Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Santa vs father Christmas

186 replies

Blinkingheckythump · 17/12/2021 23:18

I know it's totally unimportant and hence iabu but it really irks me that everything seems to be santa these days and not father Christmas. It was always father Christmas when I was growing up. I miss it! Why has it changed over time? I say father Christmas to the kids but they hear santa everywhere else so usually say santa themselves. Am I being unreasonable in wishing it was still father Christmas?!

Incase it needs clarifying, this is very lighthearted. I'm aware it's not really an issue

OP posts:
MistyGreenAndBlue · 18/12/2021 04:59

Well I'm Scottish, my entire family are Scottish and we've all always said Father Christmas, as did my friends growing up.
So much for that theory then.

beenthereboughtthetshirt · 18/12/2021 04:19

Born and bred in the South East but always Santa from the beginning as one parent is Scottish and other one English.

Blinkingheckythump · 18/12/2021 04:17

It's interesting to read that it's always santa in Scotland. And santa /santy in Ireland. These are things I did not know.

OP posts:
Blinkingheckythump · 18/12/2021 04:14

@SylvanianFrenemies

Father Christmas sounds ridiculously affected and Hyacinth Bucketesque to me, however I get that it is traditional in some parts of England so of course sounds quite natural to some.

Let me guess, OP. Do you also object to Halloween because it wasn't part of your childhood, and you are similarly unable to comprehend that there are legitimate traditions that don't originate in middle class home-counties homes?

Don't be so ridiculous. My preference for the term father Christmas is nothing to do with any of those things. Fwiw I love Halloween, I'm in a mixed ethnicity relationship (not home County!) and am faaaar from middle class. Based on more level headed replies it is likely more to do with the part of the UK I was raised in (South England).
OP posts:
TicTacHoh · 18/12/2021 03:08

Always been Santa in Scotland

Atla · 18/12/2021 02:58

When I was growing up in NW England in the 80's it was father christmas (working class background). Am in NI now and everyone says Santa, DH thinks saying FC is the poshest of posh things.

MaskingForIt · 18/12/2021 02:43

@Saoirse82 NI is part of the UK not Britain, don't want to derail the thread but this fucks me off.

Last time I dared to mention that a whole bunch of NIers jumped down my throat and told me very firmly that they were British.

I guess in this day and age anyone can identify as anything, so why not?

ApolloandDaphne · 18/12/2021 02:29

Another Scot here and it has always been Santa. I don't know anyone who says Father Christmas.

Hotelhelp · 18/12/2021 02:23

I’ve never heard a single Scottish person utter the words Father Christmas

Saoirse82 · 18/12/2021 02:21

@Hospedia

Santa is British. Last I checked Scotland, NI, and NE England were part of Britain.
NI is part of the UK not Britain, don't want to derail the thread but this fucks me off.
Saoirse82 · 18/12/2021 02:16

It's always been santa to me and I'm almost 40. However my parents would say father Christmas and the older generation to a young child might say daddy Christmas, I'm in NI. My dad said it was never santa growing up in 50s Belfast.

mathanxiety · 18/12/2021 02:11

@DramaAlpaca, 'Santy' is the opposite of twee.

AlwaysLatte · 18/12/2021 02:10

It's always been Father Christmas for me too (and subsequently my children).

mathanxiety · 18/12/2021 02:09

@DroopyClematis, I think you're right that the English feeling of unease about Santa Claus stems from a deeply buried antipathy to Catholicism, and associated with that, the Irish.

However, you used British where you should have said English. It's Santa Claus in Scotland.

Father Christmas is a very English term.

mathanxiety · 18/12/2021 02:04

I'm Irish and have always said Santa Claus.

Father Christmas always conjured up a vision of Enid Blyton's world in my head, complete with lashings of crumpets, piles of scones, clotted cream, etc.

SylvanianFrenemies · 18/12/2021 01:40

Father Christmas sounds ridiculously affected and Hyacinth Bucketesque to me, however I get that it is traditional in some parts of England so of course sounds quite natural to some.

Let me guess, OP. Do you also object to Halloween because it wasn't part of your childhood, and you are similarly unable to comprehend that there are legitimate traditions that don't originate in middle class home-counties homes?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/12/2021 01:38

Father Christmas here. And he’s always sounded friendly and cuddly to me, so there. Xmas Wink

beenthereboughtthetshirt · 18/12/2021 01:34

@SenecaFallsRedux

I agree, I also think this is why it stuck in the US, because of Catholic emigrees from Spain.

It's primary antecedent in the US is Dutch: Sinterklaas.

precisely
Strokethefurrywall · 18/12/2021 01:33

Was Father Christmas in my youth (Londoner), but have lived overseas in Caribbean for 15 years and it’s Santa here and that’s how the kids refer to him.

But we’re not weird enough to attach class connotations to how we refer to the man in red, only seems to be those in UK that do.

beenthereboughtthetshirt · 18/12/2021 01:33

@Lovinglifeand

We always said Father Christmas. I thought 'Santa' was the American name for Father Christmas and it has seeped into our lives from all the American Christmas films.

I wouldn't let it worry you. Just call him Father Christmas yourself, your children will probably chop and change depending on who they talk to but usually kids end up saying the same as their parents.

this a common misconception
PilesEdgeworth · 18/12/2021 01:33

“ The younger Britons are the more likely they are to favour 'Santa Claus' over 'Father Christmas', with 18-24 year-olds tending to use the former name over the latter by 50% to 33%. By contrast, two thirds (66%) of Brits aged 65 and older tend to use 'Father Christmas'.”

PilesEdgeworth · 18/12/2021 01:32

I feel like we need some data.

yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2017/12/06/it-father-christmas-or-santa-claus

beenthereboughtthetshirt · 18/12/2021 01:26

one Scot parent one English - always been Santa in this house from the word go

Lovinglifeand · 18/12/2021 01:09

We always said Father Christmas. I thought 'Santa' was the American name for Father Christmas and it has seeped into our lives from all the American Christmas films.

I wouldn't let it worry you. Just call him Father Christmas yourself, your children will probably chop and change depending on who they talk to but usually kids end up saying the same as their parents.

DramaAlpaca · 18/12/2021 01:00

It was Father Christmas when I was growing up in northern England.

I live in Ireland now and everyone says Santa, including my DC when they were little. I don't mind Santa, but can't stand 'Santy'. So silly and twee.