Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need to make a decision on overseas wedding ASAP.

62 replies

NYResolutions2022 · 17/12/2021 13:21

I need to make a final decision on my SIL's overseas wedding as invitations are in the post.

In a nutshell, I don't want to go, nor send my DC, but am happy for my DH to go alone, which he says he will. There will be a massive fallout though as my SIL and MIL/ FIL will see it as a massive snub.

My reasons are thus. I do not have a positive relationship with my SIL. I tried to be friendly with her for many years and have been extremely generous with her many, many times, only to be treated with constant indifference. I seemed to be a massive threat that caused upset and drew attention away from her WRT her parents and extended family and she acted like a spoilt brat many times. As a mature woman, she still acts like this. MIL is her no.1 enabler.

SIL has never once spent any time with my DC, helped us out when we needed help, has never bought me or my DC a gift, despite our generosity to her. She has deep pockets and short arms and any £ directed away from her, means she has less to spend on her self indulgent self.

My DH doesn't want to go, but says he is because his mum will get upset. I don't want to and I don't want to send my DC either. In their words, they wouldn't know her if she walked past them in the street.

I'm pretty sure there will be a nuclear fallout as this is a huge loss of face, which they are very big on. I just feel that she is not in our lives, she has had enough money out of me, has never lifted a finger to do anything for us, but expects loads back and she is a massive shit stirrer WRT me and PIL.

My DH says that she just doesn't think and she doesn't realise that it is massively inconvenient and costs a lot of money which people don't have. She just sees what she wants and can't see anything else.

I just feel that I am a middle aged woman now and I shouldn't have to pussyfoot and pander to immature relatives anymore nor spend time with people, just because we are related to them.

I need to make a decision ASAP and be able to articulate it to minimise the wrath. I know I am not going, but I don't want to send my DC either and need a reason. I also need a mature, calm line to tell them why we are not going. I can't use the money one as we can afford it, but at the expense of other things, which they will think is not an excuse as it is "SIL"

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 17/12/2021 15:04

My concern is the emotional blackmail to my DC and DH which my MIL has massive form for. I've seen her pul them aside on their own many times and say "GM/ SIL is upset because you don't want to do XXXX". If you are a kid, it is hard to stand up to her if she has you by the elbow and she is saying this to your face.

Instead of enabling your in-laws and pandering to their nonsense, why don't you empower your children to ignore this blatant manipulation? They are old enough to learn how to manage toxic people on their own.

averythinline · 17/12/2021 14:54

I'm with team just say NO especially if there is spmething else the teens want to do instead.... as you say now is your chance to set yourself free I would be simple and get DH to accept on behalf of himself and if asked just say your not coming...

Whilst relationships are not necessarily contracts I do think that you do get back to a certain extent what you put in - she has not invested any time/care/thought into her relationship with you/DC so why would you? actions seak louder than words is advice often given here,,,

Doubledoorsontogarden · 17/12/2021 14:33

Summerinsun I’m with you on this one, I would go, just me and DH. It’s a family wedding. Late teens DC can make their own mind up.

NYResolutions2022 · 17/12/2021 14:32

Maybe do it for your husband not your sil

But Mutha, I have been taking one for the team for the whole time. I am tired of it. I think also my stance now on this is because my DC are older and I no longer feel I have to tow the line and keep my mouth shut for the sake of harmony like you sometimes feel you have to do when you have a young family.

I feel like if I give into this, then that is it. I will be doing it for the rest of my life. It is now or never to say, actually you bring nothing to the table here, and I am no longer willing to do this.

OP posts:
Dozer · 17/12/2021 14:30

Teen DC with parental support are well able to handle stuff like that, and talking about it is a useful life lesson for them! (I had lots of dysfunctional older relatives so speak from experience!)

2bazookas · 17/12/2021 14:29

Trust yourself and follow your gut instinct and heart. They are telling you not to go.

Let DH go. And let DH explain to his family why you didn't.

funnelfanjo · 17/12/2021 14:29

Look, if you're worried there will be drama if you don't go, then you don't have to get involved in the drama either. I had someone dramatic and emotive in the extended family, they soon stopped trying to suck me in after my responses were all along the lines of "oh dear, what a shame" and "hope you have a lovely time" as appropriate to the situation.

SummerInSun · 17/12/2021 14:28

I actually disagree with most PP. Even if you don't like SIL, it's a very important family event. Confronting your PIL with just how badly you all get on in relation to an occasion that should be a source of joy and celebration is churlish and childish. This is not the time to try to teach your SIL what you think of her behaviour, especially if your PIL's feelings will be collateral damage. You should be the gracious one here.

If you genuinely can't afford it, of course, that's entirely different and you can say "really sorry and if it was it the U.K. of course we'd all come, but we can't afford it, however we'll juggle the budget so at least DH can be there".

Blossom64265 · 17/12/2021 14:28

No one’s home country?

Neither I nor my children will be risking the trip during a pandemic.

NYResolutions2022 · 17/12/2021 14:26

My DC are all late teens and they don't want to go because a) they don't know her very well and b) they won't be able to go on a holiday they want to go on as a result.

