Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many animal lovers are total hypocrites

164 replies

coatilove · 17/12/2021 21:50

I actually dislike majority of animals, I didn't grow up with them have never had a special relationship with any and have no interest in them at all.

However, I watched a documentary on Netflix tonight called blackfish and I cannot understand how killer whales are being held in captivity and made millions of pounds and so called 'animal lovers' go to watch them and swim with them?

As someone who dislikes animals it still makes me sick to my stomach to see an animal in captivity and I could never pay to support BS like sea world - so how can animal lovers do it?

How do animal lovers eat animals? Or go to zoos?

It baffles me, AIBU?

OP posts:
Queeen · 18/12/2021 04:13

Yanbu.

I'm vegan (for over 22 years). I don't like animals. I don't want to touch them, I don't want them in my home, and consider pets thoroughly unsanitary. I've never described myself as an animal lover. Yet I have more respect for them than those who profess to love animals, yet think nothing of eating them, wearing them, using them. So yes, most people who call themselves animal lovers are hypocrites. Most people who claim to love animals though, only really feel that way about animals they can dominate, i.e. pets.

eveningbubble · 18/12/2021 04:11

@user93948921 Absolutely, the hypocritical meat eaters with fight you to death before admitting that they are contributing to the pain that animals face whilst being slaughtered and how they are damaging the environment. They will never take accountability, well I am yet to see one

And again you are only here able to comment because we ate meat.

Draggondragon · 18/12/2021 03:56

I can't imagine not liking animals. It's not a very likable trait.

gofg · 18/12/2021 02:18

Animals in captivity for human entertainment is disgusting

Yes, pets for example

And what would you like to do with all the pets? Set them free so they can roam the neighbourhoods, breeding indiscriminately and catching diseases? That sounds so much better than being a pet. You sound clueless.

Flaxmeadow · 18/12/2021 02:09

userxx
Animals in captivity for human entertainment is disgusting

Yes, pets for example

eveningbubble · 18/12/2021 01:53

I actually dislike majority of animals, I missed that because I was reading the rest of the OP about orcas which most people agree are not acceptable to have in captivity. I dislike the majority of animals, being one yourself OP what does that really mean? or is this just another *** post.

Quasi22 · 18/12/2021 01:42

@worriedatthemoment
You sound like you know what you’re doing. The odd human treat is usually fine, providing it isn’t something toxic. A bit of carrot, some rice or half a plain digestive likely won’t do too much damage. A full roast covered in salt twice a week followed by a family sized fruit and nut bar will.

I completely appreciate the human-animal bond and why owners want to give their pets treats, I just wish they’d make better choices. A vet will usually cover diet in routine consults like vaccinations/yearly health checks (timer permitting) so if a new owner needed suggestions for healthy treats a vet could provide them. It’s certainly not all owners, and of the owners that do have overweight pets many are willing to learn. Not knowing isn’t an issue, but being dismissive of someone trying to help you can be. It would be best for owners to research before buying a pet but I appreciate this isn’t always the case and it’s much better to educate than berate and alienate people.

You get good behaviourists and bad ‘behaviourists’. I was taught the ladder of aggression at university (vet in training - not yet qualified) and it’s very possible we don’t have the full picture yet regarding a dog’s body language but at the minute it’s taught as relevant. A qualified vet that works closely with behaviourists e.g. a vet interested in shelter medicine would be better equipped to comment on current research.

Owning a dog is definitely harder than it first seems.

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 01:19

@Quasi22 we have a dog we had 2 before who lived to 15 and we did give human treats at times but always about moderation they were always a good weight never over but very active, there dogs they eat out the bin if you turn your back
Out current dog is 6 and again perfect weight has the odd human treat but we know which ones are dangerous
Its funny how you do learn your dogs language and we know when he needs to go outside etc as he just has a certain look
Yes i know about licking lips , yawning etc but tbf some behaviourists don't totally agree on all this
Dog is currenty on the floor at the bottom of the bed but he may not stay there , sofa is often his favourite place although technically he isn't supposed to , but who sees at night right
Owning a dog is hard though and I don't think people realise how hard

RobertSmithsLipstick · 18/12/2021 01:06

I watched an episode of "it's me or the dog" or something, where a little chihuahua was really aggressive and snappy.
The thing is though, that it's owners carried it around in a big handbag with a perspex window in.

It hadn't felt the pavement under its feet for years.

She had to remind them that as tiny as it was, it was a dog, that needed to do dog things!

ClareBlue · 18/12/2021 00:59

I was trying to articulate that, thanks.
Just come back from a friend who is vegan and an 'animal lover' who has two fat cats that are in a two room flat all day and fed sweets as a treat.
I bet they dream of the plains of Africa 😁

Quasi22 · 18/12/2021 00:56

Sorry my keyboard is playing up tonight! Hopefully it makes sense

Quasi22 · 18/12/2021 00:54

On the wider topic though, lots are hypocrites. Look at the pet population, so many dogs are obese because their owners won’t stop giving them human food! This can have a real detrimental impact on their health but lots don’t care as they ‘can’t help’ giving them a taste of dinner each night despite being told in no uncertain terms that they’re harming their pet. Others have overweight pets because the pet has an underlying health condition and do everything they can to get the weight off but so many allow them to be obese and cause the health issues.

