Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset at not getting thank you note to acknowledge presents

364 replies

Londonlassie12 · 17/12/2021 00:25

My dd is in an elite team sport & last Xmas & this Xmas I sent her coaches (5 in total) lovely gifts I would be delighted to recieve (yankee candle gift set.. Full sized jar with 3 little candles ) Not one of the coaches text to say thanks... Dd brought them to training last Monday... I'm very disheartened... DH is more pragmatic, his theory is we pay a fortune for training, a card & bottle of wine should suffice & I should stop acting as if we owe anymore... Aibu to be upset at not having the (expensive) gifts acknowledged?

OP posts:
tara66 · 17/12/2021 07:32

A verbal 'thank you' to your daughter when giving the gifts is enough 'thank you'.

furbabymama87 · 17/12/2021 07:30

You chose to spend that amount on them with no real idea of what their personal likes are, so if you feel deflated that's on you. As long as they thanked you when they received the gifts, that's enough. It's a bit strange that they would thank some people on social media and not others but that may have just been an over sight.

SamMil · 17/12/2021 07:28

I imagine they thanked your daughter when she gave it to them?

Grimbelina · 17/12/2021 07:28

Surely if your gift is a 'thank you' to someone (in this case for the coaching) and not a surprise or birthday gift then there isn't the expectation of receiving a thanks back (thanks for the thank you?) apart from when it is handed over. Presumably they did thank your daughter. That should be enough.

Dentistlakes · 17/12/2021 07:27

I can understand why you feel deflated op. However, when it comes to teachers and coaches, I always think a gift from the whole class/squad works best. Sometimes gifts from individuals can make people feel uncomfortable, especially if they are very generous. Maybe next time see if you can organise something from all the children and just make a modest contribution?

WonderfulYou · 17/12/2021 07:25

YABU the candles are a lovely idea but you shouldn’t be spending that much on your child’s coaches so they probably felt they couldn’t share the photos like they did with other gifts.

I would always say thank you but I’m assuming they would have said this when they were handed over?
I don’t think they need to then contact you again to say thank you again - it sounds like you gave them for the wrong reasons and not simply as a thank you to them.

Somersetlady · 17/12/2021 07:24

@Lanique

It is rude not to acknowledge a gift, whether it is liked or not. I'm staggered by the number of MNers who seem to think their rudeness is justified because 'they too wouldn't like scented candles' entitled, much? Such bad manners.

Op YANBU to be upset, especially as some gifts have been acknowledged on SM, but YABU to spend so much. I get the feeling its the kind of club where the parents are more competitive than the kids? These types of elite clubs usually are more about the parents than the children. Next year, take a step back and get them a small token.

I don’t believe we have been told the gift wasn’t acknowledged @Lanique or that the child wasn’t thanked at the time of giving just that the OP hasn’t received a personal thank you text!

The social media thing is odd but maybe they did they do individual posts or one picture of the gifts with a thank you but you can’t see the candles?

Snoken · 17/12/2021 07:23

They probably thanked your DD when they received the gift, so for me that would count as a thank you and I would not expect any additional thanks after that.

I think it's nice that you want to give them gifts but I think £35/pp is a little much. Spend that money on yourself or DD going forward instead. Yankee candles are really not everyones cup of tea and it feels horrible when you get an expensive gift and you don't like it. It's such a waste. A voucher would have been better.

FetchezLaVache · 17/12/2021 07:22

Thanking your daughter in person (as we assume must be the case) but not sending you a text is a bit rude, but not a massive biggie.

Thanking some parents for their gifts but not others on social media, however, is disgustingly rude.

Just get them a £5 bottle of wine next time. If they notice the difference in the monetary value of their gifts, they may make the connection with their lack of grace.

SaltedCaramelHC · 17/12/2021 07:21

I always assume that gifts are meant to be "from" the children, so I thank the children there and in person. I wouldn't then thank the parents, as that's then sort of acknowledging that it's not really from the child in the same way. I know it's a pretence that the child arranged it, but it's part of gift giving. I wouldn't always then thank the mum - which assumes that it was her job rather than the dad's - though if the parent collected the child and I had a chance, I might thank them as well. Or if I had something by email from a parent's account, I'd write back to them to say thanks. But otherwise, thanking the child is perfectly normal.

I wouldn't change my thanks depending how expensive a present it was. I wouldn't even know a Yankee candle was expensive. I thought it was a cheaper version of a fancy candle, but I really don't know.

I would think that if they are thanking me for teaching or coaching their child, and I then thank the child for a gift, that is enough back-and-forth. Otherwise, they might then have to reply to my thank you card/text and then I'd feel obliged to reply to their reply, which would undoubtedly wish me good holidays or ask how things were, and then I'd wish them that in return, and then they'd probably acknowledge that, and so on!!

Much simpler to thank the child in person, and to assume that the parents wanted to thank me in the first place and weren't doing it for acknowledgement. I do appreciate them hugely, so I would not assume that a lack of an additional thanks means that they do not appreciate them.

