Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there isn't a 'new' mental health crisis

32 replies

Builtthiscityonsausagerolls · 17/12/2021 19:31

Was thinking earlier about the reasons why so many people are struggling with their mental health now.

Then it got me remembering Sunday afternoons in the mid 80's with my grandmother, great gran and other matriarch of my family. The men would go to the pub, and the women would sit around putting the world yo rights, and (My great gran in particular Grin) discuss the health problems of every woman in a 5 mile radius. Phrases I remember
'She has such problems with her nerves' - anxiety
'How are you feeling in yourself?' - are you depressed?
'She has terrible baby blues' - post natal depression.

I also had an ancestor who shot himself after being demobbed after WW1. If you read any memoirs, or even contemporary literature eg Agatha Christie, there are so many casual references to what must have been nearly an entire generation of men affected by PTSD. Going back to my great gran you used to say the Great War 'knocked the stuffing' out of her dad.

You see lots of comments from the unsympathetic 'other generations just got on with it' to the sympathetic 'it's more endemic now

It just made me think. Is it? Or has it always been around we just framed/worded it differently?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Shiningpath · 18/12/2021 09:34

Other than increases obviously linked to widespread events like war, famine, etc. I think mental health problems are probably far more widespread and prevalent than in the past for a number of reasons:

People with problems live in the community instead of being shut away so issues are more visible. Less stigma means things are talked about more.

Society is more aspirational so more disappointment. I don’t look at a lion in the zoo and genuinely feel envy that he doesn’t have to go to work or pay bills. He’s a different species and different rules apply. I imagine in, say, the Victorian era society was so rigidly stratified that there was no chance of change from one level to the other or from a feminine role to a more masculine. A lot of people might have just not had aspirations (which is sad in itself) and therefore felt happier with their lot within quite tight parameters.

I saw something on Twitter that chimed with me the other day. Productivity is based on old white men’s standards from fifty years ago. I think this is particularly relevant to women. We’re expected to go to work and be as productive as men have ever been. The men of the 50s and 60s who set the standard for the modern world generally did no housework or child rearing. Yet we have to be as productive, as happy and worry free while we bear and raise children, run houses (whether shared or as is more likely, taking on the burden), have our bodies go through dramatic changes, care for relatives and all the while fit into masculine stereotypes at the same times as remaining stereotypically feminine and doing it all with a happy carefree smile society seems to want.

Sorry that was very long. It is a complex issue though.

Lockdownbear · 18/12/2021 09:19

I think there are different stresses.

Far more pressure on children to do well in exams than there was in the past. Uni was pipedream that even if kids could get the grades the families couldn't send them so it didn't actually matter.
There was still big competition for apprenticeships but work was available.

Even for women who lived through the war, raising children alone or lying in bed at night worrying will your son, husband, father come home must have been horrendous. I can see how that extended period of fear could cause long term damage.

I also think we see more MH issues with the Care in Community politics. I wonder how many big mental hospitals were full of people stressed out by the war?

LawnFever · 18/12/2021 08:59

‘Odd bod’ - not ‘nod’ although tbh what’s the difference?!

LawnFever · 18/12/2021 08:58

On the other side people were allowed to be quite eccentric without it being labelled. As long as they weren’t hurting anyone it was fine.

This is so true, my uncle clearly by todays medical knowledge had a level of autism which was never recognised or supported at any point in his life.

He worked and managed ok but was generally labelled a bit of an ‘odd nod’ because nobody knew how to deal with him, he was seen about town as generally eccentric.

My gran was never offered any support, none was available back then and she also had a husband with undiagnosed PTSD from WW2.

I often think how hard it must’ve been for her, but at the time there was nothing in terms of diagnosis or support.

Pinkypenguin · 18/12/2021 08:06

There was an awful lot of alcoholism in my parents' generation. I can remember them just downing whiskey like there was no tomorrow and not in a fun, enjoying themselves way. Several of them died of liver failure.

Both my parents were very angry people and my dad had nightmares from the war until the day he died.

