Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to not want non-family to give my kid presents?

214 replies

MamaKatja · 17/12/2021 18:33

A bit of a reality check, please.

We are trying not to spoil our 4yo DD (ahem, at least not too much), including at Christmas. I just don't like kids on a ripping-open-presents frenzy, without really being able to enjoy even one because of the sheer abundance. Our DD has also become increasingly picky, throwing little surprises from her advent calendar (lovingly, or so I thought, compiled by me) at me whenever she didn't like them.

Now, we have a rule that family are allowed to give her one Christmas present each, as are my DH and I together. Plus one from Santa, and that's supposed to be it. I negotiated a truce with her godfather, but now non-family members are piling in, including the neighbours, our nanny, a new schoolfriend's mum, and others. The result? Nine presents already!

AIBU to think that non-family should butt out?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nowhereelsetogo90 · 19/12/2021 23:28

Oh FFS. Let her enjoy her gifts!

Comingup · 19/12/2021 22:25

What an absolute fun sponge and lousy attitude.

" butt out" ?? Are you for real or just wanted a goady thread.

The look of joy and wonder on my kids faces waking up to a huge pile of presents once a year is a memory I always treasure.

Why blame the gift givers for your DD tantrums about the advent? That's your parenting to blame, not their generosity.

Hankunamatata · 19/12/2021 22:24

Buy her a boring chocolate advent calendar next year.

surreygirl1987 · 19/12/2021 21:29

@stupiduser that's lovely!

WhatIsThisPlease · 19/12/2021 21:29

YABU.

You can't spoil a child in one day. Let the people who love your DD buy her a present and teach your DD how to be grateful.

stupiduser · 19/12/2021 21:05

It's so much more important to teach her to receive gifts graciously rather than control the gifts she is given. My daughter was once given a present that was meant for the rabbit, it was a banana and she said thank you very much and acted really pleased until we realised what had happened (yes it's weird to wrap the rabbits presents I know)

StonewalledNameChange · 19/12/2021 18:39

[quote MarieChristmas]@00100001 sorry, not clear. We did a surprise for the family, packaged in a stocking and left it by their front door. It contained a board game, a book for the child, a couple of camping bits and some sweets. We thought it was a fun thing to do from our family to theirs (our kids were also involved) but it was not appreciated.

Lesson learnt. [/quote]
This seems such a thoughtful and kind gesture and I'm struggling to imagine being anything other than touched and grateful. Confused I'm sorry it was thrown back in your face like that.

thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2021 18:23

I think this is utterly weird, controlling and puritanical tbh.

As others have said, you have no right to impose that kind of thing on others. Generosity and affection should be freely given and your child's behavioural issues are no reason to restrict other people's right to give them presents.

MarieChristmas · 19/12/2021 17:53

@00100001

Unless it encroached on their Christmas Eve box or whatever?
Similar to the OP. They said that they didn't want their 3 year old to think that Christmas was about 'things'. Apparently they had even asked family not to send anything. We didn't know this, and just thought given COVID Christmas and none of us being able to be with our families, we would spread a little Christmas cheer and leave a surprise.

If I am honest, their reaction did upset me. We choose the gifts carefully to make sure it wasn't plastic tat. I wouldn't have minded if they rehomed or regifted as the pleasure for us as a family was in the preparation and the giving. (They probably have).

But their reaction did hurt. And so... we learnt a lesson. We don't do any surprises.

LittleRoundRobin · 19/12/2021 17:32

Hmm I bet you are DYING to tell her Santa isn't real too? Hmm

bakebeans · 19/12/2021 17:30

YaBU. People like to give gifts. Rather than tell people they shouldn’t buy presents. May be you should turn it into a positive learning experience for your DD. You could show her she needs to be grateful and explain to her how lucky she has received so many presents as others may not be as fortunate

mumda · 19/12/2021 16:43

Suggest a price limit and or gift ideas (too late for this year).

Mammyloveswine · 19/12/2021 16:19

My two do get spoilt but they are super grateful for the tiniest things! I am always so proud of how gracious both are!

We always encourage them to thankful, if ever they were so rude to throw a gift they've received they would have all other gifts removed and a talking to!

They are 3 and 5 (almost 4 and 6).

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 19/12/2021 15:11

My kid gets fuck all because all my family is either dead or doesn't speak to us.

Get a grip.

Chely · 19/12/2021 15:04

Give your head a shake.
Let them spoil your child as much as they want to, not going to ruin them getting a few things on Christmas.

00100001 · 19/12/2021 14:59

Unless it encroached on their Christmas Eve box or whatever?

00100001 · 19/12/2021 14:58

[quote MarieChristmas]@00100001 sorry, not clear. We did a surprise for the family, packaged in a stocking and left it by their front door. It contained a board game, a book for the child, a couple of camping bits and some sweets. We thought it was a fun thing to do from our family to theirs (our kids were also involved) but it was not appreciated.

Lesson learnt. [/quote]
What were they upset about?Confused

Yuledo · 19/12/2021 14:55

Christmas is the time for spoiling and the sheer joy and wonderment of seeing a large pile.

Birthdays were much less of a deal, with a much smaller volume of presents, and we didn’t buy presents in between. They had the anticipation of having to wait for birthdays and Xmas for things they wanted.

GreenWheat · 19/12/2021 14:54

Good grief. In my experience people being controlling around their pfb like this are usually trying to control others in lieu of having to parent and teach responses.

Tink626 · 19/12/2021 14:45

YABVU I would love my DS to be lucky enough to have presents from people other than me at Christmas.

You can't dictate to people that they can't give presents to your child. It's nasty and controlling and your child won't thank you for it when they are older.

MarieChristmas · 19/12/2021 14:28

@00100001 sorry, not clear. We did a surprise for the family, packaged in a stocking and left it by their front door. It contained a board game, a book for the child, a couple of camping bits and some sweets. We thought it was a fun thing to do from our family to theirs (our kids were also involved) but it was not appreciated.

Lesson learnt.

blubberyboo · 19/12/2021 14:13

You’re a bit controlling.

Your daughter is a separate person from you and if someone wants to give her a gift it really isn’t your place to refuse it unless it is a dangerous gift.

balboacoffee · 19/12/2021 14:10

It's one day a year Jesus! I wouldn't spread them out either. Let her open them on Christmas morning and have a bit of magic in her life for one day! 9 presents isn't a lot. Do things In the year like sorting her old toys/ clothes out and give them to charity for example. I get my daughter what she asks for and a couple more. I don't get the whole one present and a stocking thing. Me and my daughter always have a big sort out before Christmas and we pass anything she doesn't need to the local nurseries or to relatives and charity. Kids can have what they want and don't act spoilt. Regarding the throwing of the advent sit her down and tell her she can't do that and if she does it again she won't be opening another one.

lollipoprainbow · 19/12/2021 14:09

I'd love non family to give my dd presents ! Our family is tiny so I overcompensate and buy lots for her. Not really a massive problem is it ??

00100001 · 19/12/2021 14:02

@MarieChristmas

We left our friends and their 3 yo a Christmas stocking surprise last year.

This year I was told that I had upset them and that they didn't want a repeat.

Their right of course but it certainly put a dampener on my feelings towards them.

Your DD is a small child. She won't turn into a brat if someone gives her a gift.

I agree with PP. YABU

You got a child a surprise Christmas stocking? Confused