Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this should be more widely talked about

30 replies

RobotValkyrie · 15/12/2021 11:40

I stumbled on a news article about the Lancet EAT diet: some attempt to devise a sustainable diet for the whole world.
This article included an interesting criticism: that the proposed diet did not meet recommended amounts of certain nutrients.
In particular, it would only meet about 50% of the RDA of iron for women and girls of child-bearing age.

This got me wondering: just how different are men and women needs, when it comes to iron?
A quick Google tells me women (from puberty till menopause) need more than twice as much iron than men. This is obviously linked to menstruation (and pregnancy, and childbirth, which can all cause anemia). But I had no idea the difference was so stark.
This means that any dietary advice to substitute meat for plant-based alternatives (where available iron is much lower) is much more likely to result in adverse health effect in women, than in men. One size does not fit all. Women are extremely likely to need supplements (or suffer from anemia), compared to men.

I've never heard anyone advocating a plant-based diet acknowledge that difference. I have in fact been lectured by (male) vegetarians on how "people" really don't need that much iron at all. But the reality is that many women (and not just vegan/vegetarian ones) in developed countries such as the UK actually suffer from iron deficiency (whether they realise it or not. I only discovered I was anemic while pregnant because of a routine blood test)

YABU: everybody knows that and/or it really doesn't matter

YANBU: the fact women need more iron in their diet than men should be talked about (at the GP, at school), and considered whenever advocating dietary changes (be they for an individual, or for the whole population)

OP posts:
Comedycook · 15/12/2021 12:20

I always wonder why red meat is associated with men and women are more likely to eat chicken and fish...like those ghastly separate menus that existed in the past which had beef for men and fish for women. I also get irritated when I hear women say they don't eat red meat (not talking for religious reasons obviously) but dietary ones...

Chocolatewheatos · 15/12/2021 12:14

I knew that and I am pretty sure everyone I've taken nutritional advice from does. I've done martial arts for years and been vegetarian and the iron conversation comes up alot. I've never had an iron deficiency (been tested for various things over the years incl pregnancy) or taken supplements.

Mercurial123 · 15/12/2021 12:07

I agree with you, vegetarians and vegans like to lecture you that their diet is perfectly sufficient but in actual fact in many/most cases it certainly isn't.

Really? You know very different people to me. My friends who are vegetarian/vegan know that they need to supplement their diet with iron and vitamin B12. I also use vegan Omega 3 and combined Vitamin D and K.

MorningStarling · 15/12/2021 11:50

I agree with you, vegetarians and vegans like to lecture you that their diet is perfectly sufficient but in actual fact in many/most cases it certainly isn't. The fact that you can live with an iron deficiency (or the deficiency of the many dietary requirements we have that vegetarian food lacks in) doesn't mean that it is healthy.

I'm not sure anything can be done about it though because the fetishism veganism has attracted means it is "known" that it is a good diet, regardless of the truth. Plus there are constant moves to try to reduce meat intake even for regular people who have a normal diet.

Mercurial123 · 15/12/2021 11:49

As a vegetarian of 30 years, I've known to take iron supplements. It's nothing new. So I would say YABU.

Swipe left for the next trending thread