Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How am I a racist?!?

163 replies

Cinderella1 · 18/12/2021 10:48

Still a bit shaken after an exchange with someone on Nextdoor site that called me a racist. Post might be long but don't want to be accused of drip-feeding, so here it is: Original post was about the tragic fire that took the life of four young kids. A neighbour posted this:
"After the tragedy of 4 little boys died in a house fire, I will ask for any single parent which need a help with their kids for a babysitting during Xmas , I am happy to help.
I am not child minder and not insured but I am mum with two grown up boys.

Pls pls do not leave your kids alone". This person then starts asking if she's had a DBS check, etc, so my response is here: "so you think people leaving their very young kids alone for hours is less of a risk than leaving them with a neighbour? This site is not Twitter. What's next - needed a food hygiene certificate and chefs qualifications when helping in a soup kitchen? The whole world will be a better place if we got to know our neighbours better and could ask for help when needed!" , Then him: "not sure what you think your post is about? Please vent some where else where they can understand you. Me: "it's written in British English - apologies for the confusion for those who need to revisit their comprehension skills."Then this from him: "oh sorry being
Welsh I am sorry I’ve offended all you Anglo Saxons as you’ve just offended me" "Racist", "going to apologise for your racism Dora?? Or are you just an Anglo Saxon bigot???" Me: "clearly your geography is as bad as your comprehension. Wales is still part of Great Britain and English is the official language!" Him: "reported to site as clear racism. No we don’t identify ourselves as Great Britain, we obviously have our own Synedd or do you deny that??". AIBU here or is this simply insane? I am not even Anglo-Saxon btw

OP posts:
Chocolatewheatos · 18/12/2021 13:36

You started a petty argument and lost.

justanoldhack · 18/12/2021 13:32

Not the point I know but you actually do need a food hygiene certification if you want to work in a soup kitchen. I volunteered one Christmas and needed to do a course online before I could start.

user36738281 · 18/12/2021 13:23

@EmpressCixi you’re my hero, loving your responses.

oviraptor21 · 18/12/2021 13:23

As mentioned by a previous poster British English is a term widely used by language teachers and ESOL learners to distinguish from US English and various other forms. OP has already said that English is not their first language, hence their use of the term.
It absolutely is not racist and it's only people who are unfamiliar with languages who would suggest it is. However, once informed, they have no excuse to continue with that line of attack.

Yes, OP attacked with sarcasm which always draws out the worst of social media trolls. No, they were not racist.

Loki01 · 18/12/2021 13:19

I am a foreigner and I can see exactly see what you meant.
He just run out of arguments and didn't know what to say so pulled this ridiculous accusation of his a...

EmpressCixi · 18/12/2021 13:19

@GatoradeMeBitch

No, not xenophobic. Welsh are a legally recognised minority nationality and ethnicity and as such, any discriminatory attacks fall under the Equality Act 2010 as racism per the Acts definition of race:
“1)Race includes—

(a)colour;

(b)nationality;

(c)ethnic or national origins.”

Rebbeca2Cool · 18/12/2021 13:15

Umm I think this is a defo a upcoming facist Grin

GatoradeMeBitch · 18/12/2021 13:09

rightly as a racist attack

Xenophobic.

EmpressCixi · 18/12/2021 13:06

@maddening
Now to walk you through the second racist attack

To then respond to a Welsh person after mocking their “British English” “comprehension skills” who has called that out rightly as a racist attack, with not an apology but the following:

clearly your geography is as bad as your comprehension. Wales is still part of Great Britain and English is the official language!

So, first OP is telling a Welsh person they don’t know where Wales is. Informing them that Wales is part of Great Britain, a lovely reminder of their status as a conquered nation by the English, followed up by as a subjugated nation, English is the official language. Which is actually incorrect because the Welsh have regained the right to speak their language, teach in it and have gotten it recognised as an official language. This insult is an Imperialist boot to the bum type of racist attack.

Imagine the same exchange between say a Nigerian and an English poster. This is not so different.

