Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL asking DD what is your mummy cooking for tea?

181 replies

Veeveeoxox · 17/12/2021 05:09

MIL regularly face times DD she seems to always throw in a passive aggressive comment such as what is your Mummy cooking for tea? (I ordered a pizza Grin )So she then passively aggressively comments that's unhealthy. Why does she never
ask "What is your daddy cooking for tea ?"
I'm a student nurse doing an integrated masters with two assignments due in I also work on the nursing bank , her dad works from home in a low stress role. The funny thing is I do like MIL just not the expectation that her son should be waited on and not expected to help.

If I ever have a son I will not be asking my GCs what their mother was cooking for tea.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Veeveeoxox · 17/12/2021 12:02

@TheVanguardSix

I mean, if you're literally standing in the kitchen popping the fish fingers in the oven and peas on the hob and she's asking, "So what's mummy cooking for tea?" I see no problem with that (other than visual problems for not noticing the fish fingers). That would be chit-chat/small talk. But if she's regularly asking this while you're at work or you're on the sofa and your nose is in a book/you're netflix and chilling, or you're just doing fuck all and not donning the apron, ball, and chain, it IS a loaded, passive-aggressive, MIL question.

I've never been asked this, so I don't see a huge issue. But if I were regularly asked this, hell if I had my MIL in my house often enough to ask this... or my OWN mother for that matter... it would drive me up the wall.

No it's a regular thing my DD is 8 and it's being going on for years !! I was actually sat on my arse watching Netflix Confused I've always viewed her as a martyr for her sons and husband doing their washing preparing meals then saying she's tired as she still works full time. They are grown adults she doesn't need to be a martyr but I do like her most of the time just not the passive aggressive comments. I also have a cleaner which she disapproves of Blush
OP posts:
Malbecfan · 17/12/2021 11:40

I don't think it's a generational thing either; I think CERTAIN people of that generation, just as NannyOgg says.

My DF retired at 52 - he had a high-level, well-paid but stressful job so DM did all the domestic stuff apart from gardening. My DM was still in her mid 40s and working P/T. She told DF that certain domestic tasks were now to be his domain including cooking, laundry and ironing. There were some "interesting' kitchen experiments, but his confidence and repertoire grew. It's just as well because DM died very suddenly 8 years later. People asked in hushed tones how on earth DF would manage, but he has coped absolutely fine for over 20 years. He still does his own laundry and ironing, breakfasts and lunches. He has been staying next door for most of the time since March 2020 so I tend to cook dinner. He's in his late 80s and always brought me up to know how to change my car tyres, repair bike punctures and the like.

CheshireKitten123 · 17/12/2021 11:19

@stingofthebutterfly

Why, oh why, do people always manage to find problems in absolutely nothing? So she asked what you were cooking, big deal. It's conversation. That's it. Just say I'm not cooking tonight, it's my husband's turn/takeaway/whatever. It's a non-issue.
This
saraclara · 17/12/2021 11:17

My DM keeps saying how sorry she is that I have to work, She spent my whole childhood going to coffee mornings, seemingly.

I'm sorry that my DD (mother of a two year old) HAS to work, too. I'd like her to have the option, or to be able to work P/T if she chooses. But the choice is not available to her as it was to me.

I'm not being sexist, I'm not saying that she shouldn't work. All power to her if she CHOOSES to work. But she hasn't had a choice. She has to. And removal of choice is never a good thing.

IAAP · 17/12/2021 11:14

I would pick her up every single time and ask back DD can you ask MIL to ask Daddy these questions as to what he's doing with cooking / cleaning etc -and point out we are EQUAL here for parenting. Could you also point out the Granny that forcing stereotypes on young people is NOT helpful.

I would say this is she were 14 months or 14 -pointedly and loudly every single bloody time

Really though her father needs to deal with this -not you!!

saraclara · 17/12/2021 11:13

I don't get it. You said yourself that you cook the meals. Your MIL presumably knows that you do, so that's why she refers to Mummy when she talks to your DD.

She's not being sexist, she's just reflecting the situation that YOU'VE created by taking the traditionally female role when it comes to making meals.

If you want her to stop asking what mum's cooking, you need to get your DH to step up and cook, and let your MIL know that he does.

This OP 'problem' is entirely of your own making.

Nanny0gg · 17/12/2021 11:11

@Mybalconyiscracking

It’s the older generation. My DM keeps saying how sorry she is that I have to work, She spent my whole childhood going to coffee mornings, seemingly. My DDs are 16 and 18 now anyway, I absolutely choose to work, love my job and can’t think of anything worse than a coffee morning. We were poor as church mice when I was a child, she literally did not know where their next meal was coming from, she used to buy an egg and an apple for me at the end of the month. She literally starved sometimes. Pointing this out to her does not stop the constant pointed remarks about how my sisters and I never seem to sit down and no wonder we are tired!
It is NOT the older generation.

