Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Crashed into me and is now saying it was my fault!

36 replies

CarCrashBus · 16/12/2021 19:52

Name change for this because itโ€™s completely obvious who I am if you know me ๐Ÿ˜

In March a school bus drove into my car. It was a narrow street and she came flying round a corner. I stopped, backed up and pulled out of the way. She then hit the back side of my car and drove off. It was my first experience of a (very small!) crash and I had a panic attack while in the car with my two young children. She stopped down the road to pick up some school children so I went over and explained she had hit me. She started screaming that she hadnโ€™t, and she knew who was following her and theyโ€™d agree with her.
I contacted the police, because she had effectively driven off, and then called my insurance company when I got home. They said the position of the damage meant it was clearly her fault, and they didnโ€™t need to see my dash cam footage. I was quite relieved because the footage makes it obvious that she hit me, but doesnโ€™t show it directly because sheโ€™s behind me when it hits. Anyway, my insurance were amazing, sent a curtesy car, collected mine from the house and sent money to replace the car seats. I thought it was all done and sorted

Then today, Iโ€™ve had a call from the insurance company saying sheโ€™s disputing liability, and Iโ€™m shitting myself! Why does it take 9 months for this? And how can she dispute it when the insurance company said it was clearly her fault. Iโ€™m terrified itโ€™s going to cost a fortune and my insurance company might say it was my fault some how?

So, if you managed to get through all that! Has anyone been through this before? Is it likely that the insurance company will throw me under the proverbial bus and make me pay half? Anyone got any reassurance for me? Most importantly, do I need a diagram ๐Ÿ˜ฌ

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fruitloopcowabunga · 17/12/2021 14:33

We have had a couple of instances of our cars being hit that ended up in court. Actually although it sounds scary, it was all absolutely fine in the end and the court experience was quite low-key with calm/sensible/supportive judge/magistrate. It took ages to get to that point with the other drivers denying liability but we won both cases in minutes in court. I really don't think you should worry - this is why you pay for insurance.

PossiblyPertunia · 17/12/2021 14:10

A removals truck pulled in to the side of me completely writing off my car. The person behind had dashcam so got the whole thing on camera and the driver of the truck still denied fault and tried to blame me... sometimes some people just can't accept they're in the wrong. Took 7 months but we finally got found not at fault (hardly surprising but I was still worried).

ChrimboGateauxCatto · 17/12/2021 14:03

Your insurance company is there to deal with this for you. Worry about when you know you have something for sure

swishswashswoosh · 17/12/2021 13:18

@CarCrashBus

I know I wouldnโ€™t have to actually pay, but if it does go 50:50 then Iโ€™ll have to pay the excesses and lose my no claims bonus wonโ€™t I? And Iโ€™d expect my insurance bills to skyrocket as Iโ€™d have to declare it when the annual change came up?
You will still lose your no claims because you have been in an accident. This is a claim. It isn't "no claims that aren't my fault". Sorry but this is something that should be made patently clear in all policies. It always astounds me people don't know this when the financial implications are so huge. Your renewal will also be significantly higher than it was so please be prepared for this. Insurance is a scam I'm afraid. Great in huge cost claims but you'll be paying for this one way or another for the next few (at least 5) years.
CarCrashBus · 17/12/2021 13:18

@Zilla1 I was wondering about posting it on the local Facebook page but it seemed really petty! If I end up paying for this then Iโ€™ll definitely be feeling petty!

@Mamamia7962 the car is stationary and you can hear me put the handbrake on so Iโ€™m hoping thatโ€™ll save me! You can also hear what I said after she hit me and drove off though ๐Ÿ˜ณ

OP posts:
Mamamia7962 · 17/12/2021 13:05

Well from what you've said you were stationary when it happened so your dash cam footage will show that. Try not to worry, it is up to the insurance companies to sort it out.

BrambleyHedge · 17/12/2021 12:59

I was in a similar position. Took two years to resolve and ended up 50:50. Sorry

mumda · 17/12/2021 12:55

Your biggest problem once the insurance is sorted out (Other than your own insurance going up) is the number of accident claims &BEEPS& who'll ring you up for the next 6 years.

Theflamingnerd · 17/12/2021 12:52

This happened to me. I was rear ended while sitting stationary at a traffic light by a lorry. Car completely written off, driver admitted liability at the scene to police in attendance. About 6 months later his insurance company tried to dispute the claim and that I was at fault. Luckily I had about 50 pics from the scene and drivers statement to the police to refute this.

I think it's become a standard part of the process, they do it to see if any potential chancers will cave in and go 50/50 instead.

pigsDOfly · 17/12/2021 12:47

Years ago I was hit in the side of my car by a lorry coming out of a side entrance.

I was driving down an empty road on the lane furthest away from where the lorry was emerging. The drive got himself into the middle of the road, obviously to follow behind me but instead banged into me.

He tried to claim that I should have let him in and I was driving discourteously.

I handed it all over to my insurance company and they were marvellous.

The insurance company of the company the lorry driver worked for tried all sorts of ways of getting out of paying out for my written off car and the whole thing dragged on for ages.