It’s the same with ignoring a dog’s body language. It’s usually the case of just now knowing but but wouldn’t (I hope) have a non English-speaking person in your house for 10-15 years without trying to learn their language so why isn’t it the same for dogs? So many don’t know that yawning, licking lips, whites of the eyes, turning away is the dog communicating that they’re not happy. The vast majority don’t progress up the ladder of aggression to biting but that’s sheer luck. The spend most days having their space invaded and their boundaries ignored.

I could go on but I do agree with you. I think a lot of it is lack of education or the fact (as a PP said) they love what the animal adds to their own life.

SmellyOldPartridgeinaPearTree · 18/12/2021 00:52

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Tabbacus To be honest im
Not ready to give up meat yet
Im happy to reduce my consumption and all for some different non meat recipes that aren't the usual nutroast and def any other types of protein ideas other than meat , quorn etc [/quote]
You don't actually need that much protein in your diet you know. Everyone acts like you should be eating 90% protein. It's really bad for your kidneys.

SmellyOldPartridgeinaPearTree · 18/12/2021 00:50

@Hoppinggreen

I don’t go to zoos etc but I do eat meat occasionally. Funnily enough I was talking to a vegetarian friend about my volunteer work at a local wildlife rescue and she said “yuk, I could never do that” I asked her what she would do if she found an animal in distress and she said “don’t know, nothing” So who is the animal lover? Her or me?
I suppose you can love animals and be terrible in a crisis/not want to shovel shit in your spare time? Love them from afar sort of thing?
worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:49

@Tabbacus To be honest im
Not ready to give up meat yet
Im happy to reduce my consumption and all for some different non meat recipes that aren't the usual nutroast and def any other types of protein ideas other than meat , quorn etc

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:47

@Quasi22 im a fair bit older than you and I only just remember
Monkey world has lots of monkeys ( obviously lol) that have come from pet homes and circuses / street acts
Its so sad to see what they have been through but the place seems to do a lot of good from what i can tell
Not far from us se have some dolphins that seem to be hanging around and im hoping to one day catch a glimpse of them in the wild that would be amazing

Tabbacus · 18/12/2021 00:43

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Tabbacus I also
Never said we would run out of food
What i said was we would need more space tp grow crops etc and who do you thinks habitat would be sacrificed for that [/quote]
We wouldn't though, there's plenty of reputable resources to research from if you're interested.

Quasi22 · 18/12/2021 00:42

@worriedatthemoment
I’m under 25 so I don’t remember. Unless my parents never took me to see them?
I completely agree that keeping whales in captivity is disgusting. I think we are still keeping animals that will later be banned but we’re trying. Madrid zoo had bears in a tiny enclosure when I visited when I was 15. They were either trained or ex-circus animals as there were doing tricks as members of the public threw food to them. I tried to say something with my GCSE Spanish although I’m not sure I made much sense. I assumed I did as I got abuse back. I also reported to the zoo at the time.
I then asked my Spanish teacher to help me write an email to the zoo and to leave a review.

Zoos are not perfect here but we are better than most. I hope by working with them we can improve them more. I don’t want animals to be solely for entertainment but they also need to raise money. I am not sure of the answer.

Tabbacus · 18/12/2021 00:39

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Tabbacus i never said it was beneficial your twisting words to suit your narrative , what I said is that it wouldn't be a simple answer to stop eating meat and all suffering would stop and all animals saved
Re : cheaper sorry no I don't think it is
If your talking quorn wtc i don't think thats much better than a chicken nugget
Almond milk etc expensive and also pretty destructive
[/quote]
I think a lot is lack of understanding of nutrition, plenty of cheap sources of protein beyond fake meat.

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:39

@Tabbacus I also
Never said we would run out of food
What i said was we would need more space tp grow crops etc and who do you thinks habitat would be sacrificed for that

worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:37

@Tabbacus i never said it was beneficial your twisting words to suit your narrative , what I said is that it wouldn't be a simple answer to stop eating meat and all suffering would stop and all animals saved
Re : cheaper sorry no I don't think it is
If your talking quorn wtc i don't think thats much better than a chicken nugget
Almond milk etc expensive and also pretty destructive

Quasi22 · 18/12/2021 00:37
  • I wouldn’t wear leather. I certainly wouldn’t eat it!! Grin
worriedatthemoment · 18/12/2021 00:35

@Quasi22 I remember when we did have killer whales and dolphins in captivity in the uk though
I think we were one of the first to get rid off though
Other european countries have them in captivity though not just seaworld
Although i think they are going away but its now china etc

Tabbacus · 18/12/2021 00:35

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Tabbacus like i said some have medical reasons and a vegan diet would be very hard and some people cannot afford a good varied vegan diet
We have been omnivores for years [/quote]
I wasn't criticising eating meat though, but the trying to say it was beneficial to the animals and false claims about how no one could est otherwise as we'd run out of food.

HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 18/12/2021 00:34

or choose slaughter houses that are humane. There's nothing humane about slaughter.

I eat meat, I've killed animals. There's nothing humane in it. Ever.

Swipe left for the next trending thread