Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New man and younger woman friend

156 replies

Jasmine89 · 16/12/2021 17:10

Sorry another post from me! Been seeing a new man for a couple of months now, he seems lovely and is attentive and caring. We’re both in our 50s and divorced. He has a much younger woman friend who he describes as beautiful and they spend quite a lot of time together. They met through their dogs and usually go dog walking but I know she spends time at his place too. She doesn’t have family so he’s having her round for Christmas dinner as he’s not visiting his family either (so just the two of them). He did ask me to go along to something she’s organising this weekend but I can’t make it. I can’t help feeling a bit uncomfortable about the older man/beautiful young woman friendship, although he’s been very open about it. Am I being unduly paranoid?

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 17/12/2021 16:48

I've seen the trajectory of coercive, controlling behaviour start off with isolating the DP from friends then family then have the DP blame themselves for how their insecure partner feels. You made me feel uncomfortable ....

Presumably the ban might need to be for friends of both sexes given some men are bisexual or in the closet.

Am unsure about the weight being given to 'beautiful'. 'You can't see her (or him). But I might let you see them as they're not beautiful enough to make me feel insecure or uncomfortable. Wait, less beautiful people can still be sexually active and even attractive. I might need to rethink this. Ok, no friends of any age and neither sex'.

Zilla1 · 17/12/2021 16:42

@ChargingBuck and others. How dare you be the (unknowing) OW in emotional affairs with so many emotionally unfaithful men. Terrible. How can you look in the mirror in the morning?

Bookworm20 · 17/12/2021 15:51

OP, some of this sounds a little too familiar. I know most likely not, but you could be describing my exH.

He has a friend who is I would say mid twenties, hard to tell. She lives nearby, has no family and often goes to his for dinner, to hang out etc. She is going to his for xmas dinner this year. He has described women to me before as 'striking'.
Only thing is, I think this young woman is just a friend. He is the sort that would take pity on someone who was on their own, as a friend, not to take advantage of though iyswim. So I do think its just an odd sort of companionship.

I am not so aware if he has a new GF, but no reason why I would know this. I think he was dating someone a good 6 months back or so. He is slightly older then you decribe though, but he looks younger and I know his last OLD profile he lied and said he was 10 years younger.

Does he have DC?

iknowitisfun · 17/12/2021 15:26

It's a big decision op. Why not just meet the woman first and check out his interactions with her?

ChargingBuck · 17/12/2021 14:49

I didn’t say I was upset about his friendship. I’ve known about the friendship since we met although only found out she was beautiful recently!
So ... you're not upset about the friendship, but you are upset about her beauty?

I told him I felt a bit uncomfortable about him spending Christmas Day alone with her; a much younger beautiful woman (although I didn’t mention the last but!). I didn’t say I was upset about the friendship or that I didn’t want him spending Christmas Day with her.
Then what was the point of saying anything at all?
You've told him that you are "uncomfortable", but maintain that you are not "upset". How is he meant to gauge the difference?

Maybe you'd be better off dating a man who has no women friends.
You haven't even met this one, yet you feel she's a threat. That's ... not healthy.

Jasmine89 · 17/12/2021 14:06

“If someone I'd been dating for a couple of months told me they were upset about my long-standing friendship with another person, & that they'd rather I didn't spend a planned xmas day with them ... I'd finish with the datee immediately”
@ChargingBuck I didn’t say I was upset about his friendship. I’ve known about the friendship since we met although only found out she was beautiful recently! I told him I felt a bit uncomfortable about him spending Christmas Day alone with her; a much younger beautiful woman (although I didn’t mention the last but!). I didn’t say I was upset about the friendship or that I didn’t want him spending Christmas Day with her.

OP posts:
GiantHaystacks2021 · 17/12/2021 13:15

No.
I wouldn't be at home to that at all.
Leave them to it.
I'd drop him but I wouldn't bother telling him why.
Don't give him the satisfaction.

XiCi · 17/12/2021 13:14

@OnwardsAndSideways1

I don't think this is about male/female friendships, tbh.

I bet no-one on here had a single male friend in his 50's who asked them around for Christmas dinner when they were in their 20/30's and they said yes and went round so it's a moot point!

Christmas Day is a time usually reserved for those closest to us, that's just how it is...

Exactly. The whole set up is just weird.
XiCi · 17/12/2021 13:12

Funnily enough I always thought I had lots of platonic male friends. Then as soon as I split from my partner found their intentions were entirely different. Real Eye opener

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 17/12/2021 13:12

I don't think this is about male/female friendships, tbh.

I bet no-one on here had a single male friend in his 50's who asked them around for Christmas dinner when they were in their 20/30's and they said yes and went round so it's a moot point!

Christmas Day is a time usually reserved for those closest to us, that's just how it is...

5128gap · 17/12/2021 13:07

Without being rude to people who argues that from their own experience men and women can be friends, therefore the OP is unreasonable; I wonder, are you extremely attractive, and were your friends single when they met you? This women is described as beautiful, which suggests to me that she is the type of woman men are more likely to be attracted to than not. Like it or not, the more physically attractive a woman is the more likely her male 'friends' are to develop feelings for her, especially if the men do not have partners. They like her a lot, she's beautiful...why wouldn't they?

ChargingBuck · 17/12/2021 12:52

It's a revelation all right @SleepingStandingUp.
Not sure what to do about it now. Some of these guys have obviously had the unrequiteds for me for 4 decades, the poor sods ...

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2021 12:40

@ChargingBuck I have a few of those too, should I tell him partner he's secretly in love with and probably has been for 24 years???

