Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many animal lovers are total hypocrites

164 replies

coatilove · 17/12/2021 21:50

I actually dislike majority of animals, I didn't grow up with them have never had a special relationship with any and have no interest in them at all.

However, I watched a documentary on Netflix tonight called blackfish and I cannot understand how killer whales are being held in captivity and made millions of pounds and so called 'animal lovers' go to watch them and swim with them?

As someone who dislikes animals it still makes me sick to my stomach to see an animal in captivity and I could never pay to support BS like sea world - so how can animal lovers do it?

How do animal lovers eat animals? Or go to zoos?

It baffles me, AIBU?

OP posts:
Tabbacus · 18/12/2021 00:34

@ClareBlue

How many animals have gone extinct because we eat them? How many animals have gone extinct because we have destroyed, polluted, built on their habitats? Non meat eating diet that provides protein at affordable prices? Not to the entitled well off people who judge those who have limited choices and eat intensively produced meat to feed their children. The luxury of sitting in judgement. The biggest threat to animals on our planet is the self entitled middle class consumers who won't wait for a bus because they are too busy, or have to eat food that is grown in the Ivory Coast. Well that's what my goats say. I wouldn't say that because I will get hate. Goats can handle hate and genuinely don't give AF. As the most consumed meat in the world they seem to be pretty cool about life, to be honest.
Plenty of affordable protein sources, it's cheaper to eat vegetarian than it is to eat even processed meat, but again if they eat meat not an issue- but if they try and justify how its beneficial for the animals and all sorts of ridiculous claims about how they'd be extinct otherwise etc then that's silly.
worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:33

@Quasi22 not sure many of us would eat leather

Quasi22 · 18/12/2021 00:33

I wouldn’t support anything like sea world though. There are laws regarding enclosure sizes and we couldn’t keep anything like a killer whale in the U.K. as to meet welfare standards they’d need a tank about the size of England. I can’t remember the exact measurements but we were taught about it during university… there’s a website somewhere with the enclosure sizes required for each animal.

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:33

@Tabbacus like i said some have medical reasons and a vegan diet would be very hard and some people cannot afford a good varied vegan diet
We have been omnivores for years

Quasi22 · 18/12/2021 00:32

A lot of U.K. zoos do a lot for conservation (Whether you agree with saving endangered species is another matter some think species going extinct shouldn’t be interfered with). I’m veggie, eat mostly vegan although I don’t have an issue with small scale dairy farms. I wouldn’t eat leather or use other by-products of the meat industry but I do support zoos. The highland wildlife park, for example, is absolutely stunning and the animals have a lot of space. They’re educational and can do a lot of good.

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:31

@Tabbacus i said i mistook you name calling I owned that
Many products vegetarians eat an animal may be killed as you have stated with certain food
That animal is killed and left to die at least when eaten an animal provides nutrition
You can't claim to be a vegatarian because all animals matter and a hater or meat eaters and think that if we all stopped eating meat animals would be all ok
And as another poster has stated not all can afford a varied vegetarian healthy diet

Tabbacus · 18/12/2021 00:29

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Tabbacus ok maybe not you with the name calling but yes petty insults with your wording such as who can't be a vegatarian in the developed world
Some people with medical conditions can't be vegan as if your a vegatarian because its all about the animals then really should be a vegan as you know what happens to male diary cows
I think we should all waste less and maybe reduce our consumption but not be forced to give up because other people tell us we have too [/quote]
I am a vegan yes, also not arsed if others eat meat, but find the flimsy justifications odd as if it's doing a service to the animals to eat meat. It's not. And yes if people choose not to be veggie that's fine of course people make their own choices, it was in response to your statement that people can't for various reasons, but not sure what those are.

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:28

@k1233 exactly

Tabbacus · 18/12/2021 00:27

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Tabbacus I think a fair few animals have become extinct or are verging on and thats not due to eating them
Palm oil - how many animals have died from that , think it features in vegetarian foods does it not
Yes i like some meats and enjoy it I wouldn't eat any food I don't like would I , i also have meat free days if I feel like it [/quote]
There is a difference in animals becoming extinct because we stop eating them and in general. Yes palm oil is bad, as are avocados and almonds amongst other things as they lead to deforestation that causes loss of natural habit for some animals with catastrophic consequences. And? I still don't see how ah plenty of animals are killed inadvertently for some foods may as well heap more misery on by eating them. Still interested in the claim I was name calling.

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:26

@sarah13xx do you drink milk , wear leather shoes

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:25

@Tabbacus ok maybe not you with the name calling but yes petty insults with your wording such as who can't be a vegatarian in the developed world
Some people with medical conditions can't be vegan as if your a vegatarian because its all about the animals then really should be a vegan as you know what happens to male diary cows
I think we should all waste less and maybe reduce our consumption but not be forced to give up because other people tell us we have too

sarah13xx · 18/12/2021 00:24

I’m a vegetarian, have been since I was 6 (out of choice, my parents aren’t or anything). I’m a massive animal lover. There are so many people say they’re animal lovers and try to act like they’re the same as me or even a woman I know who constantly saves wild animals or any kind of bird etc but we went out for a Chinese the other week and she’s tucking into all the meat. I just don’t understand how you can go out your way driving miles and miles with injured animals in your car one night then eat them the next 🤔 In my world animals are friends not food, no exceptions but some people do seem to have their own bizarre rules around it all

ClareBlue · 18/12/2021 00:24

How many animals have gone extinct because we eat them?
How many animals have gone extinct because we have destroyed, polluted, built on their habitats?
Non meat eating diet that provides protein at affordable prices? Not to the entitled well off people who judge those who have limited choices and eat intensively produced meat to feed their children.
The luxury of sitting in judgement. The biggest threat to animals on our planet is the self entitled middle class consumers who won't wait for a bus because they are too busy, or have to eat food that is grown in the Ivory Coast.
Well that's what my goats say. I wouldn't say that because I will get hate. Goats can handle hate and genuinely don't give AF.
As the most consumed meat in the world they seem to be pretty cool about life, to be honest.

