Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to offer help to my colleagues?

64 replies

Nidan2Sandan · 15/12/2021 14:23

Our job is busy, but also not linear. You can have a low amount of work that is complicated and be short of time or a high amount of work which is simple and keep on top of it. Really depends on what comes in.

Recently I have been getting on top of my work well and found that today I actually had no tasks that needed doing, so I emailed out to the team asking of anyone needed assistance on any tasks.

Several people came back grateful and took me up on my offer.

One person emailed saying everyone will hate me for pointing out I had nothing to do and offering to help them.

Just for clarity, I just had my yearly review and my manager graded me at exceeding my targets, said my work is excellent and she is really happy with me. All our cases are reviewed twice by management so she will know exactly what I'm doing, therefore i have no issues with the boss thinking I'm short changing my work or rushing it.

Would people really hate me for offering to help? Would you be offended if I did? If you had some work which was labour intensive and I could take the "easier" stuff off your hands to help?

I'm wondering if I shouldn't have offered now, but would feel bad sitting here watching Netflix instead of working knowing my colleagues are busy (not all, some have less work than me).

OP posts:
Mxflamingnoravera · 15/12/2021 17:35

I do offer help when I am working with a colleague who is clearly working at or beyond capacity and I have a bit of slack which does happen in education adminstration. I don't email out across the board I just contact the one person I can see is stretched and might want some assistance. It has always been gratefully recieved and no one else knows so it does not set a precident for others to have to do the same.
I also builds up goodwill so that when I need help, the people I have helped are more likely to help me when I am stretched.

Comtedemontecristo · 15/12/2021 17:24

Like you I would ask for work if I wasn't busy, although I might have asked my manager rather than the team. Who sent the email? What sort of person are they?

ineedsun · 15/12/2021 17:15

@OneRuleForThem

It sounds patronising and showing off to me. Also can come across as undermining, especially sending out a GROUP email, informing everyone including the bosses implying that you’re a much faster and capable worker than everyone Else. Why on Earth did you think this a good idea?
Why on earth wouldn’t it be a good idea?!

Your response confuses me.

Chely · 15/12/2021 17:13

I'd be annoyed if you offered to take the "easier" work off my hands.

BashfulClam · 15/12/2021 17:10

This is how my team works. The first thing we do is let our t/l know and they will either see if they have anything or they will then check the workflow to see who needs a hand and ask them to pass stuff over. We had one woman who would try and pass off complex work..eh no Mary it’s quick wins please and one who would do the bare minimum after offering help so you actually didn’t have any time saved.

Nidan2Sandan · 15/12/2021 17:09

@LethargicActress

I think the mistake was in emailing round to everyone at the same time, but you weren’t wrong to offer your help.

Part of the problem could be that you end up with so many requests that you can’t fulfill them, and then a kind offer of help could lead to someone feeling let down because they can’t get help they were briefly led to believe they’d have.

Just email or ask in person individually next time.

I had a few people ask for help and I have completed everything they requested. Most of it was drawing up some letters, making quick calls or closing cases (the case closure system is a bit of a faff, lots of different unnecessary boxes to tick to get the computer to register the closure).

I have a few bits for a colleague I know has a lot on her plate which I will do tomorrow in-between my own actions.

Thanks everyone, glad I WBU and i will continue to offer to help my colleagues. Wink

OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 15/12/2021 16:56

One person emailed saying everyone will hate me for pointing out I had nothing to do and offering to help them.
This person clearly had enough time on their hands to compose & send a spiteful message, so instead of questioning yourself, you'd do better to reframe the question by wondering what their motivation for sending such an undermining email was.
Maybe they can't bear for you to look good.
Maybe they are a moaning minnie who simply has to have something to complain about.
Maybe they were sitting on their hands, not as busy as the rest, & now feel guilty for not offering their own help.

Whatever it is, it's not actually your problem.
Your best response is probably NONE. (Mindgame players just hate to be ignored. It tales all their ammunition away!)

Would people really hate me for offering to help? Would you be offended if I did? If you had some work which was labour intensive and I could take the "easier" stuff off your hands to help?
Of course not. It's what working in a team is all about.
And if you helped me, I'd also be looking out for you, when you were swamped.

LethargicActress · 15/12/2021 16:39

I think the mistake was in emailing round to everyone at the same time, but you weren’t wrong to offer your help.

Part of the problem could be that you end up with so many requests that you can’t fulfill them, and then a kind offer of help could lead to someone feeling let down because they can’t get help they were briefly led to believe they’d have.

Just email or ask in person individually next time.

