Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you manage finances/divvy up money?

109 replies

MeSanniesareBrannies · 15/12/2021 23:26

Cross post with relationships. How do you manage finances/divvy up money?

So, background info:

Me: 34, earning just over £60K (less than £20K savings). Unlikely to ever earn more than £90K.

DP: 32, earning £100K + bonus (also has £100K savings/deposit). Earnings upper limit impossible to predict.

My partner and I have been together three years, lived together two and just got engaged. He earns considerably more than me, has always paid for most things and is happy to do so. We’re buying a house (both names) and he’ll be stumping up most of the deposit.

We both work full time in fairly intense jobs, but hours aren’t crazy. We’re pretty even on housework (we’re both a bit rubbish, he possibly does slightly more, we have a lovely cleaner). No kids, but we we want them and I’ll probably stay home for a bit when we have them.

DP wants to chuck all our money (after savings and investments) in a joint account, have equal access and just not worry about it. Having read threads on here, it seems like there’s reasons not to do that? There’s lots of comments about making sure everyone has their own money, ‘ducks in a row’ and is contributing to the household according to income? If you’re long term married and happy with your financial arrangements, what do you do/would you recommend we do?

I can’t imagine ever having money based rows, but as it seems so common, I thought getting ahead of it might be good. All advice gratefully received.

OP posts:
BookFiend4Life · 16/12/2021 03:34

We both put all our income into one account, pay bills, put equal amounts into our respective retirement accounts, and the remainder goes into a savings account and debit account. We talk about big purchases and are fortunate enough to buy everything we need and many things we want.

Inthetropics · 16/12/2021 03:32

We have completely separate finances, so I have my own account and credit card and my partner has hers. Since i earn a lot more than her I pay the bigger bills and she pays for smaller stuff. It works because I am very very veeeeery organized with money (i am a saver and love a good budget) and she is more spontaneous and a "go with the flow" type of person. We are both very generous wirh each other.

BasicDad · 16/12/2021 03:27

Don't agree with all finances pooled for anyone.

Account for monthly and annual expenses - yes
Account for shared savings (holidays, deposits. Etc) - yes

Monthly and annual expenses should include everything essential, from cars, to shopping, to kids, to clothes to hairdressers and so on - everything.

But I'm a big supporter of having your own discretionary funds and personal savings once everything else is covered.

If someone is a much bigger earner. Then they should input a relative % to the shared pots. However...I'd draw a limit on the split if both parties are good earners.

2TurtleDovesInARow · 16/12/2021 03:10

All joint. I've just had a promotion which means similar split to you and your fiancé however we are 30/31 and have been together 8 years. When we got together I earned more than him and brought our first house deposit to the table. DH always credits the fact we never fight about money to the joint pooling system, however I'm sure couples who don't pool may say the same!

We use YNAB to track how we spend money. For instance we both get equal amounts to spend on clothing, going out with friends etc.

RavingAnnie · 16/12/2021 02:37

All our money is joint. My DH earns significantly more than me. About 5 times what I earn.

I have chronic illness so my career options and capability are severely limited.

I think everything joint makes sense when you have children.

Rosebel · 16/12/2021 02:31

We have a joint account where most money goes in. I have a savings account which child benefit goes in but I'd have no objection in changing it to a joint account if my husband wanted to.

timeisnotaline · 16/12/2021 02:00

We do this, full access for both (some exceptions - i have a credit card, got it a year ago and haven’t gotten around to putting dh on it, the shares are in his name because I made him open the account as I refuse to be the only one having anything to do with our finances, I have his logins though as I’m the one who does anything with it. I’m going on mat leave soon, I do the budget for that, just like I do for everything else but all accounts are joint (we have lots of accounts all against our mortgage to make it easy to bucket funds). No concerns re sharing finances.

I think at the just engaged stage we probably opened a joint account and at first used it to put the savings for our wedding in it, and were each paid into our own accounts otherwise. Then we made everything joint.

MeSanniesareBrannies · 16/12/2021 01:56

A range of options here. Thanks, everyone.

OP posts:
SmallBoyFury · 16/12/2021 01:45

Before marriage- we split everything 50/50.

After marriage we kept separate finances for a number of years then combined for ease.

