Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fucking appalled by Dr Loftus

61 replies

NewtoHolland · 16/12/2021 20:46

Imagine being a privileged and educated woman and deciding to put your expertise to use in defending rich and powerful rapists and paedophiles. Being paid to essentially tart up facts that most lay people know, that memory changes over time. And using that fact to try to discredit victims accounts. Honestly out of all the things she could do. Bet her mama Is really proud.

AIBU to be appalled by this woman and her grimey choice of job?

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/crime/ghislaine-maxwell-false-memory-witness-b1977599.html%3famp

OP posts:
imthenextinline · 17/12/2021 00:16

Lineofconcepcion

Yes she shouldn't be allowed a lawyer. In fact let's not bother with a trial and imprison her straight away. . .

She isn't a lawyer.

Sorry I misread. I thought we were on the subject of Loftus but the thread appears to have deviated way off course.

imthenextinline · 17/12/2021 00:15

@Lineofconcepcion

Yes she shouldn't be allowed a lawyer. In fact let's not bother with a trial and imprison her straight away. . .
She isn't a lawyer.
Lineofconcepcion · 17/12/2021 00:11

Yes she shouldn't be allowed a lawyer. In fact let's not bother with a trial and imprison her straight away. . .

terrywynne · 17/12/2021 00:06

There was an interesting thread a while back on defence lawyers in realtion to a horrific crime. I don't remember the details but the gist was you want even the worst criminals to have a good defence team because then they can't appeal on the grounds of being denied a fair trial because they didn't have. And that means allowing them to present their expert witnesses. And then the prosecution will try and shed doubt on those witnesses and/or parent their own.

I guess she believes her research and it's a field where there are probably experts who disagree. And maybe the prosecution team will find one of those.

madisonbridges · 17/12/2021 00:02

I haven't read anything about the Maxwell case and know nothing about Dr Loftus but there's a lot of evidence that memories can be very unreliable and can be influenced by a number of factors. The accused is entitled to mount a defence and it's the prosecution's duty to counter that.
Would you feel the same if your child were accused of a crime and an expert had knowledge to prove them innocent but because people had read stuff in a newspaper and "knew" what the facts were, your child was not allowed to use that witness? In any case, if it's so obvious to you that the expert is giving some form of enhanced facts, it will also be obvious to the jury.

BrownMilk · 16/12/2021 23:41

Is it not for the prosecution to challenge or counter what she says? Ultimately, it is the responsibility of the prosecution to make the case and that includes challenging the defence?

Toplowlight · 16/12/2021 23:22

Lawyers don’t have access to some kind of divine foresight which allows them to work out who is lying. That’s what trials are for. Our entire justice system would collapse if lawyers decided who to defend on the basis of who is ‘obviously’ guilty. It’s such an important principle that barristers aren’t actually allowed to refuse to represent someone just because they think they’re ‘obviously’ guilty. The taxi cab rule means they have to take the next case in line, regardless of who the accused is or what the circumstances are, provided they don’t have a conflict of interest. It’s not up to them to decide who they want to represent.

And they don’t act ‘regardless of the truth’. They proceed on the basis that what their client tells them is true, but their first duty is to the court. They can’t tell the court something they know to be untrue.

Dogshark · 16/12/2021 23:19

Sorry- that was to Suzanne999

Dogshark · 16/12/2021 23:18

Your comment is ignorant. Firstly, she isn’t a lawyer.

Defence lawyers in the vast, vast majority of cases aren’t making “huge money”, although I accept that in this (high profile, US) case they inevitably are. It is very common in the uk for the experts (forensic, psychiatric etc) to make more for a days work than the defence team make in several months work.

Legal aid has been consistently eroded in the uk. Few young solicitors/ barristers are choosing it as a profession.

Anyone can be accused of an offence. Just because the police/media believe they are guilty doesn’t mean they are. Would you fancy trial by media if you genuinely believed you were innocent? Defence lawyers don’t lie for their clients, contrary to popular belief.

Actually, anyone can commit an offence. The best example is death by careless driving. I doubt any drivers can say they haven’t been distracted for a few seconds. It is very much a ‘there but for the grave of god’ offence, but can result in a prison sentence of many years. Do you not think you would want a defence team to mitigate on your behalf, and put forward your remorse, the effects on your family etc? That is what lawyers do.

tara66 · 16/12/2021 23:14

So according to her everything we know that is not recorded in some way such as written down or on tape and is therefore a 'memory' may not be/is not true?

CayrolBaaaskin · 16/12/2021 23:02

She is a research scientist whose position is that recovered memories are not reliable. I don’t think we should attack her for her position. Nor should we attack défense lawyers. The purpose of a trial is to hear all relevant evidence before deciding abs to have both the prosecutions and defences position put forward well. It does us credit to have such a system.

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 16/12/2021 23:00

The science of memory is very complex, and there are well-attested instances where it has been demonstrated that it is perfectly possible to plant false memories. Dismissing what Dr Loftus has to say is very simplistic.

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 16/12/2021 22:55

@Suzanne999

I think the lawyers see it more as a ( huge money making) game. I’m winning this one, lost that one etc… I’ve never understood how a lawyer can defend, and try to get off, someone who is obviously an abuser, murderers, rapist. One of the things that put me off my first choice of career as a lawyer.
Nobody knows for certain that a given individual is guilty unless they saw them commit the crime, or unless they admit it - and in the latter case they may still be innocent. If you really think accused people shouldn't be entitled to a defence, read The Secret Barrister.
NewtoHolland · 16/12/2021 22:45

Yep not an anti-justice thread...
Acknowledged very early on that access to a defence team is an essential...

It's really interesting hearing the range of perspectives. I was just hugely hugely annoyed by this today and didn't want to vent on my own social media but wanted to explore if this was a general reaction/ feeling or not. It's been interesting learning a little more about EL and her research in general.

