Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have to cancel don’t I?

82 replies

Christening · 17/12/2021 08:08

My toddlers Christening is arranged for first week in January. It has already been cancelled twice before. We have a service, then a reception for 50 planned. People will be coming from all over the country. Some of them are vulnerable.

YANBU: of course you have to cancel
YABU: don’t cancel it will be fine

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
amidsummernightsdream · 18/12/2021 09:21

Oh im in exactly the same position but have it booked for 15th Jan, so totally feel your dilemma.

We reluctantly decided to cancel the reception this week as the cost was based on a package for 40 people and even if it did go ahead we didnt want the hassle of wondering who was/ wasnt turning up, as it was’t cheap. No one can guarantee an rsvp at the mo.
It helped that we hadnt sent the invites yet.
We will still do the religious ceremony on 15th (if church is open!) and all being well have a much smaller group of family back to ours for tea and cake.
Im prepared that also may not happen but for us, it feel much less stressful opting for a lower key option

RampantIvy · 18/12/2021 08:51

@Abraxan the OP has to pay per head, so if she is paying for 50 people and only 20 turn up that is a lot of money down the drain. They are now talking about a two week lockdown after Christmas so I wouldn't be paying for the party now.

Abraxan · 18/12/2021 08:50

[quote Christening]@Tee20x I have to pay per head for the reception and the money is due on Monday. It is £700. I really don’t want to throw money away if people are not going to come.[/quote]
Ah, missed this - forgot to filter before posting.

I'd be tempted to have the christening, but cancel the party in this case. I'd move to having a smaller number and a more informal event costing much less.

And save the bigger celebration to maybe a first birthday or similar.

Abraxan · 18/12/2021 08:49

I wouldn't cancel.
I'd have the christening party regardless, as that's usually the most important part for anyone who chooses to baptise their child.

The party I would continue with for now.
Some people may drop out.
There may be some restrictions re numbers, as before, but probably not completely stopped.

Stroopwaffle5000 · 18/12/2021 08:13

[quote Wagamamasforlunch]@ClaudiaJ1

Why would you need a buffet for a Christening? It's not a big important event like a wedding. Many people go back home and have a few people around for coffee, or a bbq/sandwiches at home.

Why do you even need 50 people? Why do you even need a buffet? It's extremely extravagant for something that isn't even really that important.

I'm guessing OP has invited 50 people because they are her family and friends and she would like them there? 50 isn't really that many people, say 12 people from each side of the family, that's 24, 26 plus the actual parents, and then 12 friends and their partners make it 50.

Celebrating a new baby is pretty important, especially after the last shitty two years. She didn't say she needs a buffet, she wants a buffet and can afford it, so what's the problem? There's nothing wrong with doing it yourself at home either, but most people would struggle to fit 50 people in their house, it's hassle buying and preparing it yourself, and a BBQ isn't really an option in January. A £12 a head buffet isn't "extremely extravagant", it's standard, same sort of pricing for a buffet for a big birthday party etc. I can imagine you would have had kittens at the last christening I went to: a 3 course sit down meal and a glass of prosecco! For 80 people! I thought it was a bit OTT but the parents had had a shitty time with their baby being born premature and in hospital for the first few weeks of his life, they wanted to celebrate and can afford it, good for them. And good for hospitality industry.[/quote]
But a christening isn't to celebrate a new baby. It is to erase the baby's original sin and so they can become a full-pledged child of God.

The idea that people think a baby is already a sinner makes me shudder, but then I'm not religious!

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 18/12/2021 08:04

[quote Christening]@Wagamamasforlunch the church does not charge for a Christening. You pay an optional £15 if you want a Baptism certificate. It is not a moneyspinner for the church.

@NeverDropYourMooncup are you suggesting that we were planning to spend £700 in order to get gifts? For my eldest’s Christening we received some books and an engraved cutlery set. Hardly a profit making exercise.

I am genuinely surprised at the open hostility towards Christianity on this thread. It is very important to me to have my baby welcomed into the church. This is my faith and my belief. Are these posters as openly hostile to all religions or do they have a specific contempt for Christianity?[/quote]
If it's a purely spiritual thing, cancelling wouldn't happen because the child would be baptised urgently for the spiritual protection it's believed to confer, just the party side would be stopped.

