Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is BU: Physios or GP/consultant?

45 replies

LittleGreyFluffyCat · 17/12/2021 20:24

Medical professionals are disagreeing about my MRI results:

GP & spinal consultant say: 'Normal wear and tear, wouldn't cause any symptoms'
Physios x2 say: 'Not a negative MRI, would definitely cause your symptoms'

^MRI says:
Mild spondylotic changes at C5-C6 and C6-7 levels. There is mild osteophytic encroachment of bilateral neural foramina at C5-C6 level causing mild impingement of bilateral exiting nerve roots. Bilateral neural foramina are minimally compromised. The spinal canal is adequate.^

YABU: GP & spinal consultant correct
YANBU: Physio is correct

I've had ongoing symptoms (worsening arm pain, tingling around neck and back, pain in back near arms) for over a year. I can't get help unless a GP or consultant agrees with the physio point of view. I can afford one more private consultation with a new spinal consultant but don't want to waste £££ if the physios are just talking nonsense.

Posting this in the desperate hope a medical person or two will see this and have a helpful opinion.

OP posts:
Iamaslummymummy · 17/12/2021 21:59

Should have continued reading. You need to see a vascular surgeon

Iamaslummymummy · 17/12/2021 21:58

You've got HSD. Have a look at thoracic outlet syndrome. Negative on mri. Normally only diagnosed by ct angiogram or doppler ultrasound. Plenty of thoracic outlet sufferers are bendy people

LittleGreyFluffyCat · 17/12/2021 21:56

Just checked back on bloods taken summer 2020 when my issues began, and my B12 was good, so I don't think it's that.

OP posts:
Tomnooktoldmeto · 17/12/2021 21:51

Essentially they’re all right from their own perspective, it’s normal for your age but if it’s impacting your life then listen to your physio

However, big shout out of agreement to @DonGray suggestion regarding B12 status (and folate as they need each other)

I’ve spent decades with physio’s and surgeons arguing over my various issues, suffered due to failed recognition of B12 deficiency and it’s role in my L4/5/S1 problems that my fantastic physio did pick up

If I had to believe only one I’d pick the physio every time

LittleGreyFluffyCat · 17/12/2021 21:42

To answer questions:

  • I've just turned 50
  • I'm in the South East so sadly not Scotland
  • By 'help' I mean get a diagnosis and treatment plan (and know what I should or shouldn't do to make it better)
  • Physio diagnosed hypermobility spectrum disorder, with minor nerve impingement in neck and other injuries in my right arm, suggested 6 weeks off work, prescription anti-inflammatories, then harder drugs - I don't believe this drug path will fix the problem.
  • GP disagrees with physio's diagnosis and doesn't recommend prescription anti-inflammatories.
  • GP can't help me any more - the only help available is a re-referral to this IPASS spinal service where you get seen by a physio - I already did that and they said 'muscle tension' (bollocks it is) - for a new referral I'd wait 12-18 months to get seen again.
  • Spinal consultant didn't recommend anything else, just 'go away this is nothing to do with me' but to be fair my symptoms have changed a lot since I saw him
  • Might have had B12 checked can't remember, will check

TBH it's hard to get all the details into this thread, it's been going on a while, and I'm just so fed up. I can't move my arms without it kicking off a load of arm pain and weird sensations up my neck and into my head.

I used Dr Google and found thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS), went to a specialist who said 'it's hard to diagnose it but you probably have it, I'll refer you to a specialist physio' - the specialist physio said I didn't have it but had spine impingement plus tennis elbow and shoulder tendon damage - GP said physio was wrong but that she can't help me anymore... I'm just kind of stuck now!

If I get a diagnosis privately that my GP will accept (so needs to be a consultant not a physio) then I can either get referred back into the NHS, or see if I can borrow some money to continue treatment privately - depending on what the diagnosis/treatment/outcomes etc are.

OP posts:
HollaHolla · 17/12/2021 21:18

@HopelesslydevotedtoGu

You probably need a specialist to look at your reports - not the GP, with all respect.

She already said that her Spinal Consultant has said the scan is essentially normal.

Whoops - apologies, I missed that they had also looked at it.
DonGray · 17/12/2021 21:18

So what do the GP & Spinal Consultant think is causing your problems and what is their suggested solution?

Have you had your B12 levels checked?

HopelesslydevotedtoGu · 17/12/2021 21:12

Really it depends what can be done about it all. If the Physio thinks the scan findings are the cause of your symptoms, what treatment do they think you could have? If physiotherapy can you continue with this anyway?

Presumably the Spinal Consultant thinks surgery and injections won't be helpful. Do they think you should have other investigation for these symptoms? Or that the scan is normal for your age, but the symptoms don't need further investigation?

I can't see the benefit of paying for a private appointment unless you can continue to be treated by that person.

Theunamedcat · 17/12/2021 21:12

So if the spinal consultant thinks it's normal them why are you having issues then

Elsiebear90 · 17/12/2021 21:09

You probably need a specialist to look at your reports - not the GP, with all respect.

The spinal consultant is the specialist.

HopelesslydevotedtoGu · 17/12/2021 21:06

You probably need a specialist to look at your reports - not the GP, with all respect.

She already said that her Spinal Consultant has said the scan is essentially normal.

jwpetal · 17/12/2021 21:05

If you are in pain then what matters is how they are going to deal with it. I had a scan after losing use of my arm. The mri specialist said nothing was wrong. The gp said well we know there is a problem because I couldn't move my arm. What are the differing solutions. Don't let them ignore the issue.

HollaHolla · 17/12/2021 21:00

@HollaHolla

Where in the UK are you? I can recommend a couple of excellent spinal neurosurgeons if you're in Scotland. I saw one NHS, and one privately.
I should say that both were extremely reluctant to slice and dice (even though we all know how much surgeons like to cut things! Grin ) They both only operated on me when it was absolutely necessary. I have had four surgeries on my lower (L4/L5 & L5/S1) spine, but I took the opinion of neurosurgeons, rather than orthopedics. You probably need a specialist to look at your reports - not the GP, with all respect.
Porfre · 17/12/2021 20:53

What sort of help do you mean?

I think the results could be a cause for your symptoms, but from the scan it doesnt sound severe enough for surgery

FelicityBeedle · 17/12/2021 20:51

Considering the dermatome pattern and it being C5 and 6 I would agree with your physios. But I am not qualified (did some of a physio degree though).

Elfonthesofa · 17/12/2021 20:51

My sister is a respitory physio and based on her anecdotal stories, I would trust the physio over the GP.

HollaHolla · 17/12/2021 20:47

Where in the UK are you? I can recommend a couple of excellent spinal neurosurgeons if you're in Scotland. I saw one NHS, and one privately.

Elsiebear90 · 17/12/2021 20:34

Sorry 40+ is normal

Elsiebear90 · 17/12/2021 20:34

Fiancée is a physiotherapist, she asked how old are you? If you are in your 20s-30s then it’s not normal, if you’re 40+ then it’s abnormal, but either way it would cause your symptoms. So I guess it’s a bit of both unless you’re very young.

LittleGreyFluffyCat · 17/12/2021 20:25

Italics fail sorry!

OP posts: