Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset at not getting thank you note to acknowledge presents

364 replies

Londonlassie12 · 17/12/2021 00:25

My dd is in an elite team sport & last Xmas & this Xmas I sent her coaches (5 in total) lovely gifts I would be delighted to recieve (yankee candle gift set.. Full sized jar with 3 little candles ) Not one of the coaches text to say thanks... Dd brought them to training last Monday... I'm very disheartened... DH is more pragmatic, his theory is we pay a fortune for training, a card & bottle of wine should suffice & I should stop acting as if we owe anymore... Aibu to be upset at not having the (expensive) gifts acknowledged?

OP posts:
larkle · 17/12/2021 06:06

None of my friends and family use scented candles anymore. They are not a brilliant choice of present, no matter how kind the intention. Stick to food or drink next time

larkle · 17/12/2021 06:03

'Most scented candles contain paraffin wax, which is derived from petroleum, coal or shale oil. When it's burnt, paraffin wax releases toxic compounds into the air, including acetone, benzene, and toluene – all known carcinogens. So not only are they damaging the environment but our health, too.11 Oct 2019'

GiltEdges · 17/12/2021 06:00

*if you're giving them with the expectation of being told how wonderful the presents are, I think you might be looking at this the wrong way.

You're presumably giving them presents to show your appreciation of the effort they've put into their coaching, rather than to be thanked or appreciated yourself.*

Completely agree with all of this. The overly extravagant gifts actually seem to be more of a desperate plea from you to be acknowledged /liked by these people. Unfortunately that isn't how gift giving works, you can't buy people. Particularly not with £35 worth of Yankee candles, which won't be to everyone's taste.

Listen to your DH and stop wasting your time, money and headspace on this.

Corbally · 17/12/2021 06:00

@LoveGrooveDanceParty

This is Mumsnet, so of course everyone is going to tell you YABU.

Whereas in the real world (or at least my real world), you thank people for gifts. It’s really rude not to.

I would definitely be scaling down the gifts in future.

But presumably they thanked the OP’s DD when they were given? I agree that thank you messages are for when you can’t thank someone in person. I wouldn’t expect one from a coach any more than I would a teacher. I’m puzzled as to why you keep repeating that you ‘give 100%’ to your child’s activity, drive her all over the country, and pay her fees on time — you’re presumably doing that because your DD loves the sport, not to do the coaches a favour?

(Off-topic, but can a seven year old really be in an ‘elite team sport’?)

lockdownalli · 17/12/2021 05:58

I don't understand.

I would only send a text or note to someone if they had sent me a present. Your DD gave the coaches their gifts and they will have thanked her in person.

It would be weird to follow that up with an additional text.

MimiDaisy11 · 17/12/2021 05:56

It is tone deaf to single out some parents on social media and not others. Though like others say as your gift is wrapped they may be waiting to open it on Christmas. Ask your daughter if they opened it.

You probably wouldn’t be feeling this anxious if you’d given them some wine. Also you took a risk getting some scented candles. Many people wouldn’t realise how expensive they are or like them.

Kokeshi123 · 17/12/2021 05:50

I think posting some gifts on SM but not others is quite rude. Also, I would have messaged the person online and thanked them, if it was their kid who handed the gift over. A written note is probably a bit much to expect though.

Tabbypawpaw · 17/12/2021 05:39

Do you think they’re waiting to see you at next week’s training? But I agree OP, it is basic good manners to get a message to you saying thanks, regardless of whether they like it or not.

Honeymint · 17/12/2021 05:30

I understand the upset, I think I’d feel a bit upset myself. But also I expect they said thank you to your daughter on receiving the gifts?

When I was younger my mum always made me send thank you cards to anyone I hadn’t been able to thank in person. I still send them now, but I feel like I’m the only one who does. (I’m my family / friend group anyway)

Then posting some gifts on social media and not others is a bit tone deaf though.

From now on if you still want to get them anything I’d stick to something small.

larkle · 17/12/2021 05:14

You sound as if you are trying to do the right thing, OP. It is a shame because you would clearly love a set of scented candles.
However, many people don't use scented candles any more because they are carcinogenic.
I agree with your husband that the right present would be something to eat or drink that the coaches can share with each other..
Try not to be anxious and next time spend the money on yourself

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/12/2021 05:12

You really have spent far too much on something, which not everyone likes - I don’t, especially Yankee as they smell so strongly. Additionally, not everyone can even safely burn candles, maybe they have small kids or the smell and / or the flickering light can set a migraine off. I suffer from migraines.