I earn a bit more than DH and we do the following-
My salary in its entirety goes into our joint savings account
DH’s salary goes into our joint current account but £700 also goes into joint savings, plus £500 into each of our personal accounts.

Our joint current account is used to pay our mortgages, groceries, insurances, all household bills, fuel, entertainment, subscriptions, charity standing orders, meals out/takeaways etc.

Our personal accounts aren’t very strict and we dip into the joint as needed. I like these accounts as I can buy DH Christmas presents etc and he won’t see the transaction on our statement.

On pay day, I usually transfer the joint current account balance from the day before into savings.

It works for us.

Nowayoutonlydown · 16/12/2021 01:37

As long as you are both good at handling money and neither of you is abusive, I can't see why not.
What I would do though is stipulate that you both have an allocated amount for spends, so you can save a small amount for yourself, whether this ends up going in gifts, holidays, hobbies or should the worst happen and you need to leave... doesn't need to be huge amounts, just enough to give you breathing space should you require it.

Ledwood85 · 16/12/2021 01:33

There's a substantial difference between our earnings.

We worked out the ratio of our after-tax earnings and split big bills according to that ratio. I pay mortgage, car payment, car insurance, kids education savings. Partner pays utilities.
Food, fuel, restaurants, household purchases we split 50/50.

Everything after bills we keep in our own accounts for us to save or spend as we wish, without any interference or judgement - the bills are paid and out of the way.
This way there are no arguments about spending on treats, weekends away, clothes, gadgets, whatever (as you sometimes see in threads on here) - pretty much same as @GirlOfTudor above. We've paid our obligations fairly based on our post-tax incomes, what's left is fair game.

I came into the relationship with a greater amount of savings and paid the downpayment on the home. Don't hold that against my partner, we're a unit and that's that.

nokidshere · 16/12/2021 01:32

We have 2 accounts. One where all the money goes in and one for bills.

That's it. No credit cards, or other accounts or separate savings.

We set it up like that 40yrs ago when we bought our first house together. There's never been any his or my money. It's just ours that's available after the bills are paid. We each have equal access to it even when I wasn't earning but I probably spend more than he does. Because we've had times when we have been totally skint I check the balance every morning and it's become a habit now. So we always know what we have (or more usually haven't) got.

Bubblecap · 16/12/2021 01:29

I have not complied with the general MN consensus on finances. We have been together 25 years, completely separate accounts. Outgoings have ebbed and flowed dependant on who is the bigger earner and whose investments are doing better. It suits us and no arguing about money ever. But we paid off our mortgage after 5 years together when an investment DH made paid it off in full. So no housing expenses for 20 years.

GirlOfTudor · 16/12/2021 00:54

My husband and I have been together 10 years. We earn around the same amount.
We opened a joint account together when we bought our house. We have our own personal accounts where our wages are paid into and any personal bills are paid out of (such as phone bills or car insurance). We both pay the same amount into our joint account each month and only joint bills/expenditure is paid from that account (such as the mortgage, utility bills and any big house purchases).
This way, the joint bills are taken care of and neither of us can complain what the other does with the rest of our money. We've always split bills equally and have never argued over money.
I would never advise anyone to pool their finances 100% with someone; married or not.

caringcarer · 16/12/2021 00:46

My dh and I both work he earns more than me but I have more investments. We both have our salary go onto our own bank accounts then we both pay a fixed amount I to joint account which covers mortgage, gas, electric, water, council tax, food, leaning products, takeaway food, the cleaner, fuel, any garden work we have done or any other bill including joint Xmas gifts and birthday gifts. With money in our personal accounts we buy each other gifts, coffees and lunches out with friends, clothing, and if I want to treat my niece or nephews I don't feel I have to to mention it to DH.

Sunflowers095 · 16/12/2021 00:43

I would heavily advise against this. There's lots of threads where it becomes obvious why - financial abuse, lack of protection, your partner could steal that money or gamble it away.

Me and DP have our personal accounts where salaries get paid into, and then we transfer most of it into our joint account. Our bills, mortgage, groceries, pet costs, holiday money, fun money for dates etc all comes out of that account.

We leave some money in our individual accounts which we use for our own savings and investments, personal spending, gifts for each other and all other bits.

We just worked out a % of our salary to split between our own account and the joint account. It works well for us - I'd be open to also having a joint savings account or investments as long as I have a personal one too.

Cheeseycheeseycheesecheese · 16/12/2021 00:30

Dp suggestion* sorry phone seems to be doing weird things...

notacooldad · 16/12/2021 00:29

We have a joint account and a savings account in my name.
I am the better one at dealing with money.
My wage goes into the joint account and then I transfer £1500 into my savings. I try not to do incidental spending such as random Costas ' just because'
Dh transfers £2500 into the joint account and I transfer that into savings. We have very little overheads.
Dh fuels my car, does the food shopping, gives me cash when I need it to save going to an atm, pays for meals out, drinks and other expenses.
It's not a case of him paying for it, it's all our money. The savings money is partly his as well.
It's worked well for 30+ years as neither of us are big spenders.

Cheeseycheeseycheesecheese · 16/12/2021 00:29

Similar to your dp, full access to all money.
Dh earns substantially more than me, but I'm a TA, so work term time only, meaning childcare isn't a concern.

We have 2 accounts (1 wages/bills, 1 savings) and a credit card each.
All wages go into same account, set amount goes into savings on my pay day (I get paid the day after dh) all bills come out of joint account, inc food shop and fuel.

Credit card each we use for personal entertainment, sensible (read affordable, so if maxed we won't be in trouble if we paid it off outright) credit limit and we have a dd from the joint account paying them monthly.

We find it easier to mix it all together, I have married friends who still have completely separate finances, it's what works best for you and dp, I don't think there is a right or wrong way to do it, as long as you're not getting yourself into financial hardship.

Peckhampalace · 16/12/2021 00:24

What was ours before we got married stayed in our own names (bought house jointly).
All earnings go into joint account and we each take the same amount for personal spends (clothes, presents, going out). any left in joint at the end of the month is used for joint saving or used to fund ISA and pension contributions. (More into mine as I was behind).

It's worked for us through periods of not working and it doesn't matter who earns the most as long as together we earn enough.

cherrytopcake · 16/12/2021 00:19

Married and husband earns more than me. Everything goes into one joint account with equal access. All bills, clothes, restaurants, holidays, food, activities, mortgage etc come out of there. All savings go into the same savings account. Nice and simple. No arguments. We don't keep tabs on each other's spending or argue over who spent more one day etc... but to be fair, he's not a big spender. And if he was, that wouldn't be a problem as he brings home more money. He never questions what I spend. Having said that we're not overly materialistic.

When I stopped working to be at home with the baby nothing changed. Except I no longer had a salary to put into the pot. This has never been an issue as we're married and support each other. One of us has to be at home with the baby & the other brings home the money. When I go back to work full time I'll be able to contribute again. No biggy.

Whilst on maternity leave I pay into by pension using savings/left over money at the end of the month so pretty ad hoc as I currently don't have an income. Just make sure you think of that. Although being married your husband's pension is also half yours if you were to divorce but it's not a reason to not continue building your own pension whilst at home with baby.

Guess this set up only really works if your partner is not financially controlling. Seeing he just wants to throw everything into one pot, he is making sense. This will be a lot more straightforward when baby arrives, as your income will diminish anyway, he'll have to support you financially whilst your pause your career and look after baby. He seems like a good egg op.

Even without a baby in the picture, I think what he is saying makes sense. It's straightforward and clearly he trusts you. FYI We had the above arrangements before baby arrived. Deposit wise he also had more but we're 50/50 owners on the house.

MeSanniesareBrannies · 16/12/2021 00:14

@Starcup Totally understand. Smile

OP posts:
MeSanniesareBrannies · 16/12/2021 00:12

@maxelly That was really comprehensive and fantastically helpful. Thank you very much for taking the trouble to write that all out!

OP posts:
Starcup · 16/12/2021 00:12

spend not seige lol

Starcup · 16/12/2021 00:11

I posted it tonight on AIBU about twenty minutes after posting this and I said it was a crosspost. Is this against the rules? Not trying to be underhand, just wasn’t getting any replies

@MeSanniesareBrannies

I can totally see why you’d post twice and that’s fair enough. It’s just sone people do duplicate posts just to troll. Then people reply in good faith and siege time doing it etc and it was just a wind up.

I totally don’t think you’re is though of course. Hope that makes sense Smile