Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Confused by the ‘great fathers’

203 replies

Electricbug321 · 17/12/2021 15:00

AIBU to be confused and frustrated that describe their DP as a great/brilliant/fantastic father in their OP, but then describe behaviour that is anything but good parenting. At best the men in those posts are only doing the fun stuff or are ‘hands on’ but only around for a few minutes a day.

Is the bar really so low for men?

OP posts:
LittleRoundRobin · 17/12/2021 18:14

@ChristmasRobins

Just strikes me that if someone suggested that a woman was a crap mum just because she wasn't a very good cook, we'd all be outraged. Maybe I'm taking the OP too literally.
Yeah I found that 'if he cares about and loves his children he'll learn to cook properly' comment a bit bizarre too. Confused

So if a man loves his children, nurtures them, gets them to bed on time, (teeth cleaned, clothes clean and dry,) gets them to school on time, reads their school books, takes them on holiday, attends all the sports days and school shows, and financially provides for them, but isn't much of a cook, he is a shit dad? Confused Come off it! Hmm

It's not necessary to be Jamie Oliver or Delia fucking Smith to be a good parent. Hmm

Daft!

RedWingBoots · 17/12/2021 18:14

@Fairyliz

I don’t disagree with you op but where exactly do you find a decent man? It’s not for me but for my daughters in their 20’s. They and all of their friends are lovely young woman but not one of them can find a good man. Young men nowadays are interested in a relationship only a shag. It’s fine now, but what do they do in ten years time when approaching 40 and desperate for a child? I can see see them putting up with one of these men child.
They are there.

They simply need to widen their net and not discount a guy due to the job he does.

WorraLiberty · 17/12/2021 18:12

@HaaaaaveyoumetTed

If he cares about his kids and their health, he'll learn to cook properly.

Things on toast with a side of veg is a nutritionally balanced meal - protein, fat, carbs, vitamins and minerals.

Better than the time he made cauliflower cheese with rosemary leaves in it.

Things on toast with a side of veg is a nutritionally balanced meal - protein, fat, carbs, vitamins and minerals.

Does he feed himself and the kids that everyday then?

Or does he have someone willing to believe he's not a lazy shit, so cooks his meals for him?

Goldbar · 17/12/2021 18:11

There's a difference between not being a great cook and not cooking.

I am not a great cook but I cook (despite hating it). And not just beige food because children need exposure to a variety of different foods.

I would like to say that is part of being a parent, but actually cooking seems optional for many men - they either don't cook at all, take kids out to McDs once a week or stick on the fish fingers. And they can still be 'great dads'.

WorraLiberty · 17/12/2021 18:09

@ChristmasRobins

Just strikes me that if someone suggested that a woman was a crap mum just because she wasn't a very good cook, we'd all be outraged. Maybe I'm taking the OP too literally.
It's not about 'not being very good at it'.

It's about pretending you can't do it because you can't be arsed to learn and of course some women finding it cute or hilarious Hmm

MunchyCrunchyy · 17/12/2021 18:08

@RampantIvy

I sometimes wonder if they have never been in a functional and equal relationship, or have had no role models in their lives that demonstrate how a relationship should be.

I feel especially sad for the women in abusive relationships with alcoholics or people with other addictions. There are far too many threads on here just now in this vein.

I can speak from experience and say no, I’m falling exactly into the same life my mum has lived. It’s such a shame and I wish certain behaviours/attitudes hadn’t been normalised for me
ChristmasRobins · 17/12/2021 18:07

@TheCloudBotherer If only that were true.

HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 17/12/2021 18:07

If he cares about his kids and their health, he'll learn to cook properly.

Things on toast with a side of veg is a nutritionally balanced meal - protein, fat, carbs, vitamins and minerals.

Better than the time he made cauliflower cheese with rosemary leaves in it.