What I could suggest is that next year you buy something a lot cheaper as a token gift. What sort of thing were the coaches thanking people for? Perhaps you could choose something more like that.

I think you have broken the first rule of gift giving; the gift is for the benefit of the receiver, not for the giver. As for thank yous, perhaps you have more time or more energy to thank people. They possibly have full lives, working (or other commitments) then training kids in the evenings. I always gave gifts to teachers with no expectation of a thank you. They were far too busy for this.

Theremoresefulday · 17/12/2021 05:09

Did they thank your daughter when she handed them over?

SuPerDoPer · 17/12/2021 05:03

We don't give gifts for the praise surely? We give people gifts that we think they will like to acknowledge that we love or appreciate them in some way. I think you've got this all wrong - you've given gifts that you would like to recieve, do you know that these people like candles? I don't and I would definitely feel awkward at receiving a deliberately expensive looking present. I'd probably re-gift or sell them on market place. I think saying thank you once, when you recieve the gift, is sufficient and there's no need to repeat this just because the giver has been overly generous. I think your DP is right, scale down the generosity and stop expecting praise for giving an unnecessarily expensive present.

camperqueen54 · 17/12/2021 04:55

This type of gift giving and the reactions you expect from others are what really puts me of Christmas tbh!

Dita73 · 17/12/2021 04:54

You are massively overreacting. If they said thank you when they were given the presents then that’s fine. If you don’t get the reaction or response you want when you give gifts then you probably shouldn’t give them if it’s going to make you so upset

Rainbowabacus1 · 17/12/2021 04:52

I totally get it op and think you have been incredibly generous to them all. Next year, I’d go to home bargains and get them some bits. You can fill a gift bag for about £5 per person Smile

ScotInExile · 17/12/2021 04:48

An elite sports team at 7 years old? What kind of sport does a 7 year old compete in at an elite level?

WeAreTheHeroes · 17/12/2021 04:45

@anotheronenow - the YC website does have candles that cost what the OP spent: full size jar candles are £24.99 and a set of three small votives is £9.99. Why do some posters try to make out the OP is lying?

It is rude not to say thank you and to only thank some people publicly. There's no way I would spend so much on these coaches though. If you ever want to give them a gift again, take your lead from what they seem to have appreciated more and certainly don't spend that kind of money ever again.

anotheronenow · 17/12/2021 04:34

Yankee Candles website doesn't have anything for 35.00 OP is there any chance you got ripped off somewhere?

So I feel like you, it's so rude and entitled when you buy a nice gift and don't get it acknowledged.

But, like a lot of the PP's I find fragrance a very personal thing and I would not like a scented candles gift set. perhaps most importantly, I would think you'd spent less than a tenner (why I was looking at the website thinking man, these are some pricey candles).

So agree with your DH. Cheapo plonk next time, if anything!

Chin up, you live and learn eh?

flyingant · 17/12/2021 04:27

I would assume the coaches think that saying thank you to the child handing them the gift is enough.

ImustLearn2Cook · 17/12/2021 04:17

@Londonlassie12 Try not to be hurt. If they said thank you to your dd at the time of receiving the gifts then I presume that if you were there they would have thanked you too. But if you weren’t there I presume that they would have thought thanking your dd was enough and it would be passed on.

When they thanked specific parents on social media for their gifts was it before you gave your gift?

Hoolihan · 17/12/2021 04:15

You think this is a really nice gift but many people wouldn't, especially for the second year running! However they should say thank you regardless - as others have said perhaps they thanked your daughter at the time. Have you asked her?

Evergreenblue · 17/12/2021 04:14

Did they ask for gifts or ask you to spend so much? If not then I don't see what your issue is, you should be teaching your child that gifts are tokens of affection, given without any expectation of recompense.
It sounds more like you are using gifts as a way to prove status and demand recognition. It's nice if they initially say thank you but you are putting way touch focus on demanding personal recognition for spending so much, that's just grabby and crass. The gift of giving should be reward enough 🤔.

TyrannosaurusRegina · 17/12/2021 04:13

PS I love yankee candles! I think they are just one of the 'in' things on MN to complain about.

TyrannosaurusRegina · 17/12/2021 04:09

If the gift was from your daughter and they thanked your daughter when she handed them over (I'm assuming they didn't just grab them out of her hands and say nothing) then that's sufficient surely?