I'm reasonably comfortable with criticism and people feeling 100% the opposite to my perspective or I wouldn't have posted in AIBU.

OP posts:
NewtoHolland · 16/12/2021 22:37

Ponoka7 fair play, could have used a much better word.

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 16/12/2021 22:27

"Being paid to essentially tart up facts "

If you care so much about women, start to remove slurs such as tart from your vocabulary.

imthenextinline · 16/12/2021 22:22

"I do find it concerning that the tone of the thread appeared to be anti- justice.

Our world is a much better place for having open justice and a right to a fair trial including the right to defend yourself."

And critiquing the evidence presented before the court is a key piece of the process. EL is not a defence lawyer, no one is being 'anti justice' we are applying critical thought.

imthenextinline · 16/12/2021 22:12

(and thank you, I'm fine now but appreciate your empathy)

imthenextinline · 16/12/2021 22:11

[quote NewtoHolland]@imthenextinline
That is really interesting to understand with more of a context that this is part of her wider agenda.
How odd.
Disassociation makes total sense as a way of coping with really distressing memories. Sorry to hear that you have been through trauma.

I would read her book to understand her POV more...but I'd hate to put any money her way.[/quote]
From what I can recall she had a personal stake with regards to how she dealt with a personal trauma of her own. Don't quote me, but I think her book ends with the 'bombshell' that AHA she, herself, experienced a traumatic event in childhood.

Which I think may have been her mother drowning (awful and very traumatic no doubt and I have absolute empathy for that) and somewhere along the line somewhere told her that she had witnessed it or discovered the body or similar, which actually wasn't the case but she internalised the story that she had.

She's always truck me as someone who would very much benefit from some personal therapy to process her own traumatic experiences but she's dedicated a lot of time to undermining the therapy profession so that's unlikely to happen, I would imagine.

Griefmonster · 16/12/2021 22:10

I accept I don't know about her in particular.

If her life's mission is ensuring serial killers and rapists are let off then she doesn't seem to have a great success rate - given those mentioned were ultimately convicted.

I can more imagine someone in her line of work, being in an academic bubble. That she doesnt actively choose NOT to take such work, rather than seeks it out?

I do find it concerning that the tone of the thread appeared to be anti- justice.

Our world is a much better place for having open justice and a right to a fair trial including the right to defend yourself.

NewtoHolland · 16/12/2021 22:04

@imthenextinline
That is really interesting to understand with more of a context that this is part of her wider agenda.
How odd.
Disassociation makes total sense as a way of coping with really distressing memories. Sorry to hear that you have been through trauma.

I would read her book to understand her POV more...but I'd hate to put any money her way.

OP posts:
Aspiringmatriarch · 16/12/2021 22:00

I think it sounds pseudo-scientific tbh. I sometimes wonder how the courts decide who is a reliable 'expert'. Yes memories can change but that shouldn't be used to discredit the accounts of victims who are coming forward with detailed and corroborated information. Yes if there are obvious anomalies, but outside of that that it just seems like a form of gaslighting.

imthenextinline · 16/12/2021 21:57

@NewtoHolland

Yeah her list includes Ted Bundy and Harvey Weinstein so Its not very pretty. I don't think being a research scientist is grimey, but choosing to line your pockets by using your research to discredit abuse victims I do feel is a very grimey choice.. It's not her research I have a problem with. It's her choice (which many people in her field don't make) to use this as a self-styled 'expert' witness to discredit victims of abuse. It is a choice to use her work in that way and I do feel it's really grimey....I could be totally wrong but I believe it isn't anything unique or exciting being able to understand that memories alter over time I think that is a widely known fact so it isn't anything particularly special in her research that gives her this role...it's a decision to use her research to reap in money, for discrediting abuse victims.
I agree and YANBU in my opinion.
NewtoHolland · 16/12/2021 21:56

Yeah her list includes Ted Bundy and Harvey Weinstein so Its not very pretty.
I don't think being a research scientist is grimey, but choosing to line your pockets by using your research to discredit abuse victims I do feel is a very grimey choice..
It's not her research I have a problem with. It's her choice (which many people in her field don't make) to use this as a self-styled 'expert' witness to discredit victims of abuse.
It is a choice to use her work in that way and I do feel it's really grimey....I could be totally wrong but I believe it isn't anything unique or exciting being able to understand that memories alter over time I think that is a widely known fact so it isn't anything particularly special in her research that gives her this role...it's a decision to use her research to reap in money, for discrediting abuse victims.

OP posts:
imthenextinline · 16/12/2021 21:52

I read one of Elizabeth Loftus' books when I was struggling after I began to have some particularly troubling memories from childhood that I had no prior recollection of.

As far as I can recall she is absolutely determined to convince the world that it is not possible to forget a trauma and then remember it at a much later date.

She is, of course, unable to prove that this is not possible for this to happen but what she did find was that it is possible for people 'remember' things that didn't happen.

She created a 'lost in the mall' experiment where people were told that a childhood scenario had happened to them and (some of them) began to believe it.

It was all linked to the 'false memory' debate of the 90s.

She worked very hard to undermine anybody who had experienced a trauma and forgotten it by saying the memories were 'planted' by therapists.

I read her work while I was trying to work out if what I was remembering was real or not. I also read plenty of work that supported that traumatic memories could be blocked out and remembered later, it was very common amongst holocaust survivors and there is plenty of research showing that children who have grown up with Social Care involvement will block out traumatic incidents that they then remember in later life and these are corroborated by their Social Services records.

I, myself, had my 'forgotten' traumatic memories corroborated also.

Elizabeth Loftus has dedicated her academic life to undermining the testimony of trauma survivors.