My concern is the emotional blackmail to my DC and DH which my MIL has massive form for. I've seen her pul them aside on their own many times and say "GM/ SIL is upset because you don't want to do XXXX". If you are a kid, it is hard to stand up to her if she has you by the elbow and she is saying this to your face.

OP posts:
GrumpyLivesInMyHouseNow · 17/12/2021 14:14

If you don't want to go, don't go.

How old are your dc? Are they old enough to decide if they want to go or not, does your dh want to take them?

In your shoes I'd simply say you won't be going and the answers to the above questions would depend on if the dc went or not.

tara66 · 17/12/2021 14:03

Tell her you won't be making any arrangements for next year because the Covid situation makes everything especially foreign travel very uncertain indeed as with France as from tomorrow - no none French nationals or residents allowed there from Britain.

Aquamarine1029 · 17/12/2021 14:03

Why are you even questioning your decision? Of course you don't go, "fallout" be damned. How your in-laws react is their problem. There's no way I would go.

MorningNinja · 17/12/2021 14:01

How old are your DCs?

Does your DH want them to go with him? Do they want a holiday with their DF?

I think the decision for you to go should be one that you decide, but as for the DCs, it's a discussion that you'd have to discuss with your DH.

givethatbabyaname · 17/12/2021 13:59

I have a SIL exactly like this. She also can’t see beyond the end of her nose. She’s not enabled by PILs to the extent you’re describing, they kind of know she’s a self-centered brat, but they supplement her extravagant lifestyle because they feel bad she’s still single when all of her friends and siblings have families of their own. SIL also has a good enough relationship with my DC. It’s fair and reasonable, in the circumstances.

I too am now a middle aged woman who’s done with pandering to her, to having to celebrate holidays and birthdays and plan vacations around her foot stomping and constant reminders that she’s not less of a person because she doesn’t have kids (but clearly I am because I do Hmm). She has no idea that parents are limited in their choices by virtue of schooling and other child-based obligations and necessities, that I’m not just getting what I personally want for myself (as if!). I also know that if/when she does marry and have her own DC, the myopia will ramp up beyond anything anyone can handle, that she and her DC will be the ones everyone will have to accommodate at all times. Thankfully, by then my DC will be old enough to have minds of their own.

All to say that I’ve recently decided that pissing her off = pissing off PILs. They’re all adults, and they choose to be enmeshed like this. Entirely up to them, nothing to do with me. But, if i choose not to pander to SIL I have to take the huffing and puffing from PIL as part of the package. Turns out I only needed to do it twice before they got where I was coming from. My relationship with PILs is constant and largely centered around my DC/their DGC. Nothing has changed on that front. If, in the rest of their lives outside of the DC, they choose to do things I’m not interested in - so be it. And if I have to choose between SIL and my DC, of course I will put my DC first. EXCEPT for one-off things like weddings….

In your shoes, I wouldn’t go. But if DH can take the DC himself, let him (assuming it doesn’t interfere with school etc). They’re his DC, her nephews/nieces, PIL’s DGC too, and a wedding is a one-off. Keep costs low because you have your own commitments. You can’t not go because of costs because you CAN afford it. But don’t spend so much that your own family holiday is jeopardised. When they ask why you’re not there, just say you weren’t able to make it: much more expensive for four than for three, other commitments, using the opportunity of DC away to get other important things done etc. You don’t need to hide that she’s not your priority. She isn’t. They just don’t like that she isn’t. And they do need to be told, otherwise this will ripple down to her DC eventually, who you will be expected to buy gifts for and attend birthday presents for when she couldn’t identify your DC in a line up.

Don’t let yourself me taken for a fool. But a wedding is a wedding, her DH will be a part of your family soon.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 17/12/2021 13:57

Nope...
You have major worries about covid Op... Don't you Grin

TheSoapyFrog · 17/12/2021 13:50

Nah I wouldn't go either.

underneaththeash · 17/12/2021 13:49

If your DH wants to kids to go, he should take them.
Stop helping her out though.

Seeingadistance · 17/12/2021 13:48

@ToughTittyWhompus

“Because I don’t fucking want to”

May as well, whatever you say will be wrong.

Yip!
NYResolutions2022 · 17/12/2021 13:46

Trying not to out myself here, but it is in the summer holidays 2022 and on an island in the med. It is no ones home country.

My MIL has said that both she and SIL know that it is inconvenient, a lot of money, there is a pandemic on, that we could lose money, that it is not somewhere we should go on holiday normally, but we will all have a lovely time and it is what SIL wants.

OP posts:
Muthalucka · 17/12/2021 13:42

Hmmm it’s a hard one. Maybe do it for your husband not your sil

Blossom64265 · 17/12/2021 13:40

The appropriate response is dependent on whether or not the destination happens to be the home country of the groom or other bride. If the wedding is overseas simply because it’s the only way her beloved’s family can realistically attend, this is a much different situation than a couple who have planned an overseas wedding during a pandemic.

InTheLabyrinth · 17/12/2021 13:40

The kids and I didn't go to BiLs wedding.
It was in term time. Any clashes in dates?

itwasntaparty · 17/12/2021 13:38

Where is it and when?

thepeopleversuswork · 17/12/2021 13:36

Can't you use COVID as an excuse? It's absolutely cast iron

Swipe left for the next trending thread