EmpressCixi · 18/12/2021 12:57

@maddening

She did not do racist attacks Empress ! Don't be daft. The British English was mentioned prior to the man taking offence due to his being Welsh. And British English is also spoken in Wales alongside welsh, he was being deliberately offended. I am married to a Welsh man, from a city that borders with Wales, it is one of my favourite places, no beef with Wales at all etc, the guy was looking for a fight.
I am not daft, thank you very much.

Posting to an unknown person online
it's written in British English - apologies for the confusion for those who need to revisit their comprehension skills.

Racism question aside. It is clearly a deliberate insult to the persons reading comprehension. So I don’t agree feeling offended by it would be “deliberately being offended” or taking offence at nothing. It was a personal attack and insult.

Now to why is it also racist. Is a racist type of insult because it

  1. Implies the unknown person may not be British, and therefore
  2. Implies that English is not their native language Hence the assertion they have a lack of “comprehension skills” in “British English”

It doesn’t matter whether the unknown person is English or not, the angle is still an ethnically based attack, as it is also say the obverse, that any native “British English” reader would have clearly comprehended the post referred to and not questioned what the OP meant by it.

Unfortunately for OP, the unknown person then revealed that they are not English but Welsh...which is recognised in law as a different ethnicity and thus can be victims of racism. So the racist insult having been done to a person of a nonEnglish ethnicity, thereby became a completed racist attack.

Harrysmummy246 · 18/12/2021 12:57

you rose to it and kept replying- that's when you mute a thread/ turn off notifications. Once you realise people are just looking for an argument etc

oviraptor21 · 18/12/2021 12:57

@EmpressCixi

You started a bun fight that then got ugly: Him: asking if she's had a DBS check?

You should have let it be. This was a question for OP. It’s relevant info and DBS checks are very common. I had to have one just to chaperone on school field trips. But no, you start a bun fight by replying:

You: "so you think people leaving their very young kids alone for hours is less of a risk than leaving them with a neighbour? This site is not Twitter. What's next - needed a food hygiene certificate and chefs qualifications when helping in a soup kitchen? The whole world will be a better place if we got to know our neighbours better and could ask for help when needed!"

Very judgmental. Merely asking if OP has a DBS check doesn’t mean he thinks children home alone is safer than with a neighbour. Then you get very sarcastic and cutting about it by ranting about soup kitchens etc.

Him: "not sure what you think your post is about? Please vent some where else where they can understand you.

Valid response to your aggressive rant imho.

Me: "it's written in British English - apologies for the confusion for those who need to revisit their comprehension skills."

You engage in a personal attack, saying his English must not be very good...which imho is a racist attack because it implies you think he isn’t English and that’s why he’s did not “understand” when really we all know that’s a polite euphemism for “why are you being so mean”?

him: "oh sorry being Welsh I am sorry I’ve offended all you Anglo Saxons as you’ve just offended me" "Racist", "going to apologise for your racism Dora?? Or are you just an Anglo Saxon bigot???"

English is descended from Aenglish, the language of the Anglo Saxons....so he’s got a point about 1) you did a racist attack on his “English” and ooops, he does happen to be ethnic Welsh, not English, so yes you were racist. Whether you intended to or not with your insult about his English, unfortunately for you, the recipient was not ethnic English.

Me: "clearly your geography is as bad as your comprehension. Wales is still part of Great Britain and English is the official language!"

And that’s you digging a hole....

Him: "reported to site as clear racism. No we don’t identify ourselves as Great Britain, we obviously have our own Synedd or do you deny that??"

He got you. I think you owe an apology. You started a bun fight and then proceeded to cover yourself in shit.

You what? 🤣
rocky1914 · 18/12/2021 12:57

@MaskingForIt

Bet he’s wanking off over winding you up. With people like that the best course of approach is simply to ignore them, and if you have to say anything, just say someone nice to the person offering.
Sorry, OP. No advice unfortunately except for maybe you could have replaced the word "British" with "Plain" as in, "Plain English". But otherwise, no you have done nothing wrong and as pp suggested, tell him to go and beat himself off to feel better and stop projecting his insecurities onto you. Wanker.... literally! 😂😂
LittleRoundRobin · 18/12/2021 12:52

@Cinderella1

He sounds a bit goady, and you don't sound like a racist, (from what you have said,) but you do sound a bit sanctimonious ...And, as a previous poster said, the way you spoke to him was a bit condescending. He had a right to ask if you have a DBS check. Even peoples parents have to have one, if they are going to be looking after their own grandkids! Utter madness I know!!!