I don't think not talking about their problems helped either of them.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 18/12/2021 08:00

Yes, people had ‘nervous breakdowns’ suffered from ‘nerves’ or if severe ‘went doolally’. The latter would involve ‘men in white coats’ and admission to the local mental hospital.

On the other side people were allowed to be quite eccentric without it being labelled. As long as they weren’t hurting anyone it was fine.

I think we gain and we lose. Drugs have upped the game though. The number of younger people who have mental health issues and have taken drugs is really high. Just say No.

Saltyquiche · 18/12/2021 08:00

Also there is quite a stark difference between traditional physical jobs like farm/mill/service work in the 1950s and the large number of seated/screen based roles today. Both have their issues, however physical work was probably therapeutic to some extent, while the internet has made the world complex with poor fitness levels and exposure to some very dark things

Saltyquiche · 18/12/2021 07:48

Society has consistently had people with good, bad and average mental health. However serious world events (pandemic and war) cause mental health to spiral in large numbers - with normally resilient people suffering beyond what is bearable normally.

HalfWomanHalfMincePie · 18/12/2021 07:43

Many people really struggled with their mental health, as happens today. The diary of Nella Last (Housewife, 49) illustrates this.

Most of us have family stories of generations gone that struggled with nerves and when you scratch the surface of those stories you find details of significant periods of poor mental health (eg described as a breakdown or similar).

ParsleySageRosemary · 18/12/2021 07:39

So many people are “struggling with their mental health” right now because it’s the modern trendy buzzword to describe what was called nerves or stress, depending on what time you’re looking at.

Also because we’re going backwards in terms of economy, society and womens rights, and people have every right to be concerned, worried and even angry about that. IMO “Mental health” is a middle class industry currently being pushed both to provide jobs that have otherwise vanished, and push the burden of socially-created issues back on to the individual, delegitimising them and preferably defusing it a little (but that’s secondary) in the process.

Seymour5 · 18/12/2021 07:18

The big rise in the number of single person households means more isolation. Growing up in the 50s/60s it was the norm for unmarried adult children to live at home and contribute to the household. We also had local family networks, much rarer these days.

DeepaBeesKit · 18/12/2021 07:13

Maybe the pressures change - permanent housewife vs working mother trying to juggle it all.

This one I always find odd though as the periods in history when working class women have been permanent housewives have been brief relative to those where they have had to work, even with younger children.

Ozgirl75 · 18/12/2021 06:59

I think behaviour that women just wouldnt put up with nowadays was quite normal back in the 1940s and 1950s, basically due to men suffering from things they’d seen in the war. This was then taken out on their children. My dad was regularly given the strap and cane at home and at school and he says they were all taught by masters who had been to war and were basically suffering from PTSD and stress which they would take out on the children.

LynetteScavo · 18/12/2021 06:54

I think there was a lot of mental health problems related to WW1 and WW2 which as a nation weren't acknowledged. We definitely acknowledge mental health more now, and there is much better meditation. In the '80's there was always some female neighbour or distant relative who "struggled with their nerves". The men seemed to smoke and drink and either stay very quite or be shouty. There did seem to be a lot more low level stress around, probably because it could be easily medicated.

DD has some issues that I recognise as mental health problems and have been proactive in seeking help for her. I had similar issues as a teen, and although my mother was aware, it was never discussed, and I don't think there was help in those day, even if my mother had tried to address my issues.

There have been good times and bad times throughout history, and I imagine during the bad times peoples mental health suffered. At the moment we're not having the best time, and we're aware enough of mental health to recognise more people than usual might be struggling.

notanothertakeaway · 18/12/2021 06:35

I think that SOMETIMES, stiff upper lip is a good approach ie accepting that sometimes, life doesn't go your way and it's best to roll up your sleeves and get on with it as best you can, rather than expecting a rosy, perfect, Instagram world

But now and in the past, many people gave struggled with mental health. It's not new

DeepaBeesKit · 18/12/2021 06:27

I think we also have different mental health triggers now.

My grandparents grew up in unspeakably abject poverty relative today but had found memories of happy childhood. Social media didnt exist and the whole community was in the same situation, everyone pitched in together and there was no shame around things like periods of unemployment, struggling with the rent etc.