It is certain members of that generation

I love a coffee morning. But I worked. My children work.
My husband cooks and in the past has changed a nappy or two and walked a crying baby in the middle of the night (which a lot of the men mentioned on here don't seem to do)

ChampagneLassie · 17/12/2021 11:11

Friend of mine her DH has not worked since the children were small (now teenagers) - she has a terrific career and has a very high level important job. Her DH does all the household stuff - hosts dinner parties for her girlfriends and caters us all, minds babies and dogs (honestly the man is a dream - I just received Christmas cards that he'd hand made! ). Her family STILL ask Q like this of her/her children and seem incredulous that she "lets" him do everything. Of course she does she's busy doing her own day job. I do think a lot of this is generational and it is such a difference to their own frame of reference its very hard for them to get their heads around.

LindaEllen · 17/12/2021 11:06

I don't think it's a sexist comment if she knows you are actually doing the cooking that evening.

People seem to look too hard for ways to be offended these days.

Squeezita · 17/12/2021 11:02

[quote NMC2022]@Squeezita well she is now (Alzheimer's) but she wasn't... and her legs and arms work just fine Hmm let's just say I belong on the stately homes threads about toxic mothers![/quote]
Oh I see! It's a shame he can't put her in a stately care home Wink

Arethechildreninbedyet · 17/12/2021 10:59

From 3pm daily my mum becomes consumed by the need for me to be ‘home for DH’ and can ‘get a nice tea on for him’ despite the fact I am also working, have children with him, have my own schedule and the fact he does shift work.

She wouldn’t be happy unless we were sat around in the dinner table in our Sunday best staring mournfully at the door with a roast chicken warming in the oven from 4pm waiting for HRH to walk in the front door. He doesn’t finish til the early hours most morning but they doesn’t matter - she’s agog I don’t wait up for him nor do I wake up and have full conversations with him when he gets in.

diddl · 17/12/2021 10:52

@kokokokokokokokoko

Tell your DD to reply "why do you never ask what daddy is cooking, mummy works very hard and has more to do than daddy".
Why get a kid involved?
kokokokokokokokoko · 17/12/2021 10:44

Tell your DD to reply "why do you never ask what daddy is cooking, mummy works very hard and has more to do than daddy".

Asi1 · 17/12/2021 10:40

My sister in laws inlaws saw my husband make our baby a bottle of milk.

She told my sister in law this a womans job and she didn't like him doing it.

NMC2022 · 17/12/2021 10:36

@Squeezita well she is now (Alzheimer's) but she wasn't... and her legs and arms work just fine Hmm let's just say I belong on the stately homes threads about toxic mothers!

MarmaladeToastAndAMarmaladeCat · 17/12/2021 10:33

My mil does this too and I find it unbelievably irritating. When we moved into our new house recently she walked around inspecting it and commenting on the cleanliness of it and attributed anything positive or negative to the woman who had just moved out ‘ooh, she’s left your oven very clean’ ‘she hasn’t cleaned these blinds’ etc. Just irritating that she automatically defaults to thinking all of this is the woman’s job.

TambourineTimesThree · 17/12/2021 10:28

My mum and mil are both guilty of making sexist comments and assumptions. Never really noticed until we had kids. Even after 15 years. I genuinely don't think it's intentional, or that they mean any offense but we can't seem to get them to stop.

For instance, if I travel with work, my mum will ask 'and what have you left for DH' s tea?' And if I go away for a week, I get horrified gasps and concern about how he'll manage. Who'll wash the clothes and what will they eat?
Then he'd be invited over for tea and sent back with enough food for an army.

If he travels for work nobody ever says anything to him about how I'll cope.

He started saying no to the teas years ago because he felt so patronised. And that actually made a difference.

These days she offers help to us both equally if we're home alone and we gratefully accept. She still can't help the horrified gasps on his behalf, though Grin

With mil, its the way she asks me everything about the children. Drives us both mad. She'll text me for ideas for their birthday gifts, but NEVER asks her own son, their father. He usually makes a point of sending replies to her. But it never sinks in.

pigsDOfly · 17/12/2021 10:27

I think OP and all the posters on here moaning about MIL always assuming that cooking food, getting up to children in the night and doing housework is woman's work, should think about what MIL's life was like and cut her some slack.

