Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many animal lovers are total hypocrites

164 replies

coatilove · 17/12/2021 21:50

I actually dislike majority of animals, I didn't grow up with them have never had a special relationship with any and have no interest in them at all.

However, I watched a documentary on Netflix tonight called blackfish and I cannot understand how killer whales are being held in captivity and made millions of pounds and so called 'animal lovers' go to watch them and swim with them?

As someone who dislikes animals it still makes me sick to my stomach to see an animal in captivity and I could never pay to support BS like sea world - so how can animal lovers do it?

How do animal lovers eat animals? Or go to zoos?

It baffles me, AIBU?

OP posts:
ClareBlue · 18/12/2021 00:02

@HeronLanyon

I was driving through regents park recently and suddenly saw some giraffes. Had forgotten the zoo was even there. Have never seen one in real life. A second of astonishment tuned quickly into sadness about the zoo, what we do to animals, that they were trapped there having to see my car driving by and others every day of their miserable lives. Awful.
Well as your car is destroying the natural environment that their cousin live in, I would say they are pretty pissed off with you
HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 18/12/2021 00:00

@user93948921

Absolutely, the hypocritical meat eaters with fight you to death before admitting that they are contributing to the pain that animals face whilst being slaughtered and how they are damaging the environment. They will never take accountability, well I am yet to see one. They will argue with you till they are red in the face that there is no pain caused to animals and it’s not a big deal. Then they get really outraged if a human is killed by a tiger for example due to their own fault. People really need to take responsibility but no one wants to give up their beloved steak and chicken nuggets. No point arguing with these people set in their ways. At least the younger generation is more aware.
Eh? How can any meat eater say there's no pain in slaughter? Of course there is. I don't think I've ever seen anyone argue differently.

And whilst I do see a difference between an animal killed for sport and then discarded and an animal killed for food, I don't think one is murder and the other not.

Dave to the environment is relative though, cows (milk and beef) = bad. Almonds, also bad.

worriedatthemoment · 17/12/2021 23:56

@Dashel some predators could live off non meat though they just also choose not too
We are all allowed a choice and out bodies are set up as omnivores , some people really cannot have a vegatarian diet
And do you really think all animals would be saved if we All went veggie we would need the land to grow more and be in competition with animals for the space
Also why would anyone breed certain animals when not needed for food they would be left to become extinct
Its too simplistic to think if we all gave up meat no animal would ever suffer again
Also people shouldn't preach there beliefs we can make our own choices
Don't sit their thinking no animal has ever suffered for you to eat something veggie or not

ClareBlue · 17/12/2021 23:55

But plenty of 'animal lovers' consume products that by manufacturing them destroy habitats of animals that lead to them unable to survive. It's not quite as simple as I'm not eating a dead animal or going to a zoo.
I hear all the time 'I don't like seeing animals in captivity' whilst the same person will consume to extent where the animals can not live outside captivity.

user93948921 · 17/12/2021 23:54

Humanely slaughter.. another rubbish way of taking no responsibility as if it’s any better lol

You’re killing animals humanely or otherwise.

Prescottdanni123 · 17/12/2021 23:52

I'm an animal lover. I dont like animals in captivity so therefore don't go to zoos etc. I think part of the reason why people do is due to lack of education on the subject. They don't understand just how bad captivity, even large zoo enclosures, can be for animals. It doesn't mean that they don't love animals though, nor are they deliberately being hypocritical.

XenoBitch · 17/12/2021 23:50

The difference is that predators in the wild don’t have a choice and need to eat meat to survive as they can’t go to Tesco for alternatives

It is a choice for a human to eat meat or diary, we have a lot of alternatives

As humans, we do try and humanely slaughter our food animals.

If you Reddit, have a look at r/natureismetal

Animals don't give a fuck.

user93948921 · 17/12/2021 23:50

Absolutely, the hypocritical meat eaters with fight you to death before admitting that they are contributing to the pain that animals face whilst being slaughtered and how they are damaging the environment. They will never take accountability, well I am yet to see one. They will argue with you till they are red in the face that there is no pain caused to animals and it’s not a big deal. Then they get really outraged if a human is killed by a tiger for example due to their own fault. People really need to take responsibility but no one wants to give up their beloved steak and chicken nuggets. No point arguing with these people set in their ways. At least the younger generation is more aware.

eveningbubble · 17/12/2021 23:48

Of course you can be non-vegetarian and still love animals. If early humans only consumed a vegetarian diet we would still have brains like giraffes. Eating meat protein was essential to our evolution.

Dashel · 17/12/2021 23:45

@worriedatthemoment

Plus we can all decide for ourselves if we are animal lovers or not We don't hate other animals because they eat other Animals do we We see it as the food chain ,
The difference is that predators in the wild don’t have a choice and need to eat meat to survive as they can’t go to Tesco for alternatives.

