Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How am I a racist?!?

163 replies

Cinderella1 · 18/12/2021 10:48

Still a bit shaken after an exchange with someone on Nextdoor site that called me a racist. Post might be long but don't want to be accused of drip-feeding, so here it is: Original post was about the tragic fire that took the life of four young kids. A neighbour posted this:
"After the tragedy of 4 little boys died in a house fire, I will ask for any single parent which need a help with their kids for a babysitting during Xmas , I am happy to help.
I am not child minder and not insured but I am mum with two grown up boys.

Pls pls do not leave your kids alone". This person then starts asking if she's had a DBS check, etc, so my response is here: "so you think people leaving their very young kids alone for hours is less of a risk than leaving them with a neighbour? This site is not Twitter. What's next - needed a food hygiene certificate and chefs qualifications when helping in a soup kitchen? The whole world will be a better place if we got to know our neighbours better and could ask for help when needed!" , Then him: "not sure what you think your post is about? Please vent some where else where they can understand you. Me: "it's written in British English - apologies for the confusion for those who need to revisit their comprehension skills."Then this from him: "oh sorry being
Welsh I am sorry I’ve offended all you Anglo Saxons as you’ve just offended me" "Racist", "going to apologise for your racism Dora?? Or are you just an Anglo Saxon bigot???" Me: "clearly your geography is as bad as your comprehension. Wales is still part of Great Britain and English is the official language!" Him: "reported to site as clear racism. No we don’t identify ourselves as Great Britain, we obviously have our own Synedd or do you deny that??". AIBU here or is this simply insane? I am not even Anglo-Saxon btw

OP posts:
Ilikeanimalsmorethanpeople · 18/12/2021 11:50

@Cinderella1 I saw your post on next door, That guy was an absolute bellend please ignore him!

2021namechanger · 18/12/2021 11:49

I’ve seen people offer to walk dogs on Nextdoor and you get people (rightly) asking “are you insured, habe you got experience” etc.

So quite frankly someone asking if she has a DBS check is pretty normal. You started a row. Not him.

Did he go weird with it? Yes. But that’s social media for you.

Cocomarine · 18/12/2021 11:48

[quote Cinderella1]@user36738281 You do not seem to understand this concept of welcoming an offer, then contacting them, getting to know them to be able to then use your own judgement vs "leaving your kids with a complete stranger" (no one has remotely suggested that. I hope my English is clear enough![/quote]
How much “getting to know them” do you think this person was suggesting, given that she was offering to babysit over Xmas?

viques · 18/12/2021 11:48

@x2boys

I don't think any of you should be using the tragic death of four boys ," to prove a point" it's very distasteful.
This with baubles on.
ArblemarzipanTFruitcake · 18/12/2021 11:48

[quote Cinderella1]@user36738281 You do not seem to understand this concept of welcoming an offer, then contacting them, getting to know them to be able to then use your own judgement vs "leaving your kids with a complete stranger" (no one has remotely suggested that. I hope my English is clear enough![/quote]
If you take a step back from this - suppose a neighbour in this situation did happen to have nefarious intentions - do you think they'd reveal them in the 'getting to know' period?

A DBS check isn't infallible but neither is individual judgement. I imagine most people would want to have known a neighbour for quite some time and witnessed their day to day behaviour, before entrusting their children to their care.

SachaStark2 · 18/12/2021 11:47

The original poster was using the article for virtue-signalling.

The guy was right to ask about DBS checks (which she could get very easily if she really wanted to sit for neighbours’ kids, they’re not expensive).

Your comparison to soup kitchens was unwarranted and weird.

The whole thread sounds bizarre and aggressive.

mumda · 18/12/2021 11:47

I hate nextdoor. Originally it was hyper-local - so literally just a small area around. They've expanded the reach unfortunately.
I should remove myself from it now as it's suggested "neighbours" to me, one of whom is my stalker.

Cocomarine · 18/12/2021 11:46

I think that @EmpressCixi has explained it all very well.

I think your mitigating factor is that you didn’t know that “British English” inadvertently put you straight into the wrong part of a Venn diagram of British racists.

PinkWednesdays · 18/12/2021 11:46

@Shiningpath

Maybe you’re not aware but there’s a strong commonality between people who put emphasis on British English, those who fly flags in their gardens and massive gammons. Your presumably innocent use of the term has led your Welsh neighbour to associate you with others who throw it around with gay abandon, usually alongside more pernicious statements about race and nationality.
Actually yes, this.

I’ve re read the exchange a couple of times and get this vibe from OP.

Cinderella1 · 18/12/2021 11:43

@user36738281 You do not seem to understand this concept of welcoming an offer, then contacting them, getting to know them to be able to then use your own judgement vs "leaving your kids with a complete stranger" (no one has remotely suggested that. I hope my English is clear enough!

OP posts:
FAQs · 18/12/2021 11:43

You are being bloody patronising to single parents!

Cocomarine · 18/12/2021 11:43

@2021namechanger

And call me cynical - but I bet the “nice OP” would actually be taken aback if someone random said “yeah great was gonna leave my kids alone on NYE, but now you’ve offered that sorted”

Bullshit offers of help help no one.

