Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think periods are a terrible design flaw in the human race

207 replies

CrumpledCrumpet · 17/12/2021 14:28

Humans are quite remarkably cleverly designed creatures. Binocular vision, opposable thumbs, walking upright - we’ve got it all going on. But honestly, who came up with periods?

AIBU to think this is a massive design fault and someone needs to go back to the drawing board and come up with something better?

OP posts:
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/12/2021 19:14

I suspect that living in unventilated, crowded rooms also meant that disease got a hold very easily; that would have applied less to the wealthy in the Middle Ages just as in the nineteenth century, but probably more in towns after the Industrial Revolution, and in earlier times when whole families lived in a one-roomed cottage in the countryside. And hospitals probably didn't help much before they had worked out about and then come to believe in germs, given that many doctors would go from one patient to another without washing at all.

And then there is all the difficulty about sewerage... A lot of disease comes from contaminated water.

Add in deaths in childbed and infancy and it's amazing the species survived, really.

stingofthebutterfly · 17/12/2021 19:11

I'm surprised nobody has claimed it's because God is a misogynistic bastard yet.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 17/12/2021 18:43

Yes it's quite astonishing how long some people lived without the benefit of modern medicine - Elizabeth I being one of them. We are frightened of bacterial infections these days, but they obviously didn't kill that many people before antibiotics, although were probably a major cause of death in/around childbirth.

ElftonWednesday · 17/12/2021 18:42

But an argument for evolution on the other hand. Those whose bodies can't deal with this design flaw have fertility issues and therefore any genes involved in this don't get passed on. Until you start adding in medical treatments and IVF of course...

Another design flaw then as I only developed endometrosis symptoms several years after having two DDs, without any fertility issues or complications.

scottishnames · 17/12/2021 18:40

Howdareyou I agree re Margaret Beaufort, and indeed other young husbands/brides. The Church taught that 'continence' (respectful self control) was pretty important. But once royal and aristocratic women did start to have sex, if they did not die or were phyiscally damaged pretty quickly, the stats do say that wet-nursing made things pretty horrendous. Just to take one well-documented example, Elizabeth Woodville, wife of Edward IV, bore 10 children in less than 20 years.

But you are right about life expectancy figures. From the middle ages onwards - prehistoric might have been different - once someone had survived childhood and the teenage years, they had a pretty good chance of living to 50-60, especially if they were a man. The highest death rates were the under 5s (beacuse of infectious disease) , and then in the under 15s (accidents/childhood illnesses). Childbirth and pregnancy seem to have been the most common causes of death among women of childbearing years.

Mufasa1118 · 17/12/2021 18:39

We have been taught by recent society to see menstruation as a negative thing.

It is actually a very powerful thing. It is an indicator of good health. It is a good, important thing.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 17/12/2021 18:38

@JCWildWest

Also echo other posts on mortality of childbirth. I'd of defo died having my DD and her too if it wasn't for modern medicine. It's like we aren't designed to reproduce very effectively
I don't know if I would have done but I might well have had a nasty infection which could have carried me off. I had antibiotics in labour because my waters had broken too early. I didn't need a blood transfusion or anything though. However, I only had one child partly because I decided that I was not well designed for childbirth and wasn't doing it again.

Your poor dd. It is a horrible thing to contemplate in your teens - that you have years and years of your life with periods. The thing that really gets me about them is the lack of control, if you just went to the loo when you needed to expel some blood it would be fine, but it just drips/gushes/pours out.

TheOrigRights · 17/12/2021 18:34

@Mufasa1118

I enjoy my period.
Mine have mostly not bothered me, but now I'm perimenopausal they (and the associated symptoms) are more disruptive.

When they're easily managed they are a good indication of health.

TheOrigRights · 17/12/2021 18:32

@Knackeredmommy

Agree, why every month and for decades?
You can rectify that by having more (and more) children and breastfeeding in between. Grin
Knackeredmommy · 17/12/2021 18:27

Agree, why every month and for decades?

HowDareYouStealThatCar · 17/12/2021 18:26

@WilliamofBaskerville

Re aristocratic brides, poor Margaret Beaufort, mother of Henry VII, had him aged just 13. She never had another child and it’s thought it was because she was so damaged by this. She was lucky to survive.
Apparently this was actually frowned upon at the time. Whilst aristocrats often married young, they weren't expected to start trying for babies until the bride was older (I suppose more late teens than early teens).

Also re the poster who said that the average life expectancy was 30 - this is due to a high infant mortality rate. Putting it simply, if 50% of the population die aged 60 and 50% die before their first birthday, then the average life expectancy is 30. It doesn't mean that everyone died before menopause. There's actually archaeological evidence to suggest that children who grew up in close proximity to their maternal grandmothers had better survival rates, so clearly we do have some evolutionary purpose post-childbearing age!

