Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fucking appalled by Dr Loftus

61 replies

NewtoHolland · 16/12/2021 20:46

Imagine being a privileged and educated woman and deciding to put your expertise to use in defending rich and powerful rapists and paedophiles. Being paid to essentially tart up facts that most lay people know, that memory changes over time. And using that fact to try to discredit victims accounts. Honestly out of all the things she could do. Bet her mama Is really proud.

AIBU to be appalled by this woman and her grimey choice of job?

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/crime/ghislaine-maxwell-false-memory-witness-b1977599.html%3famp

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
chelle0 · 31/12/2021 09:52

I said I couldn't date a defence lawyer for this reason and got told I was childish!! I don't know how they can defend some crimes, I really don't.

SpilltheTea · 31/12/2021 09:50

She's a psychologist so obsessed with her own false memory that she invalidates the memories of others. Her research on eyewitness testimony has been valuable, but research on false memories is so divided, I don't think her opinion holds much weight.

Same360 · 31/12/2021 08:56

If she’s a credible scientist who truly believes what she is saying about memory is correct and properly researched then there’s nothing wrong with her repeating it in court under oath. As has been said, there have been plenty of convictions after she’s testified, so it’s not like she’s going around getting guilty people off constantly. Being convicted of any crime should me more than just based on one memory-based accusation anyway.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 31/12/2021 08:39

@SickAndTiredAgain

You simply cannot compare the research on the complexities of memory to knowing a day is 24 hours long. They are completely different.
Indeed,

The whole field of memory is hugely hugely complex, with very few 'givens'.

Expert witnesses are there to explain complexities to the court .

NewtoHolland · 17/12/2021 14:44

@AuntMasha

That's really interesting thank you for sharing that.

OP posts:
AuntMasha · 17/12/2021 14:29

I agree with you, OP. Elizabeth Loftus also testified at the Harvey Weinstein trial that victims’ memories of sexual abuse are unreliable. But she failed to convince the jury that Annabella Sciorra’s memory of a 1990s rape by him was defective. Loftus appeared for the defence in the Ted Bundy case, trying to throw doubt on the only victim left alive who could identify him; as well as giving evidence in the OJ Simpson and Bill Cosby’s cases. Time’s Up has called Loftus’ ‘false memory’ work a ‘tool that has been used to try to discredit survivors of sexual assault for decades.’ False memory syndrome has not been ratified by the American Psychological Association and is labeled ‘controversial’ and is ‘not [an] accepted diagnostic term.’

imthenextinline · 17/12/2021 11:26

I'm just remembering that at the end of her book (I can't recall which one I read but I gave it a fair hearing and read the whole thing) she revealed that she'd been sexually abused by a babysitter and she had never blocked it out and I think that anecdote was something she also used to try and evidence that people can't forget truly traumatic incidences.

Which IMO demonstrated her complete lack of understanding around developmental trauma - children who are being abused in the family are also reliant on the family system for survival so it's makes sense as a survival mechanism to block out the abuse in order to survive in the family system. It's a very different situation to being abused by someone outside of the family on whom you are not reliant for survival.

I recognise I'm not talking specifically about the Maxell case here and I don't know what argument she is putting forward. But I do know I took the time to read her book and understand her point of view uncritically. Please understand that I was dealing with some very difficult memories that I really, really wanted to believe were not true at the time of reading her book. I wanted to believe her and be on her side.

But her work fell very short, for me. I do think she has too much of her own 'stuff' to be an objective witness. She came across to me as someone who (understandably) felt very, very angry and having been convinced she'd witnessed her mother in death and has made a career out of proving that false memories can be planted.

Of course they can. But that doesn't mean that all memories that make life difficult for other people are wrong. Because the same then should apply to innocuous memories, how then can any of us be sure we went to work yesterday? That we picked our DC up from school? What we ate for dinner?

guardiansofthegalaxychocs · 17/12/2021 09:58

@NewtoHolland

I get where you are coming from defence lawyer wise, but I guess I see specifically focusing on spouting utter shit that everyone knows about memory in order to discredit victims as somehow a bit worse in some way...it just seems like such an utter poison bullshit job. What do you do? I exploit the fact that memory isn't 100% reliable to increase juries doubts about vulnerable victims. It's such a dick thing to be paid for Especially when that argument can obv be used about both sides like the perps memories aren't 100% reliable either?? Such a shady way to make your dollar.
Defence lawyers are essential for justice to be served. Eye witness testimony is hugely unreliable. Far more so than most people realise. It’s doing her job to point that out. If we didn’t have defence lawyers we basically wouldn’t have any semblance of a fair trial. YAB wildly, wildly unreasonable.
Aspiringmatriarch · 17/12/2021 09:45

