Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think periods are a terrible design flaw in the human race

207 replies

CrumpledCrumpet · 17/12/2021 14:28

Humans are quite remarkably cleverly designed creatures. Binocular vision, opposable thumbs, walking upright - we’ve got it all going on. But honestly, who came up with periods?

AIBU to think this is a massive design fault and someone needs to go back to the drawing board and come up with something better?

OP posts:
Maireas · 17/12/2021 16:14

I wonder why so many of us need glasses/contacts.
Is it just because of modern life, reading etc?

Maireas · 17/12/2021 16:13

@Tinselscarf

Not every female was constantly pregnant or breastfeeding - miscarriages, widowhood, men off to war, etc. I have read that many ancient societies were more supportive of menstruating women.

You're not going back far enough - evolution works over much longer timescales except when there's really strong selection, and whilst periods are bloody annoying, having them isn't going to kill you before you can reproduce. So we have to look back as far as mammals ancestors. (And anyway, much of human history involved women being pregnant or breastfeeding most of their adult lives even up to Victorian times, and still in some parts of the world today.)

I know what you mean about very ancient history, but I've heard it before applied to more modern times, and I always think - every woman, all the time? Cleopatra, Elizabeth I, the wives of Henry VIII... anyway, it's a flawed system!
Dreamstate · 17/12/2021 16:05

I agree. I've been on the pill for years and there hasn't been one single moment I've ever thought I miss my period!

Tinselscarf · 17/12/2021 16:05

Also think we should consider that chickens get egg bound, before converting to any other methods.

Tinselscarf · 17/12/2021 16:04

*Our fallopian tubes are open at both ends, causing a backwash effect of blood into the abdominal cavity during menstruation. Our immune systems are supposed to clean up the resulting mess, but in some unlucky individuals (i.e me) this process partly or wholly fails, leaving old blood behind which not only causes scarring but deposits womb cells where they should not be, which in turn causes further bleeding each month, more scarring, dreadful pain, and strangest of all, can severely impact on fertility

Intelligent design, my fucking arse!*

But an argument for evolution on the other hand. Those whose bodies can't deal with this design flaw have fertility issues and therefore any genes involved in this don't get passed on. Until you start adding in medical treatments and IVF of course...

(I am not anti medicine btw, far from it, I just find it interesting how our attempts to cure some issues cause spillover issues down the line.)

Ohshitiveturnedintomymother · 17/12/2021 16:00

@CrumpledCrumpet

I mean if it’s strictly necessary that we need to shed our womb linings once a month (and as I don’t need to regularly shed any other part of my internal anatomy, I dispute this), could it at least be bundled up into a neat package like an owl pellet that we could just shoot out of our vaginas and then be done with it?
Could we shoot it out with force? Rather like a ping pong show? Wink Blush

I love this idea! Somebody get the scientists working on it stat

ErrolTheDragon · 17/12/2021 16:00

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

To be fair, teeth would be totally fine if we didn’t eat sugar
Lots of ancient skeletons have very worn down teeth. That was down to too much stoneground flour.
Cailleach · 17/12/2021 15:59

Our fallopian tubes are open at both ends, causing a backwash effect of blood into the abdominal cavity during menstruation. Our immune systems are supposed to clean up the resulting mess, but in some unlucky individuals (i.e me) this process partly or wholly fails, leaving old blood behind which not only causes scarring but deposits womb cells where they should not be, which in turn causes further bleeding each month, more scarring, dreadful pain, and strangest of all, can severely impact on fertility

Intelligent design, my fucking arse!

Chakraleaf · 17/12/2021 15:58

I quite like the cyclic rhythm of periods

MissConductUS · 17/12/2021 15:55

There are many problems with the current model, to be honest.

The Most Unfortunate Design Flaws in the Human Body

Elfonthesofa · 17/12/2021 15:54

@Magik01

While we are at it, two sets of teeth, one set lasts 10 years tops, the other is meant to last the rest of your life. What’s up with that?
It made more sense when the average life expectancy was 30.
Tinselscarf · 17/12/2021 15:50

Not every female was constantly pregnant or breastfeeding - miscarriages, widowhood, men off to war, etc. I have read that many ancient societies were more supportive of menstruating women.

You're not going back far enough - evolution works over much longer timescales except when there's really strong selection, and whilst periods are bloody annoying, having them isn't going to kill you before you can reproduce. So we have to look back as far as mammals ancestors. (And anyway, much of human history involved women being pregnant or breastfeeding most of their adult lives even up to Victorian times, and still in some parts of the world today.)

penniesdimesapplespears · 17/12/2021 15:48

I've never had major period problems thankfully so I find periods to be a mild inconvenience. I just put up with it for a few days each month. After all these years it really doesn't bother me anymore.

If I had a serious medical issue like endometriosis/ infertility etc I'm sure my views would be different.

eastegg · 17/12/2021 15:45

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

To be fair, teeth would be totally fine if we didn’t eat sugar
This isn’t true. I’ve had a year of awful trouble with my teeth which hasn’t been to do with sugar. A mixture of grinding at night/heredity and bad luck it seems. They do just go wrong sometimes!
Tinselscarf · 17/12/2021 15:45

An a former evolutionary biologist, I think much of the problem is that we've evolved in some ways but other things haven't caught up.

By moving to two legs rather than four, we've changed the pelvic capacity, whilst we've selected for larger headed babies that stay in the womb longer. This ends up leading to difficult births. The situation will only get worse as in the past the offspring wouldn't have survived to be able to give birth with their narrow hips and large heads themselves, but because of c-sections, we're perpetuating the problem. Bipedalism is probably related to a lot of back issues too.

We're also supposed to be pregnant throughout our fertile years, and then die pretty young. If you're pregnant you don't typically have to worry about periods, although admittedly the pregnancy and birth isn't much fun either.

We should probably die about when we reach the menopause, so that wouldn't have been a big issue.

I blame modern medicine.

FortVictoria · 17/12/2021 15:42

@Classica

Laying an egg sounds great. But would it involve a lot of huffing and puffing about in a toilet? Or would it be like passing a sturdy poo?

I'm not sure I'd like to get caught out and have to lay my egg at work or in a pub toilet.

This is absolutely brilliant and has made me laugh out loud. “Sturdy poo” - utterly fab description!
DivanInspiration · 17/12/2021 15:37

It is annoying to think that if I don’t have children I’ll have bled every month for no reason at all for 30-40 years.

I think if periods were properly researched and all women got the help they need we’d find them a lot easier. But they’re still not ideal.

Magik01 · 17/12/2021 15:36

While we are at it, two sets of teeth, one set lasts 10 years tops, the other is meant to last the rest of your life. What’s up with that?

IntermittentParps · 17/12/2021 15:28

TBF, walking upright has its downsides. Just ask my upper back, lower back and knees.

Classica · 17/12/2021 15:16

Laying an egg sounds great. But would it involve a lot of huffing and puffing about in a toilet? Or would it be like passing a sturdy poo?

I'm not sure I'd like to get caught out and have to lay my egg at work or in a pub toilet.

HalfWomanHalfMincePie · 17/12/2021 15:16

I always think they are a bit funny!

Like, nature has this problem in which a womb lining is no longer needed.

Solution: Put a hole in the bottom and just let it drop out Grin

Maireas · 17/12/2021 15:13

@musicalfrog

But in prehistory women wouldn't have had periods. They would have been constantly pregnant or breastfeeding from the time they reached puberty until their death/menopause. A bit like other mammals which basically breed constantly.
I've heard this argument before, but surely it wasn't constant? Not every female was constantly pregnant or breastfeeding - miscarriages, widowhood, men off to war, etc. I have read that many ancient societies were more supportive of menstruating women.
CPL593H · 17/12/2021 15:12

YANBU. An approx 40 year source of monthly misery and expense.

Loving the egg idea though. Think of all opportunities for people to put hatching photoshoots on Insta. On second thoughts... Grin

CrumpledCrumpet · 17/12/2021 15:12

@musicalfrog

But in prehistory women wouldn't have had periods. They would have been constantly pregnant or breastfeeding from the time they reached puberty until their death/menopause. A bit like other mammals which basically breed constantly.
Yes I assume this is why there isn’t a great degree of evolutionary pressure to sort this nonsense out - the most ‘successful’ females are constantly pregnant or lactating.

The ones who aren’t can get taken out by predators.

OP posts:
Nutrigrainygoodness · 17/12/2021 15:11

I'd be more than happy with a text once a month instead of an actual period it could say. 'Period here, have some chocolate, see you next month'
Or
'Due to pregnancy, this text service will be put on hold'