Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH is selfish denying the DC Christmas?

486 replies

ohganggang · 16/12/2021 21:35

Been together 7 years, married for 5. We have a 4 year old DD, a 2 year old DS and I'm pregnant with out 3rd. DH was raised as a Jehovah's Witness, they do not celebrate Christmas as they believe it is satanic. The religion has a shunning policy and DH got shunned by his family and friends when it came out he was in a relationship with a non-JW (me) at the start of our relationship as that is forbidden. He is essentially dead to his mum, dad and siblings.

DH had stopped believing in the religion long before I came on the scene and was just keeping up pretenses for his family until he got found out. He is now as atheist as they come. He has a lot of religious trauma from his childhood, from growing up believing the world was about to end, watching the kids at his school celebrating Christmas and 'knowing' they were going to be killed in Armageddon for it (they teach that God will kill literally everybody who isn't a JW, no exceptions), being taught that the world is run by Satan etc etc. He lived his childhood in perpetual fear. I have advised him to seek counselling and he won't.

He now rejects anything to do with religion, and can't be doing with Christmas. He actually gets depressed every year around the Christmas season and says it's because it brings up the trauma of his childhood. Because of this, we've never bothered with Christmas together. For the first couple of years of the relationship before living together, marriage and DC I'd just go to my family on Christmas Day as usual. Christmas 2017 after DD was born, we stayed home and did nothing and it was the first year I didn't do anything for Christmas. Me and DH had a conversation that year and he said he doesn't want to do Christmas with our kids as it will trigger his trauma and remind him of the childhood joy he missed out on. He also wants the kids to be completely atheist and have nothing to do with religion. I accepted that.

But DD is now 4, and in pre-school, and the pre-school is making a huge deal out of Christmas coming up soon. I find this problematic because obviously it causes issues for families like mine but we're in a small town with not much cultural diversity so I think they've assumed all of the kids will be celebrating at home. They absolutely haven't considered some families might not be celebrating Christmas and I've debated raising a complaint, but that's another thread. Naturally, the talk of a Christmas nativity, the kids being hyped up about an upcoming Christmas 'party' and general encouragement for the kids to talk about Christmas among themselves, has resulted in DD getting excited for Christmas.

I have told DH today that I don't think it's fair on the kids and that I don't think it's right to project his trauma on to the kids. To me it seems like a case of "I didn't get to have Christmas so why should my kids?". I do understand his trauma though. I tried to compromise saying we don't have to decorate the house but I am doing presents for the kids and me and the kids will go to my parents on the day to celebrate and he can stay at home. He says no, that he isn't comfortable with his kids having "that religious bullshit in their lives". I'm really annoyed with him.

OP posts:
LittleMysSister · 17/12/2021 10:04

Christmas is no longer about religion for most people, I think he is not wanting to celebrate because it obviously brings back the pain of being left out of the celebrations himself when he was a child.

However:

Me and DH had a conversation that year and he said he doesn't want to do Christmas with our kids as it will trigger his trauma and remind him of the childhood joy he missed out on.

Surely he can see that he is creating the same upset for his children by making them miss out too?

He could live the rest of his life having lovely Christmases with his family, rather than dwelling on the pain of his past. I hope you manage to talk him round, for your children's sake and his.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 17/12/2021 10:00

What a selfish, selfish man. Your poor kids! So it triggers his trauma of not getting to enjoy Christmas, so he stops his kids from being able to enjoy Christmas?!?! Nasty man

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 17/12/2021 09:57

Should have said that I wasn't bothered by not celebrating Christmas even though my friends did, but this is different because he is doing it as a (harmful) strategy to manage his own trauma. He's making the children carry his burden for him.

HoppingPavlova · 17/12/2021 09:57

I’d ignore him and push on with whatever you want to do with the kids. As long as you keep it ‘cultural’ and not religious he hasn’t got a leg to stand on with his complaints and can go whistle Dixie. I’d suggest he go out for the day if it bothers him.

Rainartist · 17/12/2021 09:56

Meant to add my dh made an effort for the kids particularly on the day and especially when young and excited, they wouldn't know he was struggling with it all.

You don't have to go all out Christmastastic, but like you said the children will have a worse time doing nothing now they know what other kids do do. Do what you want, whether that's Christmas at yours or going to your family.