I'd never put them on social media, and especially not where others could see; that does seem wrong to me. A gift to the club as a whole or something, maybe, but not in the way you've described.

Comtesse · 17/12/2021 07:14

We put £20 in the collection for the main teacher gifts this year for each kid which at 2 x £20 seems plenty to me. 5 x £35 is a shed load of money for people who have a lot less impact on your daughter’s life. It’s kind of you, but your DH is right, pull it way back next year.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 17/12/2021 07:13

You sound very thoughtful op and I can understand why you feel rubbish about it. I expect you're wondering what you did wrong - don't they like you, don't they like dd, did you miss the mark with the gift?

But speaking as a teacher who receives gifts from pupils at Christmas, I can tell you that I only send written thank yous to those I haven't thanked in person. So I would thank the pupil when they handed it over, and the parent if I saw them at the door.

If I receive a gift from an ex pupil or a child who is at home for some reason, I would send a thank you message.

So for that reason I think you are overthinking this. They thanked your dd when she handed them over and will probably thank you when they see you.

It is a bit rubbish to post pictures on sm though. It's really quite a slap to those who didn't send a gift at all. What sort of gifts did they put on sm? I am just wondering if they were particularly funny or warranted a share in some other way.

The only thing I did wonder was whether you are the sort of person who seeks to buy privilege for your child - did you think expensive gifts would make you better than the other parents? Because, if you are that type of person, they might have seen through it and not want to acknowledge.

gofg · 17/12/2021 07:13

I agree that they are showing a lack of even basic manners by not sending a quick text to thank you for the gifts. However, I would be agreeing with your DH in future years and either not give a gift, or just something little and inexpensive. Actually, I wouldn't bother giving a gift at all.

LizzieSiddal · 17/12/2021 07:10

I too think it’s rude not to acknowledge a gift, a tact takes seconds.
And if they’ve thanked some parents in SM and not you then that is very rude.

(I would add that I find Yankee Candles absolutely awful, the smell really attacks my nostrils! But that shouldn’t affect whether or not you get an acknowledgement for the gift.)

wtaf37 · 17/12/2021 07:10

Yankee candles?

Somersetlady · 17/12/2021 07:09

@Londonlassie12

Thanks for understanding, I'm so upset here, we give 100% to our child's activity, drive her all over the country, always pay her fees on time.. Always try our best to give a nice gift at Christmas & it's not appreciated... I do think hubby's probably right & I need to stop acting like we owe them more than term fees...
You do this for Your child’s benefit not for the coaches???
Lanique · 17/12/2021 07:07

It is rude not to acknowledge a gift, whether it is liked or not. I'm staggered by the number of MNers who seem to think their rudeness is justified because 'they too wouldn't like scented candles' entitled, much? Such bad manners.

Op YANBU to be upset, especially as some gifts have been acknowledged on SM, but YABU to spend so much. I get the feeling its the kind of club where the parents are more competitive than the kids? These types of elite clubs usually are more about the parents than the children. Next year, take a step back and get them a small token.

Somersetlady · 17/12/2021 07:06

•love not live

Joystir59 · 17/12/2021 07:06

I give all candles received to the charity shop. I can't stand them. Stop!

Somersetlady · 17/12/2021 07:06

I coach an elite sport I can’t imagine getting excited about a Yankee candle set that you obviously live but I don’t.

I am sure the coach thanked your daughter verbally when she handed over the present and will do the same with you if they don’t text.

Maybe they haven’t even opened it yet?

NotAnotherCrapHamper · 17/12/2021 07:04
  1. Putting on social media is unbelievably rude.
NotAnotherCrapHamper · 17/12/2021 07:03
  1. Did they say thank-you at the time? Notes are usually for gifts given in absentia
  2. Lots of people dont unwrap until Christmas Day. I was a Headteacher and most of my staff put gift under their trees at home
  3. You cant write 30 plus thank-you cards. Often there isnt a gift label or a card with the giver is detached from the present. As a teacher I tried for a few years but had to admit defeat (plus my time and the cost)
  4. People being snooty about Yankee candles are just wanting to feel superior. Not what I would choose but perfectly acceptable as a gift to someone that you dont know well.
rattlemehearties · 17/12/2021 07:02

This is bizarre - a gift for teacher (coach in this case) is a thank you gift, so they shouldn't thank you for the thank you... Sorry OP but YABU

CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory · 17/12/2021 07:02

I don't say this often on Mumsnet, but.... your DH is right.

rrhuth · 17/12/2021 07:00

@Londonlassie12

The sets were 35 quid each & dd helped me wrap them & she did the cards.. I feel deflated.. If anyone gives me anything ever I send a thank you immediately.... it's just nice... DH say I need to stop acting like we owe them something, tuition is costing a fortune
£35 each?!!

You are spending more on these people than I spend on my parents!