Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many animal lovers are total hypocrites

164 replies

coatilove · 17/12/2021 21:50

I actually dislike majority of animals, I didn't grow up with them have never had a special relationship with any and have no interest in them at all.

However, I watched a documentary on Netflix tonight called blackfish and I cannot understand how killer whales are being held in captivity and made millions of pounds and so called 'animal lovers' go to watch them and swim with them?

As someone who dislikes animals it still makes me sick to my stomach to see an animal in captivity and I could never pay to support BS like sea world - so how can animal lovers do it?

How do animal lovers eat animals? Or go to zoos?

It baffles me, AIBU?

OP posts:
maddening · 17/12/2021 22:53

I am veggie so don't eat or wear animals, I do struggle with my consuming dairy, it does make me feel awful. I would not go an see a killer whale or dolphins in captivity.

I live near Chester zoo, the zoo is these days more about conservation and do not see the animals being mistreated there.

XenoBitch · 17/12/2021 22:52

*Yes this! People who get dogs and then "crate train" them, wtf! What's the bloody point of having a domestic pet only to keep it in a cage all night and half the day?! Sick.

My dog has free run of the house and very often sneaks in to bed with us during the chilly winter nights smile*

My dog was crate trained.. and her crate came to be her safe space. It was no longer needed after about 6 months of getting her (and it was absolutely needed at one point as she broke a leg and was on strict crate rest)

Jaxhog · 17/12/2021 22:52

@userxx

Animals in captivity for human entertainment is disgusting. I don't think many animal lovers support them.
I agree. However, while zoos might not be ideal, they do raise awareness of animals and do a lot to preserve and learn about rare species.
Warmduscher · 17/12/2021 22:50

[quote coatilove]@Tiramesu yes that's exactly my point.

There was a viral video of someone throwing a cat in the air and everyone was outraged about animal cruelty. Even though the cat was fine, but let's take animals from their natural habitat and lock them up for Forever instead [/quote]
So are you saying the people who were (rightly) angry about a cat being mistreated are the same people going to Seaworld? I’m struggling to make sense of your train of thought here.

smurfsss · 17/12/2021 22:49

@RobertSmithsLipstick

I'm often surprised at people who claim to love animals. They get pets and don't look after them properly, or train them, then shut them away in their kitchen, because they get overexcited at visitors. (The dogs, not the people!)

Those sort of animal lovers really anger me.

I don't have any pets precisely because I'm too lazy to put in the amount of work they deserve.

Yes this! People who get dogs and then "crate train" them, wtf! What's the bloody point of having a domestic pet only to keep it in a cage all night and half the day?! Sick.

My dog has free run of the house and very often sneaks in to bed with us during the chilly winter nights Smile

Pinkbonbon · 17/12/2021 22:49

I prefer to take animals on an individual by individual basis, the same way I do ppl tbh. Some people are assholes, so are some animals. I agree that aquariums are distasteful as is eating meat. But I eat meat and I'd probably visit an aquarium. So I guess I'm a hypocrite. But at least I know it xD

HeronLanyon · 17/12/2021 22:47

I was driving through regents park recently and suddenly saw some giraffes. Had forgotten the zoo was even there. Have never seen one in real life. A second of astonishment tuned quickly into sadness about the zoo, what we do to animals, that they were trapped there having to see my car driving by and others every day of their miserable lives. Awful.

Hedgesfullofbirds · 17/12/2021 22:45

This is such a complex topic and there will always be dichotomies - personally I find the very term 'animal lover' to be saccharine! Many self described 'animal lovers' are what I would describe as 'animal sentimentalists' with a gooey, fawning behaviour toward animals, especially 'cute', fluffy, cuddly ones, which they try to humanise or anthropomorphise, giving them names and attributing human behaviours or cogniscense to them.
Respecting animals does not mean that one cannot also kill and eat them, in the same way as conservation' does not mean preserving absolutely everything at all costs.
However, I am inclined to agree that keeping animals captive to provide human 'entertainment' is abhorrent and disrespectful, in the extreme.

Incidentally OP - I am not convinced that, given your user name, you dislike animals as much as you say you do! Coatis are fascinating animals with extraordinary family dynamics and behaviours!

sjxoxo · 17/12/2021 22:45

I think you are generalising ‘animal lovers’… we aren’t one whole group of same minded people! I am absolutely an animal lover and would never swim with whales dolphins etc or say go to a circus with animals in. I find it surprising people take their kids without seeing the reality of the suffering to ge honest. I also won’t go to a zoo without doing my research & I firmly believe exotic animals don’t belong in captivity, especially not for commercial gain. There is a conservation aspect that is important and some zoos are very proactive in this so I am reluctant to write them all off. I have 2 dogs & 2 cats, all rescue & all have access to outside space etc. The problem you mention is that some people are just idiots.. you are right in that these commercial environments are not ideal habitats for these animals and by people supporting them they are enabling the continuing unnatural lifestyles for these species. Xox

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 17/12/2021 22:45

I find non-vegan animal welfare activists the greatest of hypocrites

So it has to be all or nothing then givethatbabyaname

I can be a non leather/non fur/non down'feather non animal tested cosmetic/cleaning product/toiletries vegetarian but unless I'm a vegan I should just throw in the towel .
Hmm Oh okay then

XenoBitch · 17/12/2021 22:44

@ginnig

Does anyone think zoos are useful for education eg makes kids aware what amazing creatures exist & how we should be more environmentally conscious? although maybe not such a thing now due to internet/social media.
Show them videos. There is no reason to have big cats/bears/sea mammals/any animal that has a natural territory that covers kilometres to be confined in a zoo. It is cruel.
smurfsss · 17/12/2021 22:42

I don't think animal lovers are the ones going to see whales and dolphins, or tiger cubs etc at these sort of entertainment parks.