Yes, I agree. But there have been cases of wrongful conviction based on the testimony of experts. The science around recovered memories isn't settled and in this case we're not talking about young children who may have experienced something traumatic they couldn't make sense of. I understand mounting a robust defence but surely someone presented as an expert should have cast iron credentials? My concern is somebody like this giving a veneer of credibility to a spurious argument which the jury are told to treat as gospel. It doesn't seem to me to meet the standards expected for evidence in a court case. Hopefully the prosecution will do their job well and demolish this as it seems another abusive tactic used against (alleged) victims.

CounsellorTroi · 17/12/2021 09:30

I think it sounds pseudo-scientific tbh. I sometimes wonder how the courts decide who is a reliable 'expert'.

Both the prosecution and defence may field expert witnesses. It is ultimately for the jury to decide who is reliable.

MissTrip82 · 17/12/2021 09:10

@BorisBooster

But this is every defence lawyer !
What do you mean? She’s not a lawyer, she’s a witness.

The right to a fair trial includes the right to legal representation. It’s a fundamental precept of democracy. And entirely irrelevant here, as the woman is not a lawyer and is representing nobody.

Griefmonster · 17/12/2021 08:45

@NewtoHolland

I find it so weird that there needs to be paid expert for this though...when it's a commonly known fact that memories change over time.. Do you have to get one in to say an orange is a fruit? Or that a day is 24 hrs long. It's a weird model to me. I would be gutted if my daughter's became scientists and then used their science in this way ..I just can't shake that it's shady and just ick. I think especially because with this case and Harvey W there are so many victims with very similar testimonies so it invalidates the argument about memory really anyway..so to still put that forwards..and to choose to be the person paid for doing so..I mean it's not going to be very impactful except on your pocket, and perhaps on how you make those individual victims feel.
I'd be interested if anyone knows to what extent you can refuse to present your research when requested in a court case. OP, you are describing it as her hustling for business around the seediest defendents. I have no idea if that's an accurate representation of her actions.

I think your observations above are limited though. The science of memory is not a commonly known fact. That's the point. It's an area of research. With people presenting theories on what happens when people describe memories.

And you can indeed end up with court cases (albeit generally not criminal) where people will contest what we think of as commonly known facts. I imagine somewhere in the history of court cases someone has argued that an orange isn't a fruit and a day isn't technically 24 hours....

In any case - what you are describing is distaste in this woman's choices. That is a personal reaction and so of course not unreasonable. I wonder though if the situation is as simplistic as you initially viewed it.

And the responses from posters who have been damaged by the theories of this Prof provide compelling witness to the impact of her research. I feel very moved by those words. And I am so sorry for your experiences.

SickAndTiredAgain · 17/12/2021 08:05

You simply cannot compare the research on the complexities of memory to knowing a day is 24 hours long. They are completely different.

NewtoHolland · 17/12/2021 07:58

I find it so weird that there needs to be paid expert for this though...when it's a commonly known fact that memories change over time..
Do you have to get one in to say an orange is a fruit?
Or that a day is 24 hrs long.
It's a weird model to me.
I would be gutted if my daughter's became scientists and then used their science in this way ..I just can't shake that it's shady and just ick.
I think especially because with this case and Harvey W there are so many victims with very similar testimonies so it invalidates the argument about memory really anyway..so to still put that forwards..and to choose to be the person paid for doing so..I mean it's not going to be very impactful except on your pocket, and perhaps on how you make those individual victims feel.

OP posts:
DottyDoge · 17/12/2021 07:29

If you care so much about women, start to remove slurs such as tart from your vocabulary

Off topic, but this is ridiculous. Surely this remains a predominantly English language website.

WeeFae · 17/12/2021 07:25

I have quoted and referenced her work in many research papers, and I am saddened by this. I agree OP.