It is a choice for a human to eat meat or diary, we have a lot of alternatives

Ibizafun · 17/12/2021 23:43

My dh asked me why it's ok to eat meat but not wear fur (assuming it was ethically raised and killed). Being a vegetarian who doesn't see meat as food, I wasn't quite sure how to answer him.

worriedatthemoment · 17/12/2021 23:39

Plus we can all decide for ourselves if we are animal lovers or not
We don't hate other animals because they eat other Animals do we
We see it as the food chain ,

worriedatthemoment · 17/12/2021 23:33

There are many animals though you might not love them all
I don't love cows so can eat one , I love dolphins so wouldn't want to eat one
I don't eat deer or rabbit either as always had pet rabbits and love bambi
Zoos have their place in conservation at times , keeping orcas captive is wrong although impossible to release just like that
I would love to see a dolphin and could of on holiday in a park but would rather wait for the chance to see in the wild

XenoBitch · 17/12/2021 23:29

@GetInThereLewis

PodgePie honestly, high welfare don't mean shit. I have worked in a processing plant on the 'kill line' and the high welfare stood next to the factory farmed stock. They looked no better cared for either. These words are used to remove guilt and to make the public feel like they are trying.
Yep, there are no '"nice" slaughter houses. All animals go to the same place. The extra money you pay for free range etc is what happens long before that.
youkiddingme · 17/12/2021 23:24

I think a lot of animal lovers love what animals can do for them - make them feel less lonely, act as a fashion accessory, entertain them - whatever. I love to spot an animal in the wild and if I'm lucky get a quick photo. I don't want to share a house with them and hate when other people's pets jump all over me or shit in my garden. I'm not an animal lover or hater. I appreciate animals and respect them but don't want to live with them.

Dashel · 17/12/2021 23:16

Most people I have talked to who claim to be animal lovers and omnivores seem to have a massive detachment between meat and an actual animal, food animals don’t count unless they are in a cute photo or petting zoo. Yet the idea that some cultures eat dogs or horses is just so wrong to them and that cruelty is somehow different.

I think if more people saw what the animals went through there would be a lot more vegans. There seems to be an idea that every single item of meat, egg and dairy is produced without causing suffering. Some people just don’t want to see the truth because they are selfish and value bacon or whatever above causing suffering.

belimoo · 17/12/2021 23:16

I haven't read the full thread so apologies if you've answered this but how come you don't like animals? Any idea why?

I know this isn't really the point of the thread but this is so different to my point of view that I'm genuinely intrigued. Have you ever got to know an animal?

GetInThereLewis · 17/12/2021 23:12

PodgePie honestly, high welfare don't mean shit. I have worked in a processing plant on the 'kill line' and the high welfare stood next to the factory farmed stock. They looked no better cared for either. These words are used to remove guilt and to make the public feel like they are trying.

PodgePie · 17/12/2021 23:01

@PodgePie

I have recently stopped eating meat because I watched a horrific video of slaughterhouses in the UK. I had only been buying high welfare meat but now have little faith in the industry. I do buy meat which I can prove the provenance of (I.e from farmer friends) for DD & DH but I can no longer stomach it. I absolutely love animals but I do think you can love them & also eat ethically produced meat. It’s ok to take steps to ensure high welfare to maintain these standards. We need to stop buying a chicken for £3 etc and welfare will improve.

Totally agree with SeaWorld et al. Those poor creatures should have been released years ago

Obviously I mean that I agree with comments about SeaWorld …
PodgePie · 17/12/2021 23:00

I have recently stopped eating meat because I watched a horrific video of slaughterhouses in the UK. I had only been buying high welfare meat but now have little faith in the industry. I do buy meat which I can prove the provenance of (I.e from
farmer friends) for DD & DH but I can no longer stomach it. I absolutely love animals but I do think you can love them & also eat ethically produced meat. It’s ok to take steps to ensure high welfare to maintain these standards. We need to stop buying a chicken for £3 etc and welfare will improve.

Totally agree with SeaWorld et al. Those poor creatures should have been released years ago

imthenextinline · 17/12/2021 22:59

@maddening

We have a pet gerbil who has an ikea kallax converted to a palatial home and we open up a huge run in the lounge, she is not mistreated and doss not display any stress symptoms or behaviours.
Gerbils are social animals and should live in pairs where possible.
Anordinarymum · 17/12/2021 22:58

I have pets, and I love them. I live by my own code of ethics and don't tell anyone else how to live.
To the best of my knowledge and ability I look after my pets well and care for them if they are ill. If this makes me a hypocrite then so be it.
I don't tell anyone to do anything I would not do myself not do I expect people to live by a standard I couldn't uphold.
Surely a hypocrite is someone who says one thing and does another?

GetInThereLewis · 17/12/2021 22:57

Agree op. No animal deserves to be exploited.

maddening · 17/12/2021 22:55

We have a pet gerbil who has an ikea kallax converted to a palatial home and we open up a huge run in the lounge, she is not mistreated and doss not display any stress symptoms or behaviours.

Sarahlou63 · 17/12/2021 22:54

Humans have destroyed the natural habitat of so many animals that in many cases the only way to preserve them is to protect them in zoos, aquariums and nature reserves. All of which cost money to run so they have to exhibit the animals to maintain the facilities.

Maybe if we culled billions of people and gave their land and resources back to the species they killed in the name of progress it would be equitable...

Swipe left for the next trending thread