming as a single mother or have you been honest about your living situation? If you want true financial independence get a job and then lay out lines in the sand.

RantyAunty · 18/12/2021 15:56

Can the benefits fraud posts stop.

That isn't what this thread is about.

For all any of us know OP might be in a vulnerable situation. It can be hard enough to post about issues as it is.

Dishwashersaurous · 18/12/2021 15:56

Uc is a joint claim if you are a couple, so how don't you have a joint account?

NameChangeCity123 · 18/12/2021 15:55

I have never understood people who refer to their 'husbands' when they're not married... if you want a husband, get married. If not, you have a partner. It's cringey when you then have to back track and say 'oh we're not Actually married'

Agree with others, seems a lot of this is his money anyway and you knew he had other kids before you got together so feel like this was a conversation to have had years ago

100problems · 18/12/2021 15:53

You've waded into a situation where you've moved into a home with three kids, had another kid, given up work and are worried about a conversation about a joint account and not having an exit fund.

OP, the kids aren't the problem here.

NeedsCharging · 18/12/2021 15:51

Your post makes no sense.

Your UC claim will be a joint claim and only include the first 2 children and the 3rd if born before April 2017. So Your DD will not be on the claim.

If you are only claiming child benefit for your DD who is claiming for the other 3?

RantyAunty · 18/12/2021 15:51

I've got questions. How old are his DC?
Are you saying you don't have any extra for yourself or to save a little?
Do you have access to his earning at all?

How did all 3 children end up living with him? Who was watching them before you came along?

Since you aren't legally married you are vulnerable.
You might think about returning to work sometime next year. You'd probably feel better and more secure.

OneForTh · 18/12/2021 15:51

I feel sorry for his stepchildren as you don't sound like you like them and begrudge them being there.

This is their home too, if they only see their mum once a month. You're claiming benefits so you don't have to get a job, the least you can do is keep their rooms clean, what else do you have to do all day? Their dad is at work. If you didn't want three step children then why marry him and have another???

It not not the fault of the children.