ChargingBuck · 17/12/2021 12:38

@Jasmine89

I’ve sent him a message to say I’d like a chat. I can’t just let this go and wish I’d said something when he told me yesterday she was coming for dinner. If the shoe was on the other foot and I was friends with a much younger man, I’d definitely not be asking him for Christmas if I knew it wouldn’t sit well with my new BF.
If someone I'd been dating for a couple of months told me they were upset about my long-standing friendship with another person, & that they'd rather I didn't spend a planned xmas day with them ... I'd finish with the datee immediately.

& if someone I was dating for a couple of months removed an old friend from their life in case the friendship got misinterpreted ... I'd think they were disloyal, & a sap. And finish with them.

ChargingBuck · 17/12/2021 12:34

@RedBonnet

This is my own personal view and in no way an expert opinion, just from my experience - but I don't believe men and women can ever be just friends. One of them is always in love with the other. Whether it is openly admitted or not. I've never been proven wrong. And sometimes these 'friendships' can last for years. Longevity doesn't prove anything.
Wowsers.

So ... my handful of male friends are all secretly passionately in love with me? Who knew?!

It's obviously true, as I'm not in love with any of them.
What with @RedBonnet never being wrong, looks like my so-called friends don't have a leg to stand on. AND 3 of them are married. Bastards!

iknowitisfun · 17/12/2021 11:20

I wouldn't be happy either op. Personally I would walk away from the relationship as I wouldn't want to feel unhappy and insecure in a relationship.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/12/2021 11:05

@Jasmine89

I actually don’t want him spending Xmas Day with my family, it’s too soon. If I asked him I’m sure he’d jump at the chance. I’m caught really; I can’t ask him not to have her over, all I can say is that it makes me feel uncomfortable and gauge his reaction.
So you won't want him with you but you want him to choose you, uninvite her and them both spend it alone because you're insecure?
JingsMahBucket · 17/12/2021 11:03

[quote Jasmine89]@Dozer that’s it exactly. And he says people describe her as “striking”. I haven’t said anywhere I want him to end the friendship; I know it’s up to me to see if I can accept it.[/quote]
@Jasmine89
@Dozer
again, so what? What’s wrong with him mentioning this? Some people just really are striking or beautiful and that’s just life. If his friend were somebody like Kate Winslet who a lot of people consider beautiful, what’s so bad about him saying that?

You literally asked him what she looks like.

It sounds like you’re letting your insecurity back this poor guy into a corner.

If he didn’t mention her being beautiful then when you later met her, 10 to 1 bet you’d be upset with him for “keeping it a secret from you”. Or at least people on this thread would be accusing him of doing that. He can’t win in this situation.

georgarina · 17/12/2021 11:02

He likes her, she likes the attention.

You will never come first in someone's eyes if they're focused on someone else.

Disappointing and painful but that's been my experience.

JingsMahBucket · 17/12/2021 10:54

@bubblesbubbles11

"not to see their long-standing friend"

but it's not just seeing as in happen to meet each other on dog walks - it is a pre arranged agreement to spend Christmas day. Of course that could still be platonic but chances are it is not, at least not from his side.

So what if it’s pre-arranged? That’s what appointments and plans are. The clue is in the name. They’ve known each other for ages in his own words. Why can’t they spend Christmas together in peace?
XiCi · 17/12/2021 10:42

He is spending Christmas day alone with a young woman that he thinks is beautiful. Let's face it, any hint of a chance with her and he's going to take it.

bubblesbubbles11 · 17/12/2021 10:33

"not to see their long-standing friend"

but it's not just seeing as in happen to meet each other on dog walks - it is a pre arranged agreement to spend Christmas day. Of course that could still be platonic but chances are it is not, at least not from his side.

Zilla1 · 17/12/2021 09:31

HNRTT but you have known him for two months, haven't invited him to Christmas dinner as it's not been long enough but have firm enough opinions about how he spends his Christmas with what he says is a platonic friend and you don't trust or believe him. Perhaps it might be best that you end the relationship.

PMSL about the certainty of some of the PPs I have read. I would love to see the police procedural scripted and acted by them. At the crime scene 'It's definitely the husband. The son. The neighbour. They're the murderer'. 'Sorry Ma'am, it's a burglary'.

BulldogDrummondBass · 17/12/2021 09:30

I’m another who has had a long-term, completely platonic but close friendship with an older man. In my case, his now-wife (who came along years after we were friends) made a big fuss and said she didn’t want him to see me any more. This was from early days: about a month after he started seeing her, he cancelled long-standing plans with me at her insistence. It was disappointing at the time, but I was glad he’d found someone. She is the same age as him, and that’s all good.

What’s less good is that the ban on seeing me is still in force years later. It’s counterproductive. He has lied to her to see me, and I feel mixed guilt and defiance in still wanting to see him. It’s sad, when we could all have been friends. I’m married to someone else and I have kids: there is no danger from me.

So overall, and I think you have already understood this, there may or may not be an issue, but heavy-handed demands to give her up won’t help.

gannett · 17/12/2021 09:23

Well that's good. But on balance of probability my point still stands. And why should the OP, who is worked up about it, waste her time on a man where this is even a possibility, when there are thousands of them who don't have these friendships? So many people try to convince people that they should be ok with things men do that they don't like. Its like men are an endangered species to hang onto at all costs.

Personally I want a partner who does have strong friendships. It's a good character trait imo. The idea that it's a negative is quite bizarre to me.

OP doesn't say she doesn't like this man as a person. She doesn't like this friendship, but that says nothing about the quality of his character.

But I agree she should leave the relationship for whatever reason she wants - whether that's a good reason (she doesn't like him as a person) or a bad (imo) reason (she gets het up about friendships).