Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

12 year keeps getting in trouble at school and home - am I being too HARSH or not HARSH enough?

86 replies

MNF2021 · 15/12/2021 21:31

My daughter is 12 and is constantly getting in trouble at school. It’s so stressful as nearly every few days within a week I am getting called from the school about her behaviour towards teachers, other students and nothing seems to deter her.
She has been placed on a report at school were she has to get it signed after every lesson about her behaviour and tends to end up in isolation (time away from the class for the whole day on a day to day basis). When asked why she thinks it’s acceptable to do these things, she simply responds with “that’s just the way I am or people are so annoying”
So your probably thinking, what have I done at home?
She is an only child and I have tried speaking and reasoning with her to be greeted with nothing but teen backchat and attitude. Her gadgets have been confiscated until Christmas Day, no friends over, no Christmas disco etc - all been taken away and her response is she doesn’t care!
Does anyone have any parenting advise/tips on consequences and how to make her realise that her actions will eventually get her into big trouble!! Help!
I realise I may have over indulged her being my only child and I think I am now paying the price!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
steppemum · 17/12/2021 21:58

ok I would ask for a meeting after the holidays.
Ask for a new approach, it is obvious that she is struggling both with behaviour and work.
She needs support and a plan.
so things like - time out card for when she feels overwhelmed

support/friendship groups
access to someone from student services when she needs to talk
etc.

nanbread · 17/12/2021 21:50

Of course she should also be punished at home.

Why?

If you has a disciplinary for performance at your job, would you want to be punished at home for that?

No one should be punished twice for the same thing.

Different if she's done something at home of course (although I'm not a big one for random unconnected punishments).

She's at a very vulnerable age and the OP needs to foster a good connection with her.

nanbread · 17/12/2021 21:43

[quote Harriet1216]This makes interesting reading.

www.spectator.co.uk/article/not-ill-just-naughty[/quote]
If by "interesting" you mean an absolute pile of horse shit, yes very interesting.

RightAngledTriangle · 17/12/2021 21:39

@MNF2021
Is dad around on the scene?
What is home life like?
Is she otherwise happy when not at school?
Hobbies/interests/clubs?

It could be ADHD/ASD. It could be other things that have happened over her childhood (for example, trauma). I would certainly be looking to have a chat with school on how to move forward positively, what support they can give you both, so she can get out of this negative cycle she is in, whatever the cause is.

WorkHardPlayHard1 · 17/12/2021 21:07

It sounds like she is playing up as a signal she is in pain and needs your attention. Hate to say it but is abuse a possibility? Xxx

ldontWanna · 17/12/2021 17:48

And this is why children are so lawless and without any care for discipline anymore. Of course she should also be punished at home. Why do people always want to label children with a condition these days when some kids are just badly behaved and need to be disciplined and do need punishment til they realise what they're doing Is wrong and does have consequences.

Happy, healthy , well adjusted children don't regularly misbehave. The consequences (even if just at school) are simply not worth it. Add in disappointment, upset,punishment at home etc too and it's nipped in the bud pretty sharply, if it ever even starts.

It's obviously not working for OP's daughter. That's not because punishments aren't strict enough, but because she can't or won't (because she has certain needs that are unmet) . Her behaviour is a symptom not the cause and until that cause is identified and worked on it will all be rather pointless and further damaging relationships.

Rexthesnail · 17/12/2021 13:11

Try a wobble cushion, fiddle toys, diary's, and if possible some counselling. Her school should have a school counsellor.

My daughter has similar issues although is younger and she isn't in mainstream.

Tired1234567890 · 17/12/2021 12:42

@Harriet1216

So yes. But also no. .that article clearly hates kids The article discusses the question of over diagnosis of ADHD. I don't see where you get the impression that the author of it 'clearly hates kids.'
It doesn't even believe it exists The article is a very poorly written scandal based media outrage stereotype of previous misinformed thoughts on adhd. Everything in that article can be disproved with peer reviewed studies.

In essence it's horse shit.

Harriet1216 · 17/12/2021 12:31

So yes. But also no. .that article clearly hates kids
The article discusses the question of over diagnosis of ADHD. I don't see where you get the impression that the author of it 'clearly hates kids.'

ChangeChingyChange · 17/12/2021 12:21

@Brusca

Why are you punishing her when she's already being punished at school?

Your role needs to be getting to the bottom of what's going on that's causing her to behave like this. That might mean seeking professional help if you can't work it out together.

And this is why children are so lawless and without any care for discipline anymore. Of course she should also be punished at home. Why do people always want to label children with a condition these days when some kids are just badly behaved and need to be disciplined and do need punishment til they realise what they're doing Is wrong and does have consequences.
Volhhg · 17/12/2021 12:17

I don't think you should stop her from socialising in person. If she socialises in person well with her friends out of school and her behaviour is good whilst doing that then that is something to encourage. You don't want her to be totally alienated from the world.

Tired1234567890 · 17/12/2021 12:00

[quote Harriet1216]This makes interesting reading.

www.spectator.co.uk/article/not-ill-just-naughty[/quote]
It does make interesting reading. It's very provocative but actually it's right.. kind of.

