Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think bedroom furniture isn't really a gift for a 4 YO?

62 replies

IKnowAPlace · 17/12/2021 19:37

My cousin proudly told me that their DS4 is getting a new set of drawers for Christmas from them. They're basic IKEA drawers. He's getting these this weekend with a new duvet cover then a small token Santa gift on Christmas day.

They're relying on family and friends to buy many other gifts - we've been given lists (including being asked to provide "experiences" - I like this idea, but the available days mean it's basically to cover Christmas holidays). We have to drop gifts off so they're under the tree on Christmas morning which is causing a few people issues as they live quite far out of town.

Now, I'm not hugely into consumerism and seeing mountains of plastic toys piling up at Christmas but drawers seem like more of an essential home item than a gift. The parents both have good jobs and buy each other expensive gifts (£500+) so it's not that they're needing to combine an essential purchase with a Christmas gift.

Will he clock that it's an odd gift from parents at 4? Or will the other gifts from us mean he won't notice?

YBAU - he won't notice
YNBAU - it's a bit strange

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 18/12/2021 12:17

Why can’t people accept that not everyone is the same? Kids have different desires, families have different values or different experiences of what constitutes a gift.

From everything said so far it sounds like this is a child who is going to have plenty to wake up to on Christmas Day, they are not in any way deprived.

You don’t have to buy your own child a chest of drawers. Someone else wants to. All fine.

randomsabreuse · 18/12/2021 12:04

My 6 year old is very keen to get a BIG Kallax with mini shelves on the higher boxes so her little brother can't shred her favourite Lego creations but she can still look at them, so furniture could be a gift if they keep wanting independence and getting their own clothes!

IKnowAPlace · 18/12/2021 12:00

We only buy for the kids anyway - cousin's DS and my brother's two DDs. I've spent about £35 on books (mix of ones to keep and ones to read now) and will likely spend more than that making up our adventure day.

Maybe this is why I'm a bit Hmm at what seems like a stingy gift from them. They have at least four of us lined up to offer these "experience days" too (essentially free babysitting but I don't mind that as I love hanging out with him).

OP posts:
user1506328491 · 18/12/2021 11:07

The chest of drawers, or the bed, or whatever, would have had to be brought anyway so that makes it not a gift. If they want to dial back on gifts fine. But the furniture doesn't need to be packaged up as a gift.... somewhere to keep socks is not exactly thrilling!

witsendeverytime · 18/12/2021 10:30

They are essential items, not gifts. Unless I'm seeing a relative on or around Christmas Day I don't get anyone outside of my immediate family a gift. Otherwise where would it end?
They know it's a rubbish gift which is why they've done it the way they have. Frankly I'd just say you were on a low budget and have decided not to buy gifts for the wider family and are happy not to receive any too.

oviraptor21 · 18/12/2021 10:22

Sounds a great idea to me.
If the house is already going to be overrun with presents from wider family why add to the consumerism?
4 year olds don't need 1001 presents. Just a few we'll chosen ones and a chest of drawers to keep them in Grin

FreedomDrops · 18/12/2021 10:20

I agree with others that it seems impossible to persuade (some) relatives to tone down the deluge of crap that submerges many kids at Christmas. So the parents toning down theirs seems sensible.

yoyo1234 · 18/12/2021 10:14

Their child has a small room with limited storage,they may have felt uncomfortable asking relatives to curb present buying (young children can get huge piles of presents from relatives that clutter up the place). By restricting their present buying they may be making room for relatives presents.

Camomila · 18/12/2021 09:44

Our friends bought their sons a new bed for their birthdays

So did we, DS asked for a bunk bed for his 4th birthday but didn't get one as he was too young. He was very happy when he finally got it for his 5th birthday (It's actually a mid sleeper so a bit lower but he doesn't know the difference)

RedWingBoots · 18/12/2021 09:19

@Kendodd flat pack boxes aren't interesting as they are flat.

Now the box my DD drawers came in is interesting as she can stand in it.

The drawers are still not a present though.

IKnowAPlace · 17/12/2021 23:09

To be fair, I like that they tell me what he'd like/actually use. The drop off slot isn't a huge deal to me either, just to some other family. I also think some of them like to see him unwrap their gift Confused

OP posts:
AliceMcK · 17/12/2021 23:07

@IKnowAPlace

I realise this might sound a bit judgey - I suppose I just find it odd that we're expected to buy the good gifts (from the list). I'd want the parent points for getting a cool gift Grin

The drawers will be for clothes - bedroom is tiny so there are currently just under bed storage boxes and a container for toys.