However, as I say, my insurance company were fantastic and eventually I got a much larger pay out than I expected.

I imagine this is just your insurance company letting you know what's happening. There doesn't seem to be much doubt about it being the other driver's fault so hopefully, you should be fine.

endofthelinefinally · 17/12/2021 12:43

Write it all down and do a diagram while it is fresh in your mind.
My dd was injured in an accident and it was clearly the other drivers fault. He got out of his car and shouted and ranted at her. She is tiny and was absolutely terrified.
It turned out he did not know the highway code in this country and had driven straight into her when she had right of way.
It took 3 years to resolve.

Zilla1 · 17/12/2021 12:35

Try not to stress, OP. If you have the footage then wait until the end. If you end up out of pocket, send the company a letter. If they refuse then tell them you'll start the legal process and post the crash footage on the relevant local facebook group with a statement that you are out of pocket and what the bus company have done along the process concerning their statement of events and ask for suggestions so this looks like a genuine request for help.

Good luck.

CarCrashBus · 17/12/2021 12:01

@MrsArchchancellorRidcully no Iโ€™ve got no proof, it was all by phone conversations and she was quite aggressive when I stopped her, so I donโ€™t have anything at all from her. Hopefully insurance will sort it though and it wonโ€™t come back on mine

OP posts:
MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 17/12/2021 09:54

Let the insurance company deal with it. Try not to worry though I'm afraid even a no fault claim will put your premiums up unless you have protected your no claims bonus.
Do you have evidence eg email that the insurers accepted it was her fault? That would be useful to rely on.

But really, try not to fret.

Panda8383 · 16/12/2021 21:27

This happened to me, guy crashed into me and basically accepted it was his fault at the scene..then after insurance was involved he tried to say it was me that hit him, if I remember at that point I had to draw a diagram and give an explanationโ€ฆafter this his insurers were saying we should go 50/50, I stuck to my guns and said no and then I went to the police station to speak to the officer that was there( the police were only a few cars behind me) they didnโ€™t see it but from where the damage was it obvious they hit me,eventually they accepted liability. Hope you get it sorted x

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 16/12/2021 21:27

Honestly, don't worry. It's probably not even her that's disputing it, it'll be the other insurance company (the bus company's). They try it on to see if it works, just in case they can get away with it.

Same thing happened to me; a vehicle went into the back of me when I was stationary so there was no way it was my fault and I had witnesses to prove it. The other insurer still tried to dispute liability for the damage to my car even though they'd accepted liability for my injuries!

Noodledoodledoo · 16/12/2021 21:22

I had this, I had two witnesses, plus a raft of pictures, and damage that I wouldn't be able to do but he tried to contest it.

He was a nightmare from the off, was a courtesy car he was driving, refused to give me his name, I just went snap happy and unintentionally got a picture of him when taking pictures of the location etc - sent it all to the insurance company and let them deal with it.

This was 5 years ago and I am still with the same insurance company as always the cheapest and no increase to my premium!

CarCrashBus · 16/12/2021 21:15

Ok thanks everyone. It sounds like Iโ€™m just worrying about nothing :)

OP posts:
OnTheBoardwalk · 16/12/2021 21:14

After my fault claim I found it easier to stay with my current insurer for a couple of years rather than dealing with all the claim history needed for new insurance company.

To be honest Churchill were great handling the claim so I didnโ€™t want to leave

OnTheBoardwalk · 16/12/2021 21:11

Donโ€™t worry your insurance firm sound on the ball

I had a fault claim , my insurance went up a bit but not a massive amount

Let them know you have footage and I reckon theyโ€™ll back down. My mum had bump absolutely not her fault. The other driver and their insurance were making loads of noise. I sent them Google map image showing the were completely wrong about the road layout. They soon backed down

SpiderinaWingMirror · 16/12/2021 21:04

Unless you are young and or have driving convictions, the impact of a worse case scenario losing your NCB can be over come by shopping around.
Honestly, the discount for ncb is minimal and not guaranteed. My 9 years ncb was only worth 15%, discount, or 45 quid. I stopped paying to protect it!

housemaus · 16/12/2021 21:03

@CarCrashBus

I know I wouldnโ€™t have to actually pay, but if it does go 50:50 then Iโ€™ll have to pay the excesses and lose my no claims bonus wonโ€™t I? And Iโ€™d expect my insurance bills to skyrocket as Iโ€™d have to declare it when the annual change came up?
Yep, this is true - that's the expensive bit!

BUT, it won't happen. Sounds like she was bang to rights in the first place, plus you have dashcam footage. She's just chancing it, she won't get anywhere.

CarCrashBus · 16/12/2021 20:56

I know I wouldnโ€™t have to actually pay, but if it does go 50:50 then Iโ€™ll have to pay the excesses and lose my no claims bonus wonโ€™t I? And Iโ€™d expect my insurance bills to skyrocket as Iโ€™d have to declare it when the annual change came up?

OP posts:
KrisAkabusi · 16/12/2021 20:40

Why would you have to pay half? ร€ worst it's your insurance company that would pay. That's what it's for!

NynaeveSedai · 16/12/2021 20:40

The insurance will still pay it regardless. Don't panic.