I think social media today contributes to massive issues around anxiety and self worth.

Also I think as a society we don't handle bereavement well now. We have this expectation everyone will live forever and don't cope well when they don't.

Builtthiscityonsausagerolls · 17/12/2021 23:25

Just a wee bump as found the responses really interesting

OP posts:
MissAmbrosia · 17/12/2021 20:29

I do wonder sometimes that due to more access to media, be it TV or SM etc that there is an expectation that we should all be happy all the time. That life is somehow better than it was before and we should all be grateful that our kids don't die in early childhood and we have a washing machine etc. Whereas, for most people life IS hard.

Maybe the pressures change - permanent housewife vs working mother trying to juggle it all. Man who can provide for his family vs zero hours contract and has to do more at home so wife can work etc. It's very, very hard to get that balance right so all our needs are met and yet the pressure from outside is that everything is supposed to be wonderful.

Something like Covid comes along and completely smashes everything up.

Builtthiscityonsausagerolls · 17/12/2021 20:10

In answer to a few comments
I definitely think social isolation is a big factor today. I can't think of any 'group' I'm in that is the equivalent to those Sunday afternoons of a room full of women freeing themselves up to talk about 'women's problems' (including the nerves, baby blues etc)
As for today, I think the stigma is removed (fantastic) but the health service hasn't caught up with changing attitudes.
The combination of people feeling free to ask for help, plus the lack of community support (this more for women) has just left the NHS playing catch up.

OP posts:
Builtthiscityonsausagerolls · 17/12/2021 20:04

@MissAmbrosia

My nan was a nurse and when I was growing up (we lived with her) she was often called to various neighbours for emergencies of an evening- drink/overdoses/domestic violence/complete meltdown scenarios. It didn't mean that much to me back then but as an adult I can join the dots. And there was less help available generally. Probably you got a prescription for sleeping pills or valium and were left to get on with it. Sad
That's Interesting. There are a few bits in Call the Midwife (the books not the TV show) which casually reference mental health problems that I think would have been a much larger part of the 'story' if they'd have been written today
OP posts:
JayAlfredPrufrock · 17/12/2021 20:03

I agree. But social media makes it appear much more prevalent. And more time for navel gazing.

Pigeoninthehouse · 17/12/2021 20:01

I think mental illness has always been around, just think nowadays we lack the community support that our grandparents and my parents generation had.
PTSD and other extreme trauma aside, people can cope with lots of stuff when they have human support. It's the social isolation caused by the way we live today that causes the problems.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 17/12/2021 20:01

I think it’s always been there but there was a lot less understanding and very little help. There was no choice for many but to support affected family members as best they could (and have to suffer the side effects, like domestic violence and alcoholism themselves). And for those affected they just lived miserable lives.

Like PPs, this is why the idea of the stiff upper lip and the current “I don’t know why you’re feeling traumatised over Covid; people were fine during the War!” makes me very angry. People were broken, it was just that there was no help but there was stigma, so they were left to suffer.

XenoBitch · 17/12/2021 20:01

YANBU
Nowadays we have better understanding of MH conditions and ways to treat them. It gets spoken about more.
Years ago, no one spoke about it, and a lot of people with MH spent their lives in asylums.... so out of sight, out of mind. I have a great grandparent who died in one... his death certificate cites cause of death as "insanity".
It wasn't until my own MH struggles came to a head, that I found out how many members of my family also had varying degrees of poor mental health. I found out my gran didn't leave her house for 3 years due to agoraphobia. I had no idea.
Saying that, there is a huge mental health crisis now due to Covid/restrictions. My local crisis team have four times the amount of people on their caseload than pre-pandemic times.

MissAmbrosia · 17/12/2021 19:53

My nan was a nurse and when I was growing up (we lived with her) she was often called to various neighbours for emergencies of an evening- drink/overdoses/domestic violence/complete meltdown scenarios. It didn't mean that much to me back then but as an adult I can join the dots. And there was less help available generally. Probably you got a prescription for sleeping pills or valium and were left to get on with it. Sad