So I am a little bit on the fence, but am leaning more towards YABU. So that's what I chose on the poll.

I also agree with a few posters that it is somewhat virtue signalling, and I do wonder if you would happily take someone's kids and look after them on New Year's Eve.

cherrypie66 · 18/12/2021 12:51

Get off social media

NotTerfNorCis · 18/12/2021 12:49

He sounds like a dick. Report him back for harassment.

CoffeeSonata · 18/12/2021 12:49

He is so welsh, and pro welsh language /anti English/welsh nationalistic that he can't even spell Senedd correctly if that was a direct copy and paste. Anglo-Saxon is also a loaded, goady term when used against English too. He's just a pedantic, keyboard warrior looking for a fight. Just ignore. It's definitely not you. It's not worth a reply. Your main mistake was getting sucked in and bothering to reply at all to his comment. Some people are just not worth the time or the energy. And for God's sake don't tell him the Senedd still doesn't have the power of Westminster, and the laws of the country are the laws of England AND Wales! Ignore. Not worth the brain space.

MajorCarolDanvers · 18/12/2021 12:48

British English was totally goady. It was always going to go downhill from there.

BeyondShrinks · 18/12/2021 12:46

He was right about the DBS (odds of someone known to a child abusing them are pretty high, vs odds of them dying in a freak accident when left alone)

But - as a welsh Yes Cymru-er, you were right about British English. In comparison to American English etc, it's relevant that it's British. And wales, regardless of whether it is part of the United Kingdom, remains part of the island of Great Britain

Uninterested · 18/12/2021 12:45

It sounds like you were both getting het up for the entertainment factor.

There are a lot of idiots on social media. Some of them enjoy winding people up and some can’t help but get wound up. It’s silly and sad.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 18/12/2021 12:44

Also, in general, you started the bunfight here from what I see, OP. My advice would be not to dish it.

Staffy1 · 18/12/2021 12:44

Ignore the idiot. He can report it, but I doubt the moderator will see a problem with anyone but him. If anyone is racist it’s him.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 18/12/2021 12:43

I used to work as an EFL teacher. "British English" is not racist; it's a term used to distinguish this English (with its own spellings, phrasal verbs, peculiarities of usage) from Am. E, NZ E., Aus E., etc.

Chinese students want to study with Cambridge-published textbooks because, broadly speaking, they think Br. E. a more prestigious variety than Am. E.

Yes, it's simplistic nonsense, but it's the difference between learning the present perfect, British spelling, the plethora of UK-specific usages, or not if you study with Am. E. texts.

maddening · 18/12/2021 12:39

She did not do racist attacks Empress ! Don't be daft. The British English was mentioned prior to the man taking offence due to his being Welsh. And British English is also spoken in Wales alongside welsh, he was being deliberately offended. I am married to a Welsh man, from a city that borders with Wales, it is one of my favourite places, no beef with Wales at all etc, the guy was looking for a fight.

ArblemarzipanTFruitcake · 18/12/2021 12:38

I do stand by my opinion that IF it is a question of leaving young kids ALONE for a length of time or leaving them with a neighbour, the latter is the better option.

It depends how you look at it. If you take the rare occurrence of an emergency, then obviously it is better for the children to be with someone no matter who, who can get everyone to safety.

On the 99% of times when no emergency occurs, it would be better for children to be alone than to be with a sexual abuser, for example.

That shouldn't be taking as advocating leaving children alone - the point I'm making really is that the only viable option is to stay with them yourself if you cannot find a trusted babysitter - leaving them with someone who has only just made themselves known to you isn't a better option than leaving them alone - they're equally risky courses of action.