Adhd needs short sharp instant consequences and less talking about feelings and putting the child as the centre of the panicked parents universe.
Which just so happens to be a very French based way of bringing up kids generally speaking.
So it's not that all uk kids are whiny and out of control naughty types, it's that we are all about CBT and talking Therapies over here, and where that might work for much older teens, it certainly has no evidence based positive outcomes with kids with adhd.

So yes. But also no. .that article clearly hates kids.

Tired1234567890 · 17/12/2021 11:48

[quote DrCoconut]@Tired1234567890 the 30% thing is interesting. DS is 23 and I've previously tried to explain to people who don't get it that he's about like a year 10 kid developmentally.[/quote]
Yeah like when they learn to drive it's like giving the keys to an 11 year old..
You just wouldn't.

They're more likely to have comorbidities like depression and anxiety but if your child has adhd and you're not medicating them then it's like having uncontrolled diabetes.
Meds Bridge some of that 30% gap.

DrCoconut · 16/12/2021 22:16

@Tired1234567890 the 30% thing is interesting. DS is 23 and I've previously tried to explain to people who don't get it that he's about like a year 10 kid developmentally.

Sunnyjac · 16/12/2021 21:45

Harriet1216
So, it was seem that ADHD was
controversial even back then, when
far fewer children were being diagnosed.

Like there was far less child abuse and domestic violence? Hmm

Sunnyjac · 16/12/2021 21:42

Harriet1216
It depends on your point of view. There
are studies from both sides.

I have three kids, all raised the same. Only one has the problems being discussed here. Are you telling me that I should just write off the one as naughty? I find it difficult to imagine that the people who have done studies doubting ADHD have actually lived with it. I can see she’s different, I have the comparison of the other two

OopsadayZ · 16/12/2021 20:52

@Brusca

Why are you punishing her when she's already being punished at school?

Your role needs to be getting to the bottom of what's going on that's causing her to behave like this. That might mean seeking professional help if you can't work it out together.

This ^

I think it unfair if she's in isolation all day that she can't have friends over OR have her mobile phone to connect with friends.

I can only imagine how tough it is having a child who is blatantly ignoring the school rules. But I agree with the PP instead of handing out more punishments, you should try to get to the root cause.

*Is she unhappy at school (socially? Friendships?Bullying? Struggling academically?)
*Is she undiagnosed for something? (ADHD, autism, dyspraxia, dyslexia)
*Is she in more serious trouble and she can't express this other that by acting out? (Drugs, blackmail, drinking, smoking, sex?)
*is everything alright at home? Dad in the scene?

talesoftheunexploded · 16/12/2021 20:44

I was just like this. I have ADHD.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 16/12/2021 20:16

@Hamjamwich

The kids I work with I give them laminated cards which say… “Please can I have some time to calm down” which they hand to the teacher if feeling stressed/angry/frustrated and don’t want to talk

Harriet1216 · 16/12/2021 20:13

:09Throughabushbackwards

Harriet1216

This makes interesting reading.

www.spectator.co.uk/article/not-ill-just-naughty

That is a very old article (it had no date but mentions Gordon Brown as Prime Minister!

So, it was seem that ADHD was controversial even back then, when far fewer children were being diagnosed.

Throughabushbackwards · 16/12/2021 20:09

[quote Harriet1216]This makes interesting reading.

www.spectator.co.uk/article/not-ill-just-naughty[/quote]
That is a very old article (it had no date but mentions Gordon Brown as Prime Minister!).

Harriet1216 · 16/12/2021 20:06

@Hamjamwich

Just today my DS got in trouble for saying "just leave me alone". He is clearly expressing that he wasn't coping but was punished as it was seen as rudeness
But that is rudeness.
Hamjamwich · 16/12/2021 20:05

Just today my DS got in trouble for saying "just leave me alone". He is clearly expressing that he wasn't coping but was punished as it was seen as rudeness

Harriet1216 · 16/12/2021 20:00

[quote Sunnyjac]Harriet1216

Right back at ya

www.healthline.com/health/adhd/history[/quote]
It depends on your point of view. There are studies from both sides.

Naimee87 · 16/12/2021 19:59

I'm not sure i have advice although i should as my DS also 12 is going through the very same thing. Same behaviour as well. The teacher is completely incompetent and has never found a way of motivating my DS and keeping him in check. I've done the same as you with taking away his phone/ps4/bmx etc. But still get daily texts/calls from the school. Even on weekends... AND now the school have involved so many external 'organisations' here and the situations escalating out of control. We've always seen a family therapist and now found a really nice child-psychologist who my DS has clicked with. So i guess my advice would be try to understand if the teacher/current school she is at is a good environment for her. We've lost so much time focusing on my DS and his behaviour that his school work has suffered massively. I wish i'd made a change last year. Having spoken to both the therapist and psychologist they didn't agree with punishing at home for whats been happening at school. But this is up to the parents... i really have no issues with DS at home at all. He's great! Our next big school meeting is tomorrow and i've no clue how it'll go.! Good Luck!

Swipe left for the next trending thread