PiglingBlonde · 17/12/2021 07:24

@user478843898

This technically shouldn’t work though, how can all witnesses have false memory and basically similar experiences?
That is one of the points the prosecution should be looking at in detail when they cross examine.
user478843898 · 17/12/2021 07:15

This technically shouldn’t work though, how can all witnesses have false memory and basically similar experiences?

SickAndTiredAgain · 17/12/2021 07:08

@NewtoHolland

I think in my mind defence lawyers are needed because obvs not everyone is guilty and everyone should have access to defence should they need it...but this role isn't a necessary one.
What do you mean the role isn’t a necessary one? The role of expert witness? I’d imagine you can see the importance and relevance of some expert witnesses, but if you have some then you can’t pick and choose. Because then you’re in the area of deciding which expert witnesses a defendant can have. Loftus hasn’t done anything wrong to the extent that she shouldn’t be allowed to be a witness. You may disagree with her, and the prosecution can obviously question what she’s said but I wouldn’t want a situation where expert witnesses with certain opinions weren’t allowed.
Toplowlight · 17/12/2021 07:06

I’m not specifically defending Loftus here, but expert witnesses are often an essential part of a person’s defence team.

If you have person A saying ‘I remember it this way’ and person B saying ‘I remember it this way’, you need someone acting from a position of impartiality to offer some kind of view on which account is more likely to be accurate.

Loftus’s role isn’t to say ‘the victims of this crime are lying’. Her role is to present credible scientific research in support of a proposition, which is that memory isn’t always an accurate reflection of fact. I completely understand why that feels unpalatable in this case, and I also understand why you might consider there to be a moral justification for her having refused to be an expert in these circumstances. (For what it’s worth, I wholly believe the women testifying in this trial that they were victims of Epstein and Maxwell, and I hope Maxwell is found guilty).

But, I also think we have to be careful about chipping away at the rights of an accused person to present a full defence, including expert witnesses. That means I don’t talk it’s fair to excoriate expert witnesses who present evidence on behalf of an accused. Whether or not we support the use their conclusions will be put to, they’re an essential part of a defence, and justice systems rely on those charged with offences being given the right and the opportunity to present the best possible defence.

LaBellina · 17/12/2021 07:03

This woman is some type of expert in her field and in this case used by the defense team as a witness expert. As distasteful as I find it, we can’t police which experts should be allowed to be expert witnesses on which cases as it’s a slippery slope towards robbing suspects of their right to defend themselves in court with the help of people with a certain expertise.

FrenchFancie · 17/12/2021 06:56

But there is reasonable scientific doubt about memory - it’s not infallible and people do, unintentionally, have false memories. There was a very interesting study done about memories of 9/11 in the USA and many people, for example, report watching the first plane strike on live TV - it’s impossible because it wasn’t broadcast live.

So if many many people can misremember things like that, other memories can be distorted- and that needs ‘putting to proof’ by the defence team. I’m not saying that victims are lying, purposely or otherwise, but it’s true that memory isn’t always perfect and the jury needs to consider that.

Provided what the witness is saying can be backed up by reasonable scorn evidence then it’s right that it’s considers - the jury are of course free to dismiss that evidence as BS…

NewtoHolland · 17/12/2021 05:40

She's a scientist who specialises in discrediting victims of abuse...I'm amazed at the level of support to be honest.

It has all gone a bit wrong though, at no point was my agenda that anyone shouldn't have a defense team.

It's about choosing to act as a self styled expert witness with the specific agenda of discrediting victims of past trauma and abuse.....who generally have a hard time being believed any way!

Not everyone having a defense team which is clearly an essential part of making sure courts are as fair as possible.

Random 'expert' witnesses, less essential.

Some of the comments are so random and haven't even read the first post through before reacting let alone the full thread.

OP posts:
MyDogLovesBiscuits · 17/12/2021 01:50

Ah should have RTFT, so she's not even a defense lawyer, she's a scientist presenting scientific evidence.

Well no then we shouldn't be attacking her at all for presenting facts to a court... WTF? Confused

MyDogLovesBiscuits · 17/12/2021 01:48

I agree in principle, because the people they are defending are absolute scum and some of the tactics used to discredit victims shouldn't be allowed and really are completely awful... but also think everyone deserves fair legal representation.

I do think it's a bit weird that you have picked a female defense lawyer as an example to put forward your opinion when there are thousands of male defense lawyers doing the same thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread