Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset at not getting thank you note to acknowledge presents

364 replies

Londonlassie12 · 17/12/2021 00:25

My dd is in an elite team sport & last Xmas & this Xmas I sent her coaches (5 in total) lovely gifts I would be delighted to recieve (yankee candle gift set.. Full sized jar with 3 little candles ) Not one of the coaches text to say thanks... Dd brought them to training last Monday... I'm very disheartened... DH is more pragmatic, his theory is we pay a fortune for training, a card & bottle of wine should suffice & I should stop acting as if we owe anymore... Aibu to be upset at not having the (expensive) gifts acknowledged?

OP posts:
Medievalist · 17/12/2021 07:59

But OP, the coaches will have thanked your daughter when she gave the gift. It's not normal to thank twice and in two different ways. The gift was from her and they thanked her.

@saraclara - this has already been said by many others on this thread.

underneaththeash · 17/12/2021 07:58

That wouldn't be my idea of a good gift unfortunately....
Having said that it's still quite rude not to send a text.

cherrytreecottage · 17/12/2021 07:58

Given they've posted about other gifts you can assume they have opened them but regardless of whether you're into candles or not, you've gone out of your way to spend time and money on them - I'd absolutely be sending a quick thank you note. YANBU.

Medievalist · 17/12/2021 07:56

@dudsville - wow, your brother was bloody rude! You clearly weren't asking to be thanked again, but asking a totally reasonable question!

IAAP · 17/12/2021 07:55

Sorry to the original OP if they said thanks to your daughter that would be enough for me

saraclara · 17/12/2021 07:55

I don't know why so many posters feel the need to tell OP (who's already said she has anxiety) that they think her choice of gift is rubbish. It's unnecessary and unkind. Yankee candles are popular so clearly lots of people like them.

But OP, the coaches will have thanked your daughter when she gave the gift. It's not normal to thank twice and in two different ways. The gift was from her and they thanked her.

rookiemere · 17/12/2021 07:54

Teachers get paid though, coaches usually don't. For that reason I give a bit more to the football coaches and scouts leaders than I do to the teacher. DSs football coaches ( he has stopped now) were young lads who gave up a full evening and a Sunday morning. They could have got a second job instead during that time.

Newnameobviously · 17/12/2021 07:53

I think YABU. My internal rule for presents is to send a written thank you, by text or mail if the giver wasn't there when I received it. If they give it to me in person and I open it in the spot the verbal thank yous are enough. So by my rules it's likely they thanked your daughter in person when she gave them the present or they are sitting under the tree and haven't been opened yet.

The only exception to this would be if it was an absolutely amazing, thoughtful, well chosen gift. Then I might follow up the verbal thank you with a text or card later on. This wouldn't be to thank them for the gift as much as to thank them for their thoughtfulness.

I also think you are confusing the material cost of the present to you with the value of it to the recipient. They cost you a lot of money so you are expecting a lot of gratitude. It doesn't work like that. One expensive gift set given to 5 different people with nothing in common except their job is not thoughtful. It's bordering in the transactional. I have been given many expensive candle sets over the years and all but one of them (which happened to be to my taste) went straight to the charity shop. However gifts that have prompted a second thank you have included 2 beautifully gift wrapped bars of a particular supermarket own brand chocolate (the giver had noticed I liked them months before and remembered). I was very touched by that. The cost of the 2 bars was £3.90 but the thought was priceless. And my BFF once bought me a secondhand poster from EBay for a band I liked when I was young. The cost was tiny, I think they paid as much in postage as they did for the poster but the effort and thought that had gone into it was huge.

I'd lay off the presents next year. Giving is supposed to make you feel happy not resentful.

Twixxed · 17/12/2021 07:53

I think that gifts for teachers etc are given as a kind of thank you from the parent/child, so it's not really necessary to say thank you for the thank you iyswim

schoolsoutforever · 17/12/2021 07:53

I just think people are too obsessed with gift giving and thank yous. Perhaps they’d rather not receive the gift rather than be expected to send a thank you (sorry, it’s going to sound ungrateful but I would rather not receive gifts in that sense). I just think the world has gone crazy with commercialism, gift giving and then expecting a pat on the back in return. Gift manufacturers (candle makers?) are doing very well out of this strange unnecessary cycle. I’m a teacher and would MUCH prefer a quick thank you email if it was genuine and I would respond to that. No need for presents and I’d rather not to have to send lots of thank yous on a busy end of term when I’ve a million other things to do. Sorry grump over. In regard to the social media aspect, seems odd to thank some on there but not all but that is the horror that is social media - preys on ‘popularity’ etc. Just become an old grouch, send no presents and you’ll never be disappointed (only half joking).

Porcupineintherough · 17/12/2021 07:52

@RichardMarxisinnocent since when does one only thank people for gifts one likes?