Some people do have baptisms purely for presents/a party. Which I am hostile towards despite an absence of faith - because it's hypocrisy with an extra slice of cynicism. You are mistaking my distaste for people who forget it's a religious rite for contempt towards Christianity.

girlmom21 · 18/12/2021 07:19

I am genuinely surprised at the open hostility towards Christianity on this thread. It is very important to me to have my baby welcomed into the church. This is my faith and my belief.

If it's that important to have your baby welcomed into the church, why are you considering cancelling, unless absolutely forced to do so by the government?

I understand you want your family around to join in the celebration but you say you've already previously cancelled. I can't help but think you'd just go ahead and worry about the party later if it was that important.

gogohm · 17/12/2021 22:17

At the moment we can go ahead with baptisms, whether hospitality can accommodate you is another matter

RampantIvy · 17/12/2021 22:04

@Christening Sadly, most mumsnetters are extremely intolerant of any kind of religion and are insultingly rude about people who have a faith, especially Christians because they are an easy target.

I hope the christening goes ahead and that you can have a party when things get easier.

amymel2016 · 17/12/2021 21:06

We had our DS christened last Saturday and faced the same concerns. We decided to go ahead but asked everyone to test in the morning before they came, we also let everyone know that if they weren’t comfortable to attend then that would be absolutely fine. Everyone wore masks at the church and then I made sure the venue afterwards was well ventilated, loads of hand gel, disposable paper towels etc etc We had 60 people in the end, all jabbed (over 12s) and most boostered. If you’re comfortable with some people dropping out and can make sure you have good ventilation etc then I would go ahead.

Christening · 17/12/2021 21:02

@Wagamamasforlunch the church does not charge for a Christening. You pay an optional £15 if you want a Baptism certificate. It is not a moneyspinner for the church.

@NeverDropYourMooncup are you suggesting that we were planning to spend £700 in order to get gifts? For my eldest’s Christening we received some books and an engraved cutlery set. Hardly a profit making exercise.

I am genuinely surprised at the open hostility towards Christianity on this thread. It is very important to me to have my baby welcomed into the church. This is my faith and my belief. Are these posters as openly hostile to all religions or do they have a specific contempt for Christianity?

OP posts:
LynetteScavo · 17/12/2021 19:32

You've done exactly the right thing.

Ireolu · 17/12/2021 19:28

If you don't cancel I reckon people will cancel on you closer to the time. We have just had to reschedule an international trip for the 3rd time because of all of this. There is a high probability it will not go ahead. I wouldn't lose money over it tbh.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/12/2021 19:23

[quote Wagamamasforlunch]@NeverDropYourMooncup

Meh. I grew up religious and used to think the same. Now I just think it's a nice excuse to have a party. The face wash is just a formality for most people, but you could argue the same about most church weddings. Everyone likes a party. Well not everyone, but most people Grin. And lots of churches need the income from none religious people paying to use the church for their wedding or christening.[/quote]
I'm not religious, but think that way - why go through something that is so important to so many people because they believe it is bringing their child into a spiritual 'safety' when it's easier to just have a party? TBH, I think the reason for doing the religious thing is precisely because they know it's important to others so they're more likely to get gifts that way. Using their hypocrisy to capitalise upon other people's beliefs.

Wagamamasforlunch · 17/12/2021 18:12

@NeverDropYourMooncup

Meh. I grew up religious and used to think the same. Now I just think it's a nice excuse to have a party. The face wash is just a formality for most people, but you could argue the same about most church weddings. Everyone likes a party. Well not everyone, but most people Grin. And lots of churches need the income from none religious people paying to use the church for their wedding or christening.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2021 18:04

Why would you need a buffet for a Christening?Many people go back home and have a few people around for coffee, or a bbq/sandwiches at home. having a gathering after the event isn't that rare. Even if I didn't want to see everyone, I'd struggle to fit me, DH, 3 kids, two sets of parents, GP and our siblings in my living room.

It's not a big important event like a wedding. what makes a WEDDING more important than a christening?

Why do you even need 50 people? contrary to mn's "no one cares about your kids" there are actually lots of people who do love / care about them and would want to celebrate them.

...for something that isn't even really that important. I'm assuming you aren't religious then?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/12/2021 17:58

The point of a Christening/Baptism is to fulfil a requirement of faith, it's a rite that is of religious significance, not a party with a quick wash of the face thrown in.

If you just want a party, cancel and hold a party for the child's next birthday. But if you do have faith, the baptism needs to go ahead whether 100 of your closest relatives attend armed with gifts or not. And if the splosh of water isn't the point of doing it - well, you shouldn't be doing it.

Wagamamasforlunch · 17/12/2021 17:39

@ClaudiaJ1

Why would you need a buffet for a Christening? It's not a big important event like a wedding. Many people go back home and have a few people around for coffee, or a bbq/sandwiches at home.

Why do you even need 50 people? Why do you even need a buffet? It's extremely extravagant for something that isn't even really that important.

I'm guessing OP has invited 50 people because they are her family and friends and she would like them there? 50 isn't really that many people, say 12 people from each side of the family, that's 24, 26 plus the actual parents, and then 12 friends and their partners make it 50.

Celebrating a new baby is pretty important, especially after the last shitty two years. She didn't say she needs a buffet, she wants a buffet and can afford it, so what's the problem? There's nothing wrong with doing it yourself at home either, but most people would struggle to fit 50 people in their house, it's hassle buying and preparing it yourself, and a BBQ isn't really an option in January. A £12 a head buffet isn't "extremely extravagant", it's standard, same sort of pricing for a buffet for a big birthday party etc. I can imagine you would have had kittens at the last christening I went to: a 3 course sit down meal and a glass of prosecco! For 80 people! I thought it was a bit OTT but the parents had had a shitty time with their baby being born premature and in hospital for the first few weeks of his life, they wanted to celebrate and can afford it, good for them. And good for hospitality industry.

SenseSphere · 17/12/2021 15:09

I wouldn’t cancel, assuming that an event like that is still permitted in January. I would make it clear to everyone attending that whilst you’d love to see them you completely understand if they decide not to attend. That way they have an “out”.

MindyStClaire · 17/12/2021 14:44

I'd hold off for now if you can (and if you want to - you may be less stressed if you just cancel). I wouldn't go to a party this week because I don't want to risk isolating over Christmas, but I'd go in January.

Unfortunately I suspect we'll be locked down again in Jan, but if you're happy to wait and see I wouldn't cancel just yet.

Elieza · 17/12/2021 14:23

Defo the right decision to scale back or cancel. The religious side is important but not important enough to risk peoples health over.

I’m in Scotland and we are being told to stay in as much as possible and scale back events or cancel if we want to see people at Christmas, in an attempt to slow the spread, and after Christmas. It’s only a matter of time before other parts of the U.K. get told that too. If they haven’t already been.

I’d be asking all attendees to lateral flow test first. Although we know they aren’t as accurate, it’s all we have.

Can you have a christening party instead once all the covid times are over? I know many brides are planning that as they’ve missed out on the party side of their big day. Why shouldn’t you have that too for your little one. It will be great when we can do such things again. I can’t wait til we can enjoy the freedoms we took for granted again.
Grin

0palescent · 17/12/2021 14:13

I think you've made the right decision. The party would be nice, but isn't necessary, and you obviously place importance on the sacrament.

Lacedwithgrace · 17/12/2021 14:08

Cancel, you don't need a party but could have tea and cake somewhere You can still have the ceremony with 5-10 nearest and dearest

Christening · 17/12/2021 13:30

@ClaudiaJ1 a Christening is a very important event in our lives. Just because a religious ceremony means nothing to you does not mean others feel the same.

OP posts:
AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 17/12/2021 13:27

Oh, and @ClaudiaJ1, Weddings aren't really that important either. The marriage, maybe. But the wedding party isn't that important, if you use your attitude towards it.