I'd consider myself an animal lover and I can barely face going to a zoo let alone something like Sea World or whatever. A lot of these places are closing down anyway due to huge drops in demand as more people are becoming aware of the living conditions of the poor creatures.

Anotherbrokenairer · 17/12/2021 22:41

I watched Blackfish a few years ago. I think everyone should watch it. Eye opening and made me reflect on my memories of those shows in the 90's. So sad all round.

iheartredsquirrels · 17/12/2021 22:40

A lot of 'animal lovers' also eat animals. Oh wait, it's all sanitised and not a real animal in the supermarket....

coatilove · 17/12/2021 22:40

@Tiramesu yes that's exactly my point.

There was a viral video of someone throwing a cat in the air and everyone was outraged about animal cruelty. Even though the cat was fine, but let's take animals from their natural habitat and lock them up for Forever instead

OP posts:
DroopyClematis · 17/12/2021 22:39

I understand that swimming with dolphins has helped to give these creatures diseases that aren't natural to them and is causing concern.

Also, whale watching is apparently stressing the whales.

UK Sea-life centres are trading on the 'research' ticket , like many zoos. Eg, sea-horse breeding but many breeds , born in captivity , are never able to be reintroduced into the wild, so their breeding programmes are almost null and void eg sea horses, pandas etc...

Sharks and dogfish should never be used to swim around a glass tunnel in a poxy sea life centre. In fact, most marine creatures should never be used as a day trip.
I'm not even happy about zoos either , but at least land animals have enough ( barely) land to cope with unlike sea creatures that need miles and miles of swimming to exist happily.

RunningFromInsanity · 17/12/2021 22:39

In the past, animal lovers went to Sea World/Zoos etc because they loved to see animals.
Now we know better, Sea World’s attendance has plummeted. Many holiday companies are boycotting them now. Swimming with dolphins is no longer considered a fun holiday excursion.

Nobodies perfect, we are all learning and evolving and trying to better ourselves.

HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 17/12/2021 22:38

I'm not an animal lover but do hate animals used for entertainment purposes. Zoos have in some situations done good conversation work with endangered species, but lots of zoos are very bad.

ginnig · 17/12/2021 22:38

Does anyone think zoos are useful for education eg makes kids aware what amazing creatures exist & how we should be more environmentally conscious? although maybe not such a thing now due to internet/social media.

Tiramesu · 17/12/2021 22:37

YANBU. So many people would cry or be angry about a video of a cat being put in a bin (an old news story) or a hedgehog being tortured by school kids, but pay a hidden industry to factory farm & slaughter baby animals to eat without batting an eyelid.. and profess themselves animal lovers.

tinse1 · 17/12/2021 22:36

OP, your logic is a bit too simplistic.

Most people are appalled by animals in captivity, whether they have pets or not, or whatever they claim to be.

I mean, billions of people eat meat with no thought of how it was killed or the conditions the animal was kept in. Many of those people claim to be ‘animal lovers.’ Even someone like you, who claims to be disinterested in animals, probably wouldn’t eat meat if you had to kill it.

Anyway, this documentary has obviously affected you and you are clearly now interested in an animal. This is progress! Please watch some others and become further affected and interested. Animals are wonderful and it’s a hollow life without them.

Dottybackorcid · 17/12/2021 22:32

@AllThingsServeTheBeam you claim animals don't die for your diet.

I'm intrigued by this stamen, its pretty bold. So what do you eat exactly?

WizbitsLeftEye · 17/12/2021 22:31

I watched it when it came out, it's horrifying. People really don't seem to get it. Entitled and can't see farther than their own noses. I visit zoos, but the places I go are genuinely striving to give their animals what they need, and are involved in actual preservation and conservation and breeding programs for vulnerable species. This is all something SeaWorld etc said they were doing but they lied and lied and lied.

AlizeeEasy · 17/12/2021 22:27

I think generally people don’t think about it, zoos and sea life centres are a part of our lives and generally people expect that if it’s legal then it’s fine. I went to sea world and didn’t think about it until a couple of years later

I spent time on a nature reserve in South Africa and saw the amount of space that animals in the wild use and since then I struggle to find zoos entertaining. It comes from education, I don’t think it’s right to shame people for enjoying something that they’ve never had much reason to question.

Builtthiscityonsausagerolls · 17/12/2021 22:26

Isn't it, like most things, incredibly nuanced?
My local zoo is Chester Zoo - they do wonderful conservation work. It's not like a scummy entertainment zoo.
I'm happy eating meat, but hate factory farming. Therefore I rarely eat meat, but when I do its from a free-range farm I can trust.
I think dairy is more cruel than meat - so I don't buy dairy but will happily eat free range pig.
We all have to make the ethical decisions we can.

Swipe left for the next trending thread