Sweetchocolatecandy · 18/12/2021 00:24

Unfortunately due to poaching and hunting activities in developing countries many animals are simply not safe living in the wild anymore. I think a lot of people have unrealistic, almost childlike views that animals in zoos should be living in the wilds of Africa roaming free when it’s simply not possible or safe for them. They are actually safer in enclosures- which is a sad reflection of what humanity has done to the world.

EleonorBronte · 18/12/2021 00:22

chill out, who cares?
some love animals more than people, so what?
some love people more than animals, so what?
Some love both, so what?
Some also realise we are all animals and life is a kaleidoscope of beauty and terror. We are all gonna die, just fuck it off.

Kpo58 · 18/12/2021 00:22

How do you come to that conclusion then? Animals don't die for my diet.

Animals will die regardless of your diet. Small animals die in fields when crops are harvested, insects are killed due to pesticides. Animals are killed when their homes are destroyed to make way for whatever is the new super food that cannot be grown in the UK. Animals die because of the runoff from manmade pesticides. Microplastics are released when people wash non natural materials. Animals due due to the lack of water because cotton is a water hungry crop.

The only really ethical diet would be to cleanly kill a wild animal, like a deer and use every part of it or growing your own food.

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:21

@Tabbacus I think a fair few animals have become extinct or are verging on and thats not due to eating them
Palm oil - how many animals have died from that , think it features in vegetarian foods does it not
Yes i like some meats and enjoy it I wouldn't eat any food I don't like would I , i also have meat free days if I feel like it

Tabbacus · 18/12/2021 00:20

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Tabbacus its a fact not a tired argument and I don't have to justify or admit anything to you
Im a grown adult and can accept others can make different choices to me without name calling and petty insults[/quote]
Where did I name call or make petty insults?

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:19

@Tabbacus its a fact not a tired argument and I don't have to justify or admit anything to you
Im a grown adult and can accept others can make different choices to me without name calling and petty insults

PodgePie · 18/12/2021 00:15

@GetInThereLewis

PodgePie honestly, high welfare don't mean shit. I have worked in a processing plant on the 'kill line' and the high welfare stood next to the factory farmed stock. They looked no better cared for either. These words are used to remove guilt and to make the public feel like they are trying.
I know enough farmers to know this isn’t the case. And before you suggest otherwise - these are farmers who either arrange on site slaughter or choose slaughter houses that are humane.
MushMonster · 18/12/2021 00:13

Zoos have changed a lot OP.
They no longer take animals from the wild to put in cages. Many only keep animals that needed rescuing, and did not adapt to get back to the wild, species that need protection, animals that have been taken from trafficking.
They do a much better work of protecting animals and species than the old versions.
It is sad to see some of the species that need big territories, or lots of interaction, they look sad. On that I agree. I wish all of them could make it back to reserves in their natural habitats, but let's face it, many of them are in troubled numbers back on their countries of origin due to poaching, safaris and so on.

Humans are animals too. So about eating meat (though me personally I have reduced to almost zero how much I eat), I will never judge another human for taking their place in the food change. Wasting meat though is something that I cannot cope with.
I do love my pet cats. They are members of our family. We treat them well, and I see no harm in sharing warm place, food, and cuddles with them.

Tabbacus · 18/12/2021 00:12

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Dashel some predators could live off non meat though they just also choose not too
We are all allowed a choice and out bodies are set up as omnivores , some people really cannot have a vegatarian diet
And do you really think all animals would be saved if we All went veggie we would need the land to grow more and be in competition with animals for the space
Also why would anyone breed certain animals when not needed for food they would be left to become extinct
Its too simplistic to think if we all gave up meat no animal would ever suffer again
Also people shouldn't preach there beliefs we can make our own choices
Don't sit their thinking no animal has ever suffered for you to eat something veggie or not [/quote]
These same tired arguments get trotted out time and time again, if you eat meat just admit you enjoy eating dead animals because you like the taste or whatever.

Interested who these people are that can't have a veggie diet in the developed world, beyond choosing not to (not judging but no need to falsely justify it just say yeah their death is worth it to me). Animals eat a load of crops and take up a fair amount of space, there would still be enough food for humans and animals if we weren't artificially overbreeding them. Do all animals we don't eat become extinct? No. There just wouldn't be such numbers but they also wouldn't be living in shitty conditions, often separated from their parents when young, and then killed to end up wrapped nicely in the supermarket.

Summerfun54321 · 18/12/2021 00:09

Love animals, hate the idea of domesticating them for pets or keeping them locked up in zoos.

gofg · 18/12/2021 00:03

Well said @worriedatthemoment

Tabbacus · 18/12/2021 00:03

@Hoppinggreen

I don’t go to zoos etc but I do eat meat occasionally. Funnily enough I was talking to a vegetarian friend about my volunteer work at a local wildlife rescue and she said “yuk, I could never do that” I asked her what she would do if she found an animal in distress and she said “don’t know, nothing” So who is the animal lover? Her or me?
The one who doesn't contribute to the demand for the slaughter of animals and doesn't feast on their flesh. Hope that helps.
Swipe left for the next trending thread