I'm of the MIL generation, in fact I'm probably quite a bit older than most posters MIL and I can tell you that in their days all these things would have been their jobs. Whether they had jobs outside the home or not, they still did all the 'wife work'.

I doubt, in the case of most of them, they're saying these things to put you down or in a passive aggressive way, they're just making the assumption that your work/life balance is the same as theirs was; and from what I can gather from one of my daughters, for a lot of women it's still the same.

My exh did absolutely nothing in the home, nothing with the children and the idea of him attempting to cook even the most basic meal is laughable.

He also continued to pursue all his hobbies after we were married, which meant I was on my own most evenings and every weekend; all these things contributed to him being my exh.

I don't make the assumption that my daughters/daughter in law should be the ones doing the wife work because that's not how my mind works; also I grew up seeing my own father cook and involve himself with us children so my perspective is probably different from a lot of your MIL.

In so many ways things have moved on for women in regard to outside working and in the home, but remember whilst you and your DH/DP might split house work, cooking and childcare equally this would very likely not have been the case in your MIL's day and for many, many women it still isn't the case.

TheOldLadyOfThreadneedleStreet · 17/12/2021 10:22

This is not relevant really and I get why the OP is annoyed. In our house I do nearly all the cooking (I like cooking, am wfh and have the time, am good at cooking and my DH is pretty dire though willing) and my DM keeps on having a dig at poor DH for not helping me. Even as DH is making her cups of tea and looking after her, he’s spent loads of time sorting her Wi-Fi and teaching her how to use Netflix, doing all her diy, driving her around, doing some shopping, generally being lovely. He has the patience of a saint. We do put up with it though, we do blame it on DM getting frail and a bit quarrelsome with it, she has definitely got worse than she used to be in the last few years.

Pinkypenguin · 17/12/2021 10:21

@Billandben444

Yes, it's a generational thing and will die out when we do. Then you'll be the generation saying something deemed inappropriate to your adult children and reading about it on MN.
I don't think it will.

Maybe it won't exist in such an obvious way, but there's a lot of internalised misogyny on MN and they're not all the 'older generation'.

Some women fall over themselves to blame women for some abuse or neglectful behaviour by their husbands or sexist behaviour by work colleagues. You must have seen on MN, it happens all the time.

It's not much of a stretch to think they'd be telling women to get more organised rather than actually think the DH should step up more.

Incidentally my mother in law used to PA buy me cook books!

Squeezita · 17/12/2021 10:19

@NMC2022

My dad is 72 and does everything. When I say everything, my mum won't get her own glass of water or dry a dish All the cooking, cleaning, life admin, everything - my dad does it all. That's what I grew up with probably why I'm single as I have high expectations Grin
Your poor dad! Is your mum ill or something?
TabithaTiger · 17/12/2021 10:17

It's annoying, but remember that DMs and MILs are just a product of their time. I'm sure our future DILs will roll their eyes at some of the things we say. What's the norm to us now will seem dated in 30 years time!

It's worth remembering that, although modern men do seem to be able to cook and care for their children, in the majority of households, women do carry the bulk of the mental load still! We're not as liberated as we may think!

MajesticallyAwkward · 17/12/2021 10:14

I remember by DGM being horrified when she found out me and DH split the cooking and cleaning and I don't have a meal on the table ready for the hard working man coming home from work. The outrage when she called and I said DH was ironing 😁

I asked if she thought he should have food on the table for me because he was home an hour earlier. I've also had to point out that having a sahp is a luxury, our mortgage is significantly higher than my grandparents and parents (my parents house was £17k, ours £130!) and everything costs more so we need 2 incomes. It's a very outdated view of 'wife work' and definitely doesn't fit with a 2 income family that we all need to challenge.

NMC2022 · 17/12/2021 10:13

My dad is 72 and does everything. When I say everything, my mum won't get her own glass of water or dry a dish
All the cooking, cleaning, life admin, everything - my dad does it all. That's what I grew up with probably why I'm single as I have high expectations Grin

TheVanguardSix · 17/12/2021 10:12

I mean, if you're literally standing in the kitchen popping the fish fingers in the oven and peas on the hob and she's asking, "So what's mummy cooking for tea?" I see no problem with that (other than visual problems for not noticing the fish fingers). That would be chit-chat/small talk.
But if she's regularly asking this while you're at work or you're on the sofa and your nose is in a book/you're netflix and chilling, or you're just doing fuck all and not donning the apron, ball, and chain, it IS a loaded, passive-aggressive, MIL question.

I've never been asked this, so I don't see a huge issue. But if I were regularly asked this, hell if I had my MIL in my house often enough to ask this... or my OWN mother for that matter... it would drive me up the wall.

Swipe left for the next trending thread