Sorry for the long post - I'm a bit of an evolutionary biology/history enthusiast Blush

scottishnames · 17/12/2021 18:23

Maireas She was certainly abused - inappropriate touching - by Somerset, as a teenager. And there were certainly rumours about her and Leicester and Essex and others. She may well have had emotional and - to a certain degree physical - affairs (so far as we know, she almost certainly did) , but I think she was far, far too canny to have risked pregnancy out of wedlock.

Politically, she made great and very effective use of her claims to virginity for political purposes. And on her deathbed, she declared that she was a virgin. This was at a time when people genuinely believed that sinners were puished in hell. So far as I - and others - can tell, she was not personally devout, and was very, very pragmatic when it came to religion. But telling an open lie on your deathbed would have been an absolutely enormous and shattering thing to do for anyone at that time.

We don't really know much about her gynaecology. There were hostile rumours that she was physically not capable of sex; on the other hand, spies for one potential foreign husband quizzed her washerwoman (!!) who reported that things were normal - though of course we don't know what precisely the washerwoman meant by that.

You are correct, in that she might have had periods for a long while. But she was extraordinary - a complete and utter exception.

Having said all that, not all women married in Tudor times, and, as I said above, poor ordinary women did not usually marry until their mid 20s. However, there is some evidence to say that poor nourishment and tough physical work (in the fields etc) meant - compared with today -that periods started later, around mid- late teens. And might sometimes have been delayed/non-existent.

And, of course, the Church taught that periods were part of Eve's punishment; they were expected to be troublesome. If you'd been brought up with this outlook - and had no other possible explanations presented to you - then you'd expect pain, discomfort etc etc etc.

Mufasa1118 · 17/12/2021 18:23

I enjoy my period.

MadCattery · 17/12/2021 18:07

Speaking of design flaws, most (if not all) other mammals have breasts that enlarge for nursing and then recede. It would certainly be more convenient...

LoveMySituation · 17/12/2021 18:04

I bumbled along reasonably happily with periods, I just did what was needed and carried on as before. It was having boobs I absolutely loathed(and still do) It was perimenopause that made me think if there's a god it's a) male and b) misogynistic. And realise that I'd got off very lightly with periods for the last thirty years. Who the hell connects oestrogen to bone mass, puts receptors for it in every part of the body? Someone who seemingly hates women and doesn't want us to be healthy after we've done what we're supposed to do

JCWildWest · 17/12/2021 18:01

Also echo other posts on mortality of childbirth. I'd of defo died having my DD and her too if it wasn't for modern medicine. It's like we aren't designed to reproduce very effectively

JCWildWest · 17/12/2021 17:59

My DD said this to me the other day. And I couldn't give her a good or solid answer, it does seem like a design flaw. DD is really suffering with heavy periods and cramps and can't understand why her reproductive system is designed to cripple her, which seems quite reasonable.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 17/12/2021 17:58

I don't know.

I think about how much I hate staying in to wait for a parcel.

Then I imagine having to sit on a nest of eggs and not being able to leave them for nine months.😱

wonderstuff · 17/12/2021 17:56

I also object to the length of time we are fertile, 13-45ish? Seems very unnecessary in order to replace the species, there should be a switch or something. Loving the idea of owl pellets.

I have found cbd coated tampons are really effective at reducing period pain, not as much fun as smoking cannabis but they do allow you to get on with stuff.

WilliamofBaskerville · 17/12/2021 17:56

Re aristocratic brides, poor Margaret Beaufort, mother of Henry VII, had him aged just 13. She never had another child and it’s thought it was because she was so damaged by this. She was lucky to survive.

Atmywitsend29 · 17/12/2021 17:54

If modern medicine left us to our own devices in regards to childbirth, how many of us would have died in childbirth still? I'd have died at 20 years old because my baby was large, overdue, and back to back and I had to have an emcs.
My sister has had episiotomies with both of her babies and pre-emptive antibiotics. Probably would have died of sepsis way back when.
And our inefficient pelvises would cease to exist in the gene pool Grin

SickAndTiredAgain · 17/12/2021 17:53

@ginghamstarfish

I always think teeth, backs and not growing new limbs (and new teeth) as some animals do are a major giveaway that humans were not 'designed', and not sure how religious folks explain this, although I'm sure they do come with something.
Agreed! If the liver can regrow, I think it’s a poor effort for teeth not to be able to.
Crazykatie · 17/12/2021 17:51

One day of course it will be possible to turn off or on the breeding cycle and do away with all the bother of periods until like all mammals we have to cope. At least some others are seasonal breeders which would make it easier, however it has been a very successful evolution, increasing the influence of the human species over other animals in fact the whole planet.

Rosewaterblossom · 17/12/2021 17:50

Yes I agree, and what do men have to put up with? Sweet FA.. 🙄

scottishnames · 17/12/2021 17:49

Should be - re poor Queen Anne - she had seventeen pregnancies over 20 years, not over 25. Even worse.

Aristocratic women also tended to marry much younger than ordiary women. From the 16th cent, the average age of marriage of ordinary women was mid-late 20s, whereas aristocratic women typically married in their teens.