Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How am I a racist?!?

163 replies

Cinderella1 · 18/12/2021 10:48

Still a bit shaken after an exchange with someone on Nextdoor site that called me a racist. Post might be long but don't want to be accused of drip-feeding, so here it is: Original post was about the tragic fire that took the life of four young kids. A neighbour posted this:
"After the tragedy of 4 little boys died in a house fire, I will ask for any single parent which need a help with their kids for a babysitting during Xmas , I am happy to help.
I am not child minder and not insured but I am mum with two grown up boys.

Pls pls do not leave your kids alone". This person then starts asking if she's had a DBS check, etc, so my response is here: "so you think people leaving their very young kids alone for hours is less of a risk than leaving them with a neighbour? This site is not Twitter. What's next - needed a food hygiene certificate and chefs qualifications when helping in a soup kitchen? The whole world will be a better place if we got to know our neighbours better and could ask for help when needed!" , Then him: "not sure what you think your post is about? Please vent some where else where they can understand you. Me: "it's written in British English - apologies for the confusion for those who need to revisit their comprehension skills."Then this from him: "oh sorry being
Welsh I am sorry I’ve offended all you Anglo Saxons as you’ve just offended me" "Racist", "going to apologise for your racism Dora?? Or are you just an Anglo Saxon bigot???" Me: "clearly your geography is as bad as your comprehension. Wales is still part of Great Britain and English is the official language!" Him: "reported to site as clear racism. No we don’t identify ourselves as Great Britain, we obviously have our own Synedd or do you deny that??". AIBU here or is this simply insane? I am not even Anglo-Saxon btw

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Derbee · 19/12/2021 00:50

@tillytown

Ignore the people trying to make a big deal out of you writing British English OP, its a completely fine thing to write, they are just as bad as the troll tbh.
Yes, ignore the many people who are offering you a differing view, and explaining why your comments could be taken in a way that you didn’t foresee. Nothing will ever come of asking for opinions, and genuinely listening to the answers. Hmm
Cinderella1 · 18/12/2021 19:14

@blacksax I bow to your wisdom GrinWine

OP posts:
CMZ2018 · 18/12/2021 17:56

Ignore the crank

maddening · 18/12/2021 17:41

Empress it is not an attack, your take is obtuse

tillytown · 18/12/2021 16:19

Ignore the people trying to make a big deal out of you writing British English OP, its a completely fine thing to write, they are just as bad as the troll tbh.

5foot5 · 18/12/2021 16:09

@Allmadeoflego
Hate to say this but I think it depends where you live. Mine straddles two areas - and there is a marked difference between the content.

One is all “does anyone know a good gardener”. The other is a hotbed of nastiness.

Yes ours is very much the former. The nearest I can think of to a difference of opinion recently was early last month when a poster was outraged that the display of pumpkins outside her door had been vandalised. Amid all the commiserations was one poster who said "Mate, it's November 6th! " I thought it was funny but it caused lots of huffing and puffing such as "Oh that makes it alright to go on other people's property does it, just because it's no longer Halloween?"

Squeezita · 18/12/2021 16:04

I’m diverse and I would have taken British English to mean as opposed to American English.

Racists tend to just focus on ENGLISH.

Suzanne999 · 18/12/2021 15:52

Someone with far too much time on his hands.

kirinm · 18/12/2021 15:50

@Cinderella1

I'm not really a time on social media, so not experienced with Twitter, FB, etc. Nextdoor was useful in terms of finding info about reliable tradesman, etc. With risk to derail my own thread - I would trust a basic DBS check a lot less than my own personal judgment. The police officer who abducted and killed the young woman would've had an enhanced DBS check, I'm sure. Most child abuse happens by close family members, etc. Anyway, my question was how me mentioning British English on a small South London platform can be reported as racist? I responded more to his comment not understanding what I was on about. English isn't actually my own first language so I am genuinely trying to understand how can those words (sarcastic as they were) being construed as racism Confused
South london is hugely diverse and if you'd said British English I'd have raised an eyebrow too.
GrannytoaUnicorn · 18/12/2021 15:46

@blacksax

Take comfort in the knowledge that one can be both Welsh and a dickhead at the same time.
GrinGrinGrin
GrannytoaUnicorn · 18/12/2021 15:46

Speaking of Anglo-Saxons, this video (& it's sequel) is both fascinatingly educational and amusing in equal measure

GrannytoaUnicorn · 18/12/2021 15:43

@CharSiu

One of my friends has a tiresome husband who spends his life enjoying winding people up online. He has an incredibly boring job and is a complete dullard. I have no idea what she likes him but each to their own. Sounds like you have come across someone like him. As a total aside DH family name is an incredibly rare ancient Anglo Saxon name.
I'd love to know what that surname is! I don't suppose you'd feel comfortable sharing it but I'm intrigued
Squeezita · 18/12/2021 14:54

[quote Cinderella1]@Ilikeanimalsmorethanpeople thank you and sorry, guess that was quite outing Blush[/quote]
Invite me to your nextdoor OP, I’ll give him a few home truths. 🤣

Swisscheeseleaves · 18/12/2021 14:43

Poking at someone for not understanding "British English" when you don't know them and have no idea of their ethnicity or background does sound pretty racist, yeah. Maybe stop picking arguments with people on social media in future?

100problems · 18/12/2021 14:36

But that's the salient point OP. You thought one thing, he thinks another. As DM says "opinions are like arseholes, we all have one but we don't all need to hear them".