Comedycook · 17/12/2021 18:05

@HaaaaaveyoumetTed

The cooking thing I get. DH is a shit cook, prior to us getting together he existed on ready meals, biscuits and things on toast and 3 times a week, the kids get fed 'things on toast' or very occasionally pasta and pesto. If I died, DH would likely feed the kids stuff on toast and a side of veg everyday. But they'd be in bed on time, teeth cleaned, clothes clean and dry, in school on time, read their school books, taken on holiday, and financially provided for. He'd keep the cleaner though.
I understand. Dh is also a shit cook...he lived alone for twenty years before he met me. He didn't starve but he ate frozen beige food! If I'm out, the kids get fed... mainly beige food but he'll boil some veg to go with it! If I died, they'd all probably all survive on nuggets, chips and peas!
ChristmasRobins · 17/12/2021 18:04

Just strikes me that if someone suggested that a woman was a crap mum just because she wasn't a very good cook, we'd all be outraged. Maybe I'm taking the OP too literally.

Goldbar · 17/12/2021 18:04

If I didn't have to cook and do the basic stuff which keeps us alive and healthy, I would have more time to develop a 'real connection' with my DC. I'm jaundiced but I'm afraid I don't view waltzing in to do the fun stuff like playing games and park trips as being a great parent if a parent can't also do their share of the basic graft.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 17/12/2021 18:01

@Fairyliz

I don’t disagree with you op but where exactly do you find a decent man? It’s not for me but for my daughters in their 20’s. They and all of their friends are lovely young woman but not one of them can find a good man. Young men nowadays are interested in a relationship only a shag. It’s fine now, but what do they do in ten years time when approaching 40 and desperate for a child? I can see see them putting up with one of these men child.
You bring them up to have the confidence to throw the rubbish ones back and model good relationships to them growing up so they know a good one when they come across one.

My DD is 29 and has a wonderful partner but she had a few duds along the way. I was always impressed at her ability to disengage from them and move on. I'm not sure I'd have had that confidence in my 20s. She told me once that when she was feeling unhappy and her boyfriend was making out that it was her with the problem, she'd ask herself what would her (step)dad do in that situation, and then she'd dump them. It really brought it home to me how important it is for us to set the bench mark our daughter's measure their relationships against.

TheCloudBotherer · 17/12/2021 17:59

@ChristmasRobins

I see the key to being a good parent as having (or at least working towards) a real connection with one's kids, taking time with them and treating them with loving kindness and compassion. Couldn't give a damn about whether someone can cook or whatever. I don't think that's a low bar- it's a very high bar.
It's a "very high bar" which the majority of women seem to be able to reach. Because it's not a high bar at all. Treating anyone with kindness and compassion is pretty basic. If someone can't manage it with their own children, then they aren't failing to reach an unreasonably high bar. They're just crap parents.
WorraLiberty · 17/12/2021 17:59

@ChristmasRobins

I see the key to being a good parent as having (or at least working towards) a real connection with one's kids, taking time with them and treating them with loving kindness and compassion. Couldn't give a damn about whether someone can cook or whatever. I don't think that's a low bar- it's a very high bar.
Treating them with loving kindness involves looking after their health and feeding them properly.

It's a basic life skill to pass on anyway if a parent can be arsed.

Goldbar · 17/12/2021 17:58

The threshold for 'great father' often seems to be several rungs below the level at which a mother would have social services intervening.

In many cases, it doesn't seem to require making a material contribution towards meeting children's basic physical, emotional and material needs.

ChrimboGateauxCatto · 17/12/2021 17:57

I think that some women forget that a huge part of teaching the next generation by modelling healthy relationships. Treating women with respect. Not being sexist. Etc. And yes the bar is that low.

minipie · 17/12/2021 17:55

I often remark that I'm not a brilliant mother but I'd make a fucking fantastic father.

I love this and am stealing it Grin

ChristmasRobins · 17/12/2021 17:52

@NellieBertram Yes, of course.

WorraLiberty · 17/12/2021 17:52

@HaaaaaveyoumetTed

The cooking thing I get. DH is a shit cook, prior to us getting together he existed on ready meals, biscuits and things on toast and 3 times a week, the kids get fed 'things on toast' or very occasionally pasta and pesto. If I died, DH would likely feed the kids stuff on toast and a side of veg everyday. But they'd be in bed on time, teeth cleaned, clothes clean and dry, in school on time, read their school books, taken on holiday, and financially provided for. He'd keep the cleaner though.
Nah I'm not buying that.

If he cares about his kids and their health, he'll learn to cook properly.

We have the internet now to teach us how, there is literally no excuse not to learn.

NellieBertram · 17/12/2021 17:49

@ChristmasRobins

I see the key to being a good parent as having (or at least working towards) a real connection with one's kids, taking time with them and treating them with loving kindness and compassion. Couldn't give a damn about whether someone can cook or whatever. I don't think that's a low bar- it's a very high bar.
"Loving kindness" also means healthy food, bedtime routines, regular bath, nappy changes, clean suitable clothes, safe home, supporting education. A mum who never did any housework, left kids in wet nappies in front of the TV all the time and didn't know the names of their teachers would not be a good parent, however much time she spent making a connection.
ChristmasRobins · 17/12/2021 17:42

I see the key to being a good parent as having (or at least working towards) a real connection with one's kids, taking time with them and treating them with loving kindness and compassion. Couldn't give a damn about whether someone can cook or whatever. I don't think that's a low bar- it's a very high bar.

GrealishHairband · 17/12/2021 17:37

I lucked out in the DH stakes. We had DD on the way 3 months after first getting together. He could have turned out to be a right knacker. I said from the off I’m not doing this on my own, if you’re in, you’re all in, he was still more than young enough to mould into shape and right from the start it’s been 50-50. If I’m honest, as I’m a former shift worker it’s probably been more 60-40 in his favour as he had to get used to cooking for the kids, doing the bedtimes, entertaining them all day while I slept. I then took a job where I worked away, for days on end, he had to learn their routines, get them to their various clubs and make sure they had money for non uniform days. I didn’t do it, so he had to. I suspect there were a few days where they all had beans on toast twice a day or a few too many McDonald’s in a week, or school uniforms weren’t ironed or homework didn’t get done, but he learned quickly, the way I would have had to and now it’s widely acknowledged that he is the better parent Wink

It’s great, I get to lie in all weekend and devote time to my hobbies. Kidding. But in the household we are equals, he wrapped half the Christmas presents the other day for the kids as he knew they needed doing and I was out with both of them and he was in the house on his own, that’s the sign of a good partner/father, sees what’s needs doing and just gets in with it, no drama, no desperate need for accolades.

HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 17/12/2021 17:30

The cooking thing I get. DH is a shit cook, prior to us getting together he existed on ready meals, biscuits and things on toast and 3 times a week, the kids get fed 'things on toast' or very occasionally pasta and pesto. If I died, DH would likely feed the kids stuff on toast and a side of veg everyday. But they'd be in bed on time, teeth cleaned, clothes clean and dry, in school on time, read their school books, taken on holiday, and financially provided for. He'd keep the cleaner though.

Fairyliz · 17/12/2021 17:29

I don’t disagree with you op but where exactly do you find a decent man?
It’s not for me but for my daughters in their 20’s. They and all of their friends are lovely young woman but not one of them can find a good man. Young men nowadays are interested in a relationship only a shag.
It’s fine now, but what do they do in ten years time when approaching 40 and desperate for a child?
I can see see them putting up with one of these men child.

GarlandsinGreece · 17/12/2021 17:22

I have been lucky enough to have both a fantastic father and husband. My dad was always making us forts, or taking us on long bike rides. He is fastidious about cleaning and did all the cooking growing up. He worked odd shift patterns, too, but never let it get in the way of spending time with his children.

My husband has a hugely successful career, yet makes breakfast for all, takes out the bins, empties the dishwasher, feeds our dogs, while I go to the gym at 6am. He does this three times a week. He often offers to make dinner, as he loves to cook. While we have a weekly cleaner, he likes to tidy and never, ever makes a mess.

I honestly couldn’t imagine being with anyone who did less than this. Even my ex-boyfriend, who has his many faults, was a keen cook and kept the house really clean.

Swipe left for the next trending thread