IAAP · 17/12/2021 07:51

@Comtesse

We put £20 in the collection for the main teacher gifts this year for each kid which at 2 x £20 seems plenty to me. 5 x £35 is a shed load of money for people who have a lot less impact on your daughter’s life. It’s kind of you, but your DH is right, pull it way back next year.
I donated £20 to the teacher collection of a £60 voucher there was no suggested amount it is a highly affluent area and very well off parents and a good class teacher - class of 30 - 20 contributions ‘comments in the card from all families who donated’ I won’t be doing that next year - I give to the teacher direct next year not because she’s not a good teacher - but because I want it to reflect what we put in from a thought wise and money wise
MrsLarry · 17/12/2021 07:51

I think you're massively over thinking. If likely be slightly put out that someone didn't thank me, but then I'd think nothing more about it. The fact you're so upset and posting on a public forum is just wierd. Sounds more like you think you've done an amazing thing and you want to be covered in glory. You say you have anxiety, do you also have some narcissistic tendencies?

dudsville · 17/12/2021 07:47

I agree with those that say you don't need to give so much, and you've already taken that on board. I just sympathise with being excited about giving a gift only for it to go unacknowledged. I gave my brother a nice bottle of whiskey once. He thanked me immediately upon opening but it wasn't the time to open the bottle. As I wasn't a whisky drinker at the time and didn't know if the bottle I got was good I asked him about it later, and his response was "I didn't realise I had to thank you twice". I was so embarrassed, I wasn't seeking accolades, but it's true I was seeking to know if it was truly enjoyed.

The only time I don't say thank you is when I get things from my ex as I'm now trying to "grey rock" him. It's so uncomfortable.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 17/12/2021 07:47

@Ionlydomassiveones

If someone gave me a load of Yankee candles I’d be silent too. Your DH is completely right.
Me too. I have a phobia of fire and never use candles in my home. A gift of candles would be totally useless to me.
Haveyoubrushedyourteethtoday · 17/12/2021 07:47

I’d send a thanks text. It make sure I spoke to you when next you dropped off the child. I’d consider it rude not to. It’s not like a 7 year old put thought or money or effort into it. So while I’d thank the child, I’d thank you too.

3luckystars · 17/12/2021 07:46

They probably were overwhelmed with gifts and didn’t know who gave what. I find it extremely difficult if I am landed with a load of gifts, I can’t remember anything and wouldn’t know who to thank the next day, so I stopped having birthday parties years ago!

If you want to give them a gift, and there is no need to do this, if one coach made a really big impact on your child, I would write them a letter when your child is finished with the club and give them a thank you gift then. Christmas gifts like this are all forgotten about or regifted by the new year.
I would not expect a thank you card or a text or any acknowledgement for this. Sorry you feel you wasted your money but it was a nice thing to do.

rookiemere · 17/12/2021 07:45

And although the price shouldn't matter, I'm flabbergasted that some Yankee Candles cost £35, I'd assume they'd be on a par with a Body Shop gift box so £10-20 max.
If you're giving a gift to someone you don't know then surely something less specific is good, or if you must go down the candle route, then a wee candle and a voucher or money. I always used to give the coaches amazon vouchers so they could get what they wanted.

cookiemonster2468 · 17/12/2021 07:44

@Londonlassie12

Thanks for the replies, yes I think that's the end of the gifts, I spent 35 quid each on 5 coaches so 175 quid😢 a simple thanks for acknowledging would be nice...
They probably have no idea that you spent so much on candles.
DontTellThemYourNamePike · 17/12/2021 07:43

I don't think how much the gifts cost and the fact that they are Yankee candles is relevant. A thank you for any gift is polite and if I was in the position of your DD's coach and received a thoughtful gift, I would say thank you to the parent. I don't think it's worth getting upset over though (even though I would be a bit miffed myself!)

On another note, scented candles aren't everyone's idea of a welcome gift. We can't have them in the house because DP and DS2 have asthma and they can cause problems, particularly for DP.

onelittlefrog · 17/12/2021 07:40

@rookiemere

This is where I find etiquette so complicated. You bought the gifts to say thank you to the coaches for presumably giving up their time for free. Now you're in a snit because they didn't say thank you back. Where does it end ? I'd suggest people not giving gifts in future if it's so dependent on getting a thank you.
Yes I agree.

You don't give gifts to expect things in return, even a thank you note.

If you want to give a gift then you give a gift and that's the end of it.

cookiemonster2468 · 17/12/2021 07:37

Personally I hate Yankee candles and think they're a bit of a tacky gift!

But regardless of that... I think if your daughter gave a gift in person they will have said thank you to her. I wouldn't then expect a thank you card.

Also people who don't buy yankee candles themselves won't necessarily know how expensive they are... they're just candles. They might not actually know you have spent extra on them.

StruggleStreet · 17/12/2021 07:37

I said YABU because I thought you were expecting a handwritten note, YANBU to expect a text or some sort of acknowledgment, maybe they just haven’t got around to it yet though.

£35 is a lot of money, I don’t spend that on close relatives. Maybe scale it back next year or just give them a card, you pay them for the job they do, I don’t see why you feel you need to get them a gift.

My children are still really young so I don't know what the etiquette is for teachers, etc but this seems excessive.

Rollmopsrule · 17/12/2021 07:36

It was rude of them to single out certain gifts on social media. No more expensive gifts for them just a card next year. Your DD will be non the wiser though and it was nice to involve her her giving the gifts.

rookiemere · 17/12/2021 07:36

This is where I find etiquette so complicated.
You bought the gifts to say thank you to the coaches for presumably giving up their time for free. Now you're in a snit because they didn't say thank you back. Where does it end ?
I'd suggest people not giving gifts in future if it's so dependent on getting a thank you.