Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was the punishment not severe enough

64 replies

countesskay · 16/12/2021 10:22

My daughter was suspended from school last week along with their friend for attacking another child. (3 days) I was in utter shock about this and explained so when I got to the school.

My DD wouldn't talk during the meeting, but afterwards explained that the boy was a friend and her part in this was 'flooring him' swiping him.off his feet, her other friend then jumped on his back.

This stupidly happened because my DD and the other child involved took things too far after a Santa hat was swiped from the head of the other friend by the victim.

My daughter 11 had the following punishment.

A whole day/evening in their room, no electronics, phones etc.

A cancelled weekend trip to grandma's where their brother went alone. She stayed in the house with me.

No phone during the whole suspension.

No internet access at all, apart from school work.

No consoles during school hours, but had access Saturday and Sunday

We had the reintegration meeting today and the teacher openly said ' we wouldn't expect any gaming devices at all during the time'

I wish they'd have discussed these ideas before the exclusion. They were excluded Friday so with the weekend that's 5 days.

The messages seemed mixed in the meeting in front of my DD, the attack was vicious and malicious, however it is likely the other child will want to be friends with DD again and they can organise a restoration chat?

I feel annoyed tbh, this is the first time we've ever experienced this and I tried to read as much advice online as I could.

DD was spoken to calmly about the cause and effect, especially the dangers of hurting someone whether it's playful or not. We also gave them ample reflection time alone as well as losing the privilege of seeing their grandma and speaking to their friends for a week or have their phone
We got them to do school work during school hours despite being set one piece a, day by the school.

Advice online seems to be to discuss, give a consequence and try to move on

But now I just feel like a shit mother.

(she has low level behavior issues anyway, bottles feelings, feels overwhelmed with school and doesn't enjoy it, gravitates towards the 'silly' kids and joins in, play fight, late to lessons )

Was I too Lenient? I'm a over thinker and struggling with this at the moment.

OP posts:
Beamur · 16/12/2021 11:11

The punishment is done and I think what you did was fine.
It's the next stage that matters now.
It was a stupid, heat of the moment thing which went too far. The lad involved might think a bit harder next time though about how far he provokes his friends in a joke.
The fact that she was worried about him, whether he was hurt and if they would still be friends does show she's twigged there are consequences.
Draw a line. Say you hope this is the last time you have to do this and give her your confidence that she won't do this again.

HibiscusIsland · 16/12/2021 11:03

Sounds ok

WorraLiberty · 16/12/2021 10:59

I think you got it right apart from not visiting her gran, as that feels like her gran's being punished too, unless she'll be seeing her again before Xmas?

however it is likely the other child will want to be friends with DD again and they can organise a restoration chat?

If I were the victims mum, I would not be happy about that at all.

Toplowlight · 16/12/2021 10:55

I think you got it about right. The most important part of this isn’t really the punishment - it’s the discussion to make her understand why what she did was wrong, and how bad the consequences for the other child could be. Piling on excessive punishment wouldn’t actually teach her any empathy and would honestly be just as likely to make her feel like a hard done by victim. I think you struck the right balance between ensuring there are consequences for the behaviour, and having the discussion to make her understand the other child’s perspective.

Countless studies have shown that punishment isn’t an effective motivator of good behaviour in children, so don’t take too much to heart posters saying they would have come down on their kids like a ton of bricks. That’s their decision and their right, but it’s not a more effective strategy.

ditalini · 16/12/2021 10:47

IMO, there's only so much punishment that a child can take before they start to feel sorry for themselves and it becomes counterproductive.

It feels to me like you got the balance about right and it doesn't read like you were giving her the message that it was no big deal. At age 11 I think punishment carried out over 3 days is about the most they're going to manage to cope with before it moves into "so unfair" territory (whether right or wrong, that's just the way we're built).

yumyumwinegimmie · 16/12/2021 10:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

ChangeChingyChange · 16/12/2021 10:43

*no tech and leaving only for meals I mean

ChangeChingyChange · 16/12/2021 10:42

God what a vicious thing to do. And yet she still had access to consoles during the weekend. Sorry YABU if my child did this I'd come down on her like a ton of bricks - make a lasting impression. I genuinely would have had her in her room with no tech aside from meals during that time. I would have had her write a letter of apology and I would have contacted the parents of the boy for her to apologise. I think you're being extremely lenient. She'll know next time she can basically get away with it and will it make her think twice? Probably not.

countesskay · 16/12/2021 10:40

@RoastedParnsip I believe she is, she's not a hugely emotional child, but she was shocked that he was hurt, and appeared upset they he may not want to be friends anymore (she's had no ability to contact him, I didn't want to jeopardise the reintegration)

I think the teacher wanted to see more remorse, but she just Internalises upset rather than burst into tears or anything

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 16/12/2021 10:34

It is not up to the teacher how you choose to deal with your DD at home.

JudgeRindersMinder · 16/12/2021 10:33

I think you got it just right…and it was very easy for the teacher to mention their “expectations” after the event. Hopefully your dd has learned from the experience and it won’t happen again

cansu · 16/12/2021 10:29

I don't think you were too lenient and I am a teacher. You were supportive of school and kept her inside and removed her phone. That is fine.

RoastedParnsip · 16/12/2021 10:29

Depends is your daughter remorseful for what she did to that child?

BlackeyedSusan · 16/12/2021 10:28

Sounds fine to me.

Keep talking about consequences of actions generally.