Sceptre86 · 15/12/2021 16:34

I don't work in this kind of sector but my dh does. He works in a small team and I know his other colleague definitely offers when she has a lighter load and he reciprocates.

RavingAnnie · 15/12/2021 16:21

I find some of the responses on this thread utterly bizarre. Of course you should support your colleagues when you have capacity. That's team work. And of course you should take the initiative to request more work rather than sit around twiddling your thumbs. This is work 101 surely. If v people are responding badly to that that says more about them than you.

MedusasBadHairDay · 15/12/2021 16:07

YANBU, seems like a perfectly normal thing to do to me. Nothing offensive or patronising about it.

KatherineJaneway · 15/12/2021 16:02

@girlmom21

I bet the person who's said that also has nothing to do and doesn't want to offer help so they're annoyed you did.

I'd be grateful for the help.

Exactly.

It was a lovely thing to do. I know Id be grateful.

TarpaulinEyes · 15/12/2021 15:50

I used to do this if I had some free time in one job I had. It made a nice change from my usual work. It was also a good way of getting to know other people who worked there.

lockdownalli · 15/12/2021 15:36

YANBU

It is completely normal practice in my sector. Your colleague is a knob. Just ignore them.

Fatgalslim · 15/12/2021 15:33

It would be appreciated where I work, I'm guessing the people who say it wouldn't are those that sit around doing not a lot when others are busy.

czechitout · 15/12/2021 15:32

and btw, I do not regard the offer as patronizing or wrong. I suppose it was a friendly offer from a colleague. I think you've done well.

czechitout · 15/12/2021 15:30

One person emailed saying everyone will hate me for pointing out I had nothing to do and offering to help them.

If everyone will hate you that should include the one who emailed this. Does she (or he) hate you already? You may ask?

(Interesting how some people say how other will react or feel, somehow excluding themselves from that universal and natural reaction.)

LadyDanburysHat · 15/12/2021 15:20

I don't think it comes across as patronising. It is a perfectly normal thing to do in my job. Sometimes managers will email out to say one of their team has capacity if anyone needs help too.

I think it was a nice thing to do.

mynameiscalypso · 15/12/2021 15:17

Your behaviour would be normal (and expected!) in every workplace I've ever been at. I would always offer to help out in similar circumstances (and would also avail myself of any such offers if I needed it).

ContadoraExplorer · 15/12/2021 15:14

Balls to them! I hate when people sit around doing bugger all while the test of their team are still busy with their allocated tasks. It should be the norm that if anyone is at a loose end they offer to pick work up. It's called teamwork...

OneRuleForThem · 15/12/2021 15:09

It still comes across as patronising to me. I am just explaining how your colleague might have seen it the same why I have. However, I wouldn’t give it any more thought if I were you, because there is no competition between: sending an email to a group offering your help and sending an email to someone personally saying “our colleagues will hate you”. The second example is nasty and bullying and you’re not the one who sent that one.

Nidan2Sandan · 15/12/2021 15:04

@evilharpy

If this happened within my team there would be nothing but grateful responses. And copying in the bosses would be reasonable as they might have something ad hoc for you to help with, we do a lot of random project stuff as well as the main job. We also (individually) have peaks and troughs while we wait for everything to inevitably kick off at once. Absolutely nobody in my team would think you were being a dick.
Incidentally one of the line managers did email me and ask me to pick up a few bits of her work (which I did).

I'm just annoyed that I'm sitting here second guessing myself when I was just trying to be helpful, a "team player" even though that buzz phrase brings me out in hives, because I know after xmas we get really busy so helping now means less stress all round next year.

Argh, I dont know what to do. That email has really bothered me. Sad

OP posts:
DilemmaDelilah · 15/12/2021 15:04

It is completely normal in my team to offer support to colleagues if we have a quiet time ourselves - and none of us are afraid to ask our colleagues if anyone has any spare capacity to help if we are double-booked, on leave etc.

ImInStealthMode · 15/12/2021 14:56

Seems fine to me OP. In my company there are 2 larger teams who have different roles but work in tandem with each other and there's a lot of crossover in the subject matter they each work on. The nature of our work means that each team's busiest periods are at different times of year, so there's some give and take in helping each other out where possible. We scratch their backs, they scratch ours.

I agree it sounds to me like the person who moaned is also at a lose end but can't be bothered helping out anyone else and is annoyed that you've put them to shame.

evilharpy · 15/12/2021 14:54

If this happened within my team there would be nothing but grateful responses. And copying in the bosses would be reasonable as they might have something ad hoc for you to help with, we do a lot of random project stuff as well as the main job. We also (individually) have peaks and troughs while we wait for everything to inevitably kick off at once. Absolutely nobody in my team would think you were being a dick.