I did wonder if I were just a cow, as my first thought to the reported OP was “hmm, virtue signalling”.
FortunesFave · 18/12/2021 11:43

I do think it's not wise to offer to babysit for people you don't know! Or to take strangers up on their offer! He was right to question it. Any old weirdo could say "oh I'm so helpful, I'll babysit for strangers so no more children have to die..." which is maudlin and weird.

PinkWednesdays · 18/12/2021 11:41

I don’t tolerate racism or racist language at all, and so have no hesitation calling it what it is, but I don’t see what you said as racist. It sounds like he’s being goats and difficult.

Although your post and interaction was also unnecessary.

It’s very typical of social media, people act and say thing they never would in real life.

EmpressCixi · 18/12/2021 11:39

You started a bun fight that then got ugly:
Him: asking if she's had a DBS check?

You should have let it be. This was a question for OP. It’s relevant info and DBS checks are very common. I had to have one just to chaperone on school field trips. But no, you start a bun fight by replying:

You: "so you think people leaving their very young kids alone for hours is less of a risk than leaving them with a neighbour? This site is not Twitter. What's next - needed a food hygiene certificate and chefs qualifications when helping in a soup kitchen? The whole world will be a better place if we got to know our neighbours better and could ask for help when needed!"

Very judgmental. Merely asking if OP has a DBS check doesn’t mean he thinks children home alone is safer than with a neighbour. Then you get very sarcastic and cutting about it by ranting about soup kitchens etc.

Him: "not sure what you think your post is about? Please vent some where else where they can understand you.

Valid response to your aggressive rant imho.

Me: "it's written in British English - apologies for the confusion for those who need to revisit their comprehension skills."

You engage in a personal attack, saying his English must not be very good...which imho is a racist attack because it implies you think he isn’t English and that’s why he’s did not “understand” when really we all know that’s a polite euphemism for “why are you being so mean”?

him: "oh sorry being Welsh I am sorry I’ve offended all you Anglo Saxons as you’ve just offended me" "Racist", "going to apologise for your racism Dora?? Or are you just an Anglo Saxon bigot???"

English is descended from Aenglish, the language of the Anglo Saxons....so he’s got a point about 1) you did a racist attack on his “English” and ooops, he does happen to be ethnic Welsh, not English, so yes you were racist. Whether you intended to or not with your insult about his English, unfortunately for you, the recipient was not ethnic English.

Me: "clearly your geography is as bad as your comprehension. Wales is still part of Great Britain and English is the official language!"

And that’s you digging a hole....

Him: "reported to site as clear racism. No we don’t identify ourselves as Great Britain, we obviously have our own Synedd or do you deny that??"

He got you. I think you owe an apology. You started a bun fight and then proceeded to cover yourself in shit.

user36738281 · 18/12/2021 11:39

How arrogant do you have to be to think people don’t comprehend “British” English lol. How many languages do you speak OP?

ArblemarzipanTFruitcake · 18/12/2021 11:38

@2021namechanger

And call me cynical - but I bet the “nice OP” would actually be taken aback if someone random said “yeah great was gonna leave my kids alone on NYE, but now you’ve offered that sorted”

Bullshit offers of help help no one.

Yes, this.
Cinderella1 · 18/12/2021 11:38

I'm not really a time on social media, so not experienced with Twitter, FB, etc. Nextdoor was useful in terms of finding info about reliable tradesman, etc. With risk to derail my own thread - I would trust a basic DBS check a lot less than my own personal judgment. The police officer who abducted and killed the young woman would've had an enhanced DBS check, I'm sure. Most child abuse happens by close family members, etc. Anyway, my question was how me mentioning British English on a small South London platform can be reported as racist? I responded more to his comment not understanding what I was on about. English isn't actually my own first language so I am genuinely trying to understand how can those words (sarcastic as they were) being construed as racism Confused

OP posts:
2021namechanger · 18/12/2021 11:37

And call me cynical - but I bet the “nice OP” would actually be taken aback if someone random said “yeah great was gonna leave my kids alone on NYE, but now you’ve offered that sorted”

Bullshit offers of help help no one.

madisonbridges · 18/12/2021 11:36

@catfunk

Maybe because you kept bringing up BRITISH English and Great Britain. You both sound awful tbh.
She mentioned British English and GB once. It's hardly "keeping bringing it up".
2021namechanger · 18/12/2021 11:33

Reading this back it sounds more like you started this. He made a valid point and you went off on a tangent about soup kitchens.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 18/12/2021 11:31

Correcting anyone's English is a dick move. He's was a dick too. Move on.

catfunk · 18/12/2021 11:31

Maybe because you kept bringing up BRITISH English and Great Britain.
You both sound awful tbh.

user36738281 · 18/12/2021 11:31

You were being quite rude but you don’t like it when it’s handed back to you lol. Also you shouldn’t blindly trust neighbours and your opinion isn’t the only correct one. People are allowed to disagree with you. I have written it in “British” English, hope you understand.

blacksax · 18/12/2021 11:30

Take comfort in the knowledge that one can be both Welsh and a dickhead at the same time.