Cinderella1 · 18/12/2021 14:31

@EmpressCixi I think everyone here got your opinion - you don't need to keep ramming it down people's throats again and again, so just give it a rest! If you want to feel insulted and offended by anyone who doesn't agree with you (Such as @oviraptor21) you will be. I've already said that he made other comments to other people (too long for here) before I made my first. My use of "British English" was clearly unfortunate - should've used "Plain English" instead but was in no way meant to be racist, FGS, just plain sarcastic! The original lady who offered help posted just a couple of hours after the incident. Was her offer genuine, if a bit misguided? Most of us, who aren't jaded cynics seem to think so. Emotions where running very high in our local community. Her first response to the tragedy is "Hope there is something I can do to help prevent something like this from happening again!" His -"Do you have a DBS check?????" My own somewhat apparently limited comprehension skills, lead me to believe that there is quite a difference between someone saying - "Kind offer but it might be good to still have a check run" and someone asking in the way he did - context! Was I intentionally sarcastic and possibly insulting - yes, insult me back - sure, I can take it. I guess him calling me an "Anglo-Saxon bigot" isn't racist either in your book? But to call someone racist in their own community and even report them over something like this is just plain bonkers to me!

OP posts:
BeyondShrinks · 18/12/2021 14:15

Rude, sarcastic, patronising - yes

Racist/xenophobic - a bit more open to interpretation, I say no, but I don't disagree with those saying yes

Correct for stating it is safer that a random, unDBS-ed, internet-posting person look after a child - hell no

PlanktonsComputerWife · 18/12/2021 14:04

Kids as an informal term for children isn't an Americanism. It's existed in English in this sense since the 16th century. www.etymonline.com/word/kid#etymonline_v_1843

Fomofo · 18/12/2021 14:04

Telling people off for their comprehension skills is pretty rude

Valeriekat · 18/12/2021 14:03

I believe there was a court case in which it was decided that Wales and being Welsh did not meet that definition and he was being ridiculous.

Avaynia · 18/12/2021 14:01

You started a fight so you could virtue signal as much as the op and now you want to be mad that he reacted. Yabu

EmpressCixi · 18/12/2021 13:56

@oviraptor21
As mentioned by a previous poster British English is a term widely used by language teachers and ESOL learners to distinguish from US English and various other forms.

That’s not the context the OP used it in though. Let’s review the context:

Him to that OP: Do you have a DBS check? (Substantially)

Our OP: so you think people leaving their very young kids alone for hours is less of a risk than leaving them with a neighbour? This site is not Twitter. What's next - needed a food hygiene certificate and chefs qualifications when helping in a soup kitchen? The whole world will be a better place if we got to know our neighbours better and could ask for help when needed!"

His response: not sure what you think your post is about? Please vent some where else where they can understand you.

Our OP: it's written in British English - apologies for the confusion for those who need to revisit their comprehension skills."

So, firstly, the “it” she is referring to that is written in British English doesn’t actually use any unique British words or construction. In fact, it actually has the Americanism of “kids” used to refer to children, so could argue it’s written in US English moreso than British English.

Secondly, OPs intent is clear she’s not genuinely sorry for any confusion for “British English” because it’s not actually written in a particularly British way. There is no confusion like you have with sayings have opposite meanings, ie to table an issue in British English means to put it on the table to address now, whereas in American English to table an issue means to set it aside to address later. None of that in her post. Her intent was obviously to be insulting back to the person who objected to her aggressive rant in response to his DBS question that wasn’t even directed to her in the first place.

But of course, people who think the OP is reasonable to use insulting comments in discourse, are likely to also engage in using insults on those who disagree with them too. As you so handily demonstrated by saying myself and those who agree with me are essentially ignorant/uneducated:
it's only people who are unfamiliar with languages who would suggest it is (racist)

BrightYellowDaffodil · 18/12/2021 13:49

NextDoor is a hotbed of loons. Well, ours is anyway - you should have seen the posts when the council gave us smaller waste bins to encourage more recycling (complete with the ability to have a larger one if you could prove you needed it), you’d have thought the council were removing everyone’s first-borns. And as for the time someone complained that a wide footpath through farmland had an electric fence down one side (“Won’t someone think of the kiddies that could get hurt?” “Well, keep the blighters away from the fence then!”), well…the most charitable thing that could be said about that bun fight was that it was highly entertaining.

Ignore them, OP!

laudete · 18/12/2021 13:42

English isn't actually my own first language so I am genuinely trying to understand how can those words (sarcastic as they were) being construed as racism

Instead of, "apologies for the confusion for those who need to revisit their comprehension skills," you should have simply written, "apologies, this isn't my native language."

He was being very rude about your language skills; your English is excellent and easily comprehensible. However, "comprehension" is more typically used to suggest an insult. (Additionally, Wales is part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland but English is an official language not the official language. A subtle but important difference.)

FWIW, I do not think you were being racist. Your English skills are excellent. However, languages are quite complex and it is easy to be caught out by unintended interpretations. As you speak 7 languages, you must be aware that many words/phrases do not translate literally between languages. I can assure you that - superficially - all English language variants (UK, Aus, USA, etc) are readily understood in context. It is mostly just spelling and some nouns that are different eg colour/color, rawlplug/anchor, flipflop/thong.

I hope this makes you feel better and eases your concern. x

100problems · 18/12/2021 13:40

I don't think, based on the evidence, you're a racist. You are a twit for engaging on Nextdoor with a dick. Lie down with dogs and get fleas OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread