Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL asking DD what is your mummy cooking for tea?

181 replies

Veeveeoxox · 17/12/2021 05:09

MIL regularly face times DD she seems to always throw in a passive aggressive comment such as what is your Mummy cooking for tea? (I ordered a pizza Grin )So she then passively aggressively comments that's unhealthy. Why does she never
ask "What is your daddy cooking for tea ?"
I'm a student nurse doing an integrated masters with two assignments due in I also work on the nursing bank , her dad works from home in a low stress role. The funny thing is I do like MIL just not the expectation that her son should be waited on and not expected to help.

If I ever have a son I will not be asking my GCs what their mother was cooking for tea.

AIBU?

OP posts:
SallyWD · 17/12/2021 09:10

It's very annoying but she's from a different generation where generally the women cooked.

ShinyHappyPoster · 17/12/2021 09:07

Maybe she's assuming it's your responsibility not because you have a vagina but because you do usually make dinner and even if it's ordering in pizza, it seems to be you that does it Hmm

Wotagain · 17/12/2021 09:06

@Veeveeoxox

She is a nice person but I think she just furthers sexism if my OH has to stay over because he has a meeting in London she will get up super early prepare a cooked breakfast for him then pack his lunch Confused he's 34!!!
Yet you think it’s ok for him to not routinely cook for the family, even though you’re the one with the heavier time commitments?
C8H10N4O2 · 17/12/2021 09:04

@LizzieSiddal

I’m in my mid 50s and would ask “what are you having for tea”. I’d never assume the mother is cooking rather than the father who wfh. It’s pure sexism.
Yes I'm similar and agree its sexism first and foremost.

My DF who would be in his 90s was entirely capable of cooking, laundry and cleaning. She lived with rather than believed the patriarchal expectations but made sure her own sons were capable and not pathetically dependent on a woman to feed them.

I have often had discussions with younger women including friends of my DC who still have that ingrained sense that ultimately the woman is responsible and is "lucky" if their male partner pulls their weight at home.

Patriarchy is alive and well, it just changes messaging from time to time.

Pippapet · 17/12/2021 09:04

@Dollywilde

My MIL is like *@hugr* ‘s mum. DD is going through a spell of bad sleep and MIL keeps saying ‘oh Dolly you must be exhausted poor love!’. DH is supremely fucked off with it because he and I are sharing the bad nights and so he is also exhausted. It’s very funny Grin she does it with our house as well ‘oh Dolly you’ve made this place look beautiful’ - when DH has picked out half the furniture. It’s strange, she’s such a modern woman who’s raised a very equality focused man but she can’t seem to remember that sometimes Grin(I do love her to bits I think it’s just generational! And I don’t mind getting all the credit).

Tbh my main way of deflecting is to treat her like she’s lost her marbles a bit. Have you tried ‘what do you mean, cooking? Oh DH is on it tonight! Isn’t it lovely he has time to cook for us all when I’m so busy with all these assignments’

If her son isn’t cooking for you then that’s your bigger problem tbh.

It sounds like she's just trying to show you appreciation, even if it's slightly clumsily done. As the mother of DSs myself, personally in the future if I have a DIL who made my DS happy, was doing a great job with my DGC, and the house, I'd be falling over myself to try and show appreciation in any way I could too. There's all to many unhappy households out there. I'd be grateful as a MIL if my DS's and my DGC's wasn't one of them.
SilverGlassHare · 17/12/2021 09:02

DMIL does this. If DS was messing about with a feather duster, it would be ‘oh helping mummy clean?’ If he was wearing something a bit small for him, it would be ‘mummy needs to get you a bigger top’ etc etc. I just laugh and say ‘oh daddy does the cleaning in this house!’ or similar. I do really love MIL but she’s a bit old fashioned about family gender roles.

Wotagain · 17/12/2021 09:02

I think the reason your mil asks ‘what’s mummy cooking for tea’ is because she’s aware that lazy git Daddy doesn’t routinely cook tea,
Quite how you can joke you’ve had to go ‘on strike’ about cooking to get your lazy git DH to step up is baffling.

Charmatt · 17/12/2021 09:00

We once went to visit for my FIL's birthday and he offered us a drink. I said I was happy to drive if my DH wanted a glass. My MIL asked if I had asked permission to drive my DH's car!

Now, every time I drop my daughter off anywhere in my DH's car, she giggles and says, 'Have you asked permission?'

When we paid off the mortgage, MIL told me that I was very lucky that my DH had managed to pay it off early and give me security. The assumption that I was a kept woman really annoyed me - I put her straight!

A lot of women of that generation think they should defer to men - they often didn't work and their role was to look after their man. Everything has changed, but in their eyes, equality didn't happen - we just took on more!

Perversely, she hates it that I have a management job - she thinks I should work part-time for a few hours a week, preferably what she calls, 'a little job'.

Rosebel · 17/12/2021 09:00

My MIL was horrified last time she came for a meal because DH had cooked.,when "poor" DH had been at work.
I had also been at work and then looked after our son but apparently I should have cooked.
She will also ask me about the DCs but never DH. It really annoys me.
In some ways she's quite modern but at other times she seems to think it's still 1950s.

Veeveeoxox · 17/12/2021 08:59

She is a nice person but I think she just furthers sexism if my OH has to stay over because he has a meeting in London she will get up super early prepare a cooked breakfast for him then pack his lunch Confused he's 34!!!

OP posts:
Savoury · 17/12/2021 08:58

I advise you pop on camera and say:
“Oh MIL, I agree and it’s DH’s turn to cook. But he’s nowhere to be seen. Can you have a word with him?”

She won’t have a word and she won’t ask again!!

TheCreamCaker · 17/12/2021 08:57

THIS

Why, oh why, do people always manage to find problems in absolutely nothing? So she asked what you were cooking, big deal. It's conversation. That's it. Just say I'm not cooking tonight, it's my husband's turn/takeaway/whatever. It's a non-issue.

elliejjtiny · 17/12/2021 08:47

My Mil does this. It works both ways though. If she sees me doing any kind of "man's work" she practically gives me a medal and then tells dh off for not putting the bins out/carrying something heavy. The other day she was shocked when we had people round for dinner and dh was cooking and I was putting up the fold up table.

bucketsoflove · 17/12/2021 08:46

You don't have to get wound up about this stuff. Just say I've ordered pizza and ignore the rest. Or, it's DHs turn to cook, I have no idea what we're having.

She'll either get the message or you can stop the FaceTime sessions/let your DH supervise them so you don't have to engage with her at that time of day. I'm not sure why he's not anyway if you're so busy and it's his mother.

Pandamumium · 17/12/2021 08:46

I had the opposite with my MIL. A few years ago, when my children were mid teens she was convinced my DH came home every night and cooked dinner. At that time my husband was regularly coming home around midnight. My children even tried to convince her she was wrong, but she wouldn’t believe them

EIIa · 17/12/2021 08:42

I thought the complaint was about calling it tea 😂

PinkSyCo · 17/12/2021 08:40

Your MIL sounds sexist rather than passive aggressive. You say that your DH does his share of the cooking, so what does she say when your DD tells her that her dad’s making her tea?

ilovesushi · 17/12/2021 08:38

Maybe it's just a simple unloaded question. If it's around dinner time she's probably wondering to put on for herself and is making chit chat? If you usually do the cooking, then it's normal of her to ask what you are cooking.

DrBlackbird · 17/12/2021 08:36

And the patriarchy is perpetuated by younger other women on MN endlessly criticising their mothers their sisters who just needed a bit of sympathy during difficult times. It rolls on, generations of women keeping each other in line.

I’ll be here Your DDs will all be on here one every day, slagging you off.

There, fixed it for you.

OP my favourite was when my MiL told me that I should be ashamed of not polishing my DH’s shoes because unpolished shoes would leave a bad impression of him by his work colleagues. Oh and the time that she told him it was a shame that I had taken a sip of his tea because it left less for him Hmm But her pointed comments were much more dysfunctional than simply a generational women do the cooking kind of thing.

Peakedtoosoon · 17/12/2021 08:34

I'd reserve judgement on what you would or wouldn't say to GC/DIL until you do actually have an adult son. It's much harder to get it right than it looks and it seems some people are determined to find fault.

Why not take it that she's acknowledging and appreciating that you do the lion's share?

NandorTheRelentless · 17/12/2021 08:30

You're preaching to the choir here though, we are all outraged- but that's not going to change the world

Each time she says something either you or dh or dd need to say "no it's dh turn this evening" etc

IntermittentParps · 17/12/2021 08:29

Also she stood over my hob and cooker observing it all and making comments
You can order people out of your kitchen. I'd have given her her marching orders.

OP, sexism aside, I think you need to knock on the head this thing about 'unhealthy' food. Tell her not to make comments like that as you don't want your DD to have an anxious relationship with food.

MyOtherProfile · 17/12/2021 08:27

Coach your daughter to say oh it's daddy's turn today so we are having pizza.

oviraptor21 · 17/12/2021 08:24

Just lean across and say "DH's turn tonight Grin"

UntilBubleSings · 17/12/2021 08:24

It's a DH problem you have, not a MIL problem

Swipe left for the next trending thread