Fair point that the whole experience of building the drawers this weekend will possibly be a fun thing in itself. Only a kid could enjoy flat pack!

It sounds like they are expecting wider friends & family to supply Christmas for their child.

I don’t have a problem with wider family buying gifts off the list, especially if we are struggling, but they give the presents themselves, they don’t go under the tree.

HamCob · 17/12/2021 23:00

I agree OP - furniture is a crap present for a young child. Our friends bought their sons a new bed for their birthdays. It's marginally more exciting than drawers I guess but still mean spirited in my opinion no matter how it's dressed up.

Fluffybeebee · 17/12/2021 22:56

I got an Ikea desk for Christmas when I was 12/13. This was my main and only present that year. I can't tell you how utterly gutted I was, I was desperately trying not to cry the whole Christmas period. I wanted a HiFi system. I don't think I have ever quite forgiven my parents but I have never told them how upset I was. No idea what possessed them!

marriedmadness · 17/12/2021 22:51

This is how they have money OP! Buying essentials and then letting everyone else do the hard work. They have a brass neck to boot, dictating what others should buy.

inappropriateraspberry · 17/12/2021 22:50

Just the drawers? Not redecorating the bedroom? A 4 year old would love a new room, but can't see them being excited over drawers in their own!

HappydaysArehere · 17/12/2021 22:45

Sounds like a cop out. Children remember Christmases. So I suppose he will reflect with delight on those chest of drawers and probably give his own children the same in future years.

Toplowlight · 17/12/2021 22:41

It’s a totally crap present but I doubt he will notice if there are other things for him to open. That said, his parents are CFs for being so prescriptive and demanding presents be under the tree etc.

MuchTooTired · 17/12/2021 22:34

I might have two weird nearly four year olds, but my DTs would love this as a present. A building project to complete with mama or dad one on one, something just for them that’s theirs that they can store their treasures in that the other can’t go in, and the big kids have one so they’re big kids too. If it came with a set of rainbow/mermaid tractor/digger stickers to decorate with their little minds would be blown with excitement.

If it was a Victorian chest of drawers like the ones I used to have I’d be chuffed if it were the main gift for me too Grin

On the face of it it seems a pretty naff gift, but I do genuinely think kids see things differently. I got mine big boy/girl beds for their birthday this year complete with bedding that they picked and they were thrilled - I literally couldn’t think of a single toy to get them that they’d play with and they needed new beds!

Icebreaker99 · 17/12/2021 22:32

YABU about the bedroom furniture, good for them getting his something useful and if he's getting all those other gifts from relatives he's hardly likely to feel hard down by.

YANBU about their instructions and demands on gifts for others.

I really, really hate this idea that kids have got to get some fuck-off huge main present from their parents, why?!?

Anotherlovelybitofsquirrel · 17/12/2021 22:31

I cannot abide when parents give basics such as that sort of thing as a gift. Like when people decorate their child's bedroom as a "gift" for their birthday. It's tight and selfish.

MissBPotter · 17/12/2021 22:26

There’s no way that this is reasonable if they’re well off and spending over £500 on each other AND being very grabby by forcing others to basically buy their kid toys. A malm is a very boring gift for anyone!

Bagadverts · 17/12/2021 22:24

Maybe he asked for it or helped pick it. As seen from another thread children ask for a range of querky or odd (to adults) things.

The only thing is inconveniencing others by asking for gifts to be delivered earlier if this will put people out either due to distance or wanting to see gifts being opened. If they want under tree presents as well maybe should buy. If they ask nicely and friends or relatives or happy what is the problem?

julieca · 17/12/2021 22:18

@Kendodd

I think plenty of four year olds would love that. Especially flat packed to build and coming in a big box.
I really doubt it.
shellylongbottom · 17/12/2021 22:17

@londonrach

Yabu. The nasty mn who said parents were tight no idea re real life. A new set of drawers is amazing gift. I'm tight, my dd getting second hand toys either free or £1 or £2 but gets gets food and love. She doesn't care and aged 5 asked for nothing from santa.

Good for you! I hate plastic waste and we mostly do second hand clothes and toys. Hate buying loads of gifts and then the old toys get pushed aside.

As you say, most important thing is love and lots of food! Kids can enjoy anything, they'll be happy with a bowl of soapy water, nevermind purpose built toys