HotelCaliforniaOnRepeat · 17/12/2021 09:55

I'm atheist. My immediate family are agnostic or atheist - so religion does not feature.
My Xmas is all about family & friends - people we appreciate in our lives. It's about treating each other well and particularly in current times just enjoying ourselves and recharging our batteries.
I think your dh is being unfair to the dc and passing his problems down. IMO it's straightforward- some people believe x, some believe y; we are doing z. Kids don't need anything too in depth at that age, but no Christmas will take more explaining than having your own version.
Make it what you want your Xmas to be.

Derbee · 17/12/2021 09:54

It’s not just about Christmas. Your DH is being massively selfish by not dealing with his trauma, and making his family carry the weight of it, whilst he obsesses with a new cult (in this case, ex JW propaganda).

Just make clear to him that your children are celebrating Christmas. If he doesn’t like it, tough. Your compromise can be to go to your parents. If he’s still not happy, he can leave. Don’t saddle your children with your husbands trauma.

he said he doesn't want to do Christmas with our kids as it will trigger his trauma and remind him of the childhood joy he missed out on

He’s doing the same to his children. He is the epitome of selfish

Rainartist · 17/12/2021 09:53

Yanbu - my dh hates Christmas for different reasons but it also brings up childhood traumas. If left to him he'd get them a present or two like birthdays (not stockings Santa etc) but I'm not sure he'd do anymore, maybe a tree if kids nagged him idk.

I do most of it and I'm happy to. Your dh does sound like he's of the whole I suffered so you should suffer mentality which is abusive imo.

Firstly Christmas is actually based on a pagan festival of bringing light into the darkest part of the year, the Christians monopolised it. Secondly it is a secular festival for most people these days, people I know of other cultures and religion do something for the time/day, even if it's only having the bank holiday off, watching TV and eating nice food.

I think you need to make a stand against him if you want your dc to celebrate, why does his miserable opinion trump yours?

sashh · 17/12/2021 09:50

OP your DH needs counselling.

I'm celebrating Winter Solstice next Tuesday.

There will be food and drink and fun.

I'm atheist but usually do something with the pagan calendar because I like to mark the turning of the year.

I think if you want to raise atheist children then exposing them to as many different cultural and religious experiences works better than ignoring things.

Are your children allowed to celebrate birthdays?

guardiansofthegalaxychocs · 17/12/2021 09:49

Also, I think you know this, schools in this country will celebrate Christmas. I taught in schools where we had only a handful of non Muslim children and we still did secular Christmas and taught them what Christians believe. Parents occasionally wanted to talk about it but once they understood it was just about having cultural understanding rather than trying to convert their children, they all allowed their children to participate. We had halal Christmas dinner etc too.

HaveringWavering · 17/12/2021 09:48

This thread makes really sad reading. Putting the specific issue to one side, your husband recognises that he has issues stemming from childhood trauma but flat out refuses to seek help. He sounds like he has a lot to say on the subject of Christmas, his childhood and the JW religion, yet your posts are strangely lacking in detail about what he actually says when you ask him to get counselling. What justification is he actually giving? You need to get him to face up to the fact that he needs help, and you need to act as soon as you possibly can to nip this in the bud before he really damages your children’s childhoods- your eldest is now old enough to be firing clear, lasting memories.

Do not let him get away with stonewalling you.

guardiansofthegalaxychocs · 17/12/2021 09:46

If everything you say about what a kind and loving partner he is, is true then I’d be strategic. Christmas is probably a hugely tense time. So in the new year I would sit him down and let him know that you are concerned that his trauma is now starting to impact the kids. You need him to consider counselling and that you think it would be good for him to be able to talk more. Be up front that you would like to celebrate secular Christmas with the children next year. That you don’t want to discuss it now but you want him to seriously unpick whether denying the kids the fun is what he is trying to achieve.
He’ll likely be ruffled up by the conversation but you then have a year to process together and come up with a plan you can both agree on.

HappydaysArehere · 17/12/2021 09:44

Does he celebrate birthdays by giving cards and presents?
I would definitely celebrate Christmas as much as possible and say you loved Christmas and not celebrating really depresses you. Yes get a tree and presents for the children. It’s important to give children times to look back on and happiness to pass on to their children.

Newmumatlast · 17/12/2021 09:43

*outside thought

Newmumatlast · 17/12/2021 09:42

@ohganggang

Been together 7 years, married for 5. We have a 4 year old DD, a 2 year old DS and I'm pregnant with out 3rd. DH was raised as a Jehovah's Witness, they do not celebrate Christmas as they believe it is satanic. The religion has a shunning policy and DH got shunned by his family and friends when it came out he was in a relationship with a non-JW (me) at the start of our relationship as that is forbidden. He is essentially dead to his mum, dad and siblings.

DH had stopped believing in the religion long before I came on the scene and was just keeping up pretenses for his family until he got found out. He is now as atheist as they come. He has a lot of religious trauma from his childhood, from growing up believing the world was about to end, watching the kids at his school celebrating Christmas and 'knowing' they were going to be killed in Armageddon for it (they teach that God will kill literally everybody who isn't a JW, no exceptions), being taught that the world is run by Satan etc etc. He lived his childhood in perpetual fear. I have advised him to seek counselling and he won't.

He now rejects anything to do with religion, and can't be doing with Christmas. He actually gets depressed every year around the Christmas season and says it's because it brings up the trauma of his childhood. Because of this, we've never bothered with Christmas together. For the first couple of years of the relationship before living together, marriage and DC I'd just go to my family on Christmas Day as usual. Christmas 2017 after DD was born, we stayed home and did nothing and it was the first year I didn't do anything for Christmas. Me and DH had a conversation that year and he said he doesn't want to do Christmas with our kids as it will trigger his trauma and remind him of the childhood joy he missed out on. He also wants the kids to be completely atheist and have nothing to do with religion. I accepted that.

But DD is now 4, and in pre-school, and the pre-school is making a huge deal out of Christmas coming up soon. I find this problematic because obviously it causes issues for families like mine but we're in a small town with not much cultural diversity so I think they've assumed all of the kids will be celebrating at home. They absolutely haven't considered some families might not be celebrating Christmas and I've debated raising a complaint, but that's another thread. Naturally, the talk of a Christmas nativity, the kids being hyped up about an upcoming Christmas 'party' and general encouragement for the kids to talk about Christmas among themselves, has resulted in DD getting excited for Christmas.

I have told DH today that I don't think it's fair on the kids and that I don't think it's right to project his trauma on to the kids. To me it seems like a case of "I didn't get to have Christmas so why should my kids?". I do understand his trauma though. I tried to compromise saying we don't have to decorate the house but I am doing presents for the kids and me and the kids will go to my parents on the day to celebrate and he can stay at home. He says no, that he isn't comfortable with his kids having "that religious bullshit in their lives". I'm really annoyed with him.

He needs to realise he is going to cause them the same trauma but by a different route. He is being like an evangelical Christian but the atheist version. He's treating it dogmatically like it is a religion. He needs to seek therapy to ensure he doesnt traumatise his own children who should be free to make their own choices not ridigly follow his because he says so ... exactly what happened to him. What if they dont want to be atheist? What if they do but want Christmas? He is doing exactly what was done to him - forcing beliefs and customs to their detriment.

As their parent you have a responsibility to your children too. If you think it is negatively impacting them you should put their best interests first not your relationship. If he is unwilling to get therapy and to change, for me my kids would come first and he would get an ultimatum.

He doesnt have to engage in Christmas. But he shouldn't be dictating to his family what they do.

And to be honest yabu expecting school not to do Christmas things when it is part of this country's culture. You are expecting schools not to do activities which compliment the culture of the country majority because of your children. And not because of any religious belief even - because of some odd situation where your husband is traumatised and therefore as a byproduct of his trauma, preventing his children from engaging in something they seem to otherwise want to given you took them for xmas at your family. There will be other children in the school from other religions who are confident and stable in their beliefs and will understand that most people in the UK have Christmas and therefore are perfectly capable of doing Christmas activities without being traumatised or it threatening their beliefs. If it did threaten them, their beliefs quite frankly would be fragile. That's why I've never understood people excluding kids from RE or activities like that - if your beliefs are based on a rational and strong foundation they wouldnt be threatened by outside though and education would they

RedRobyn2021 · 17/12/2021 09:39

@Chocolatewheatos

He's going to do to his kids what his parents did to him. Tell him you're going to do Christmas for the kids. You could even just do present opening and dinner with your family and he doesn't have to go. But your kids shouldn't miss out because he did.
I think this is a bit far

The children will survive not having Christmas, lots of children aren't Christian and don't celebrate Christmas.

His mother abused and traumatised him. He isn't doing that to his children and to say so is clumsy at best.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 17/12/2021 09:35

Seems a bit nonsensical to admit to a traumatic childhood not celebrating Christmas and then inflict the same thing on his own kids.

He needs therapy for his own issues.

Your kids need a normal happy childhood which includes enjoying Christmas.

MMMarmite · 17/12/2021 09:35

Good post @user1471474462

Chocolatewheatos · 17/12/2021 09:34

He's going to do to his kids what his parents did to him.
Tell him you're going to do Christmas for the kids. You could even just do present opening and dinner with your family and he doesn't have to go. But your kids shouldn't miss out because he did.

MMMarmite · 17/12/2021 09:32

@MMMarmite

What I would add, is for people who have never experienced abuse, going to therapy seems like the easiest and most logical thing to do. That's because there isn't really any trauma to uncover or face and process. For this who have been abused, taking a step to engage in therapy and therefore unleash repressed and neatly boxed up emotions is HUGE. The prospect of talking about it can be physically painful. It won't feel like a healthy step, it will feel horrific for him. So expect resistance, empathise but keep pushing. xx

Absolutely. Dealing with trauma is awful. The only thing worse is the consequences of dealing with it Sad

Sorry that should say the consequences of not dealing with it!
RedRobyn2021 · 17/12/2021 09:31

I had a boyfriend when I was 19 (my first love ❤️) whose family were JW and he became atheist too. A lot of what you e said sounds familiar. I have no advice, it's really difficult.

BettyfromBristol · 17/12/2021 09:31

The two JW siblings at my DCs school were the saddest children I have ever known. Unable to form real friendships and removed from so many of the best bits of primary school. I don't think they were bullied but the other children just thought they were weird and mostly ignored them despite the efforts of the staff.

It was also a strain on the school as a TA had to be in a separate room with them for much of the time from October onwards as they weren't allowed to even see the classroom decorations etc. They may as well have been tutored privately.

Earlier this week I had the pleasure to be in a setting where children of many faiths and none were having a Christmas party. They all had a fabulous time at Eid too.

OP, you need to tell your DH that either he gets specialist therapy or he moves out. He does not get to emotionally abuse your children or dictate that his views are more important than yours. My DH is a Christian, I am not, but we worked together to give our DC magical Christmases when they were small.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 17/12/2021 09:30

Your children will be fine until he is in a better headspace not celebrating Christmas, is not the end of the world, I say this as a child who didn’t.

That's not necessarily true, and I say that as someone who never celebrated Christmas as a child though all my friends and schoolmates did.

Their dad having better mental health is more important.

Yes his mental health problems need to be dealt with wherever they come from, but while the children don't have to celebrate with him it's not a good idea to let his MH problems dominate the family. The OP said she was carrying his problems for him, she can't keep doing that and neither can the children. Celebrating with the OP's parents seems a reasonable compromise. This is a boundary issue, his irrational fears that his children will become "religious" shouldn't stop them celebrating even if he can't.

The family can't just wait for him to be in a better headspace, especially not if he is doing nothing to help himself and he seems to be getting worse.

MMMarmite · 17/12/2021 09:30

If you do manage to get him to agree to therapy, do your research and pick a very experienced therapist who has an interest in trauma. General counselling is not going to cut it here.

I recommend The Body Keeps The Score, and Mindsight, to help you understand yourself about how trauma can be healed.

MMMarmite · 17/12/2021 09:28

What I would add, is for people who have never experienced abuse, going to therapy seems like the easiest and most logical thing to do. That's because there isn't really any trauma to uncover or face and process. For this who have been abused, taking a step to engage in therapy and therefore unleash repressed and neatly boxed up emotions is HUGE. The prospect of talking about it can be physically painful. It won't feel like a healthy step, it will feel horrific for him. So expect resistance, empathise but keep pushing. xx

Absolutely. Dealing with trauma is awful. The only thing worse is the consequences of dealing with it Sad